Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think of you really want to be financially independent you shouldn’t get married

34 replies

LovelyYellowLabrador · 18/02/2022 23:18

Been eating dirty John on Netflix and reading comments afterwards
Mainly along the lines of she should have remained independent
But surely if your married your not financially independent
I mean if your dh racks up loads of debt he’s going to take you down too ?

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 18/02/2022 23:51

Basically yes. Marriage only benefits the dependent partner (financially, I mean).

From a purely financial perspective if you have your own money its very risky getting married (which is why so many men are reluctant). It might make sense to pool resources for a house etc but its not worth the risk of getting into a situation where all your assets can be split down the middle and you could be on the hook for their debts.

If you're planning to be at home its an entirely different ballgame of course and then you'd be silly not to. But if you work and have assets its daft getting married.

amispeakingintongues · 18/02/2022 23:49

@TheMeditativeRose

Interdependence and team work is a thing.

DH and I earned about the same when we met.

I developed a chronic illness and no longer work. But I do my best to support him with things like cooking, organising our lives. He does the lion’s hate of the cleaning though.

Now he earns nearly eight times the amount he did when we met. He is very open about the fact he couldn’t do that without my support. He’s also very open about how much motivation he gets from the fact he sees it as his job to protect me financially as I am unable to work.

Now we are in a financial position in our mid forties that, even if we split up, we’d both be ok for life.

You can with trust and team work end up in a place you could never have ended up alone, even with challenging circumstances (in my case a decade of illness).

I once saw a contemporary dance piece that demonstrates that very clearly. It focussed on moves where the two dancers supported one another. It wasn’t about traditional lifts where the larger/stronger person lifted the smaller one. It was about balances and moving against one another in a supporting way. Each dancer was both supporter and supported, and in some movements/positions they were both supporting and supported at the same time.

If we’d both been pursuing our careers in the way we did when we met, we’d both progressed, but I doubt we’d be earning combined what DH earns himself.

Elizabeth Warren wrote a book called the Two Income Trap which looks at the pressures people feel in the modern world with stagnant wages and rising costs. Basically in the face of that it’s better to have one person who earns the family a lot of money and one person who saves the family a lot of money. It doesn’t have to be along traditional lines.

Given how hostile and competitive the world can be financially, especially at the moment, I think being part of a team makes a good life and financial independence more achievable, not less. As a society we’ve gone a bit too far down the road of individualist thinking. Life is easier and better when it’s not a case of everyone for themselves.

This is such a brilliant comment.
TheMeditativeRose · 18/02/2022 23:42

Interdependence and team work is a thing.

DH and I earned about the same when we met.

I developed a chronic illness and no longer work. But I do my best to support him with things like cooking, organising our lives. He does the lion’s hate of the cleaning though.

Now he earns nearly eight times the amount he did when we met. He is very open about the fact he couldn’t do that without my support. He’s also very open about how much motivation he gets from the fact he sees it as his job to protect me financially as I am unable to work.

Now we are in a financial position in our mid forties that, even if we split up, we’d both be ok for life.

You can with trust and team work end up in a place you could never have ended up alone, even with challenging circumstances (in my case a decade of illness).

I once saw a contemporary dance piece that demonstrates that very clearly. It focussed on moves where the two dancers supported one another. It wasn’t about traditional lifts where the larger/stronger person lifted the smaller one. It was about balances and moving against one another in a supporting way. Each dancer was both supporter and supported, and in some movements/positions they were both supporting and supported at the same time.

If we’d both been pursuing our careers in the way we did when we met, we’d both progressed, but I doubt we’d be earning combined what DH earns himself.

Elizabeth Warren wrote a book called the Two Income Trap which looks at the pressures people feel in the modern world with stagnant wages and rising costs. Basically in the face of that it’s better to have one person who earns the family a lot of money and one person who saves the family a lot of money. It doesn’t have to be along traditional lines.

Given how hostile and competitive the world can be financially, especially at the moment, I think being part of a team makes a good life and financial independence more achievable, not less. As a society we’ve gone a bit too far down the road of individualist thinking. Life is easier and better when it’s not a case of everyone for themselves.

Avarua · 18/02/2022 23:36

There's no such thing as financial independence while children are young. None. It is a fiction. The law is set up to protect the vulnerable party: the one who bears children.

It's fine to be independent if you don't have kids or dont anticipate kids. If you do, you're a mug thinking you're independent from their father.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 18/02/2022 23:34

Not necessarily, if the debt is solely in one partners name and can be proven to have not been incurred for the benefit of the family then it can be taken off of the split of assets so it's not shared, it would depend on how the debt was incurred and what proof exists.

There's definitely an argument for a childfree couple who both work and maintain separate finances remaining unmarried, but there are arguments for marriage in that situation too:

  • so that the other partner is next of kin in the event of illness
  • for inheritance purposes in the event of death and the transfer of any shared assets like property
  • just because they want to have that legally recognised relationship
LovelyYellowLabrador · 18/02/2022 23:25

Well say you have two people both work full time, no children but the dh has a drug habit or gambling addict or shopping addict and runs up thousands in debt he’s going to take her down too surely ? So even in these circumstance no kids both working full time you are not financially independent if your married ??
Or have I got it wrong ?

OP posts:
HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 18/02/2022 23:24

And I say that as the main earner. In my relationship I earn 4 times what my DH does, if we were to split it would be me paying maintenance/sharing my assets in the divorce, DH would have nothing to split.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 18/02/2022 23:23

My view is that if one partner in the relationship is going to have to be financially dependant on the other to facilitate childcare/the advancement of the other persons career then marriage/civil partnership is absolutely necessary to offer the dependent person some level of security.

If neither party will be financially dependent on the other then marriage is just a matter of preference.

sst1234 · 18/02/2022 23:22

Many men think the same. Hence the many posts from women on here complaining that the father of their children, someone they’ve live for a long time will not commit to marriage. Personally I think women gain from marriage more than they lose. I know it’s not quiet an equivalence but it’s more important that women stay self sufficient and independent after children, rather then relying on a partner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread