Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I worse off than someone on on UC??

166 replies

Underduvet33 · 18/02/2022 20:12

AIBU here to be annoyed? I recently heard someone say that they get £1300 in Universal credit per month and work 12hrs a week earning approx 300 pounds per month- plus they get all their childcare free as on UC plus require less childcare as only work 12 hours a week

That leaves them with 1600 to spend on rent etc (do they get help with this too??)

I don’t get any benefits I have 2 children in nursery full time- so I can work full time. Even with one of my children receiving 30 hours free - after childcare costs are deducted from my take home salary I’m left with 1100 a month to pay rent bills etc. i am in a good job with a good profession but it seems I’m worse off than someone on benefits?

Have I got this all wrong? If I quit my job worked and worked a small part time job claiming benefits of get more money per month in my pocket and spend more time with my kids?

I really think I must have misunderstood because I don’t get the impression that people on benefits are living the high life?

What have I misunderstood??? Were the numbers I told incorrect??

OP posts:
babycornfortea · 19/02/2022 20:47

I met up with an old uni friend this week. She has two kids, single parent but gets fairly good maintenance from the dad and has wealthy parents. She says she gets around £3000 in UC a month, including rent and childcare costs... she also said she might consider going back to work in about six months or so, her second child has just turned 3, but that she only wanted part time work that fitted in with school hours, as she's loved being with her kids and doesn't want to miss them growing up, and why should she when she's far better off on UC.

As a contrast, I too am a single parent, I work full time as a teacher and earn nowhere near that amount, less than £2k after tax etc, despite nearly killing myself in the process with stress, and barely seeing my child who has been full time childcare from 9 months, that I have paid for by myself. I get £6.27 a week from the father in CMS, and because I was stupid enough to save up money since I started working after uni, I am entitled to child benefit and child benefit only.

How is that fair?

Graphista · 19/02/2022 20:16

@MaryAndHerNet oh thank you

It's so easy for people who've never lived on under £1000 a month to moan that £1000 a month is loads.

So true

I've not had ch on all winter too expensive. I use a wee space heater and I'm mostly in bed with hot water bottle too

If you are a single household even a good salary doesn’t go far . Everyone know that single living costs so much more than living with a partner .

True Mse/Martin Lewis recently posted about this on sm

Are we due a government statement on UC credit cuts ? Are government interns trying to set the tone with middle income mums to lambast those less fortunate?

I wouldn't be surprised

XenoBitch · 19/02/2022 20:05

@Schlerp

What’s with all the benefits bashing/OMG someone is getting something I don’t from the government posts?

Are we due a government statement on UC credit cuts ? Are government interns trying to set the tone with middle income mums to lambast those less fortunate?

This.

Seen a lot lately. I must be doing UC wrong. Some "glamorous" lifestyle I lead on the £640 a month I claim.

Schlerp · 19/02/2022 19:47

What’s with all the benefits bashing/OMG someone is getting something I don’t from the government posts?

Are we due a government statement on UC credit cuts ? Are government interns trying to set the tone with middle income mums to lambast those less fortunate?

Smallkeys · 19/02/2022 19:42

If you are a single household even a good salary doesn’t go far . Everyone know that single living costs so much more than living with a partner .

MaryAndHerNet · 19/02/2022 19:39

Typos here: It's so easy for people who've never lived in under £1000 a month to loan that £1000 a month is loads.

My fingers are cold, I'm at home, under a duvet and sleeping bag, can't afford heating. I'll retype it:

It's so easy for people who've never lived on under £1000 a month to moan that £1000 a month is loads.

MaryAndHerNet · 19/02/2022 19:38

Graphista

I've nothing to say really, but I want to say yay for your posts. Very good very good.

It's so easy for people who've never lived in under £1000 a month to loan that £1000 a month is loads.

Graphista · 19/02/2022 19:15

@LightfoldEngines it was even harder in real life to not exclaim/laugh/even rage when dealing with people - who in several cases had spent YEARS openly looking down their noses at me! Coming to me to ask for advice and help because they had NO idea how it all worked.

