Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I worse off than someone on on UC??

166 replies

Underduvet33 · 18/02/2022 20:12

AIBU here to be annoyed? I recently heard someone say that they get £1300 in Universal credit per month and work 12hrs a week earning approx 300 pounds per month- plus they get all their childcare free as on UC plus require less childcare as only work 12 hours a week

That leaves them with 1600 to spend on rent etc (do they get help with this too??)

I don’t get any benefits I have 2 children in nursery full time- so I can work full time. Even with one of my children receiving 30 hours free - after childcare costs are deducted from my take home salary I’m left with 1100 a month to pay rent bills etc. i am in a good job with a good profession but it seems I’m worse off than someone on benefits?

Have I got this all wrong? If I quit my job worked and worked a small part time job claiming benefits of get more money per month in my pocket and spend more time with my kids?

I really think I must have misunderstood because I don’t get the impression that people on benefits are living the high life?

What have I misunderstood??? Were the numbers I told incorrect??

OP posts:
lanbro · 19/02/2022 08:46

It's always best long term to be in employment. I live in an area with a high proportion of uc claimants, many don't work at all and can't understand those who do. I often wonder what will happen when their children have grown and they lose most of their income.

I employed a woman who at 29 had never worked and had 4 children. She was getting around £1400 in UC but when she started working for me it didn't drop by that much, and she obviously had her wage. She has since distanced herself from a group of friends who were mocking her for working and losing some benefits.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/02/2022 08:45

@TibetanTerrah

There's no point attacking me *@Piggyk2* - I never said UC was the high life. OP asked about being better off and I gave my perspective. Working two jobs to have the same disposable income - i.e. very little - as if I had a child and worked part time.

As I said, it is what it is. There's no envy from me.

Possibly, but then you don't have a child to support so there's probably a similar amount left at the end of the month either way. Kids aren't cheap.
Lifeisbeautiful01 · 19/02/2022 08:42

I totally support a benefit system but the truth is that when my children were both in childcare, I had far less disposable income than my best mate who worked a few hours a week and didn’t need childcare as much (both single parents). It was a long game though and by staying in work my financial outlook now is far better.

Smallkeys · 19/02/2022 08:42

Yup it’s the longer term , career aspirations and pensions where your employer pays in . Getting out able to meet people and all that. Sure some people with kids do get a fair amount but it still comes at a cost in other ways. I always felt the worse place to be is single and on benefits pretty sure you get barely anything.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 19/02/2022 08:40

@INeedNewShoes

*I’m a single parent with 2 in primary school and I work about 19h a week. I receive £1400 approx UC and £750 wage.*

I'm a single parent to one primary age DC. I earn around £1000 pcm and only get £200pcm tax credits.

Whenever I read threads on UC I wonder if I'd be better off on UC than tax credits...

Are you sure that's right? I earn exactly the same you and I'm on tax credits. You should be getting the maximum amount of child tax credits which is about £63pw, plus a small amount of working tax credits. I get £42pw WTC.
hupfpferd · 19/02/2022 08:39

My colleague gets a hefty payment from UC every month and is definitely better off than I am.

This is because I am lucky enough to have a mortgage.

if you rent and you earn less then about £30k you seem to be better off on UC.

CayrolBaaaskin · 19/02/2022 08:36

I think it’s helpful to discuss these issues. They are really important to us single mums.

I worked in the city making low six figures when dds were young. I needed to pay for a nanny so I could do my job. Commuting costs and rent were huge. I paid loads in tax and had to pay back my child benefits. It was a really tough time because I was so busy and stressed and exhausted at the end of the week.
Shortly after that I lost my job and ended up on jsa and tax credits. I wasn’t actually that much worse off financially because my outgoings decreased so much. And I had way more time with dds and when they went to nursery some me time.

Not sure if I have a point beyond sharing my experience. I suppose just that we should drop stereotypes and look at facts. If we were to incentivize people to work more maybe more help with childcare or tax deductions for all childcare. That said, I don’t actually think we should encourage single mums to work full time - it’s incredibly difficult and not worth it imo. I suppose it has been helpful to my career that I didn’t give it up though and benefits me long term

dottydodah · 19/02/2022 08:34

I really feel uncomfortable reading these threads TBH.There seems a rather nasty undervibe to many posts ,suggesting that people on benefits (Of which many are ,due to circumstances beyond their control)should have the very bare minimum,while those of us able to be in work should be living the high life! Surely the whole point of a democratic society should be providing support for those on hard times? No one knows if they may be in such a position in the future !

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 08:23

There's no point attacking me @Piggyk2 - I never said UC was the high life. OP asked about being better off and I gave my perspective. Working two jobs to have the same disposable income - i.e. very little - as if I had a child and worked part time.

As I said, it is what it is. There's no envy from me.

Piggyk2 · 19/02/2022 08:18

[quote TibetanTerrah]@Piggyk2 I'm 34, if I can stretch to a place alone I'm not doing a houseshare. I DO work two jobs thanks. I've looked at 'cheaper areas' but whilst it would be bigger, it wouldn't be that much/any cheaper than what I'm paying now as my place is so small, plus the added cost of commuting further to my jobs.

None of what you've said is relevant to my post though, that if I happened to have a child, even one I only had 50% of the time, I could get the majority of my rent paid by UC for a place 4 times bigger than where I live now. It is what it is.[/quote]
UC often sell the rent element but they give you less money to live off of compared to the old system!

It is very relevant you just don't want to hear it. How can you be sure of what you would get from UC? It goes on you your salary.
I used to get £820 from my wage and 680 from UC which includes my rent. Its hardly the high life is it for TWO people???

I wouldn't envy people on UC because it's cones with part time work, lack 9f childcare quite often and a lot of other things your too ignorant to acknowledge.

ByHook0rByCrook · 19/02/2022 08:09

I think my favourite bit of benefit bashing was when my dc's father informed me he would no longer pay the mortgage because he found out how much UC I was receiving- to help care for our disabled dc. I was working part time at the time, and it made me realise I needed to scramble to get the mortgage in my name to protect my dc from their feckless, selfish father and keep a roof over their heads, because he certainly didn't give a fuck.

Luckily I managed to find full-time work from home and have subsequently been able to sort out financial independence since then but fucking hell. The cold-heartedness displayed in threads like this is nothing compared to fathers like him.

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 08:03

@Piggyk2 I'm 34, if I can stretch to a place alone I'm not doing a houseshare. I DO work two jobs thanks. I've looked at 'cheaper areas' but whilst it would be bigger, it wouldn't be that much/any cheaper than what I'm paying now as my place is so small, plus the added cost of commuting further to my jobs.

None of what you've said is relevant to my post though, that if I happened to have a child, even one I only had 50% of the time, I could get the majority of my rent paid by UC for a place 4 times bigger than where I live now. It is what it is.

Piggyk2 · 19/02/2022 07:51

@TibetanTerrah

I'll get flamed but I am definitely worse off than someone on UC. I'm single with no children and get no benefits and pay extortionate private rent for a tiny studio. In principle I could go out and have a one night stand, get pregnant and id be entitled to most of my rent covered for a much bigger flat. Fortunately I have no interest in being a parent so I won't be doing that Wink

I must say it was worse when Labour were in power though. I knew two people who lived alone, no children, in expensive parts of London (Balham and Islington) who had their rent covered and only worked part time for "pocket money". Meanwhile I was working full time on just above minimum wage with a 3hr daily commute as I couldn't afford to live in London. i was very glad when the tories came in and both of those people were told they'd only get housing benefit to cover a houseshare, although my male friend suddenly found a girlfriend and got her pregnant in a matter of weeks Hmm

You are a SINGLE person. This alone gives you options which equivalent to money. Move to a cheaper area... and save.

Live in a house share. Work 2 jobs.

There's no way that as a single person I would be paying extortionate private rent.

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 19/02/2022 07:48

Working is always better, short term some people have a few extra quid in their pockets but long term they can end up with fewer options, less likely to have a career to grow and less financial independence.
Work always pays!

neverbeenskiing · 19/02/2022 07:40

@LizziesTwin I completely agree. Not my circus, not my monkeys though.

LizziesTwin · 19/02/2022 07:36

@neverbeenskiing Your SIL is daft as she’d be better off long term building up her pension and having more chance of being promoted. Short term rather than long term thinking.

Piggyk2 · 19/02/2022 07:34

@Aaaabbbcccc

If people are working 12 hrs a week why are they not working full time like the rest of us?
The government will only cover approx £640 per month on UC in childcare for one child. If you put pen to paper and look at the prices of playschemes they are on average £40 per day times that by 5 its £200 a week..... times that by 4 is £800 a month.
neverbeenskiing · 19/02/2022 07:15

Yes if you are a single parent on let’s say for arguments sake minimum wage you are better off working part time than full time. The system is so messed up

SIL is a single parent, with one child in primary school and works 16 hours a week. Her work offered her a promotion which would mean working full time and she turned it down, because she wouldn't be any better off than she is currently with her wage being topped up by benefits. Her exact words were "only a mug would work 37.5 hours a week when they can work 16 for the same money!"

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 02:28

I'll get flamed but I am definitely worse off than someone on UC. I'm single with no children and get no benefits and pay extortionate private rent for a tiny studio. In principle I could go out and have a one night stand, get pregnant and id be entitled to most of my rent covered for a much bigger flat. Fortunately I have no interest in being a parent so I won't be doing that Wink

I must say it was worse when Labour were in power though. I knew two people who lived alone, no children, in expensive parts of London (Balham and Islington) who had their rent covered and only worked part time for "pocket money". Meanwhile I was working full time on just above minimum wage with a 3hr daily commute as I couldn't afford to live in London. i was very glad when the tories came in and both of those people were told they'd only get housing benefit to cover a houseshare, although my male friend suddenly found a girlfriend and got her pregnant in a matter of weeks Hmm

jellybeans · 19/02/2022 01:45

@Aaaabbbcccc

If people are working 12 hrs a week why are they not working full time like the rest of us?
  1. Are you a single parent? It is a whole different ball game stress wise.
  2. They may have health problems or caring responsibilities.
  3. Stats show a large number of mums (and more dads now) work part time or not at all. So no, not everyone 'works full time'.
  4. Often they are worse off by doing more hours or come out the same but for more stress and childcare problems.
  5. Who is to say '40 hours' is the magic number we should all be aspiring to. It has changed over time and cultures. For many it does not cover the bills. People with lower paid jobs (often lone parents) often have less flexibility and autonomy. Not easy with childcare.
  6. Covid has made things very hard for single parents with constant school closures etc.
  7. Most single parents work or have a good reason not to.

Yes I am a working lone parent but am lucky my job is a bit flexible. But it has been a nightmare with covid and school closures, after school club closing etc. I do 2/3 'fulltime' and happy with that as the other parent opts to not be involved at all so I have to do everything single handedly. When I was partnered up it was a doddle even with a useless exH!

Aaaabbbcccc · 19/02/2022 01:33

If people are working 12 hrs a week why are they not working full time like the rest of us?

kazillionaire · 19/02/2022 01:07

Just to clarify, by fair I meant that a loan should not be taken as income but in the world of uc it is

kazillionaire · 19/02/2022 01:06

Single parent here, my uc is 205 per month and child benefit is 34 per week because I am a student and I receive 501 per month student loan, yes loan which has to be paid back - how is that fair? I also have a mortgage and two children and that is my total income, doesn’t really inspire people to better themselves does it?

ScrollingLeaves · 19/02/2022 00:53

A terrible stumbling block with UC is when you have a part time job, say self-employed, that pays in a lump some after a period of time rather than weekly/monthly.

For example, (using made up figures but so you understand the principle) if you can earn fifty pounds a week without losing your UC and you are paid that within a certain time ( a month?) You will be OK. For example A has had no more than £200 that month and will continue to get UC.

But if you get a lump sum after three months you run into problems. For example, B has done some editing work over 3 months and gets paid £500. That will be seen as having been earned over one month not three months and as being £300 over the month’s limit.

Back pay coming as a lump some also Cayuses problems.

This could mean your UC is stopped and it takes all sorts of form filling and 5 weeks to get it set up again. A debt causing nightmare.

Graphista · 19/02/2022 00:33

Have I got this all wrong?

Yes!

Insofar as you are directing your anger at the wrong person to blame

Benefits bashing is tiresome, arrogant and shows you don't understand who is TRULY to blame for your own struggles!

Clue: it isn't those of us on benefits! It's the extremely wealthy paying fuck all taxes who are in power and who are keeping housing prices high and wages low!

Don't fall for their misleading myths, don't be party to their blame game

Biggest factor is always rent. Who benefits from that - Landlords.

Exactly!

Which includes a number of mps inc the new housing minister who voted AGAINST legislation that would have meant landlords were required to ensure housing was fit for human habitation!

Half of these problems would be solved if every man who fathers a child is made to pay for that child!

They'd certainly be much better off than they are now!

It's shameful how bad we are at enforcing this as a country

Plus the fact that child maintenance isn’t calculated for UC.

This came about BECAUSE so many men don't pay cm!

When I was 1st on benefits whether he paid or not the amount he was SUPPOSED to pay was deducted from my and dds benefits. As a result I often went without food and other essentials to ensure that dd didn't