Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby /toddler sessions run by a man

169 replies

SleepingStandingUp · 19/02/2022 00:12

If you were looking for paid sessions for baby / toddler would it put you off if the person leading it was a man? Would your baby's age make any difference? Talking to a male friend about career options but we were undecided if it would be doable.

Yabu - no one would go
Yanbu - of course people would go

OP posts:
scandikate · 19/02/2022 05:43

It would make me want to go to be honest. I have a boy and find it really sad that he never sees any male adults working with children. There has never been a single male at any nursery or playgroup setting and now he's at school the only male working there is the caretaker.

cuno · 19/02/2022 05:38

Small children are more at risk of pedophiles within their own families. Standing in a circle singing with 15 mums, 15 toddlers and one DBS checked man is hardly a risk.

Absolutely. Or it could be singing with 12 mums, 3 dads and 15 toddlers and you wouldn't know if the other dads are paedophiles. They can see the toddler just as much as the man leading the play group, but neither would be alone or looking after the child. I don't know what difference it makes unless people don't take their toddlers out anywhere where there are men.

I understand the risk that men as a group pose, and I am very wary of men myself. I would never let any man other than my daughter's father look after her. But even an objection to male play group leader is OTT for me.

TheGoogleMum · 19/02/2022 05:37

I think it would go down better with toddlers than babies but wouldn't necessarily put me off (in fact we used to go to a toddler sports class run by a man and he was great!)

Moonface123 · 19/02/2022 05:33

If anything l would prefer it.

tcjotm · 19/02/2022 05:31

@haikyew

Wiggles are a band Many would be irked because Most pedos are men
A band that jumps around singing toddler songs. Not too dissimilar from many toddler groups!

Small children are more at risk of pedophiles within their own families. Standing in a circle singing with 15 mums, 15 toddlers and one DBS checked man is hardly a risk.

tcjotm · 19/02/2022 05:28

@Momijin

Not sure why a man would need to have expert or in depth knowledge of breastfeeding and giving birth to run a toddler group!

It wouldn't affect how I feel about going to a play group. Lots of children entertainers are men in my experience and they're fab.

It would also make dads more comfortable about going I think.

If you were responding to me, no of course they wouldn’t. But OP mentioned baby groups too and they can be more for new mother support and discussion and those topics can come up. That might be a bit weird for the mums. But if it’s just a singing/play type one of course that experience isn’t relevant and it doesn’t matter who teaches it..
MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 19/02/2022 05:28

The best school teachers, particularly in primary that my children had were men. I felt as though they actually wanted to be there and had a passion for teaching. I felt like some of the female teachers actually didn’t like the job but it was convenient around their own families (obviously not all, they have had a few superb female teachers).

So no, wouldn’t bother me in the least. The only time I have objected to a man in any situation was the very young boy they sent to shave me for a caesarean, I don’t know which one of us was more horrified. Not sure I would have wanted a lady either to be fair. Happy to do it myself!

cuno · 19/02/2022 05:24

I'm assuming it's a play group. Would not bother me at all. He's not going to be alone with my toddler or responsible for her care so it's no different to the dads that may or may not attend being around my daughter in a setting like that, and it's not like those dads are DBS checked etc. She wouldn't be at any additional risk so I don't see what the issue is.

Twicklette · 19/02/2022 05:19

À bit different but in the secondary school where I taught there was a push to find male TAs . The majority of students with additional needs are boys. Traditionally TAs are middle aged women with a mummy approach to helping. Many boys hate this kind of support and feel so embarrassed. They reject the help and gain nothing from these TAs. Instead the school looked for male TAs, often young graduates thinking of teaching as a career. These men were so popular with classes and particularly with the young boys who required additional support. It was recognised as a successful approach to targeted learning support in classrooms.
There is a real reluctance to let men have a role in child rearing and education, amongst many women, who believe that mummy knows best. It is not healthy for boys who need support to have a 'mummy' in the classroom. Successful male role models are so important for these boys and we let them down by not recognising the part men should play in their education. The underachievement of boys in the classroom has been a problem forever. Sadly childcare roles are more gendered than ever with so many women demanding mummy replacements.
OP, tell your friend to look for a TA role initially. So many schools want men and there is often positive discrimination in place to attract men. We do our young people and children a disservice by wanting a mummy style replacement in childcare.

Hellolittlestar · 19/02/2022 05:15

I went to an antenatal class run by a man. I never went back as I though he’s full of shit and couldn’t possibly relate to anything a woman is feeling during giving birth.

I would happily attend a toddler class from 18+ months. Any earlier than that, I would not have felt comfortable with it.

haikyew · 19/02/2022 05:07

Wiggles are a band
Many would be irked because
Most pedos are men

Momijin · 19/02/2022 05:03

Not sure why a man would need to have expert or in depth knowledge of breastfeeding and giving birth to run a toddler group!