I think the most shocked person was the one who said to me they weren't going to claim yet even though they could because they had enough to last them a month of outgoings and were confident they would find another job in that time having worked for the same employer for 25 years in a low paid entry level role.

Their response when I pointed out to them that for starters there was at least the 5 ww to consider, but that there was also huge backlogs because there were so many new claimants so the reality was more like 2-3 months, was quite something - they genuinely thought I was having them on! Then I pointed out that this also meant there were a lot of other people ALSO desperately job hunting at this time. Again they were sceptical.

The phone call ended

They then spent that evening looking up the 5ww and backlog info and learning that yes it was real, and also on job sites seeing that there were few jobs available, none in their industry (hospitality) and coming to the realisation they were up against applicants who were younger but also had more experience and qualifications in other industries that were still hiring.

They called me the next day and basically ranted at me about it all - even though I of course didn't make the rules or create the circumstances!

It took them almost 11 months to find a new job and even then it was part time and lower paid. They're still looking for something full time and better pay and conditions now around a year later.

To say they've had a rude awakening is a HUGE understatement

What's very amusing is they've gone from "tories have their faults but they are good for the economy and working people" on sm to

"Fuck the tories and UC and fat cat ceos who don't pay decent wages" Grin

As I said...interesting

And don't even get them started on energy price rises and how the govt handled that!

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 19:10

@Graphista Kent. The size of my entire flat inc bathroom and kitchen is roughly the size of my DM's bedroom in her modest three bed. It really is small. It's hard for people to get their heads around unless they see it! There was a thread running a while ago talking about London 'crash pad' type micro-flats. Posters saying it's impossible to live like that but here we are, I do. My rent is £600 a month, with bills to go on top of course, but with covid making the market competitive and pushing rents up anyway, even if I moved to the cheaper seaside towns 15-20 miles away I wouldn't get anything for less than that and would make getting to my two jobs next to impossible. As I say, it is what it is.

Feelingnotatallok · 19/02/2022 19:00

BigPurpleEgg
You say that you wouldnt be any better off if you worked ..so you 'dont and wont..' go back to.work until you return to your teaching job which could be done p/t....
but work is contributing to system.. so you are happy for others to support you to stay.at home... genuinley??
Since when was this ok to.choose this as a lifestyle...
.

Graphista · 19/02/2022 19:00

@LightfoldEngines did you see those threads too? They were really quite astonishing!

"But dds horse riding lessons aren't a luxury it's exercise"

"But the £000's of savings I have are earmarked for a house deposit/holiday/new car next year"

"But surely they can't really expect us to stop having hobbies"

Are all comments (I may be paraphrasing slightly but the gist is very accurate) I remember reading on those threads!

Totally not living in the real world

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:55

@TibetanTerrah thanks for the compliment but I find it hard to believe even 4 times bigger roughly where do you live?

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:54

What do people mean when they say this though? Many people working full time receive UC because they don't get paid enough. How many hours is acceptable to work for you to be "worthy" of getting UC?

Excellent point

Because frankly being poor or not isn't about morals or lack thereof but about the personal circumstances one finds themselves in, in the vast majority of cases through no fault of one's own. Also morality measurements/judgment seem to be applied FAR more to the poor - who are pretty powerless to change their circumstances - than to the rich - who often DO have the power to change not only their own circumstances but that of others

Would he not just be expected to pay CSM calculated maintenance?

Wow! Do you really thing that's ALL nrps should pay?

If his name is still on the mortgage it's still also an asset for him, childcare if he works too then why shouldn't he pay half/for when he's at work and therefore unable to have the dc? These are joint dc you don't leave/divorce your kids (although many nrps act like it!)

"Better off in work" means better off for your specific circumstances.

No in most cases it means more income WITHOUT accounting for increased outgoings

That's obviously not a like for like comparison!

Agree with that - a lot of that on this thread!

