Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I worse off than someone on on UC??

166 replies

Underduvet33 · 18/02/2022 20:12

AIBU here to be annoyed? I recently heard someone say that they get £1300 in Universal credit per month and work 12hrs a week earning approx 300 pounds per month- plus they get all their childcare free as on UC plus require less childcare as only work 12 hours a week

That leaves them with 1600 to spend on rent etc (do they get help with this too??)

I don’t get any benefits I have 2 children in nursery full time- so I can work full time. Even with one of my children receiving 30 hours free - after childcare costs are deducted from my take home salary I’m left with 1100 a month to pay rent bills etc. i am in a good job with a good profession but it seems I’m worse off than someone on benefits?

Have I got this all wrong? If I quit my job worked and worked a small part time job claiming benefits of get more money per month in my pocket and spend more time with my kids?

I really think I must have misunderstood because I don’t get the impression that people on benefits are living the high life?

What have I misunderstood??? Were the numbers I told incorrect??

OP posts:
Bluffysummers · 19/02/2022 00:17

@Ponoka7

My DD has two children and has never got that. She got around £1k a month. You don't get any other money towards your rent, that's it. Your example is very lucky to have her child care covered, a lot of nurseries give set hours, if you are talking about her 15 free hours. Every two year old gets that. You don't get free childcare on UC, people on low incomes get 30 hours for a 3/4 year old.
@Ponoka7 just to say if you’re In work you don’t get 15 free hrs for 2 yrs olds x
Autumn42 · 19/02/2022 00:07

I had much more disposable income as a single parent on benefits and have friends who have since partnered up and same for them … I also until recently spent my entire salary on childcare…. we have to watch the pennies, I drive an old car and it’s been years since we’ve had a holiday. ….
However I now have a supportive husband and we own our own house with a mortgage, if I do a few extra hours we see the benefit of that whereas I lose 95% or any overtime when on benefits. i can also work in a role which requires me to do some hours which wouldn’t be covered by commercial childcare. Yes it is frustrating when it’s always assumed that families on UC are so much worse off than everyone else when that’s not always necessarily the case (the system just assumes a partners income is free for you to spend, completely ignoring the fact that your partner may have maintenance and general living costs of their other children to pay for, not to mention the things they feel they reasonably should be entitled to if their earning a decent salary) however I wouldn’t swap what I have now for that extra bit of disposable income

oviraptor21 · 18/02/2022 23:45

@Loveandlimpets

The thing about benefits though is that government policy could change at any time. People on benefits can never fully rely on it continuing as it currently is. You're far better off working.
The same could be said about work, especially in the current economic climate.

I assume the poster with higher rate DLA and £750 per month "spare" is using that money for the additional needs of the disabled child.

Lalala1 · 18/02/2022 23:42

@INeedNewShoes

Have u checked the benefits calculator online?
I’ve seen some people say they are better off staying on tax credits and that’s why the haven’t changed to UC but I think eventually everyone/most will have to change over

Bedsheets4knickers · 18/02/2022 23:41

Op keep working , benefits seem great when you have kids but once they've flown the nest you'll be glad you have kept your job

Bedsheets4knickers · 18/02/2022 23:39

@TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY

well im a single mother with a disabled child in a 3 bedroom(did have another son but hes recently moved out) my uc had different rules to normal uc as i cant work because im a carer and home educator(i know H.E s not a valid reason not to work but as i dont have a child in school and a single mother im his 24/7 carer)so i get left alone and dont have criteria to do

between us both via various benefits i get 2167 a month
before my other son moved out out it was an extra 685 a month on top

i also get 140 a year warm home front for the gas and 25 a week if its below 0

my rent is 500 and i get 480 which is included in the above amount, my council tax is fully paid, which i dont know how much a month is as its automatically paid to the council

quite Frankly i haven't worried about money since 2012 when my 17 y old was diagnosed at 8 then in 2015 my 11 y old was diagnosed at 5.

when my ex was living here(left sept 2020) between 2 adults on carers allowance and 2 kids on high dla and full rent and council tax paid we were getting 750 a week

where i live thats really good money

EDIT i read this back and im not boasting at all even though it sounds a very boasty, braggy post, im just saying it as it is as that's been/is my circumstances

No this really isn't a Braggy post
jellybeans · 18/02/2022 23:35

I very much doubt anyone in UC is well off. Plus you are at the mercy of constant changes, forced into unsuitable jobs etc. It is a pittance for most.

INeedNewShoes · 18/02/2022 23:30

I’m a single parent with 2 in primary school and I work about 19h a week.
I receive £1400 approx UC and £750 wage.

I'm a single parent to one primary age DC. I earn around £1000 pcm and only get £200pcm tax credits.

Whenever I read threads on UC I wonder if I'd be better off on UC than tax credits...

Lalala1 · 18/02/2022 23:18

@DeckTheHallsWithGin

You can see how it won’t be long before benefit claimants will be required to submit their dna so the absent fathers can be traced to pay towards their offspring.
What would having their DNA do? Even with their DNA absent fathers and even NRPs would still get away with not paying cms it would make no difference! Plus the fact that child maintenance isn’t calculated for UC.
MaryAndHerNet · 18/02/2022 23:15

Single parent to an 8nyear old.
I get £970 a month to live on.
Rent
Council tax
Electric
Etc
And it's gone.

The reason some get more in UC than others is rent. They'll pay up to the LHA allowance of whatever area the claimant is in. So for example, of I rented a home for 700, they'd pay maximum 575 towards it.
If I had childcare to pay, they'd pay up to 85% of that child care in arrears. I'd have to pay for the first.month and claim it back the month after.

EntitledTo will tell you if you can claim.
I did a calculation the other day for someone earning £2k amonth and they could claim 500 or so.

Pinksalty · 18/02/2022 23:05

I’m a single parent with 2 in primary school and I work about 19h a week.
I receive £1400 approx UC and £750 wage.
This includes housing element of £750 and my rent is £1000. I have a deduction on my council tax of approx £100p/m, but still pay £98 a month. I don’t pay any childcare, as I specifically chose my hours so I didn’t have to find childcare (no option for after/before school club as the waiting list is in years)
As I didn’t work for 10 years, I’ve started again at the bottom of the ladder career wise, but I’m working my way up and intend to be full time on a higher salary once my children are in academy and can be trusted before/after school.

Katya213 · 18/02/2022 22:51

I was working as a nurse full time with the hospital bank. Every month I was struggling to make ends meet, childcare costs, £800 rent ( I’m a single mum.) roll back to two years when the pandemic started, there were no bank positions as they had all their permanent staff on standby for covid, so I lost my job and had to go on universal credit.

I can honestly tell you, it was dire for me. I had no money for food. I got £1200 a month, £800 out of that to pay rent, water rates, tv license, heat and electricity. We were left with nothing, my grandmother had to help us with food every week. It was awful for me but got us out of a hole at the time.

Lovemusic33 · 18/02/2022 22:35

It is possible someone can get that much, it depends how much their rent is which will also depend on where they live. Rent in some areas is much higher than others.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 18/02/2022 22:33

@DeckTheHallsWithGin

You can see how it won’t be long before benefit claimants will be required to submit their dna so the absent fathers can be traced to pay towards their offspring.
Well I'd hope so. The unpaid CMS bill is in the billions.
DeckTheHallsWithGin · 18/02/2022 22:24

You can see how it won’t be long before benefit claimants will be required to submit their dna so the absent fathers can be traced to pay towards their offspring.

Piggyk2 · 18/02/2022 22:23

Your kids won't be in nursery forever OP and when they get to high school you will still have your professional job. Don't underestimate that thinking the grass is greener.

SaySomethingMan · 18/02/2022 22:23

I don’t know anyone personally in UC but have read countless on these threads and on other baby boards how much worse off people would be if they worked full time or upped their hours. The overwhelming majority in UC are (most likely) better off on it.

Embracelife · 18/02/2022 22:18

In long term.m you will be.much better off and have a pension
When dc are teenagers you will be laughing and off on nice holidays with them

Loveandlimpets · 18/02/2022 22:15

The thing about benefits though is that government policy could change at any time. People on benefits can never fully rely on it continuing as it currently is. You're far better off working.

MissMaple82 · 18/02/2022 22:12

You are being unreasonable. UC is different fir every person. She probably has high housing costs. It's really nine if your business, stop being so jealous of someone needing benefit support

RandomMess · 18/02/2022 22:11

One of your biggest assets is your pension tbh

FTEngineerM · 18/02/2022 22:09

but it seems I’m worse off than someone on benefits?

Financially in the short term yes.
But in reality in the long term you’re quids in.
You will be finished with nurser fees soon, or at least full time nursery fees anyway. You have a great job that will allow for progression and promotion so when they’re a bit older you won’t be earning minimum wage you can work half the amount of hours as them for the same money! That’s how I see it.
Someone who’s chosen to reduce hours and take a low paid part time job to max out on benefits isn’t going to be able to get a mortgage in 1/2/3 months time, are they?

I know it’s tough to save a deposit but if you could, when you can.. they can’t.
Then add in your pension, any additional company benefits like bupa private health care for you family.

LightfoldEngines · 18/02/2022 22:07

And OP has a lot of family support which I assume comes in handy when her DC are sick, her friend does not and that’s probably the biggest factor in only working 12 hours.

hibbledibble · 18/02/2022 22:00

Yanbu to be annoyed you are worse off working.

Are you using tax free childcare/childcare vouchers? Are you entitled to any UC, have you checked?

On the plus you do get career progression, and pension contribution. You are staying in the job market, which might be difficult to re-enter if you left. You are also setting a good example for your children by working, and they have the social and developmental benefits of attending nursery. You are doing great!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 18/02/2022 21:53

[quote Musereader]@Waxonwaxoff0 there is no minimum hours for the working tax credit element of UC, it works nothing like tax credits.

UC is all the elements you are entitled to added together, minus deductions for earnings and other things. There is no minimum hours for any element, no element added or taken off for working or not working. You have to be working to get childcare and a work allowance (money disregarded from wages) is allowed if you are working, that is all.[/quote]
I see. I'm still on the old style as when I did the calculator I'd be worse off by £100pm if I changed to UC.