It wouldn't affect how I feel about going to a play group. Lots of children entertainers are men in my experience and they're fab.

It would also make dads more comfortable about going I think.

tcjotm · 19/02/2022 04:52

Doesn’t seem to bother toddlers that the Wiggles are a bunch of men.

A man may also have loads more experience of parenting than a first time mother. Obviously no first hand knowledge of giving birth or breastfeeding but neither may some of the mothers.

Wouldn’t bother me, though it’s probably not a very lucrative career option for him!

Cognoscenti · 19/02/2022 04:40

I'd like to go to a baby/toddler class run by a man, all of ours have been led by women which is fine, but if would be a nice change to go to a male-led one.

Flittingaboutagain · 19/02/2022 04:34

Wouldn't be a problem once toddlers but definitely would avoid whilst breastfeeding especially in the early days when baby latched on and off exposing me.

RainbowCrayons · 19/02/2022 04:28

We did messy play run by a man. He was wonderful and we still keep in contact. And DS did baby gym and is still there in the bigger classes still with the same male teacher. He responds well to men and I think it's nice to get that balance as he was at home with mostly just me for most of lockdown and now all the staff at his nursery are female.

Holskey · 19/02/2022 02:00

We attend a music class run by a man. It's great to have a visible man in such a setting for a change. Does depend on the type of class to some extent though - I attended a newborn yoga and massage class (yoga for the mums) and that was very much about our bodies etc - wouldn't be right for a man.

I do think leading a class is different to a role where a man is left alone with a child. Of course most men aren't paedophiles, but the majority of paedophiles are men, and there is no shortage of them unfortunately.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 19/02/2022 01:25

I regularly attend a toddler class thst is run by a man. He does baby classes too.

If anything its a selling point to me. My DD loves him. Hes great with the children. I thibk the fact he's a man has almost become a bit of a USP. The class now often has a fair few dads attend and its lovely to have a bit of variety!

KatherineofGaunt · 19/02/2022 01:22

My DH would have loved this. He's a SAHD (DC now at nursery more so less time to go places) and would have welcomed even one group run by a man so there was another man around to talk to. He's found being surrounded by female carers and group leaders all day isolating as they generally ignore him.

HiJenny35 · 19/02/2022 01:18

We had a man who ran a song group, it was packed every week, a woman ran the same on alternative days and hers was always empty also a man at drama and dance group. I prefer going to things run by a man, everything in preschool is ran by women so I always wanted my child to see men in nurturing roles too.

NumberTheory · 19/02/2022 01:09

I wouldn’t have thought I’d have a problem before I had kids. But after putting up with a lot of men and young, childless women talking crap when mine were babies, I might be a bit wary now. I’d be fine with a male nanny. And I’m fine with male nurses and doctors for any type of care. But stuff where people are often giving their own opinions, rather than giving research lead care, I’ve just found people who haven’t given birth are too often a pain. And that sort of thing often comes with leaders of baby groups. I left a couple because they were run by young women who talked a lot about what people “should” do and it was patronizing and not at all supportive. To me, baby groups are all about the mutual support when you’ve just had your life turned upside down.

By the time the kids were school aged (probably a couple of years before) this wasn’t an issue any more. It was just those few years when they were really young.

LolaLuffnagal · 19/02/2022 00:50

@DropYourSword

Wouldn't bother me at all. My DS's daycare lead was a man. It was eye opening talking to him though about how much distrust there is for men in that line of work. I think it's a little disingenuous of posters writing on here "why would it". It absolutely shouldn't make a difference- but the reality is that it does and there are plenty of Mums who would unfairly not trust a man in a childcare type setting, simply because he's a man.
Yes, this.

I work in a nursery and every male colleague I have worked with over the years (not very many admittedly, under 10) has had at least one parent request that their child's nappy is not changed by them. I don't agree with it, if the worker is caring and trustful enough to look after their child then they should be able to participate in all areas of care.

Op, we need more male childcare workers so it would not bother me in the slightest, in fact I would welcome it. But sadly my opinion counts for nothing.

NuffSaidSam · 19/02/2022 00:49

@Thisischarming

It is hard for male nannies to find work

That's not my impression.

That's what the male nannies I know have told me.

I'm also a nanny.

Thisischarming · 19/02/2022 00:48

It is hard for male nannies to find work

That's not my impression.

avamiah · 19/02/2022 00:45

My daughter is 12 now but was taught to swim at the age of 6 by a male swimming coach who still teaches now and has a waiting list for new students.She does tap and drama and singing lessons now as she attends a stage school and most of her teachers are male and very successful as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread