Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is maternity discrimination?

266 replies

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 18:50

I am on maternity leave and due back to work at the end of May. I have a 4yo and 8mo. When I return to work I will have had a full year of mat leave. My pregnancy was uncomplicated but my son fell very poorly at 14 weeks old. He pulled through but is now being investigated for potential cerebral palsy. I had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance. They were receptive to this and went away to work on a new position for me in the company in reduced hours/responsibility.

Today I had a further meeting with them where they outlined a new position to fulfil a business need and which suited my needs. I was made aware they had offered my current role to the person who is my maternity cover currently. However, it was then explained that my new role would be on a significantly reduced salary pro-rate, almost £6 an hour less equivalent. I raised a concern that as a woman returning from mat leave I was entitled to either my old job back or a different role on the same pay. They then said in that case I could either have my old role back on my old hours & salary, or accept the new job on the reduced salary (“hourly rate”).

I spoke to ACAS who advised because my employer has verbally offered my current role to someone else, they have effectively brought my current job to an end. As this has happened while I am on maternity leave and they have offered the role to my maternity cover, it could amount to discrimination. ACAS have also advised me that verbal job offers and acceptances are legally binding. My employer is therefore obliged to offer me a job on similar terms than I was on before as they have effectively brought my current job to an end.

Does this sound right? I don’t want to raise hell unless I have to as I work for a small company and I’ve been there for 15 years. I’d really appreciate any advice and will answer any questions. Thank you.

OP posts:
Watapalava · 19/02/2022 09:12

She doesn’t have to decide in a week no

But then they don’t have to find her a lesser role

They could throw it back at op and say it’s your old role or none

Watapalava · 19/02/2022 09:11

Spudjulia

You clearly haven’t read full thread

What you are saying is what everyone has said

They are allowing her to return to old role

There is no case

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:09
  1. "a whole week* to consider this and sort childcare for a child with additional needs? Don't make me laugh. You don't need to stick to their timeframes. Stick to the legal ones.
spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:06

www.acas.org.uk/your-maternity-leave-pay-and-other-rights/returning-to-work-after-having-a-baby

Read that. Specifically - If you use additional maternity leave, you still have the right to return to your job on the same terms as before you left. But if it's not possible because there have been significant changes to the organisation, you could be offered a similar job.
In this case, the job cannot be on worse terms than before. For example, the following must be the same:
• pay
• benefits
• holiday entitlement
• seniority
• where the job is

  1. if you request a position with less responsibility/hours, you won't necessarily be on the same rate of pay.

  2. if they've offered your old job to someone else, that's their problem to sort out. You are still entitled to go back to your own job or a similar one with the same terms as your old job (see ACAS above). This is protected in law and it would be discrimination if you aren't able to return to it.

  3. ignore any of the posts that suggests that accepting your maternity rights is cheeky or stupid or greedy. These laws are there to protect women at a vulnerable time in their lives. There's so much inequality in the workplace, cling onto the rights we do have!

  4. please get proper legal advice, don't try to navigate this on your own and definitely don't get swayed by some of the completely ignorant posts on this thread.

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:02

The whole thing about offering the job to the maternity cover... they have probably just said that OP has indicated that she might not want to come back to the same role, and that the mat cover can stay in the role if she doesn't. I doubt that there have been any contracts signed because they are also very clear that OP can have her old job back if she wants it.

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 08:58

Goodness, OP, you still don't seem to be getting it. You stated clearly in your update that they are still saying that your old job is yours if you want it, so you don't have a case. Quite the contrary, it sounds like they have bent over backwards to give you options that they didn't have to give you. Not all employers would do that.

I also think the timescales that they have given you are very fair. You have a whole week to consider this and sort out childcare arrangements etc. They cannot keep it open indefinitely because there are other people who need to know what's going on. It isn't fair to keep them hanging while you have all the time in the world.

You seem very focused on your own needs and quite oblivious to the needs of the business. I find it really surprising that someone who has occupied a senior management role can be quite so unaware, but maybe the stress of your current situation is getting in the way of you thinking straight.

SerendipityJane · 19/02/2022 08:46

If the OP is an exemplar of the standard of "senior management" in the UK - unable to decide what they want, unable to articulate it, and unable to work with others to attain it, a lot of things start to make sense about the state of the country.

Yes; I did.

whiteroseredrose · 19/02/2022 08:40

When I went back to work after DC I asked to work 4 days a week and to step down from my Manager role back to a Rep one.

My hourly rate stayed the same, it just went to 80% and I kept my manager level car.

I was very surprised.

PolkaSpace · 19/02/2022 08:19

Maybe seek legal advice if you considering going to court. It all sounds confusing.

GreyGoose1980 · 19/02/2022 08:10

I agree they should not have offered your role to a replacement before concluding conversations with you in relation to a new role. However your posts are a bit unclear in terms of your expectations. Are you looking for less hours or a role with less responsibility as the two are different. The former would have required you to put in a flexible working request with the assumption that it was with reference to your current role / grade. Advising them you want less responsibility indicates you want to step away from your current job grade for work life balance reasons and then it’s reasonable to assume the pay would alter accordingly without this being discriminatory.

brainhurts · 19/02/2022 08:04

Ok so they have offered you your old job , and the offer is still open . You asked for reduced responsibility they facilitated this , this of course comes with a lower salary.
You have been told if you take your old job back due to a restructure you will have less responsibility anyway, presume on same pay .
You need to decide what you want , I can't see how they have discriminated against you .
It does however seem you are trying to build a case against your employers as your needs have changed due to your child's health. Really sorry your son has been poorly 💐

Grumpsy · 19/02/2022 08:04

So OP - by your logic a person can be a finance director before going on maternity leave paid 200k PA, and request to come back as a project accountant, due to work life balance, for which the standard salary is 50k PA, but because they left on the higher salary they expect to be paid the higher amount. This is ridiculous - no company would pay more for a lesser grade and lesser responsibility.

Seriously take a step back, have some objectivity and give your head a wobble.

You have asked for less responsibility, they’ve offered it to you, they’ve also offered you your old job. You can’t have your cake and eat it. Pick one.

Also the constant comments of “would this help my case” make you sound self entitled and like you are determined to bring action against your employer either way.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 07:45

Op, a other thread said you went back on 28 hours after your first child was born. You say you are just naive and never managed an employees mat leave before, but you have managed you own.

Did you not experience a drop in income when you went from full time to part time? You also said that you requested a further reduction in hours previously and they had given business reasons (which you understood) why this would not be possible.

In addition to this you also asked for a job with less responsibilities. They have created 2 options. Both of which you have first refusal on. You have had more than 26 weeks off, which changes (slightly) what they have to offer you.

You also said you needed ro make your decision about what you were doing by 28th Feb. That's next Sunday. So you need to make the decision by the last working day before that. You were aware of that deadline. I know things have changed for you so you may be able to request to push that slightly. But they will need a decision soon if the new role is starting 4 weeks later.

You would struggle to say they are demoting you purley based on a reduction of hours. Because they have already outlined a business case that says your role can not be accompanied on less than the 28 hours you are on now. And also they supported you for several years working part time between your children, they just can't reduce it further. They have a history of supporting you where they can. And are now trying to keep you in the business by offering multiple options.

girlmom21 · 19/02/2022 07:37

You can't have it all ways. You can have less hours and less responsibility and the same pay. You're entitled to an equal level/pay job but you don't want the level.

Watapalava · 19/02/2022 07:29

Op if I was your boss I’d just say it’s this role or none

They don’t have to find a suitable role for you

You are entitled to request

They must consider it but do not have to agree

If you need them about they’ll give roles out now and you’ll be left with your old role equivalent (allowed and within rules) or none
You are effectively shooting you self in the foot here

tirednewmumm · 19/02/2022 07:27

@Ohtheaudacity

Thanks everyone, I think my main issue is they’ve verbally offered my job to my maternity cover before offering me a viable alternative. Can they now rescind this offer from her and reinstate me into my old job? Doesn’t that leave them in hot water with her? Sorry if I sound clueless, it’s because I am 😂
I would guess it isn't a formal written offer they've verbally said to her look it looks like A isn't coming back in which case we would like to offer you the chance to stay permanently. That's legally v different to formal offer and they haven't taken the option off the table for you to go back to your old job
Pandoh · 19/02/2022 07:17

If your old job hasn't been formally offered to your mat leave cover so you can have it still, and you asked for less responsibility then its weird acas think you have a case. Yes you have to be given your job or another that isn't on less favourable terms, but when you specifically request less responsibility you're the one changing the spec essentially and it doesn't mean legally they have to pay you the same just as you're off mat leave.

Chestofdraws · 19/02/2022 07:10

Yeah I’m also very surprised at what acas said. You requested this. You can’t honestly think you should do a lesser role for the same money?

Your old job is still available, they are permitted to verbally discuss with anyone else if they’d take the job since you indicated you don’t want it. This isn’t the same as a formal offer.

They are also entitled to restructure, it looks like they are making your current role redundant, so they will need to follow a consultation process and then give who they think is the best candidate the job, which could well be your maternity cover.

RedHelenB · 19/02/2022 07:08

@LadyCleathStuart

OP there was a very similar case to this in my local area a few years ago. I know about it as it made the paper because it was a high profile local employer. It was woman demoted after asking for part time hours on return from maternity.

Anyway the woman won her maternity discrimination case, as rightly she should have. I would say if ACAS are saying you have a case then you probably do.

That was because she was demoted, presumablyagainst her wishes. The OP has asked to have a role with less responsibility than her old job.
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 19/02/2022 07:02

had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance.

I'd be the first one to support someone in a discrimination case. However, as you say above, you want fewer hours and less responsibility. Your employer has agreed to this - giving you the option of a role with reduced responsibility and a lower salary accordingly. Which means they would need to identify someone to take over your old role. Which they have done.

I can't imagine any court deciding that it is discriminatory to pay someone less for doing less, when the reduction in responsibility was at the employee's request.
Or am I missing something ?

daisypond · 19/02/2022 07:02

Op, you seem happy to take on board the comments that people make that seem to agree with you, eg, the one by @Itsalmostanaccessory. But they are wrong. Ignore that poster. You have no claim here whatsoever. Ask for a job share on your old job. If they can’t agree to that,accept your old job back or take the new job on reduced pay and responsibilities. The only way you get to keep your current salary is by going back to your old job (or a similar one with similar responsibilities) full time.

Newmumatlast · 19/02/2022 06:35

@LadyCleathStuart

OP there was a very similar case to this in my local area a few years ago. I know about it as it made the paper because it was a high profile local employer. It was woman demoted after asking for part time hours on return from maternity.

Anyway the woman won her maternity discrimination case, as rightly she should have. I would say if ACAS are saying you have a case then you probably do.

To be fair your description suggests she was demoted because she asked for part time. OP is effectively asking for a demotion as she isnt just asking for part time but also less responsibility
TidyDancer · 19/02/2022 06:29

This does read as if you are trying any which way to get your old salary whatever job you return to. Surely you must've understood that less hours and less responsibility would equate to less pay? Fundamentally, it was you who requested this and not them.

Bottom line is that you actually need to decide what you want to do here and until that point you're just pissing in the wind. If you want your old job (or the equivalent, which they've held for you and said you can have) then take it. If you want something 'lesser' then take that instead (they've also created and offered you this).

I completely get that it's a difficult situation for you, but I can't see where your employer has gone wrong. They're trying to do right by you, you just seem determined to be combative about it. Ultimately, the outcome of this is all in your hands.

WulyJmpr · 19/02/2022 06:14

OP they've done exactly what you asked and given you two options for your career going forward and you are acting shocked and offended by their flexibility.

jotaaaaaa · 19/02/2022 05:59

@Ohtheaudacity

So, I have somewhat of an update (yes I know it’s late but I’ve just checked my email…)

I have received an email from my manager explaining that my maternity cover has not “technically” been offered my exact job role/title. They have tweaked the role slightly and changed the job title slightly (think “head of sales” to “sales manager”). They say this new role is part of a wider company restructure and is effective 1st April. I am not due back until early June but when I am back I will join the team in this new, lesser worse paid job. Does this change things? Does this help my case? They are still, confusingly, saying that I can return to my old job if I choose, while in the next breath saying that job will cease to exist from 1st April 2022. I’m so confused!

Agree with PP that the 'does this help my case' makes you look like you want them to mess up

I would caution you that the employment tribunals are really backlogged at the moment, you could easily be a year (depending on location) before you get a final hearing. Also, the employment tribunals don't work in the same way as the civil courts and you are responsible for your own fees no matter the outcome. If you were to instruct my firm (a reasonably large Scottish firm, but by no means one of the more expensive firms) you'd be looking at having to pay us circa £10k +VAT upfront to run this for you and you wouldn't get this back from the employer even if you win. No win no fee or legal aid options are fairly few and far between for employment work

Swipe left for the next trending thread