Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is maternity discrimination?

266 replies

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 18:50

I am on maternity leave and due back to work at the end of May. I have a 4yo and 8mo. When I return to work I will have had a full year of mat leave. My pregnancy was uncomplicated but my son fell very poorly at 14 weeks old. He pulled through but is now being investigated for potential cerebral palsy. I had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance. They were receptive to this and went away to work on a new position for me in the company in reduced hours/responsibility.

Today I had a further meeting with them where they outlined a new position to fulfil a business need and which suited my needs. I was made aware they had offered my current role to the person who is my maternity cover currently. However, it was then explained that my new role would be on a significantly reduced salary pro-rate, almost £6 an hour less equivalent. I raised a concern that as a woman returning from mat leave I was entitled to either my old job back or a different role on the same pay. They then said in that case I could either have my old role back on my old hours & salary, or accept the new job on the reduced salary (“hourly rate”).

I spoke to ACAS who advised because my employer has verbally offered my current role to someone else, they have effectively brought my current job to an end. As this has happened while I am on maternity leave and they have offered the role to my maternity cover, it could amount to discrimination. ACAS have also advised me that verbal job offers and acceptances are legally binding. My employer is therefore obliged to offer me a job on similar terms than I was on before as they have effectively brought my current job to an end.

Does this sound right? I don’t want to raise hell unless I have to as I work for a small company and I’ve been there for 15 years. I’d really appreciate any advice and will answer any questions. Thank you.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 18/02/2022 21:22

I think your mistake was to equate less hours with less responsibility.

What you should have asked was to return to your old role or an equivalent job but on reduced hours.

Instead you asked for less responsibility so they created a new role for you on less pay.

I don’t think you’d get very far as during the mediation process they will just say of course your old role is still available. They may or may not have good business reasons why that role cannot be part time. If they don’t have good reasons and refuse reduced hours, then you might have a case.

worriedatthemoment · 18/02/2022 21:21

@Crimesean but surely it does if you are going to another role with less responsibility , so if you were a manager of a team of 10 and you then go back in a admin role , it will be less money surely

Imdonna · 18/02/2022 21:21

does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?

No because the job is there for you. The job offer is likey to be dependent on your decision.

CatJumperTwat · 18/02/2022 21:21

it was the choice between this new role and my old job, financially I would have to accept my old job.

How did you ever think you could reduce your hours and responsibility but not your pay? It just doesn't make sense.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:20

You told them you didnt want to return to your old job.
They offered it to someone else. That's what happens when you resign a position. They didnt give it ti her because they like her more and try to stick you somewhere else. They wanted you back in your role. You said no.

You then requested a demotion. You want fewer hours and less responsibility. They didnt have a role available so they created one for you. They didnt have to do that. They only need to offer you your old job. If they wanted rid of you they could have simply said your old job is not possible part time but is available for you as before. They clearly want you to stay in the company.

You want to stay in the company too but with less responsibility. That means taking a step down the ladder. Which means being paid less per hour. But you asked them for that.

You can have your old job if you want. Or you can have the job down the ladder which you asked for. But you cant be paid a senior manager salary when you're not doing the work of a senior. You wanted less responsibility.

AlexaShutUp · 18/02/2022 21:20

So what were you expecting actually, OP?

Did you think they were going to reduce your responsibility in a new role while paying you the same salary as your old role? Confused

I really don't understand how it is maternity discrimination if they are happy to give you your old job back. How are you being discriminated against exactly?

You can't possibly know what they have or haven't agreed with your maternity cover. That's a completely separate issue because it clearly isn't standing in the way of you going back to your old job if you choose to do so.

formalineadeline · 18/02/2022 21:18

does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?

Who cares? They're not making you apply for it, they've said you can have your old job back.

What do you actually want here? Your old job?

In which case, great, they've told you it's there, problem solved. If you took them to tribunal for "discrimination", what remedy would you be asking for if they've given you your job back.

Or a new job with reduced responsibilities?

In which case, also great, they've created one for you because they want to retain you. But obviously a demotion means a pay cut.

so I’m not really any clearer on what to do

Well do you want to do your old job or do you want the new job?

I don't really understand what you're asking us for at this point. There's nothing to do except decide which job you want - you've got two open to you.

Viviennemary · 18/02/2022 21:18

You need to make up your mind whether or not you want your old job back. How on earth can your firm move forward if you won't decide. If you want your old job and they give it to your colleague that's discrimination. Have you told them formally you are not returning to your old job.

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:15

And yes, I told ACAS the entire story as written here, every single detail. I tried to call our work HR advice line but they are shut until Monday morning.

OP posts:
Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:14

If it was the choice between this new role and my old job, financially I would have to accept my old job. Even though my current nursery choice won’t take my son any more due to his physical disability. Id have to find a way to make it work.

OP posts:
Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:12

Wow there’s a lot of comments here and I’ve read them all although can’t reply to everything individually.

For clarification, I am not a chancer. Well I don’t think I am. I really don’t know how these things work and I had read the online literature and spoken to ACAS who had all backed up my feelings of being a bit upset. However I’m looking for as many perspectives as possible which is why I came here. The HR folk who have commented seem to think I am not being unreasonable but many others do… so I’m not really any clearer on what to do. It’s just that they have offered my job to my colleague and although it’s not my problem how they resolve that situation, does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?

I do think my feelings are clouded a lot by my sons health situation right now. It’s been rotten. It’s felt like setback after setback and today with my job situation felt like even more bad news.

I apologise if I came across as entitled or lazy, I’m just a mum trying to do right by my family.

OP posts:
Tohaveandtohold · 18/02/2022 21:11

They are offering you either the old role back with the same pay and terms or as you requested, a new role with less hours and less responsibility which will mean less pay surely. It’s up to you to decide.
It’s not your problem what they verbally offered your maternity cover, I’m sure before she was employed, she would have been told that if you wish to come back then the role is yours.
You decide what you want and not concern yourself with what they’ve verbally offered someone else, they already told you that you can have the job back so I don’t know what your issue is really.

Imdonna · 18/02/2022 21:09

The point about offering the job is really dependent on how converstations were actually worded.

Did you tell them you absolutely couldn't come back into the same role and hours?

When they offered your replacement the job, was it an actual verbal offer. Or was it 'there's a chance the person you are covering isn't coming back. Would you take the role if She doesnt'

Or if you told them there's no way you could take the role on again, that's what they communicated to her.

You weren't there for the second converstation. So when they say they verbally offered it, it may have had caveats.

They have your role for you, if you want it. You don't. You want less hours and less responsibility. Roles with less responsibility, usually come with less pay. You have requested a change. You haven't just asked for a flexible working agreement. You asked to change roles. They aren't trying to force you to take another role.

nanbread · 18/02/2022 21:09

@Itsalmostanaccessory I mean if she brought up the fact that it's discrimination with them, to have offered her old job to someone else before she had handed in her notice / agreed to new role.

Asiama · 18/02/2022 21:07

It's not maternity discrimination. They have said you cab had your old job back.

The fact that they have offered it to your maternity cover is a red herring. Any problems this creates is between your employer and the cover.

RealBecca · 18/02/2022 21:05

The other person isnt your lookout. What do you want to happen? Old job or new job?

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:05

@nanbread

She did bring it up. They told her that she could still have her old job back. So she clearly didnt tell ACAS that bit. Her old job has not been closed off to her.

They confirmed that she can still have it if she wants it. They would no doubt just offer the maternity cover a sideways move or withdraw the offer. But that's nothing to do with the OP as long as her job is still available, which they have confirmed it is.

nanbread · 18/02/2022 21:04

It doesn't really leave them in a bad situation with your mat cover if they rescind the offer, presumably they've been there less than 2 years so they could just end her contract.

nanbread · 18/02/2022 21:02

I think given you haven't accepted the new role yet and presuming you haven't handed in your notice or informed them you no longer want to do that job formally then yes, they were wrong to offer the job to someone else and this could be seen as discrimination - however I would think if you brought it up they would most likely just offer it back to you... Not sure of legal standing.

In terms of the new role, the only thing they have to keep available to you is your existing job. They don't have to offer you another job on the same pay.

Speak to maternity action or similar to get solid advice.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:02

@LadyCleathStuart

She asked for reduced responsibility. Not just sort time work. She wants reduced responsibility.

She has asked for a demotion. Didnt use those words but that is what she has asked for.

Your salary increases as you rise up through your company, and increase your responsibility. If you want to reduce it then you need to take a step downwards. She cannot be paid a senior manager salary when she is doing a role that is below that, as per her own request.

Flickflak · 18/02/2022 20:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 18/02/2022 20:57

If its been longer than 6 months they don't have to give you the same job back but they do have to find you an equivalent role.

gogohm · 18/02/2022 20:57

You said you asked for less responsibility, this comes with a lower pay packet. It's not discrimination because you could have your old job

Gilly12345 · 18/02/2022 20:56

You told your employer that you wanted to reduce your hours/responsibility, surely reduced responsibility means reduced pay?

riotlady · 18/02/2022 20:49

Surely it would only be discrimination if you said “yes ok, I do want my old job back” and they said “whoops, you can’t have it, we’ve offered it to someone else”? As it stands, they’ve offered you your old job, it’s just depending on your deciding if you want to accept it (which it sounds like you don’t anyway?)