Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take away the Xbox for a week?

91 replies

Butterbegood · 18/02/2022 19:04

DS 12 has restricted time gaming and controls in his phone re: how long he can use the phone per day, and what he can do in it.
The last couple Of months that we have been battling re gaming time in particular. Today he was allowed a couple of hours as he’s in hols. Told him no more gaming , not on phone and not on Xbox today.
Found out he’s been on phone games plus downloaded new apps to his phone ( Tik Tok and others) that we’ve said no too.
This isn’t the first time that he’s got round controls to get more time or play games. He’s constant pushing boundaries but generally a good kid, does okay at school, plays sports etc
I told him he’d lose the Xbox for a week - DP is wondering if that’s too strict but given that this is about the 4th or 5th time he’s been caught like this I feel like he needs consequences.
Have tried explaining why he can’t have unlimited gaming time and unrestricted internet access but apparently we’re the worst parents in the world…
AIBU in taking his Xbox for a week and restricting the phone to calls and messaging only??

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 19/02/2022 11:51

Yanbu.
My eldest is a shit self regulator. I remove his tech every so often. He's lovely without it.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 11:49

Not to mention the huge numbers of children coming into Secondary with reading ages well below their age because of the disruptions to their education in the last 2 years. Secondary teachers aren’t trained to teach children HOW to read, that’s supposed to be done by the time they leave Primary so everyone is playing catch up or learning new skills. Not just the children.

OP posts:
Crimesean · 19/02/2022 11:48

You will split the room on this OP - everyone knows unlimited gaming and screens is bad for kids' health (mental and physical) but sadly a lot of parents give in for an easy life.

You are absolutely doing the right thing, kids need help to regulate their impulses and choose a variety of age-appropriate activities.

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 11:47

Yeah, Fortnite. I know but they are ageing out of that one mostly, thank goodness. But there are other almost as bad ones out there… they don’t all have the same consoles so go to those types as they can play together in grps.
Comments have been helpful. I think
More freedom in weekend but same rules on school
Nights might be the way to go.
Like I said, I work in Secondary education and the issues around screen time and gaming affecting reading abilities, the word gap, attention span and knock on effects of that on non-literacy subjects are huge so we won’t be budging on school night rules.
I think parents forget how much kids from yr 7 + are using screens now in school too- from quiz games, to homework, emails from school, front of class teaching, Google classroom to do work and hand in homework on top if ICT learning like Office. And coding.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 19/02/2022 11:35

You would be better off taking away Fortnite tbh. Awful game, turns kids demonic. I've had to ban it as has friends of mine with their kids. They get over it and are nicer humans as a result.

GirlInACountrySong · 19/02/2022 11:32

Just for balance though

Op is not completely wrong in having some rules around this

Your 16 year olds could come and work for us ( huge retail company, non food)

We pay well. But oh boy!! The phone use is off the scale

The minute they leave the shopfloor it's head down in their phone...that's if they aren't sneaking looks at it whilst working. Sit in the canteen it's silence, no interaction

Balance is key but they don't seem able to regulate themselves. I even see them walking home up the hill head down in the phone

Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 11:18

Some good comments and I’ll
Sit him down and talk to him. Funny how the one thing he’s fine with - strict gaming time during the school week- is the one thing he’s fine about! I should say that he other screen time isn’t restricted so although he can’t play Fortnite he can watch tv.
Decided to take away his time this weekend only and talk to him. But yes gaming does make him ruder, talk back, complain about getting off, angry so giving him more time in the school week will not work for us. He does not self regulate - tried that. Hopefully it will come. But until he matured a bit we’ll stick to trying to parent him.

OP posts:
Notanotherwindow · 19/02/2022 10:27

I think you need to be less strict with the time restrictions tbh otherwise he'll never learn to self regulate. Stayed up till midnight gaming? Too tired for school? Tough. You're going anyway and it'll teach you better for next time.

