Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not prioritise my pension?

67 replies

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 11:37

My parents paid loads into their pensions and both died without really benefiting from them. In part, I do attribute their early deaths down to stress leading to poor decisions.

AIBU then in not worrying about working PT because of pension)

OP posts:
Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 13:08

The current state pension is just under £180 a week, which tbh is more than I get now. I earn more at the moment, but then my outgoings are high.

OP posts:
Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 13:07

@Pluvia, he retired after her death, then died himself a few years later.

OP posts:
dottydodah · 19/02/2022 13:07

I felt a little like you .My DF died when I was young ,and had no retirement to speak of .I have been a SAHM for a while now ,and previously had a small pension from my FT job in my 20s and 30s .I think its always hard to see into the future TBH.I mean you could live to 100 and need every penny . I often think peoples expectations of Retirement can be unrealistic as well .People on average salaries expect world class cruises,retirement bungalows and so on .Would you want a 5 star retirement funded by a longer working life .Or happy with a break in England and a small flat?

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 13:07

Why do you assume that, @EmmaH2022? Has there been any suggestion that the state pension will be scrapped?

(Just in case, that is a genuine question borne out of curiosity not an aggressive grilling!)

@loislovesstewie but if I was made redundant in ten years, I’m not sure my parents would have recommended never working again. Well, perhaps my dad, although he retired rather than being made redundant!

I suppose if it doesn’t much matter to you where you work or how long you spend there choosing a job by pension makes sense but to me, it seems to suggest misery and frugality in 30s, 40s and 50s in exchange for living it up in your 60s and beyond, except you may not get there.

You can’t live totally in the moment but I don’t think it’s wise to solely live in the future either.

OP posts:
Pluvia · 19/02/2022 13:05

It wasn’t so much that they cut themselves off, more than they both persisted in jobs they loathed. At one point, my mother was caring for her elderly parents too and started to drink very heavily, which led to her death.

But earlier you said your father retired at 53, which is young. And it seems your mother died from alcoholism, not from the effects of continuing to work in order to maximise her pension.

Get some advice — someone who can crunch the numbers, work out how much your state and work pension will be — and take it from there. I wouldn't want to be heading into my 60s and 70s on the minimum, but maybe you have family who'll bolster you and inheritances to come and it makes sense for you.

Twirldream · 19/02/2022 13:03

To not plan for retirement is foolhardy, and if you are able to save/invest for it then you should (obviously some just can’t do this).

How many pensioners are leading a comfortable retirement with nothing but the paltry state pension? It is not unheard of for many pensioners to be unable to afford heating, decent food etc. They don’t get an annual heating allowance and free TV license because they have ample income. That is possibly the future for those who choose to ignore that beyond retirement they could still live for a few more decades yet, and will need more than the state pension to live a good life rather than just live hand to mouth on very little ££.

eightlivesdown · 19/02/2022 13:02

It’s more to do with not placing all my eggs in a future basket which may never be needed.

Don't place all your eggs (money) in any basket, future pension or current spending. Place a bit in each; enjoy life today and provide for the future.

Check (don't guess / assume) how many years National Insurance contributions you have, and that you'll reach 35 years in due course to receive a full pension (otherwise consider voluntary contributions to make up the shortfall). Check where you are with your workplace pension. This will help you decide whether to go part-time, or continue full-time at least for now.

You own your house and have some level of workplace pension, so are well-placed to have a nice life now and when retired if you are sensible.

EmmaH2022 · 19/02/2022 12:53

@loislovesstewie

My father in -law is 91, he has a local government pension(so do I). He was made redundant in his late 50s and hasn't worked since. I think he's got his money's worth, don't you?
Definitely! My dad had an excellent pension too. He used to tell me frequently how I should choose jobs according to pension.
Theremustbemoretome · 19/02/2022 12:52

The benefit of planning and paying into a pension now means you shouldn’t be living on the breadline in your retirement. We choose to plan for our retirement but if we die before then/early into retirement, then our DC will still benefit.

Obviously everyone’s financial situation varies but if you can save for retirement then I think you should, or have some sort of other backup plan like investing in property, or stocks and shares etc. You could be retired for 30-40 years and that’s a long time living on a tiny state pension.

loislovesstewie · 19/02/2022 12:51

My father in -law is 91, he has a local government pension(so do I). He was made redundant in his late 50s and hasn't worked since. I think he's got his money's worth, don't you?

EmmaH2022 · 19/02/2022 12:47

@Towardsthenorth

But there is a middle ground. Not prioritising a pension just means I think I am inclined to enjoy life a bit now - part time, and so on - rather than not having a pension at all.

And if you do own property then the state pension isn’t too bad, as far as I can see.

I am 46 and assume that there won't be a state pension if I get there, or it will be a lot lower, or means tested.

I think that if you have property and you're enjoying life then it sounds like you could prioritise saving and investing.

It's not just a choice between working more or not. There are other ways to save for the future.

GeneLovesJezebel · 19/02/2022 12:41

My DF died before he could take his private or OAP pension, and he didn’t leave a will so second wife got everything.
So personally I’d say don’t sweat it if you can’t afford it.
I personally prefer money in the bank that I can get anytime, rather than waiting to be old enough to get at it.

