Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think punish him on your own bloody time and give DS his toy back?

532 replies

toddlertantrumishell · 19/02/2022 12:54

DS very favourite toy is his paw patrol tower and all of the characters and cars that park in it. It is all he plays with. Yesterday I was out for the day and DS had lots of tantrums with DH and DS bit him. As punishment DH took his tower and all the cars and characters away from him and has said he can have them back Sunday night when DH gets home if he's been a good boy all weekend.

Of course DS shouldn't be biting, and his tantrums are savage and go on for fucking ages, I get it. But it's midday Saturday and I'm alone with him all weekend and he's doing my absolutely head in. He's done nothing but cry and whine and moan. He won't play it with anything else he's tearing around the house looking for his tower. I cannot deal with the crying anymore and I'm in for an entire weekend of a relentlessly tantrumming toddler, because he's being punished for annoying DH with tantrums?

Aibu to think punish him in your own bloody time and don't make me deal with the reality of it?! I want to give it back just to stop the fucking noise before I really lose it with him myself. I'm pregnant and knackered and honestly he is on my final nerve

OP posts:
IForgiveYouPaula · 21/02/2022 17:42

@velvet24

Beyond abusive? come on !!!!
@velvet24 I know right? It’s a miracle social services never took my children away based on what I’m reading. My children are living proof that a punishment does work. They weren’t bad kids at all but like most children they test you on occasion. Never gave an empty threat. Invitations were revoked, DS consoles were confiscated and no desert was given if dinner wasn’t finished. Firm but fair, if I said no I meant it. I’ve raised two well adjusted young adults who know the difference between right and wrong, are respectful and don’t sulk!
Pumperthepumper · 21/02/2022 17:38

@EdgeOfACoin

For the people who say 'punishment doesn't work', what would you do in the following scenario:
  • Child normally bites when bored and hungry. Parent has learnt to anticipate this and steps in before child can get either bored or hungry by providing food and entertainment. Child has never been punished for biting. Child sees no reason to bite as all needs are being met.
  • Parent and child are in a situation where hunger and boredom are unavoidable. For instance, situations I have been in personally include being at an airport where flights have been delayed at a time when the cafés are either closed or full; a bus on a country lane that is stuck behind a car that has broken down and there is no way around the car; a severely delayed train.
  • What do you do when the young child is bored and hungry because the spare banana has already been eaten and the toy is no longer sufficiently entertaining? What do you do when the biting begins out of boredom and hunger, as the child has never been expected to handle small amounts of boredom or hunger?

I don't yet have a toddler. I'm curious.

What I do when the biting begins out of boredom or hunger having failed to meet their needs? Ask them not to, and distract if possible. Which it always is, draw on the window? Stickers? Play eye-spy? What good would a punishment do when they’ve already bitten by that point?
Shehasadiamondinthesky · 21/02/2022 17:35

You need to work as a team.
If your DS grows up with one parent punishing and the other ignoring the punishment then he will play you off against each other like fiddles and his behaviour will get much worse but you and DS father need to discuss this properly like adults.
Its all so easy to get into good cop, bad cop mode especially when you are good cop because your DS will like you more but that is very unhealthy in the long run.

velvet24 · 21/02/2022 17:31

Beyond abusive? come on !!!!

Devora13 · 21/02/2022 17:25

Don't you just hate it when they enforce something and leave you to deal with the fallout? Poor little love.
He needs to develop cause and effect thinking, and is very young for this. Natural or logical consequences will help with this, not an unrelated, illogical punishment. He won't even remember what it's about. Your DH needs to be patient, there is such a thing developmental stages. We would co-regulate his big feelings when tantrums are happening, 'Wow, I can see this is really hard for you! Do you need a hug? I'm right here when you need one!'
A logical consequence, once he's calm and he and dad have repaired, would be for him to help clean up dad's bite wound, rub some healing gel on it, and perhaps read 'Teeth are not for Biting ' or similar together.

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 16:49

@BlondeWidow

Fucking hell that's beyond abusive

Poor kid 😢 This actually brought tears to my eyes 😢

Don't be ridiculous, it's a toy not food and drink!
velvet24 · 21/02/2022 16:34

@Mirw

Your DH is torturing your child. Your DH is being ridiculous. Get hold of your DH abd find out where the toys us snd give it back. This is not an appropriate punishment for a 3 year old. To show your DH he is wrong, taje away his phone for a couple of dats or his xbox or whatever, his golf clubs snd see how he likes it. He is a complete a*.
Blimey ive seen it all now, torture??!!
velvet24 · 21/02/2022 16:34

[quote CallmeBadJanet]@toddlertantrumishell While unpleasant, annoying and stressful, your DS's behaviour (tantrums) is normal. Toddlers bite when they can't express themselves, i.e. they don't have the language to describe their feelings or understand them. So there's no way he will understand or learn from having a toy removed from him. He will understand that his dad is angry though, which is why he's whining so much; he doesn't feel safe. Your DH's thinking of how to correct your DS's behaviour is flawed, you can't "punish" a toddler. Your DS probably learned this style of parenting from his family; it needs to change. Check out Good Inside, online or podcast and Family Lives website. You need to work together as parents to raise your children. ❤[/quote]
Punishments DO work

Quartz2208 · 21/02/2022 10:02

@JustUseTheDoorSanta

But if I said no I would stick with it. The child is too young to understand timeframe, so it isn't quite the same as with an older child, he can just be told he earned it back now.
THroughout the course of the tantrum - if I said no to something whatever the age and whatever the response yes I would stick with it. Backing down teaches that the tantrum gives the required response.

I would never take something away for having a tantrum as per the OP (mine was in response to a question by Edgeofacoin) as I dont think having a tantrum is a punishable offence

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 21/02/2022 09:28

But if I said no I would stick with it.
The child is too young to understand timeframe, so it isn't quite the same as with an older child, he can just be told he earned it back now.

Quartz2208 · 21/02/2022 09:11

@EdgeOfACoin

Boredom and hunger mean that it is more difficult to regulate their emotions and therefore they lose control and that is when the behaviour happens.

But the upshot is still the same, surely - what do you do in this situation if a child is biting you on a delayed train because they haven't learnt to regulate their emotions? I presume telling them off would be a form of punishment?

How do you stop them from losing control in the first place?

raisingchildren.net.au/toddlers/behaviour/crying-tantrums/tantrums

Sometimes you simply cant stop them from losing control - a delayed train pushes everyone to the limit as adults we are just more aware of what that limit should be in terms of behaviour

Remaining calm and consistent and reassuring where you can and letting it roll is what you can do.

In delayed trains for example adapt around it - the worse thing you can do is say no and then back down. In ours DS (who is older I will say) asked for some M&Ms and I said yes - I knew he was finding it difficult and some sugar at that point helped. But if I said no I would stick with it.

Tantrums are not pleasant to witness but at a toddler age they are a part of development and sometimes unavoidable. Understanding that what they are saying is that I dont like this situation I would rather be somewhere else is what we are all saying (in the delayed train) its just their way of saying it

Bertiebiscuit · 21/02/2022 09:04

You don't have to follow DH s bad judgement call - I would have given the toy back personally, DH is being too controlling of both of you, you and DS

PrincessNutella · 21/02/2022 08:54

0h no absolutely don't punish him like that. It is very cruel.

Newmumatlast · 21/02/2022 08:47

@toddlertantrumishell

DS very favourite toy is his paw patrol tower and all of the characters and cars that park in it. It is all he plays with. Yesterday I was out for the day and DS had lots of tantrums with DH and DS bit him. As punishment DH took his tower and all the cars and characters away from him and has said he can have them back Sunday night when DH gets home if he's been a good boy all weekend.

Of course DS shouldn't be biting, and his tantrums are savage and go on for fucking ages, I get it. But it's midday Saturday and I'm alone with him all weekend and he's doing my absolutely head in. He's done nothing but cry and whine and moan. He won't play it with anything else he's tearing around the house looking for his tower. I cannot deal with the crying anymore and I'm in for an entire weekend of a relentlessly tantrumming toddler, because he's being punished for annoying DH with tantrums?

Aibu to think punish him in your own bloody time and don't make me deal with the reality of it?! I want to give it back just to stop the fucking noise before I really lose it with him myself. I'm pregnant and knackered and honestly he is on my final nerve

I get the frustration but I think if one parent makes a decision on a consequence the other one follows it through because otherwise it shows the child you don't mean what you say. But privately communicate to DH that you'd prefer for consequences to be dealt with at the time. I do think a whole weekend is alot for a toddler who is say 2 but maybe appropriate if say 5. DH dealt with it yesterday, you Saturday so you are only dealing with an extra day of it (Sunday) so perhaps one less day of consequence would've been better which is what I'd perhaps tell DH
EdgeOfACoin · 21/02/2022 08:32

Boredom and hunger mean that it is more difficult to regulate their emotions and therefore they lose control and that is when the behaviour happens.

But the upshot is still the same, surely - what do you do in this situation if a child is biting you on a delayed train because they haven't learnt to regulate their emotions? I presume telling them off would be a form of punishment?