If he is rude and aggressive from gaming too much just take it off him for the day every time he is rude. Aggressiveness loses it for the whole week. Again, consequences. He'll learn. Lying and dishonesty. OK, fine then he can't be trusted, take his phone off him and he has to earn it back.

No game time or phone until homework is completed and chores are done.

You don't need such strict controls and rules, it doesn't do them any favours to treat them like they're 8 years old still. I'd be sneaking behind your back too at his age.

Give him a bit more control over how he spends his time and more responsibility for his behaviour. Make it clear what the expectations are for behaviour and attitude, how many warnings he gets and what the punishment will be. Specify what exactly bad attitude and rudeness looks like. He is old enough to get this.

CharSiu · 19/02/2022 10:22

No computers or consoles were allowed in the bedroom at all until he was 16. We still choose to never have any kind of electronic stuff in the bedroom.

CharSiu · 19/02/2022 10:18

DS is a young adult now. At High school I let him self regulate apart from a couple of weeks removal when his GCSE exams were coming up.

He was on for at least a couple of hours everyday. In High school he did a combination of football teams at school and a local club, air cadets, volunteering at park run and a once a week paper round. He also worked as a kitchen assistant for a few months. He also often went to the local park for a quick kick about. We lived a 5 min walk from his school and the park. That’s relevant, DH had to commute by train in to London for school which took an hour each way, I had a walk of 45 mins in the quite rural area I grew up in. What a waste of time that all was for all those years.

I also gamed with him sometimes as did his Dad. We still game together. DH is a Professor and I also worked in higher education till I retired. DH and I were programming back in the 1990’s so even though we are older we have always had a lot of tech at home and when it was in its infancy.

He got three A levels at grade A. He is similar to us loves lots of playing sport and lots of gaming.

You say you are a gamer. What type of games do you play?

OhWhyNot · 19/02/2022 10:12

I found it worked well

A few days without gaming and ds stopped asking and was in a much better mood it’s so addictive

It didn’t stop him pushing boundaries completely he is that age

girlmom21 · 19/02/2022 10:11

@Butterbegood

‘ He has 3 hours to use on gaming Mon -Thurs and choose when he plays.’

That’s 3 hours total across the week, not 3 hours a day ( unless he decides to use the 3 hours in one go, which has t happened yet!)

You can't even play a cooperative game in less than 40 minutes. OP this is really extreme.
zingally · 19/02/2022 10:07

I dunno...

You say he's a good kid, doing well at school etc, and otherwise nice?

I feel like personally I'd pick another battle.

Elieza · 19/02/2022 10:03

You said you’ve told him what the punishment will be.

If you go back on what you said then it lets him know to push your boundaries and you’ll capitulate.

That’s not good. He needs to know that what you say is law. And indeed that some rules (like the law) can’t be wheedled round. Or he won’t respect anyone.

So in future, whatever you decide to do, I’d suggest you don’t dish out punishments at the time if you think they may be too hard. Instead tell him there will be consequences for his actions. And discuss with your partner or take time yourself to consider what would be appropriate.
Then tell him.

trumpisagit · 19/02/2022 10:00

I do think you need to make some adjustments so he has some more control.
At some point he needs to learn to make the choice to turn off devices and do something else.
I have kids of similar age, and older. Their time on devices isn't restricted, but they have to do the after school activities they are signed up to, do homework to a good standard and join in with meal times.
Also reasonable bedtimes with no devices in rooms.
They do choose to go out and meet their friends etc. Sign up for after school clubs etc so gaming is not all they choose to do.

Ionlydomassiveones · 19/02/2022 09:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

oceanskye · 19/02/2022 09:56

I have found 12 to be peak xbox obsession age! Personally I dont restrict my boys gaming, but it naturally limits itself by us only having one TV in the house, plus them having a sport or hobby most days. My 15 year old hardly ever plays it now as he has other stuff he'd rather be doing, but my 12 year old jumps on most days for an hour or two.

Cakelover17 · 19/02/2022 09:55

@Butterbegood

‘ just don't understand why you're punishing restricted phone use by taking his Xbox away. It doesn't make any sense.’

Because he used the phone to play a game for another 2 hrs. Then when I looked at the phone I realised he had added other stuff.
And honestly, taking away gaming time is the most effective consequences for him.

But he can still carry on ignoring you breaking the rules on his phone…
Butterbegood · 19/02/2022 09:52

‘ just don't understand why you're punishing restricted phone use by taking his Xbox away. It doesn't make any sense.’

Because he used the phone to play a game for another 2 hrs. Then when I looked at the phone I realised he had added other stuff.
And honestly, taking away gaming time is the most effective consequences for him.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 19/02/2022 09:42

See to me you're using a lot of words to say that you don't trust your parenting and the shit you've installed in your kid. He's rebelling because you're trying to control his every move. You need to unclench slightly and get him involved in what's fair.

gamerchick · 19/02/2022 09:39

@Butterbegood

‘John Boy from the Walton’s’ 😄 That might be my favourite yet ! We’re trying to find a balance between online and offline for him. So that he reads books, plays outside, socialises IRL as well as using tech. I don’t subscribe to the ‘everyone else has it so that’s okay’ line of parenting anyway. Tik Tok isnt harmless, no social media is harmless which is why most SM has age restrictions. And why SM is linked to the huge increase in mental health issues amongst young people. With the kids I work with the happiest, well adjusted ones doing well or okay in school aren’t the ones who’s parents give them unlimited freedom and who are glued to their phones all day. I don’t think it’s a coincidence. It is hard though. Hard to regulate and help kids find the balance while engaging with their peers via tech.
I agree. My 15 yr old isn't allowed any SM at all. He understands why.

I just don't understand why you're punishing restricted phone use by taking his Xbox away. It doesn't make any sense.

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 19/02/2022 09:38

Just to add both my children are high graders, Ds1 got 4 x A* at A level and Ds2 is about to sit his mock GCSEs and should come out with mostly 9s. Because we ensure the homework is done and they are motivated to do their best. That was the rule since primary.

Also my sons had desktop gaming computers which are downstairs in a study room they had. Phone were handed over at night as a precaution and a no consequences rule if they felt like they needed an intervention with their phones. Just ask and we will take them off you etc.

They weren't gaming all night which obviously some teens are.

Hangingtrousers · 19/02/2022 09:31

Absolutely nothing wrong with being a nerd!!!? Ffs

Cakelover17 · 19/02/2022 09:27

@Butterbegood

‘ He has 3 hours to use on gaming Mon -Thurs and choose when he plays.’

That’s 3 hours total across the week, not 3 hours a day ( unless he decides to use the 3 hours in one go, which has t happened yet!)

3 hours across the week is very restrictive. I think you are spending too much time controlling, restricting and punishing his gaming and it’s forcing him to try and sneak around. Some kids do fine with less gaming, but your son is very much into it and your approach isn’t working, it’s just causing him to lie to you. So why not meet him half way?

Making gaming such a highly sought after prize isn’t helping the situation. And personally I’d punish by taking the phone rather than the Xbox, you are just hitting him were it hurts with an indirect consequence doing that. If you took the phone because he bypassed your restrictions and downloaded apps he’s not allowed then taking the phone is the direct consequence, and also stops him being able to do more sneaky things, because the Xbox is far easier to monitor his use of in real time.

RoseMartha · 19/02/2022 09:24

@Butterbegood
My teens are calmer when not on her phone. I get this.

That sounds fair. Then do you give him longer in holidays?

I do think restricting gaming and the phone is important. But likewise you need to review timings at regular intervals and increase now and then.

I would have a discussion with him about needing to talk to you about apps he would like. Can you put a block on him downloading them?

Then go through each app he downloaded with him and decide if he can use it or not. And say why and when he is likely to be allowed it.

Restricting him from using all the apps because he hasnt followed the rules makes sense. But I dont think I would totally ban the xbox for the week also.