Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is maternity discrimination?

266 replies

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 18:50

I am on maternity leave and due back to work at the end of May. I have a 4yo and 8mo. When I return to work I will have had a full year of mat leave. My pregnancy was uncomplicated but my son fell very poorly at 14 weeks old. He pulled through but is now being investigated for potential cerebral palsy. I had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance. They were receptive to this and went away to work on a new position for me in the company in reduced hours/responsibility.

Today I had a further meeting with them where they outlined a new position to fulfil a business need and which suited my needs. I was made aware they had offered my current role to the person who is my maternity cover currently. However, it was then explained that my new role would be on a significantly reduced salary pro-rate, almost £6 an hour less equivalent. I raised a concern that as a woman returning from mat leave I was entitled to either my old job back or a different role on the same pay. They then said in that case I could either have my old role back on my old hours & salary, or accept the new job on the reduced salary (“hourly rate”).

I spoke to ACAS who advised because my employer has verbally offered my current role to someone else, they have effectively brought my current job to an end. As this has happened while I am on maternity leave and they have offered the role to my maternity cover, it could amount to discrimination. ACAS have also advised me that verbal job offers and acceptances are legally binding. My employer is therefore obliged to offer me a job on similar terms than I was on before as they have effectively brought my current job to an end.

Does this sound right? I don’t want to raise hell unless I have to as I work for a small company and I’ve been there for 15 years. I’d really appreciate any advice and will answer any questions. Thank you.

OP posts:
Imdonna · 18/02/2022 22:01

@Ohtheaudacity

I really didn’t come here maliciously or expecting things to be sugarcoated. I came here because I was reading and being told one thing but wanted to get as many opinions as possible before starting unnecessary drama with my employer. I am not unbelievably stupid, just totally naive to this kind of thing and trying to do my best. I appreciate all the comments, every single one. I get the picture! Wishing you all a relaxing weekend x
I am not trying to be rude, but you are senior management. Have you never handled a mat leave for someone who works for you?

Did you not consider that if we all could go back into roles with less hours and a drop in seniority and less responsibility and keep the wage, that the vast majority of us would do that after having kids?

I, genuinely, just can't follow the thinking that you thought you would keep the wage for less hours and less seniority.

sanbeiji · 18/02/2022 21:58

Ok so everyone has established that you don't have a case - but re role.
A job share/PT only works if a role has clearly defined working hours in the first place.
I'm presuming that the reason your asked for less responsibility as well as hours is because as senior management, you can't work less hours?
If you worked long hours as FT there's no reason to think you wouldn't do the same as PT. Just less days. So you'd effectively be losing money (although I guess you're losing it anyway).

Your salary is lower, but is it cheaper than working FT and paying for your son's care? Where's the father?

Ultimately if you want a 'job share' type role a small company is unlikely to be the right place. They don't have a huge pool to share out the work (even then senior management is hard to delegate).

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:53

I really didn’t come here maliciously or expecting things to be sugarcoated. I came here because I was reading and being told one thing but wanted to get as many opinions as possible before starting unnecessary drama with my employer. I am not unbelievably stupid, just totally naive to this kind of thing and trying to do my best. I appreciate all the comments, every single one. I get the picture! Wishing you all a relaxing weekend x

OP posts:
Boombastic22 · 18/02/2022 21:49

And ACAS can be great but also not! Law is always shades go grey but this actually seems pretty straightforward..

SW1amp · 18/02/2022 21:49

Are you sure you explained the situation properly to ACAS?

Because while they are happy for you to go back to if you want, there is no case.

I’m really really surprised you could honestly think that you should be entitled to a job with less responsibility but the same pay.
Presumably you would expect a payrise if you got a promotion with more responsibility so the reverse would be true when you take a step back

Boombastic22 · 18/02/2022 21:48

You’ve got no claim on the face of it - they’re offering you your old job back. It’s irrelevant what they may or may not have offered your mat leave. If you don’t want it it’s your choice but you have no loss, the job is there for you.

WulyJmpr · 18/02/2022 21:46

@Ellie56

I would say trust ACAS not randoms on MN.

If you are in a union ask them.

