Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is maternity discrimination?

266 replies

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 18:50

I am on maternity leave and due back to work at the end of May. I have a 4yo and 8mo. When I return to work I will have had a full year of mat leave. My pregnancy was uncomplicated but my son fell very poorly at 14 weeks old. He pulled through but is now being investigated for potential cerebral palsy. I had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance. They were receptive to this and went away to work on a new position for me in the company in reduced hours/responsibility.

Today I had a further meeting with them where they outlined a new position to fulfil a business need and which suited my needs. I was made aware they had offered my current role to the person who is my maternity cover currently. However, it was then explained that my new role would be on a significantly reduced salary pro-rate, almost £6 an hour less equivalent. I raised a concern that as a woman returning from mat leave I was entitled to either my old job back or a different role on the same pay. They then said in that case I could either have my old role back on my old hours & salary, or accept the new job on the reduced salary (“hourly rate”).

I spoke to ACAS who advised because my employer has verbally offered my current role to someone else, they have effectively brought my current job to an end. As this has happened while I am on maternity leave and they have offered the role to my maternity cover, it could amount to discrimination. ACAS have also advised me that verbal job offers and acceptances are legally binding. My employer is therefore obliged to offer me a job on similar terms than I was on before as they have effectively brought my current job to an end.

Does this sound right? I don’t want to raise hell unless I have to as I work for a small company and I’ve been there for 15 years. I’d really appreciate any advice and will answer any questions. Thank you.

OP posts:
formalineadeline · 19/02/2022 05:52

takes away some of the more time consuming and stressful parts of my current role and distributes tasks to two sub-team leaders (one of whom would be me in their vision!

Per your request!

They've gone so far as to consider restructuring their business simply to retain you as an employee - and your response is to throw a strop. Seriously.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 05:49

@Ohtheaudacity

Thank you *@Itsalmostanaccessory* the restructure doc that I’ve been reading takes away some of the more time consuming and stressful parts of my current role and distributes tasks to two sub-team leaders (one of whom would be me in their vision!). This does change things as it reduces the takehome and workload from one particularly difficult element of the job. With the support of two others sharing my workload I feel I’d be better equipped to handle the job. My employer is saying I need to make a decision about all this by Friday next week, but it feels like a short amount of time to make such a big decision; which job I choose depends on childcare and that can’t be sorted at the drop of a hat. It’s also a big decision for my family that I can’t make in such a short space of time. I can’t sleep I feel so stressed about it.
A week is really not a short space of time. If you have taken 52 weeks of mat leave, not including annual leave you need to get it sorted ASAP, your rights to return disappear if I remember rightly.

Surely, you had some idea of how your childcare would work when you approached them?

I found this on maternity action. This is applicable if you have taken more than 26

However, if your employer can show that it isnot reasonably practicable for you to return to the same job, you are entitled to be offered a suitable alternative job on similar terms and conditions.

You have been offered the suitable alternative.

formalineadeline · 19/02/2022 05:46

My employer is saying I need to make a decision about all this by Friday next week, but it feels like a short amount of time to make such a big decision; which job I choose depends on childcare and that can’t be sorted at the drop of a hat.

But you were the one who initiated the request - surely you use whatever childcare plan you based your request upon.

They have bent over backwards to accommodate you and retain you, don't respond by creating drama. It will poison your employment relationship if you do.

Does this help my case?

You don't have a case. Continuing to make comments like that makes you sound like you are spoiling for a fight to try and force them to pay you the same money for a demoted post you requested.

It won't happen. There is no case. You need to snap out of that mindset.

Anniegetyourgun76 · 19/02/2022 00:47

I Don think you can claim discrimination for verbally offering the job to someone else if they're still willing to let you have it. You're right, they do have to offer you a comparable job and salary to your old one, they did that and you turned it down so they offered you another role at the appropriate rate for that job, it's your choice which you take up.

Asiama · 19/02/2022 00:31

I agree with @Itsalmostanaccessory. I would ask them to confirm whether it means that when you return, if you want to maintain your level / terms and conditions, that you would get the team leader job.

How many people does this restructure involve?

Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/02/2022 00:29

Usually if you have taken 52 weeks leave then you dont need to tell them your return date. It's already set and you'd just discuss it shortly before to make sure it goes smoothly.

The difference here is that you've told them you dont want your old job, and they've sorted a new one for you. If you choose not to tell them anything then they will have to keep your old job/equivalent role open for you. They will hire people to fill the new roles. You then wont have a choice. You'll have to return to your original role or resign.

If you want the option of the other job, then you'll need to tell them before they fill the roles. If you dont, then they still need to give you the old job but you wont have options. If they try to tell you there is no job at all because you didnt choose then they are breaking the law.

Ohtheaudacity · 19/02/2022 00:19

Thank you @Itsalmostanaccessory the restructure doc that I’ve been reading takes away some of the more time consuming and stressful parts of my current role and distributes tasks to two sub-team leaders (one of whom would be me in their vision!). This does change things as it reduces the takehome and workload from one particularly difficult element of the job. With the support of two others sharing my workload I feel I’d be better equipped to handle the job. My employer is saying I need to make a decision about all this by Friday next week, but it feels like a short amount of time to make such a big decision; which job I choose depends on childcare and that can’t be sorted at the drop of a hat. It’s also a big decision for my family that I can’t make in such a short space of time. I can’t sleep I feel so stressed about it.

OP posts:
Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/02/2022 00:13

If your job wont exist anymore then they need to offer you an equivalent job at the same salary and hours. Which sounds like the same job they have retitled. It would be yours, not hers.

If you dont want that job and you want the demotion then you can accept the job they have created for you.

Email them back asking:

What will be the title and salary of the full time job you would return to, which must be equivalent to the job you had when you went on maternity. See what they say.

They are allowed to restructure and change things, as long as they offer you an equivalent role. So ask them what role they are offering to match the one you had.

Then you need to decide if you want to go back to that or if you want the reduced responsibility you asked that. Reducing your role down the ladder means a paycut and that is not discrimination.

Ohtheaudacity · 19/02/2022 00:06

So, I have somewhat of an update (yes I know it’s late but I’ve just checked my email…)

I have received an email from my manager explaining that my maternity cover has not “technically” been offered my exact job role/title. They have tweaked the role slightly and changed the job title slightly (think “head of sales” to “sales manager”). They say this new role is part of a wider company restructure and is effective 1st April. I am not due back until early June but when I am back I will join the team in this new, lesser worse paid job. Does this change things? Does this help my case? They are still, confusingly, saying that I can return to my old job if I choose, while in the next breath saying that job will cease to exist from 1st April 2022. I’m so confused!

OP posts:
Yearofthetygerburningbright · 19/02/2022 00:00

I think that the OP has inadvertently confused the employer who is trying to do the right thing. Unless there is an undercurrent of attitude or 'persuasion' on the part of the employer, which the OP has not reported here, and which might make it discriminatory.

It might be that, maybe, the employer has procedurally done things in the wrong order or wrong way which makes it technically discrimination that the OP could bring a case for.

I think the OP needs to get some proper legal advice, and then on the basis of that explain to the employer what she means by "less hours/responsibility" as I agree that fewer hours is one thing (and also results in potentially less responsibility as a side effect e.g. if jobsharing or taking on half the number of projects or people to manage) but actually wanting a role that carries less responsibility is another thing.

If you want a certain pay packet per week OP, you are going to need either:

X hours at Y level of responsibility - this is your old job but having gone part time which they have to consider properly but not have to give you

or:

A hours at B level of lower responsibility (where A>X but not full time) - this is to be negotiated if your company has the business need for it and can accommodate it.

This of course has to be balanced by the OP (not your employer) against your quality of life and how many hours childcare you would need.

If they do not properly consider letting you have the first option, then that would be a different matter and discriminatory. But it's not clear yet IMO. It sounds to me as though your employer is one of the better ones and is negotiating with you, however clumsily.

Merryoldgoat · 18/02/2022 23:02

I still don’t understand how you could’ve thought fewer hours and less responsibility would equate to the same money as before.

AlexaShutUp · 18/02/2022 22:49

Yes @Itsalmostanaccessory, exactly.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 22:42

@MajorCarolDanvers

ACAS know what they are talking about. If they say you have a case then you do.

You should take their advice and follow it carefully b

And once more with feeling.

Acas have told her she has a case because, by offering the job to her maternity cover, they have removed the job from her. This is unlawful.

That is all entirely true. And she would have a case if this is what they had done.

The OP has confirmed this is not what has happened. Her job is still her job. If she wants it, it is hers. The company have confirmed that they are not removing it from her. They are not shoving her aside. The job is hers.

They may offer the maternity cover a sideways move or just end her contract. What they do with the maternity cover has nothing to do with the OP. All that matters, legally, to the OP is that her job is still hers. It 100% is.

If OP brought a claim against them, the first step is mediation. The company would restate their position that her job is and always has been, hers. She can have it. No issues at all.

That would be the end of the case.

ACAS have misunderstood her complaint. She has asked for a demotion. She does not want her old job. She doesnt want full time hours. She doesnt want senior management responsibility. She wants a new job down the ladder with less responsibility and fewer hours. They have created that job for her but it means a payout because it is a step down. This is not discrimination.

The OP is legally entitled to her old job or equivalent at the same hours and same pay. She has been given that. She has refused it and asked for a demotion.

She is not entitled to a totally different job whilst maintaining her senior management salary. It is not discrimination. Full stop.

Watapalava · 18/02/2022 22:36

No acts act in the advice given

They have 100% misheard OP

If they have given the job to someone else and OP can’t have it - discrimination

They have offered if but OP can have it back - OP has not been discriminated against

The mat cover may take issue but that’s nothing to do with OP

OP needs to be grateful really as they didn’t have to offer her anything other than her old role

nanbread · 18/02/2022 22:33

Can you try to negotiate salary on the new role, taking on slightly more responsibility than they've suggested / pulling on your 15 years of valuable experience?

MichelleScarn · 18/02/2022 22:33

Do you understand that you will still get less money? You'll be paid pro-rata for the hours you do if they agree to a job share. That means less pay but it is not discrimination. You know that, yes?

Good point and just reiterating!!

MajorCarolDanvers · 18/02/2022 22:32

ACAS know what they are talking about. If they say you have a case then you do.

You should take their advice and follow it carefully b

Itsalmostanaccessory · 18/02/2022 22:29

Do you understand that you will still get less money? You'll be paid pro-rata for the hours you do if they agree to a job share. That means less pay but it is not discrimination. You know that, yes?

You also know that not all jobs are suitable for job sharing. If they say no, you can challenge that. Could win or lose.

I dont understand why you feel like you're swimming against the tide. Your employer sounds really good.

Your job is yours if you want it. You dont want it. You told them what you do want but they dont have that for you so they went and created a role for you, to your specifications.

They clearly want you back. They didnt need to create a new role for you. They did that because they want you back. It is actually going to cost them more than a job share or flexible working. They'll need to pay someone to do your old job and pay you for your new job. They're creating more expense for the company in order to get you back and this new role clearly isnt essential to them. They've made it just so you can come back and work at the level of seniority that you have chosen. That obviously comes with less pay. But it is what you asked for.

You're not entitled to the same pay if you request to come back to a different job. You're only entitled to the same pay if you return to the same role or make a sideways move.

It really sounds like they've done what they can to accommodate you. It would have been easier and cheaper for them to just make your role flexible working or job share. It sounds like that's not suitable for the job.

Watapalava · 18/02/2022 22:25

Job share is best bet but if the cover knows you can’t cope returning full time they may hold out and say no - knowing full well you’d likely leave and they’d get full time role

If I was them it’s what I would do as I can’t afford a part time role

Watapalava · 18/02/2022 22:24

As pp says there is no discrimination because the job is yours

You’ve been declined reduced hours due to business needs - they are entitled to do that

It’s ‘return to current role or leave‘ normally

They’ve been good to find another role for you. They could have declined all requests and you’d have ended up handing your notice in if your senior role doesn’t suit

Don’t bite the hand that feeds you they’ve done you a favour

The mat cover it’s not relevant and none of your business really

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 22:19

@Sunshineboo I would absolutely consider a job share, I will suggest this, thank you

OP posts:
ChicCroissant · 18/02/2022 22:13

It’s just that they have offered my job to my colleague and although it’s not my problem how they resolve that situation, does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?

No, they offered her the job because you'd said you didn't want to return to it - that's not them showing a preference!

Sunshineboo · 18/02/2022 22:12

he here. they can rescind the offer to the other candidate and put you back in it - it's shitty but frankly the mat cover will have less service and the risks to the organisations are lower.

Alternative roles offered must be on same basis so same pay level and responsibility level. because you requested a less responsible job, I don't think it was unreasonable to offer you the lower paid alternative (assuming that what was offered was the correct going rate for that role).

You are well within your rights to say you have considered it and don't wish to accept this role and will either take your old role back or an alternative with the same responsibility, status and pay as before. albeit on fewer hours with flexible hours or whatever. they can then consider this and see what they can do - at the moment the ask has been less hours and less responsibility - ie they have perceived that to be another type of job

if job share is something you would consider, please tell them that. if you remain clear in your communication, firm but sticking to the facts - ie i don't want this, i will accept that then they will find it very hard not to accept.

good luck - these times can be tricky and stressful x

jotaaaaaa · 18/02/2022 22:05

Acas aren't allowed to give you legal advice - they can tell you what the law says and help you apply it to your situation, but they cannot give legal advice. I'd recommend you seek advice

I'm an employment lawyer and agree with the posters saying that if you have asked for a different role altogether, there's no requirement for them to accommodate this on the same rate of pay. If they were saying your job no longer existed and they were finding an alternative role for you, that would be different.

In terms of the Mat leave cover - I don't think the fact that they have offered her the job suggests that she is necessarily their preferred option - they just think you don't want it and it makes sense to offer it to the person who's been doing it for a year. If she's not been employed for 2 years it doesn't matter what they've said to her or offered her - they can let her go fairly easily and mostly free of risk

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 22:04

@Imdonna I really truly have never handled a mat leave for any of my employees. I don’t want to go into my line of work but I would say probably about one in a thousand job applicants are from women of a child bearing age. That’s why sometimes I feel like I’m swimming against the tide. And why I asked for the advice.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread