Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take away the Xbox for a week?

91 replies

Butterbegood · 18/02/2022 19:04

DS 12 has restricted time gaming and controls in his phone re: how long he can use the phone per day, and what he can do in it.
The last couple Of months that we have been battling re gaming time in particular. Today he was allowed a couple of hours as he’s in hols. Told him no more gaming , not on phone and not on Xbox today.
Found out he’s been on phone games plus downloaded new apps to his phone ( Tik Tok and others) that we’ve said no too.
This isn’t the first time that he’s got round controls to get more time or play games. He’s constant pushing boundaries but generally a good kid, does okay at school, plays sports etc
I told him he’d lose the Xbox for a week - DP is wondering if that’s too strict but given that this is about the 4th or 5th time he’s been caught like this I feel like he needs consequences.
Have tried explaining why he can’t have unlimited gaming time and unrestricted internet access but apparently we’re the worst parents in the world…
AIBU in taking his Xbox for a week and restricting the phone to calls and messaging only??

OP posts:
OnTheBenchOfDoom · 19/02/2022 09:21

I have sons who are now almost 19 and almost 16 and quite honestly I didn't really restrict their gaming etc. The rule was you put in effort with homework and school reports have to say you are applying yourself. However, we did have family dinners, watch TV shows together, play board games and they had a hobby they went to twice a week plus they both read before bed, it was expected. Ds2 still reads. So they had a variety of things as well as the gaming side which leads into a social side, gaming with friends and then conversations at school. But there were rules in place too. They had to come off when asked with no complaining and they both voluntarily got off when Dh came through the door after work to greet him or we returned with a Costco haul or supermarket shop. They helped put it away. They did chores (no pay) helped make dinner and cleared up after dinner.

I think if a parent is modelling reading, playing with the children, sewing or whatever, going out to hobbies it is one thing, if a parent is binge watching tv, on MN or Instagram etc then it is hypocritical to say to a child you have to read whilst we watch GOT or whatever.

I do think that 3 hours from Mon-Thurs is restrictive. He'll come out of school at what 3pm? He'll have some homework and then whatever his bedtime is. What does he do to entertain himself on evenings? But holidays are meant to be fun, let him game. My parents worked when we were children so we spent our holidays doing whatever we wanted, no direction from the parents. It was bliss.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 09:17

Thanks @Chuckles19 I find that reassuring…
Now if I could just find a way to get the little bugger to read for pleasure…

OP posts:
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 09:16

‘ He has 3 hours to use on gaming Mon -Thurs and choose when he plays.’

That’s 3 hours total across the week, not 3 hours a day ( unless he decides to use the 3 hours in one go, which has t happened yet!)

OP posts:
Chuckles19 · 19/02/2022 09:13

Absolutely do it. As a secondary teacher, I wish more parents would have harsher consequences around screen time, it really affect their ability to focus on anything that doesn’t involve a screen.

Since the closures we are really struggling with the behaviour of SOME children who have had extended time at home with few consequences or boundaries. It’s essential to follow through with consequences.

Also, so many are now far more obsessed with their devices than they were before the closures. Some of the boys talk about gaming non stop, I hear them saying how they sneak onto them at all hours. (Obviously, I am not talking about all children).

The kids may say they hate you now, but will thank you in the long run. It also makes the children more receptive to boundaries at school.

You sound like a fab mum!

ILiveInSalemsLot · 19/02/2022 09:04

He’s so much more pleasant on the nights where he knows he has no gaming time left and just hangs out and plays or does other stuff.

I found this too. As mine grew older and started to get more homework, they were able to focus on that better if there was no gaming to rush for.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 08:59

@RoseMartha
‘How long so you give him on school nights?’

He has 3 hours to use on gaming Mon -Thurs and choose when he plays. So he might play 2 nights or 3 nights shorter time. That actually works fine - not much fuss as most of his friends have similar restrictions in school nights or are just off busy with sports and clubs so not online.
He’s so much more pleasant on the nights where he knows he has no gaming time left and just hangs out and plays or does other stuff.

OP posts:
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 08:55

‘John Boy from the Walton’s’ 😄
That might be my favourite yet ! We’re trying to find a balance between online and offline for him. So that he reads books, plays outside, socialises IRL as well as using tech.
I don’t subscribe to the ‘everyone else has it so that’s okay’ line of parenting anyway. Tik Tok isnt harmless, no social media is harmless which is why most SM has age restrictions. And why SM is linked to the huge increase in mental health issues amongst young people.
With the kids I work with the happiest, well adjusted ones doing well or okay in school aren’t the ones who’s parents give them unlimited freedom and who are glued to their phones all day. I don’t think it’s a coincidence.
It is hard though. Hard to regulate and help kids find the balance while engaging with their peers via tech.

OP posts:
RoseMartha · 19/02/2022 08:53

@Butterbegood

How long so you give him on school nights?

I would suggest two hours on school nights and weekend and holidays are negotiable depending on what else you need to do. But more than the two hours.

You can say you have had two hours on the xbox you or we all go out and on your bike with your mates or we are going out to wherever and later you can go on the xbox again.

So you break it up a bit.

Does he get aggressive while on it or after?

What parental app do you use?
Certainly make sure he is off gaming and the phone in time to wind down for bed.

This will be an ongoing issue from now on really. All that my teen girls (13 and 14), want to do when at home is be on their phones. One does make up practice and experiments on different looks sometimes though.

I still have restrictions on their phones as we have had multiple issues with me having to call the police due to their usage despite having parental controls. Which I dont think is the norm. But my eldest has SN and just does not get done things no matter how many times it is explained by several people as well as me.

Fizzgigg · 19/02/2022 08:40

You need to loosen up and move with the times for your sons sake. He sounds like a good kid so stop trying to make him into John Boy from the Walton's. Let him have Tik Tok, it's harmless and most kids his age have it... do you want him to become a nerd... wouldn't it be worse if he didn't want modern things or friends but instead preferred stamp collecting on his own? You'd be wishing he was the opposite then...

This is so obnoxious. I mean, god forbid your child be a 'nerd' or liked things that aren't 'modern'. Seriously? You say that like it's an awful outcome or would make him an embarrassment of a child. Jesus. Race to the bottom or to be just like everyone else.

ILiveInSalemsLot · 19/02/2022 08:39

I have 2 teenage boys and they get 2hrs gaming each on weekends and school holidays. None during the school week. There’s no resentment and they’re happy.
Do what works best for your dcs.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 08:31

So anyone with kids this age - HOW much gaming time per day, school days and weekends, do you give your child?
And do they still get their activities done, homework done, eat dinner with you etc and have time for that as well as lots of screen time?

OP posts:
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 08:27

‘How can he go out with his friends when he can't arrange anything with them because he's not allowed his phone?

Why let him have a phone at all if that's the case? ‘
He has a phone - he can call and message as much as he likes, it’s apps and certain games that are restricted. He hasn’t actually ever lost his phone. We also live somewhere we’re many of his friends live around our street, and if he were to go to the park on any given day someone would be there too.

OP posts:
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 08:25

‘ YABU and you're being far too strict and old fashioned... I assume you're an older parent and don't understand how 12 year olds interact with each other in modern times. ’

  1. I’m not an older parent 2) I was and am a gamer 3) I work in Education with kids around that age!

Of course I understand that he socialises online, he also socialises offline when kicked of the devices. My issue is the time spent - there is ALWAYS someone online at any given time to play with but these kids are mainly from school so he sees them too
And 2) the sneaking around, disabling parental controls ( even tho he knows he’ll be caught) to download apps and game he’s been told he can’t have because of age restrictions.
Tried talking to him, and have tried self regulation but the issue is he will literally game for 6/7/8 hours given the choice. But when his limitedtime is up he goes off and does other things

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 19/02/2022 07:30

How can he go out with his friends when he can't arrange anything with them because he's not allowed his phone?

Why let him have a phone at all if that's the case?

I don't think you should remove the Xbox completely for the week but if you're firm on time allowed then stick with it.

DontWantTheRivalry · 19/02/2022 07:21

Although my son is only 8, so not comparable to dealing with teachers, we took his Xbox off him because he started getting really defiant towards his time restrictions and always trying to push the boundaries. He would complain and get really stroppy whenever we told him to turn it off and we told him that if he couldn’t stick to his time limits then we’d take it off him and when he continued complaining that’s what we did. He’s been without it for over 2 months now and although the first few weeks were hard he doesn’t even mention it now and it’s lovely.

Like I said though, I know this isn’t comparable to teenagers as that’s how they socialise now.

However, my sister’s son is 16 and he spends all his time in his bedroom on his Xbox. I wish I was exaggerating but I’m not and he hardly comes downstairs. Over the weekends he will turn it on as soon as hr wakes up and sit on it until 1-2am. In the week, he disappears up to his room and plays on his Xbox until he falls asleep.

It really is like he’s addicted.

Now I know there is fault on my sister’s side for allowing it to happen but she said that never really restricts him because it wasn’t worth the fall out and she didn’t want to stop him playing with his friends. I think her situation shows that unless dealt with, unrestricted access to technology can snowball until you find yourself in a situation that becomes very difficult to deal with.

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all.

gamerchick · 19/02/2022 07:04

@NuffSaidSam

If he's generally good, I'd personally try a more grown up approach with him. You're going to have to make that move soonish anyway, so why not now as it's clear the current system doesn't work. Give him a chance to self-regulate instead of setting arbitrary limits and punishments.
This. A 'digital detox' as mentioned about is good for kids but your approach needs tweaking. Currently you're treating him like a small child and that may bite you on your backside if it carries on. He's on the cusp of the teens and being a teen sucks as it is without being punished for every little thing by your parents.

Ask him what he thinks would be fair, ask his opinion and then come to a compromise. He needs to learn how to self regulate.

PinkSyCo · 19/02/2022 06:57

I think allowing a 12 year old only two hours gaming time per day in the school holidays is really tight, especially when the weather’s too shit for bike rides or meeting up with mates. How old are the siblings you expect him to play with and are they into the same things as him?

haikyew · 19/02/2022 04:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

bardos · 19/02/2022 04:12

I personally do not restrict screen time and my daughter hardly ever sits for hours on end in front of one. However, today I kept her off school and obviously did not go anywhere due to the weather, and she took the iPad to bed and lay in bed watching it all morning- I asked if she wanted to play and she said no. I think just like adults, kids also need time to do what they want to relax. I like to sit on the sofa watching tv in the evening, so if on a boring day my daughter wants to do the same, why is that so wrong?

I understand not wanting them on it 24/7, but it seems he's pushing boundaries and sneaking on his phone, because he knows he wouldn't be allowed if he asked

Seemssounfair · 19/02/2022 03:15

When ds started spending more time on screens we didnt limit it we helped get him more engaged in other things instead so his screen time naturally reduced and it was never a battle.

He is just a child, but turning into a teen he needs help to develop other hobbies , that are personal to his interests not just play with sibs and not time controls on the one thing he enjoys.

‘ god help you both when they get to14/ 15/16’

I would interpret this as the devils makes work for idle hands. If he has things that interest him and keep him productively occupied he will have less inclination to go looking for the other inappropriate things to do through boredom and you will have less battles when he hits the teen years.

Redroceritsover · 19/02/2022 02:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

NuffSaidSam · 19/02/2022 01:18

How good teens are at self-regulating will differ, just like it does with adults. But you need to be giving him a chance and then helping him to self correct when necessary. At some point you have to have the reins of his life over and it's much kinder to do that a little bit at a time and help him along than control everything until he's 18 and has no clue how to manage anything himself.

Why don't you sit down with him and talk about everything he needs to do in a day, how he can manage his time and then let him have a go. He'll almost certainly fuck up a bit, but just be there to talk it through, make the changes.

You need to work with him.not against him at this age.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 01:14

‘ Play with his siblings? Ok so maybe he doesn't want to.’
The upshot is - when he’s away from screens - we’ve been away for a week without gaming or phones - he happily does other things and plays with
Siblings.
When we have the Xbox or phone games as an option it’s a constant battle over time and he’s obsessed with playing and ride and aggressive regardless of of time allowed on devices.

OP posts:
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 01:10

Ok, so taking onboard feedback - 2 hours gaming time in one day plus tv time isn’t too much so for those who agree with that then how much gaming time do your 12 year olds get?
And what else do they do in a day, usually? And are they getting 2 hours a day +
And I if you don’t check their phones or they time spent on them,
Are they self monitoring on screen time okay?

OP posts:
GirlInACountrySong · 19/02/2022 01:10

@Butterbegood

‘ god help you both when they get to14/ 15/16’

Why exactly??

Because you will be battling harder...can't you see that he's outgrown your 'rules'

Play with his siblings? Ok so maybe he doesn't want to.