How do you stop them from losing control in the first place?

Quartz2208 · 21/02/2022 08:17

You are missing a bit though - its not like the toddler goes I am bored and I am hungry so I will bite. That is putting a logic and rationale behind it that simply doesn't exist. And that is why punishment doesn't work - because it isn't a deliberate logical choice. Boredom and hunger mean that it is more difficult to regulate their emotions and therefore they lose control and that is when the behaviour happens.

Those situations you describe though as stressors for everyone - having just been through one everyone was getting frayed and snappy and it is the same just they dont know when to stop

Those are stressful situations Edgeofcoin where adults have a reaction to it -

threatmatrix · 21/02/2022 08:14

So, is this how you are going to be for the rest of his young life? Just let him have what he wants for peace and quiet ? No wonder he’s like he is.

EdgeOfACoin · 21/02/2022 06:45

For the people who say 'punishment doesn't work', what would you do in the following scenario:

  • Child normally bites when bored and hungry. Parent has learnt to anticipate this and steps in before child can get either bored or hungry by providing food and entertainment. Child has never been punished for biting. Child sees no reason to bite as all needs are being met.
  • Parent and child are in a situation where hunger and boredom are unavoidable. For instance, situations I have been in personally include being at an airport where flights have been delayed at a time when the cafés are either closed or full; a bus on a country lane that is stuck behind a car that has broken down and there is no way around the car; a severely delayed train.
  • What do you do when the young child is bored and hungry because the spare banana has already been eaten and the toy is no longer sufficiently entertaining? What do you do when the biting begins out of boredom and hunger, as the child has never been expected to handle small amounts of boredom or hunger?

I don't yet have a toddler. I'm curious.

BlondeWidow · 21/02/2022 02:05

Fucking hell that's beyond abusive

Poor kid 😢 This actually brought tears to my eyes 😢

CelestiaNoctis · 21/02/2022 01:51

With tactics like that I hope your partner is away on a parenting course. Taking a toy from a 2 year old, so funny. He's still a toddler.

Ztava · 21/02/2022 00:32

Treated not tested !

Ztava · 21/02/2022 00:30

I strongly advise both you and your husband to attend some positive parenting sessions. Or listen to some videos or read on this subject. Specially that you are planning to have another child.
Poor poor that small child being tested this way. It so so sad to hear these stories in such advanced country .

Your main concern must be the well being of your child and god knows how damaging it must be mentally going through this hell situation at such young age !!
Punishing a small child like this!!! In another country the social services would be on your doorsteps. !
Please read up please learn please , for the sake your previous son and the one who is in the way!
I only can pray . With lots of love .

EarringsandLipstick · 20/02/2022 21:34

@nannykatherine

You don’t say how old he is

She does. In her posts. Where she also says the situation is sorted.

nannykatherine · 20/02/2022 21:09

@toddlertantrumishell

DS very favourite toy is his paw patrol tower and all of the characters and cars that park in it. It is all he plays with. Yesterday I was out for the day and DS had lots of tantrums with DH and DS bit him. As punishment DH took his tower and all the cars and characters away from him and has said he can have them back Sunday night when DH gets home if he's been a good boy all weekend.

Of course DS shouldn't be biting, and his tantrums are savage and go on for fucking ages, I get it. But it's midday Saturday and I'm alone with him all weekend and he's doing my absolutely head in. He's done nothing but cry and whine and moan. He won't play it with anything else he's tearing around the house looking for his tower. I cannot deal with the crying anymore and I'm in for an entire weekend of a relentlessly tantrumming toddler, because he's being punished for annoying DH with tantrums?

Aibu to think punish him in your own bloody time and don't make me deal with the reality of it?! I want to give it back just to stop the fucking noise before I really lose it with him myself. I'm pregnant and knackered and honestly he is on my final nerve

I agree with you Give him back the tower !!! You don’t say how old he is but I guess 3 ish This age long drawn out punishments don’t work … Often biting is a communication issue when they get frustrated .. How is his speech ..? When he kicks of try validating his emotions and talking Theo what’s happening .. In my experience (vast) Stand offs never work .. Neither does taking tous They forget why so it’s pointless ..
hellithurt · 20/02/2022 20:36

@Mirw

Your DH is torturing your child. Your DH is being ridiculous. Get hold of your DH abd find out where the toys us snd give it back. This is not an appropriate punishment for a 3 year old. To show your DH he is wrong, taje away his phone for a couple of dats or his xbox or whatever, his golf clubs snd see how he likes it. He is a complete a*.
Sorry posted too soon! Read the 10 posts by the OP! Your comment is ridiculous!