Common sense should be called upon in the very first instance.
AlexaShutUp · 18/02/2022 21:43

It seems very clear that ACAS have misunderstood the situation. I cannot believe that they would advise the OP that she would have a case when her old job/old t&c are clearly open to her. There is no evidence of anyone else getting preferential treatment. Only a vague idea that the OP's maternity cover may or or may not have been offered a job that won't impact on the OP's entitlement to her old job if she wants it.

Nocutenamesleft · 18/02/2022 21:40

@Littlegoth

I work in HR.

ACAS are the experts, not the people of mumsnet. The issue is that they’ve offered your job to someone else before you’ve agreed to a new role. If you now can’t go back to your old job (should you wish to) and they need to ensure that replacement roles don’t disadvantage you, whether that’s financially, work life balance otherwise it’s potentially discrimination.

You are entitled to make a flexible working request doing your pre maternity job but part time or compressed hours. This shouldn’t be at least pay per hour, but of course salary will be pro rata to your working hours.

A verbal job offer can be rescinded, however as the candidate is already working for them this creates a problem between those 2 parties.

They’ve really made a mess here!

If you see above. They’ve offered her her old job back. But she said she didn’t want that. It looks like they’ve give it to both people the same job roles.
Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:38

@Ellie56

Acas have told her she has a case because they have taken her job away and given it to someone else. They've closed the job off to her.

The OP has clarified that they have not. The company have been quite clear. Her job is hers if she wants it. The OP would start a case against them, it would begin with meditation, they would restate their position that her job is and always has been available to her and that would be the end of her discrimination case. She doesnt have a case.

What the OP actually wants is to have a demotion which she requested but to be paid her old salary. She cant have that. That is not discrimination.

She is entitled to the same salary if she returns to the same or equivalent role which is available to her. All she needs to do is take it. She cannot have the same salary if she asks them for an entirely new position which is a step or 2 down the ladder.

Comefromaway · 18/02/2022 21:36

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Comefromaway

Job sharing in a senior management role which requires continuity is actually not often possible. It is a valid reason to say no.[/quote]
Depends on lots of things, you can’t really say that anymore with most roles these days. That’s why the OP needs to speak to an employment lawyer who can advise on the specific situation.

Custom and practise doesn’t really hold water these days

FawnFrenchieMum · 18/02/2022 21:35

@Ohtheaudacity

Thanks everyone, I think my main issue is they’ve verbally offered my job to my maternity cover before offering me a viable alternative. Can they now rescind this offer from her and reinstate me into my old job? Doesn’t that leave them in hot water with her? Sorry if I sound clueless, it’s because I am 😂
I don’t think it matters what they have offered the other person as long as you can have your job back. I assume in this case they would have to have two people doing the job. You need to worry about yourself not what they have offered someone else.
Ellie56 · 18/02/2022 21:35

I would say trust ACAS not randoms on MN.

If you are in a union ask them.

formalineadeline · 18/02/2022 21:34

Everything online talks about being entitled to the same pay and benefits

For the same job. Everything online talks about being entitled to the same or equivalent role for the same pay and benefits.

Talk about selective reading.

Come on, you're starting to sound like those people who think part time employees get paid a full time salary.

Why would pregnancy mean you should be entitled to be demoted without a pay cut?

nothing anywhere says about what if you reduce responsibilities/seniority

Because that's obvious? And not maternity specific.

Upgrade in responsibilities (promotion) = upgrade in pay

Downgrade in responsibilities (demotion) = downgrade in pay

Why would there be a special website explaining that.

AlexaShutUp · 18/02/2022 21:33

I agree that you might have a case if they refused to reduce your hours in your old role and they can't adequately demonstrate a business need. But that's a pretty big leap and it sounds like they have been pretty reasonable overall, so there is no reason to assume that they don't have a valid reason for refusing.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:32

@Comefromaway

Job sharing in a senior management role which requires continuity is actually not often possible. It is a valid reason to say no.

smalltreethisyear · 18/02/2022 21:31

Agree with comefromaway

Just an example:

If your current role is headteacher but you asked to return as a teacher on a part time basis, your pay would be significantly reduced as you would be on reduced pay per hour and because you reduced your overall hours..

If you asked to stay as headteacher but in a PT/job share role, you would be on a reduced salary but not ‘per hour’ pay.

It sounds like your employer is being really reasonable.You just need to decide what you want to do.

Imdonna · 18/02/2022 21:30

Honestly, I wasn’t sure! Everything online talks about being entitled to the same pay and benefits etc. but nothing anywhere says about what if you reduce responsibilities/seniority.

Are you seriously saying f you thought employers were obliged to keep your pay the same, even if yih want less hours and less seniority?

You have asked to change jobs. You get the same terms if going back to the same job. If they agreed part time, you would get the same wage pro rata. Not the same take home. But you also wanted to drop I responsibility/seniority. They don't have to keep paying for you a senior wage, because you requested the step down.

Senior management is extremely difficult to do part time and/or job share up the vast majority of jobs.

Comefromaway · 18/02/2022 21:29

If it was declined due to business need you (& ACAS) need to evaluate whether you think those reasons are valid. So for example you employer needs to demonstrate that they have tried to recruit a job share etc.

Valid refusal (an office worker wants to only work weekends when business hours and client needs are Mon-Fri)

Not valid refusal (someone wants to work mornings only and employer hasn’t even tried to recruit someone to work afternoons)

AlexaShutUp · 18/02/2022 21:28

Honestly, I wasn’t sure! Everything online talks about being entitled to the same pay and benefits etc. but nothing anywhere says about what if you reduce responsibilities/seniority. To you - and many others - what I’ve asked is a stupid question, but I came here with good intentions as someone who really had no idea. I do really appreciate the advice. In the absence of a mum or similar to ask, I came here for the truth and it seems like that’s what I’ve got

You are entitled to go back on the same pay/same benefits, but only if you go back to the same job!

It is completely unreasonable to expect the same pay for doing a more junior role. That would make it completely unsustainable for organisations and incredibly unfair to other staff. I'm amazed that you would think this is possible tbh.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 21:28

Everything online tells you that you are entitled to the same job or equivalent sideways move at the same hours and pay. They offered you that.

You said no and you requested a downwards move.

If you requested a demotion from senior manage with lots of responsibility to a role with really reduced responsibility the you are not entitled to return to the same pay.

Your job with your pay and hours is available if you want it. They are not discriminating against you.

You have requested a downwards move. They have agreed. But that comes with a drop in pay.

Did you really think you could keep your senior manager salary after asking for a totally new job with fewer hours and much less responsibility? That would be mad.

You can have everything you are legally entitled to. They're offering it. They want you back.

Or, you can have the demotion that you have requested which comes with a bloody obvious drop in pay.

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:25

@Comefromaway

I think your mistake was to equate less hours with less responsibility.

What you should have asked was to return to your old role or an equivalent job but on reduced hours.

Instead you asked for less responsibility so they created a new role for you on less pay.

I don’t think you’d get very far as during the mediation process they will just say of course your old role is still available. They may or may not have good business reasons why that role cannot be part time. If they don’t have good reasons and refuse reduced hours, then you might have a case.

Hi, thanks for replying. I did put in a flexible working request for reduced hours but it was declined due to business need.
OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 18/02/2022 21:24

“ does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?”

But they don’t have a preferred candidate? It sounds like they hadn’t even considered the mat cover being permanent until you told them you wouldn’t/couldn’t do your old role.

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 21:23

@AlexaShutUp

So what were you expecting actually, OP?

Did you think they were going to reduce your responsibility in a new role while paying you the same salary as your old role? Confused

I really don't understand how it is maternity discrimination if they are happy to give you your old job back. How are you being discriminated against exactly?

You can't possibly know what they have or haven't agreed with your maternity cover. That's a completely separate issue because it clearly isn't standing in the way of you going back to your old job if you choose to do so.

Honestly, I wasn’t sure! Everything online talks about being entitled to the same pay and benefits etc. but nothing anywhere says about what if you reduce responsibilities/seniority. To you - and many others - what I’ve asked is a stupid question, but I came here with good intentions as someone who really had no idea. I do really appreciate the advice. In the absence of a mum or similar to ask, I came here for the truth and it seems like that’s what I’ve got 😊
OP posts:
formalineadeline · 18/02/2022 21:23

So take your old job and make a flexible working request (for fewer hours, not fewer responsibilities). Or go back and start looking for a role in a different organisation that ticks all/more of your boxes.

my current nursery choice won’t take my son any more due to his physical disability. Id have to find a way to make it work

Sounds like that'd be the case though whatever job you go back to?

When you're ruling out the lower pay grade role, is that after taking into account the value of any savings you make elsewhere by also working fewer hours?