Don't forget to factor in the cost of getting to work.

Glad you mentioned this but it's just one potential cost of working

Sometimes you can be technically better off working more, but the difference is swallowed up by work related expenses.

That's a relief to see

Not to make it so that every single person in work has a better living standard than every single person on benefits.

But here I have to reluctantly agree with the "bashers"

It SHOULD be the case that working offers a better lifestyle than not working. Not because it's morally better but because that simply seems fair and right.

Where the "bashers" and I disagree is that the way to achieve this is NOT to penalise benefits claimants (who are often barely managing, didn't choose to be claimants, have zero power to change things for either themselves or the "bashers")

The correct and best way to achieve this is better wages, better working conditions, more flexible employment options, better childcare provision and better social care provision so that people with additional challenges to working but who could work can do so.

Two things I think would actually solve a LOT of problems (unemployment, economy issues, work/life balance for population, health of population) are -

1 To have the maximum working week be something like 30 hours. That way employees aren't getting frazzled and their health and relationships being affected, there'd be more jobs available as the work still needs to be done and so there'd be more people in work and earning, most working class and lower middle class people spend rather than hoard their money so there's the economy boost.

2 have an actual living wage, I reckon around £12 an hour. Again those on lower level wages tend to spend rather than save, economy would be stimulated, people would be less stressed which is healthier.

As they said we wernt entitled to anything which is fair enough.

Is it though?

Not everyone is in healthy and fair relationships financially. The one claim per couple nonsense really screws those in abusive relationships, in relationships with addicts or even "just" in relationships with someone who isn't good managing money. Also it's funny how the state treat you "as if you are married" only when it BENEFITS

them to do so!

although still my older children don’t get full entitlement to uni loans because of my partners income

See I think that is wrong. You and their father's income should be included and you both should be helping out your dc as much as you can, your partner shouldn't be held liable for the costs of the dc, same applies when they're younger too imo. BUT this would only work IF nrps were paying reasonable amounts of cm and this was enforced (and yes I see your partner also pays cm - even more reason why he shouldn't ALSO be held liable for your dc, their father should be covering half their costs)

Those that moan about how much you get on UC have never actually experienced it.

Very much my experience too, see my comments on those who due to the pandemic ARE now claimants

You are assumed to be fraudulent from the outset

Yes this really pisses me off! The vast majority of claimants are ordinary honest people just trying to get by

But I have looked at it, and if I had a child I could work a lot less with basically the same amount of disposable income.

But you likely haven't accounted for the costs of said child. If you don't have dc chances are you have no idea of all the costs and practicalities involved!

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 18:51

@Graphista you talk a lot of sense on threads, but I said four times bigger than I live now, not four times more expensive.

Considering I live in basically a shoebox of a studio flat, so no separate bedroom/living area, with not even room for a sofa, a television or a desk, I think I can safely say that a lot of one bedroom flats would be four times the size. As there is also a lower limit on rents, it still costs a fair chunk of money to live here, i.e. somehow going even smaller doesn't really mean cheaper iyswim.

Other than that, I agree with everything you said Smile

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:51

@DogsAndGin - and did you ALSO calculate what their outgoings would be? I think not!

Eg what was the rent? Gotta be at least half of that and that's based on rent where I am which is one of the cheapest housing areas in the country!

£1600 for 4 people to live on is fuck all!

Plus you can't just choose to have 2 adults not working, at least one of them would be having to job search while claiming.

Yep - and job hunting costs too!

plus my job is really flexible.

Makes a huge difference

It's easily swallowed up by needing office clothes and to look more put together than when I had a rubbish kitchen job.

Things like this also make a difference

@Butterbegood ahh you started off so well! Not all children raised by parents on benefits are work shy and lacking in ambition. Many do all they can to "escape" but it's certainly not made easy for them!

although every time I did some overtime my housing benefit had to be reassessed and was usually messed up which made it a bit of an admin nightmare

For many it's not just an admin nightmare but leaves them in dire financial straits

I STILL hate having to make changes cos they never seem to get done as smoothly as they're supposed to be and UC was originally intended (not under the tories) to be a more flexible and responsive way of benefits working BECAUSE the legacy system was a nightmare that way but that's not what's happened is it?

And if you're on a very tight budget with vulnerable people to consider the security of knowing what you've got coming in really helps a lot.

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:50

Shortly after that I lost my job and ended up on jsa and tax credits. I wasn’t actually that much worse off financially because my outgoings decreased so much.

See - working also has costs shocker!

If we were to incentivize people to work more maybe more help with childcare or tax deductions for all childcare

The vast majority of people WANT to work!

Lack of childcare, unreasonable working conditions/hours, lack of jobs, lack of employers who are actually willing to make adjustments so that potential employees CAN work for them (flexible hours, wfh, adjustments for disability, adjustments for those with caring responsibilities...), employers who expect employees to do the work of 2/3 people rather than EMPLOYING more staff...

All these things (and I'm sure there's other things too) contribute to people who COULD be working not being able to.

I am mostly housebound and I had HOPED that with the pandemic revealing that many jobs CAN be done as wfh I'd be able to find at least something part time/flexible wfh...nope! Because the vast majority of employers STILL don't trust wfh as a viable option and expect employees to go into "hq" at least one full day a week.

The flexibility and understanding they were really forced to show during the pandemic has all but vanished.

Plus tbh a lot of businesses went under with the perfect storm of brexit + pandemic + lack of real support from the govt especially small businesses

A number of my friends and family who worked from the age of 16/18 full time until the pandemic - around my age so we're talking 30 odd years! Have suddenly and very unexpectedly found themselves out of work as even larger seemingly stable companies have gone under too and they are overwhelmed trying to navigate the benefits system (I've had umpteen conversations along the lines of

"they [govt] can't seriously expect us to live on £x"

"yes they can and have done for years, this is what those of us on benefits have had to manage on for a long time"

"Graph I'm so sorry [for previous negative comments/attitude towards benefit claimants] I had no idea!"

At which point I've had to bite my tongue SO hard not to say "well I and others DID tell you but you wouldn't believe us!")

It's been...interesting!

LightfoldEngines · 19/02/2022 18:40

@Graphista

4 times bigger than where I live now.

Utter rubbish! There are limits on housing costs that are paid in benefits

The cold-heartedness displayed in threads like this is nothing compared to fathers like him.

Agreed and the ignorance

As I said, it is what it is. There's no envy from me.

Aye right!

No one knows if they may be in such a position in the future !

Absolutely! I always say on these threads life CAN turn on you

At 30 I was married, healthy, working in a good decent paid job, by 35 I was a divorced single mum with a disability

There were a couple of threads at start of lockdown posted by people suddenly out of work and not being paid - this was before furlough etc came in - complaining and claiming that THEY should be treated better than "other" benefits claimaints because they were claiming due to Covid which was beyond their control. As if other claimants had deliberately chosen their circumstances just for the hell of it! There was one in particular who very vocally complained about being expected to use her savings (in excess of £20k iirc) to live on because it was in her mind set aside for a house deposit and she should have been allowed to keep it aside for this AND claim benefits.

She rightly got her arse handed to her and then...quelle surprise she had the thread deleted!

A few were genuinely shocked at how low the amounts were and the rules on savings and were indignant until those of us well used to being on benefits pointed out we'd had to accept that for years, decades even in some cases.

They also sometimes got huffy if we pointed out (in the genuine spirit of helping!) where they could make cuts to their outgoings, how they could reduce costs via loyalty cards, cash back schemes etc

I remember one being very insulted that I had said she should be getting her dcs back to school stuff in the supermarket or somewhere like Wilkos rather than the extortionately expensive WH Smith's!

The entitlement of these posters was quite something to behold!

It did make for some rather brilliant entertainment.

The ignorance was astounding.

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:38

4 times bigger than where I live now.

Utter rubbish! There are limits on housing costs that are paid in benefits

The cold-heartedness displayed in threads like this is nothing compared to fathers like him.

Agreed and the ignorance

As I said, it is what it is. There's no envy from me.

Aye right!

No one knows if they may be in such a position in the future !

Absolutely! I always say on these threads life CAN turn on you

At 30 I was married, healthy, working in a good decent paid job, by 35 I was a divorced single mum with a disability

There were a couple of threads at start of lockdown posted by people suddenly out of work and not being paid - this was before furlough etc came in - complaining and claiming that THEY should be treated better than "other" benefits claimaints because they were claiming due to Covid which was beyond their control. As if other claimants had deliberately chosen their circumstances just for the hell of it! There was one in particular who very vocally complained about being expected to use her savings (in excess of £20k iirc) to live on because it was in her mind set aside for a house deposit and she should have been allowed to keep it aside for this AND claim benefits.

She rightly got her arse handed to her and then...quelle surprise she had the thread deleted!

A few were genuinely shocked at how low the amounts were and the rules on savings and were indignant until those of us well used to being on benefits pointed out we'd had to accept that for years, decades even in some cases.

They also sometimes got huffy if we pointed out (in the genuine spirit of helping!) where they could make cuts to their outgoings, how they could reduce costs via loyalty cards, cash back schemes etc

I remember one being very insulted that I had said she should be getting her dcs back to school stuff in the supermarket or somewhere like Wilkos rather than the extortionately expensive WH Smith's!

The entitlement of these posters was quite something to behold!

Graphista · 19/02/2022 18:36

If people are working 12 hrs a week why are they not working full time like the rest of us?

Are you really that lacking in imagination?

Lack of work (there really aren't as many jobs available as the right wing claim, plus as a single parent you have to find a job that works around childcare - that means you generally can't work before 9 or after 5, evenings, weekends, bank holidays etc)

Lack of childcare

Lack of decent public transport to where the jobs are

Jobs have ridiculously too high entry requirements

All sorts of reasons

In principle I could go out and have a one night stand, get pregnant and id be entitled to most of my rent covered for a much bigger flat.

But you'd also have higher costs with a child - you seem to have conveniently "forgotten" that aspect

Re "better off in work" calculations usually only look at the difference in income!

They don't account for commuting costs, childcare above what you might be able to claim for, clothes, shoes and equipment you may need to get, if there aren't decent storage options for lunch you're likely buying lunch at work, the loss of things like free prescriptions (not the case in Scotland thankfully)

It's not just about more income

@LizziesTwin the sil isn't "daft" she is trying to cope NOW it's incredibly hard and stressful being a single parent, sometimes you do make short term decisions that aren't ideal for the long term as that's what works for you right now!

Work always pays!

No it really doesn't!

It should - but it doesn't

And when I say should I mean wages should be actual LIVING wages not the crappy nmw we have now that even a single adult with no kids can't afford to live independently on!

And AGAIN it's not benefit claimants keeping wages low, it's those who are doing MUCH better and have the power to change things - CEO's, mps, high level civil servants etc

Piggyk2 · 19/02/2022 15:56

[quote TibetanTerrah]@Piggyk2 The same could be said for you. You have no idea how much I earn, how much my bills are, how many hours a week I have to work (hint: it's a lot) and how much money I have left after paying everything.

I'm not suggesting anyone on UC gets 'too much', and have never said that. But I have looked at it, and if I had a child I could work a lot less with basically the same amount of disposable income.

I would also point out before you start name calling yet again, that if I thought having a child and being on UC was that easy, I'd just go and get pregnant. It's not easy. But my life isn't either. It's not a race to the bottom, I simply answered the OP with the facts of my actual life, not what I 'think'.[/quote]
You couldn't just leave it could you?

I have no idea how much you earn... you started comparing first. I replied and told you how it was which was factually not based upon your "thoughts".

I wasnt born a mother and I too have worked 60 hours each week even whilst pregs.

Have you actually read my posts? Have you? Because even the GOV will ONLY fund childcare to a certain point.... so once you have kids.... you can't just think I'll work 5 days sometimes it isn't possible money wise. On UC you pay all your UC UPFRONT it's a struggle juggling everything.

I have done both so I can give you a 2 sided view.

I never named called. You yourself said your opinion was unpopular... and continued to speak upon others situations.

Do t shoot the messenger. I'll let you have the last word!

TibetanTerrah · 19/02/2022 13:36

@Piggyk2 The same could be said for you. You have no idea how much I earn, how much my bills are, how many hours a week I have to work (hint: it's a lot) and how much money I have left after paying everything.

I'm not suggesting anyone on UC gets 'too much', and have never said that. But I have looked at it, and if I had a child I could work a lot less with basically the same amount of disposable income.

I would also point out before you start name calling yet again, that if I thought having a child and being on UC was that easy, I'd just go and get pregnant. It's not easy. But my life isn't either. It's not a race to the bottom, I simply answered the OP with the facts of my actual life, not what I 'think'.

dangermouseisace · 19/02/2022 12:17

I’ve gone from benefits to full time work, with kids. I don’t know if I’m better off (was on sickness benefit) but I do not care. It’s so much less stressful to be able to pay the rent independently. To not be worried about that brown envelope. And then there’s contribution to a pension, career progression etc. Being on benefits isn’t the high life, it’s a safety net but a “hostile environment”. You are assumed to be fraudulent from the outset.

Danikm151 · 19/02/2022 11:58

Those that moan about how much you get on UC have never actually experienced it.
It’s all based on an individual’s circumstances, an amount is deducted from your UC depending on how much you earn.
If you rent you can earn £335 before UC reduced more if you don’t have housing costs. Then 55p is taken from UC for each £1. You’re still paying tax and NI and paying into the system you are receiving help from.

£1500 a month might be great for some but for someone that has a car/financial payments/childcare it doesn’t stretch as far.

Piggyk2 · 19/02/2022 11:50

@TibetanTerrah

There's no point attacking me *@Piggyk2* - I never said UC was the high life. OP asked about being better off and I gave my perspective. Working two jobs to have the same disposable income - i.e. very little - as if I had a child and worked part time.

As I said, it is what it is. There's no envy from me.

I'm not attacking you. Your ill informed. You have no actually real life experience of UC personally I gave you mine which is factual nit what you "think".
Autumn42 · 19/02/2022 10:50

@OrganisedChaos22

I guess it varies.

When I was a lone parent, working 20 hours a week with tax credits / housing benefit around £700 pm plus wages I was comfortable. And enough to save for driving lessons take ds away etc
It change to UC and it went up by 240! To £940pcm

I met dh. When he moved in I notified them. He was in a crap job then rubbish wage. £1000 pcm, Plus my 20 hours. But we were so much worse off. Despite it being 1 household pot. As they said we wernt entitled to anything which is fair enough. So although the 'money' was the same figure so to speak. We then had 2 cars to run out of it. His Csa for dsc, 2x fuel costs etc. Pay all the rent etc. So basically his wage covered his stuff and the rent that I originally had help with. Leaving not much. Then my wage covered food.

No holidays etc.

And yes it's the right thing to do but now I know why so many don't report a dp moving in etc. If I had done it illegally I would have still got £940 UC and my wage and we would have had his wage too.

Thankfully now he's in a better paid job after training etc.

Yes exactly the same when moved in with my partner, much of his salary went in csa payments, running his car and the bigger house we needed for when his children came to stay extra food etc and yet I lost all my tax credits so went from being comfortable to it being a struggle to afford the basics. If I hadn’t got a half decently paid job then it wouldn’t have been possible at all for us to live together. Now my older children have grown up it’s not such an impact, although still my older children don’t get full entitlement to uni loans because of my partners income but neither can expect him to subsidise them either