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 12:41

But there is a middle ground. Not prioritising a pension just means I think I am inclined to enjoy life a bit now - part time, and so on - rather than not having a pension at all.

And if you do own property then the state pension isn’t too bad, as far as I can see.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 19/02/2022 12:40

On the fence. My parents provided for themselves and having a comfortable retirement and are in their 80s. Parents sibling and partner didnt. Have watched them scrape, lose their house as couldnt afford it, end up in horrible rented accomadation finally offered council elderly housing in late 60s. I would not want that

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 12:39

We do own property but then if we didn’t I’d definitely prioritise that over pension.

OP posts:
tygh787 · 19/02/2022 12:36

I think it depends whether for example you own a property. My parents had a tiny pension but their house trembled in value and they took out their maximum mortgage twenty years ago.had they been more risk averse or paid more into their pension, they wouldn't have been able to get the house. Twenty years later - they can downsize and have plenty of money for their retirement. But thats London where houses went from 500k to 1.5mil in twenty years. Not sure that this will happen again. But downsizing is always an option as a three bed house will always be more than a one bed flat even if prices crash

cheapskatemum · 19/02/2022 12:31

My Mum never worried about a pension & died age 52, so I can see where you're coming from. I'm not worried about mine because I'm very good at living within my means (hence username Smile). Agree with PP who says you do you. There is no way I would have thought I'd be working until age 67 before getting my state pension when I entered the workforce. I say this as an example of no-one knowing what the lay of the land will be when you are due your pension.

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 19/02/2022 12:22

It's a matter of personal choice. I live a very modest life now in order to prioritse pension later. Is it the right decision - only time will tell. Others my age live in nice houses and drive nice cars but have no pension. I can't say that my way is better than theirs, or that they will regret their decision.

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 12:18

That’s really interesting @MeanderingGently and quite refreshing, to be honest. I must admit, I can’t necessarily see myself needing a fortune in my dotage but I could well be wrong!

OP posts:
Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 12:17

@AllOfUsAreDead - it’s more to do with not placing all my eggs in a future basket which may never be needed.

I may live until I am well into my nineties or even beyond, but even so, I suspect that when I look back I will have wished I enjoyed my forties and fifties more. I don’t want to ‘save up’ my enjoyment of life for the future, I suppose.

OP posts:
MeanderingGently · 19/02/2022 12:17

I have always opted out of pension schemes, all my life. When I was a single parent I could barely afford to live and still ended up with debts just to pay the bills, so no, a personal pension wasn't an option for me. I needed every penny I could muster just to survive.

Years later, I don't regret any of it. The one job I ever had which paid well and gave me more money, I still opted out and went travelling with the extra cash instead. I'm extremely glad I did it, I had some amazing travels which I certainly couldn't have done if I'd waited until I retired, I'm too frail with health conditions these days.

I'm not long off retiring now and I'll only have my state pension when I do, but I have everything I need and will be able to live off the state one. I don't own any assets - I rent and have a lease car - but I will be able to manage on the state pension. My current job is part-time and in a low-paid sector, and I earn about the same as the state pension per month, so I already know I will be able to survive in retirement.

Honestly, it depends what you want out of retirement. I am always surprised by these people who have huge pension savings, what are they planning to do with the money?? And, like you OP, I also had relatives who put everything into a pension but died just before retirement age so they never got to enjoy it anyway.

AllOfUsAreDead · 19/02/2022 12:14

I think you may be unreasonable, and this will sound morbid, but it's not as if your parents died from something that is genetic and will cause you to die young too. Your mum from the sounds of it died from alcoholism and stressing, which will both of course lead to worse things. Not sure on your dad, but you said stress so again leads to worse things. Unless you believe you will also become stressed once retired and suffer the same outcome, then yabu because you will live longer than them then and will not have the money to take you through retirement. You'll have to work forever, which may then also cause stress.

Think there may be more of a middle ground here for you really, think you are reacting emotionally about this too much, understandably.

eightlivesdown · 19/02/2022 12:13

If you have the resources to invest for the future (pension, ISA, whatever) it's sensible to do so. Not to an extreme extent and thereby deny yourself a reasonable current standard of living, but a balanced approach between enjoying life today and making provision for the future.

You say your parents didn't really benefit from their pensions, but you could be retired for 40 years; you just don't know. And that's a long time to live on a minimal (only state pension) income.

You also say you parents were stressed, but getting older knowing you haven't made financial provision for retirement is surely also stressful.

SamphiretheStickerist · 19/02/2022 12:07

There is always a middle ground and this is often filled by that compulsory work pension... wasn't around when I was young and I am now, in my 50s, scrambling to make up for what I didn't give a single thought to in my 20s, 30s.

If you can't or don't want to prioritise a pension then at least give it a little bit of thought. Your older self will thank you for any additional monies they get.

Towardsthenorth · 19/02/2022 12:06

So, I guess, you could always go back F/T at some point

I could, but I think once I’ve tasted the good life I’ll be decidedly reluctant to go back to it Grin

One of the problems is I’m not massively enjoying my job, but I earn too much to do anything else. So part time gives me some breathing space from it.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread