Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby /toddler sessions run by a man

169 replies

SleepingStandingUp · 19/02/2022 00:12

If you were looking for paid sessions for baby / toddler would it put you off if the person leading it was a man? Would your baby's age make any difference? Talking to a male friend about career options but we were undecided if it would be doable.

Yabu - no one would go
Yanbu - of course people would go

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 19/02/2022 11:58

I suppose it might put some women off, if they've suffered poor experiences before then being with a strange man in a group setting with other strangers might be off putting. For me I wouldn't think twice though

grey12 · 19/02/2022 11:54

Wouldn't really care because I would be with the baby all the time 🤷🏻‍♀️ if it was babysitting maybe I would think twice....

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 19/02/2022 11:29

I used to attend a mother and toddler group where one of the volunteer leaders was an older man - probably of an age to be a grandfather rather than a father. He was actually a friend of my father's. He was a widow with his own children and part of the group that ran the session. The volunteers mostly were involved in setting up, organising refreshments and planning but they were in and out of the main hall and interacting with the parents and children. The children loved him and would gravitate towards him.

110APiccadilly · 19/02/2022 11:20

Unless it was breastfeeding support or something, it would be fine. Might be quite nice for us as a family as DH and I are both part time working and look after DD when the other is working, so it is DH who takes her to toddler groups about half the time.

Incidentally - as you mentioned male nurses on children's wards - I was in hospital as a young child and I still remember the one male nurse on the ward as he was very funny - extremely good at cheering us up.

Chely · 19/02/2022 11:19

I didn't have a problem with male members of the maternity team, wouldn't have a problem with male leader at a baby group.
I do have a problem with baby groups in general though so avoid like the plague.

pizz · 19/02/2022 11:16

@haikyew

Wiggles are a band Many would be irked because Most pedos are men

It's a baby session don't be ridiculous. Is no male ever allowed to cast his eyes on your child? It's a bit much, your staying with them the whole time. Understandable if it's a nursery worker changing nappies, not a bloke singing songs with a ukulele.

HelloDulling · 19/02/2022 11:16

We used to go to a gymnastics club run by a bloke. He was a former Commonwealth Games winner, and was brilliant with the kids, esp the toddler/preschoolers. We’ve also had a male swimming teacher lots of times.

People are weird though. I remember one of the mothers at school complained that the music teacher was a man, because her 4 year old DD had come home talking about him. He’s the nicest man in the world, two girls of his own, and is universally adored by all Year groups. She just didn’t want her DD to have any contact with any men at all.

NotYourOscarSpeech · 19/02/2022 11:13

My toddler would be delighted to go to a Mr Tumble toddler session that’s for sure!

birdy747 · 19/02/2022 11:11

Sleepingstandingup - this isn't about me or a father who wants to be around his own kids. It's about a man who wants to be around other people's kids.

Comedycook · 19/02/2022 11:10

I used to take my Ds to a 0-6 month baby class. Not baby sensory but similar. A man ran the sessions. He was really good...he had a very gentle, calming demeanor

GlitchStitch · 19/02/2022 11:07

I tend to see the opposite of wariness to males in early years settings. The ones I've seen are absolutely fawned over, even if they are mediocre.

Justkeeppedaling · 19/02/2022 11:05

1-2% of men are paedophiles in the general population

Are you sure? That seems very high.

CounsellorTroi · 19/02/2022 11:04

I’d be absolutely fine with a toddler group run by a man, particularly one who had his own child - parents are aren't leaving their children unattended anyway so the risk is miniscule.

Bit naive to think a man with his own children is automatically “safer”. As has been pointed out most abuse happens within the family.

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/02/2022 11:00

I've been to sessions run by men. I really don't understand the issue.

Crimesean · 19/02/2022 10:59

1-2% of men are paedophiles in the general population. Now, we know that paedophiles will actively seek out roles where they have access to potential victims (priests, medical staff, childcare providers, schools etc.) so we can expect that percentage to be higher amongst individuals who work in those sectors.

I would therefore always be more cautious of a male in such circumstances, even though most male nannies/nurses/priests etc. are harmless. It's natural to calculate risk and attempt to mitigate it (by, for example, choosing a female nanny).

I'd be absolutely fine with a toddler group run by a man, particularly one who had his own child - parents are aren't leaving their children unattended anyway so the risk is miniscule.

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/02/2022 10:56

Bookmark

Today 10:25 luxxlisbon

birdy747
It would be weird. Why would he want to be around babies/toddlers confused We've learnt lessons about paedophilia, let's not pretend to forget them to 'be kind'.

Why would women want to be around babies or toddlers? confused”

Indeed. I’m a mother/grandmother. My own young ones are just fantastic. I’d be a terrible play leader because I don’t particularly like other peoples babies and toddlers, just not interested.
I’m obviously not very good at being a woman Grin

FudgeSundae · 19/02/2022 10:52

Wow. So it has been repeatedly shown that paternity leave where it is paid and it’s use it or lose it improves inequality for women as it helps the father to be more involved in childcare early on. Our statutory shared parental leave is fairly shit but it does exist, but I do not understand why we refuse to see fathers as equal parents. It’s not just terrible for fathers - it’s bad for mothers too!

Yes, historically these have been “mummy groups”. Yes, sometimes these are very unwelcoming towards men (and working mothers, and gay couples, and formula feeders…) But surely we should be moving forwards towards groups for all kinds of parent? If you want a breastfeeding group - great! If you want a group with other gay couples or adopted parents - amazing! If you want one run by a man - fab!

I despair of the PPs who think it’s weird for men to be interested in children, or that “all men are pedos”. Hmm

SleepingStandingUp · 19/02/2022 10:43

@birdy747

It would be weird. Why would he want to be around babies/toddlers Confused We've learnt lessons about paedophilia, let's not pretend to forget them to 'be kind'.
So do you have kids? Is their Dad around? Do you assume he's a paedophile?

He has three kids, he's bloody brilliant with mine because he's caring and funny and silly, he's very approachable so he gets talked to more at group than I do. He's always worked public facing jobs and it suits him. It's really very sad that you'd see him hanging out with my toddlers (whilst I drink coffee) and assume he must want to abuse them

OP posts:
SecondhandTable · 19/02/2022 10:39

I've never been to a group ran by a bloke before (I have two young children and am an avid group-goer so I have been to maaaany groups over the last few years). It definitely wouldn't put me off at all. I feel it's sad that there is such a lack of representation of men in early years stuff, good male role models are important for children. I do go to a church playgroup though that is huge and has a whole team of volunteers and two of them are blokes. It's a very popular, huge playgroup and well attended so that definitely doesn't put people off. Another church playgroup I used to go to often has the reverend around helping out which again doesn't seem to be an issue. Oh I have also been to baby/toddler music group and a drama group that I go to sometimes and both of those had a bloke playing musical instruments as part of the sessions but they don't tend to do any of the talking or other input in to the sessions, so are otherwise women led. I would say these two groups in particular had a greater proportion of dads attending with their kids than the other groups I've been to so perhaps dad's are more likely to take their kids to these types of things and might work particularly well with a male running those types of groups?

Justkeeppedaling · 19/02/2022 10:39

their concensus professionally was that women might not feel comfortable having it led by a man, as he hasn't had the same experience of them at parenting

I don't think that's fair at all. It's "just" the pregnancy and giving birth but that men can't do - after that it's even stevens - or should be anyway.

JessicaKenny2018 · 19/02/2022 10:37

We had portage for my son with additional needs, we had the only man that worked in our area and he was amazing, other people I now know who also had him have said the same.

SpaghettiNotCourgetti · 19/02/2022 10:34

@birdy747

It would be weird. Why would he want to be around babies/toddlers Confused We've learnt lessons about paedophilia, let's not pretend to forget them to 'be kind'.
For the same reason women might like being around babies and toddlers? Because they're cute and funny? Because it's fascinating to watch their development? Humans never learn as much as quickly at any other point in the lifespan.

OR, obviously, it could be because we're in fucking Paedogeddon.

JFC. I loathe attitudes like this. How does one cope in normal life thinking this shit?

SlashBeef · 19/02/2022 10:29

@SleepingStandingUp not something I really had to think about as my kids reception teachers were female but considering it now, no I wouldn't feel comfortable with a male teacher being involved with toileting or personal care.

JemimaTiggywinkle · 19/02/2022 10:27

Tbh when you book baby groups you don’t always know who the group is run by until you turn up to the first session.
I would probably be mildly surprised it was a man but wouldn’t care. If anything I’d be pleased - most babies don’t see many men regularly apart form their dad/close relatives.

And as pp has said it’s good to have role models - not reinforcing that child rearing is women’s work.

RebeccaCloud9 · 19/02/2022 10:25

Depends what. Toddler play group, Baby sensory session, pre school activities etc, totally fine. Would be a welcome change I think and may encourage more dads to attend. Good to have males in this role and setting.

Newborn support group/small baby stay and play/breastfeeding cafe type thing, no way. It would feel very 'mansplainy' I think, these are very much women's spaces for woman-to-woman support in the very early days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread