Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is maternity discrimination?

266 replies

Ohtheaudacity · 18/02/2022 18:50

I am on maternity leave and due back to work at the end of May. I have a 4yo and 8mo. When I return to work I will have had a full year of mat leave. My pregnancy was uncomplicated but my son fell very poorly at 14 weeks old. He pulled through but is now being investigated for potential cerebral palsy. I had a meeting with my manager in January and explained my personal situation and how my desire now was to reduce my working hours/responsibility (my current role is senior management with a huge workload) to have a better work life balance. They were receptive to this and went away to work on a new position for me in the company in reduced hours/responsibility.

Today I had a further meeting with them where they outlined a new position to fulfil a business need and which suited my needs. I was made aware they had offered my current role to the person who is my maternity cover currently. However, it was then explained that my new role would be on a significantly reduced salary pro-rate, almost £6 an hour less equivalent. I raised a concern that as a woman returning from mat leave I was entitled to either my old job back or a different role on the same pay. They then said in that case I could either have my old role back on my old hours & salary, or accept the new job on the reduced salary (“hourly rate”).

I spoke to ACAS who advised because my employer has verbally offered my current role to someone else, they have effectively brought my current job to an end. As this has happened while I am on maternity leave and they have offered the role to my maternity cover, it could amount to discrimination. ACAS have also advised me that verbal job offers and acceptances are legally binding. My employer is therefore obliged to offer me a job on similar terms than I was on before as they have effectively brought my current job to an end.

Does this sound right? I don’t want to raise hell unless I have to as I work for a small company and I’ve been there for 15 years. I’d really appreciate any advice and will answer any questions. Thank you.

OP posts:
Westerman · 19/02/2022 10:16

@Ohtheaudacity

Wow there’s a lot of comments here and I’ve read them all although can’t reply to everything individually.

For clarification, I am not a chancer. Well I don’t think I am. I really don’t know how these things work and I had read the online literature and spoken to ACAS who had all backed up my feelings of being a bit upset. However I’m looking for as many perspectives as possible which is why I came here. The HR folk who have commented seem to think I am not being unreasonable but many others do… so I’m not really any clearer on what to do. It’s just that they have offered my job to my colleague and although it’s not my problem how they resolve that situation, does that not demonstrate they have a preferred candidate for my job over me?

I do think my feelings are clouded a lot by my sons health situation right now. It’s been rotten. It’s felt like setback after setback and today with my job situation felt like even more bad news.

I apologise if I came across as entitled or lazy, I’m just a mum trying to do right by my family.

Butl doesn't thm having created a new role for you, a whole new job, prove that they've gone over and above to retain you?
Imdonna · 19/02/2022 10:14

However, legally they are on thin ice as this job is the closest equivalent to her old job therefore she should be offered it first - not the cover.

Its been offered to the op. She has first refusal.

From what I read her mat cover is being offered one of the 2 roles that will support.

Which is exactly what ops wants. Again, the restructure doc is generic. Theres every chance that op, as this has been a restructure during her mat leave will remain on the same rate of pay. That happens all the time. Jobs change, but the pay remains the same because the change wasn't requested by the employee.

Op needs to confirm what her rate of pay would be. Op already works part time. If she goes back on the same 28 hours, she would still be part time, less responsibility, same pay. Which is what she wanted.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 19/02/2022 10:08

Regardless, she's allowed by law to return to a similar role with the SAME pay and conditions

No one is disagreeing with that. But OP said she wants less responsibility. In which case they don't have to pay her the same. Why would they?!

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 10:04

It seems that the employer has repeatedly stated that the OP can have her old job back if she wants it, so I suspect that they are well aware of her rights coming back from maternity leave and I don't think they are going to try and deny her these rights. They have just offered her an alternative option with less responsibility and less pay because that's what she asked for.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/02/2022 10:01

@daisypond

What are you talking about? I've spent this whole thread telling her she is wrong and has no case for discrimination. What on earth are you on about by saying I'm wrong?

nanbread · 19/02/2022 09:58

You have had more than 26 weeks off, which changes (slightly) what they have to offer you.

Well, not much tbh. It should be a similar job - as similar as they can get it.

I.e. they cannot really offer the cover the "sales manager" role that's MORE similar to OP's old one but not identical.

My old employer tried this, offered me my same title/ role back but working for a different team (which I didn't want to work for) - while keeping my cover in my old team. One email later and I had my exact old role back.

nanbread · 19/02/2022 09:54

@spudjulia

I have received an email from my manager explaining that my maternity cover has not “technically” been offered my exact job role/title. They have tweaked the role slightly and changed the job title slightly (think “head of sales” to “sales manager”). They say this new role is part of a wider company restructure and is effective 1st April. I am not due back until early June but when I am back I will join the team in this new, lesser worse paid job.

For ease of reference. The OPs job has been "tweaked" and shared between 2 people and pay is less. That's against the law. A woman can return to her job after 52 weeks maternity leave to a similar job - similar being the same pay and conditions.

But that's only if OP accepts those terms and takes the new, lesser job?

It sounds like the "sales manager" role the mat leave cover has been offered is the equivalent of her old role, but with less of the take home work, making it potentially more doable for OP, and possibly on the same pay.

Now the employer may have "tweaked" the job role and changed job title as part of a faux restructure, in order to get round the obligation of offering OP her old job back...

However, legally they are on thin ice as this job is the closest equivalent to her old job therefore she should be offered it first - not the cover.

Making her redundant while on mat leave and giving her cover the job also leaves them on v v thin ice, legally.

They would be v unwise to do either of these, until OP has confirmed she doesn't want the old job back.

If I were OP, I would tell them you PLAN to take the "head of sales" role which by the time you return will have become the "sales manager" role, and formally confirm your return within the legal timelines, if you think the new role will 1. Definitely happen and 2. You could potentially take it on in your circumstances, at least in the shorter term. You could then explore job share etc.

I would also start looking for another job with options for flexible or part time working, as the parent of a child with extra needs you will probably want/need it.

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:49

@spudjulia

They are still, confusingly, saying that I can return to my old job if I choose, while in the next breath saying that job will cease to exist from 1st April 2022. I’m so confused!

This is possibly key in understanding what the OP meant. Her 'old' job won't exist anymore.

So what do you think they mean when they say that she can go back to it?

I think they mean that there is an equivalent job in the revised structure that is open to her if she wants it. What else could it mean?

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:48

@spudjulia

No, the way I read it,

Well maybe the OP can confirm.

Regardless, she's allowed by law to return to a similar role with the SAME pay and conditions.

Yes, we all know that.

But that assumes that the OP will go back to the same job or its equivalent, not a less senior role with less responsibility. In this scenario, she has been given a choice between the two.

What the OP seems to have been expecting is that she could go back to a lesser role while keeping the same pay and conditions. That isn't an option and it doesn't have to be.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:46

They are still, confusingly, saying that I can return to my old job if I choose, while in the next breath saying that job will cease to exist from 1st April 2022. I’m so confused!

This is possibly key in understanding what the OP meant. Her 'old' job won't exist anymore.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:43

No, the way I read it,

Well maybe the OP can confirm.

Regardless, she's allowed by law to return to a similar role with the SAME pay and conditions.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:42

I think by detonation you mean demotion. And as I wrote in my first post point 1 - if you request and accept a role with less hours and less responsibility, it won't necessarily be at the same pay.

I've also copied and pasted the definition of "similar', which means it must be on the same pay and conditions.

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:41

[quote spudjulia]**@Imdonna* read the update after midnight. The restructured* role is for less pay. Her old job won't exist after April.

Read my point 1 for an answer to your last question.

[/quote]
No, the way I read it, there are 2 new roles and the OP is being asked to make a choice between them.

One is a slightly tweaked version of the OP's original role, presumably on the same T&C as she was on previously, but with a bit more of a structure below her than she has had to date. When they are saying that she can go back to her "old role", it is essentially this position. Her old role but with a bit more support in place.

The other choice is a lesser role, supporting the person in the old role, which is in line with the OP's request for a demotion. The pay and hours are less, but the OP does not have to accept these terms if she doesn't want to, as she can still go back to her old role (or an equivalent version of it) if that is what she chooses.

LakieLady · 19/02/2022 09:39

@Ohtheaudacity

So, I have somewhat of an update (yes I know it’s late but I’ve just checked my email…)

I have received an email from my manager explaining that my maternity cover has not “technically” been offered my exact job role/title. They have tweaked the role slightly and changed the job title slightly (think “head of sales” to “sales manager”). They say this new role is part of a wider company restructure and is effective 1st April. I am not due back until early June but when I am back I will join the team in this new, lesser worse paid job. Does this change things? Does this help my case? They are still, confusingly, saying that I can return to my old job if I choose, while in the next breath saying that job will cease to exist from 1st April 2022. I’m so confused!

I'd ask them the question directly, OP, eg. "I thought that role was coming to an end on 1/4/22. I won't be back from mat leave until June. Please could you clarify what role you are anticipating that I will be returning to in June."

I think there's been a real lack of clarity in communications between you and your management/HR, tbh. I'd be minded to put everything in emails from now on so that there's a record, and that everyone is clear about what both sides are asking for and expecting.

If your current role won't exist when you return, that is mat. discrimination imo. One part of the organisation I work for had a real habit of messing people about when they returned from mat leave because they preferred their mat cover in the role. They kept their grade, salary and often identical job titles, but delivering different projects. Sometimes it wasn't a problem, and in a few cases the employee preferred the new role, but in several it meant working from a location that was less convenient for them and some staff left as a result.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 09:39

[quote spudjulia]**@Imdonna* read the update after midnight. The restructured* role is for less pay. Her old job won't exist after April.

Read my point 1 for an answer to your last question.

[/quote]
Op is reading that it's lesser paid from tbe restructure doc. That doesn't mean if she takes this option her pay will be lesser.

A restructure doc, is generic. It will not be specific to the op.

Still dont get wethwr you believe that if op takes the detonation you think she should be on the same pay.

Op has been off longer than 26 weeks which changed what they have to offer her. After 26 it's into additional maternity leave Maternity actions advise.

However, if your employer can show that it isnot reasonably practicable for you to return to the same job, you are entitled to be offered a suitable alternative job on similar terms and conditions.

Note the words similar. Op is being offered an alternative role and may be offered similar terms and conditions.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:37

I have received an email from my manager explaining that my maternity cover has not “technically” been offered my exact job role/title. They have tweaked the role slightly and changed the job title slightly (think “head of sales” to “sales manager”). They say this new role is part of a wider company restructure and is effective 1st April. I am not due back until early June but when I am back I will join the team in this new, lesser worse paid job.

For ease of reference. The OPs job has been "tweaked" and shared between 2 people and pay is less. That's against the law. A woman can return to her job after 52 weeks maternity leave to a similar job - similar being the same pay and conditions.

jacks11 · 19/02/2022 09:34

YABU.

This is terrible, if it’s true that simply having been on maternity leave entitles a woman to expect the same pay even if it has been their request for a change of role (including less hours, less responsibility). I can understand that coming into play if having been on maternity leave you come back to find your role has been given to someone else or substantially changed (not at your request) BUT in this instance this is a change YOU told them you wanted. They acted in good faith, I think, and tried to accommodate your request. I suspect they’ll think long and hard about doing so again after this.

I am baffled by your stance- though I suppose if ACAS says they have acted contrary to legislation then you can chose to fight it. I don’t really understand why you thought that a change of job to one with less hours, lower workload and less responsibility should be paid the same? In any other situation an employee essentially asking for a new job would not be in a position to demand and expect to be paid the same for a different job.

That makes a mockery of the system- presumably they were happy for you to come back to your job but it was YOU who I requested essentially a new role to fit around your family needs, not that your employer decided to move you without your consent. You indicated you no longer wanted the job you had. I imagine that reducing your hours and responsibility (for the same pay) did not work for your employers so they have sought to create something more suited to your needs- with a salary to match the requirements of the new role. They have accommodated your request.

Unfortunately, I suspect ACAS will be right in terms of the law and you can force your employer to give you the new job and the salary you want (though I imagine it may make things strained at work, but that may not be a consideration for you) or you can claim discrimination and get a settlement. I think it is behaviour like this which puts employers off trying to be flexible and makes some employers wary of women of child-bearing age.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:33

@Imdonna read the update after midnight. The restructured role is for less pay. Her old job won't exist after April.

Read my point 1 for an answer to your last question.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 09:31

Oh I did read the thread, and every post by OP. In her update after midnight she says her current job is being 'restructured' in April and the new role is paid less. That's against the law

No it isn't. The restructured role has no indication it will not be on the same wage.

The lower wage will be if she picks the option with less hours AND a demotion. That's absolutely legal.

You really believe they are o liged to keep the same rate of pay AND give the op the demotion she has requested?

AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:26

Oh I did read the thread, and every post by OP. In her update after midnight she says her current job is being 'restructured' in April and the new role is paid less. That's against the law.

You missed the part where they said that she could still go back to her old job if she wanted it.

spudjulia · 19/02/2022 09:24

@Watapalava

Spudjulia

You clearly haven’t read full thread

What you are saying is what everyone has said

They are allowing her to return to old role

There is no case

Oh I did read the thread, and every post by OP. In her update after midnight she says her current job is being 'restructured' in April and the new role is paid less. That's against the law.
AlexaShutUp · 19/02/2022 09:21

Of course she can stick to the legal timeliness, but then her options will be more limited. Either go back to her old job or hand in her notice. The employer is under no obligation whatsoever to keep the other option on the table beyond a week if that doesn't suit them.

And yes, a week to sort childcare probably isn't enough but the OP has presumably already started investigating options already so she won't be starting from scratch. And she will still have the rest of her maternity leave to finalise what she is doing.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 09:20

OP has been offered her old job back and told it is still available but it will end April 2022. So needs to look at the redundancy process I think to check it's been followed.

The role has been changed. So yes the old role, is technically redundant. But as op is on Mat leave she has been offered the new version of the role. That closer fits her needs. Which us what they need to do.

It also appears its been changed to suit op (less responsibility but at the same level) and to suit her requests. Which again further complicates it.

Imdonna · 19/02/2022 09:16

ignore any of the posts that suggests that accepting your maternity rights is cheeky or stupid or greedy. These laws are there to protect women at a vulnerable time in their lives. There's so much inequality in the workplace, cling onto the rights we do have!

No one said she should accept her maternity rights

) "a whole week to consider this and sort childcare for a child with additional needs? Don't make me laugh. You don't need to stick to their timeframes. Stick to the legal ones.*

Op was fully aware that she needed this sorted by 28th February (though the reason isn't clear) in November

Also there no indication she has to be back at work by then. Only that she needs a devision. She has the rest of her mat leave to actually get it in place.

PolkaSpace · 19/02/2022 09:12

@spudjulia

https://www.acas.org.uk/your-maternity-leave-pay-and-other-rights/returning-to-work-after-having-a-baby

Read that. Specifically - If you use additional maternity leave, you still have the right to return to your job on the same terms as before you left. But if it's not possible because there have been significant changes to the organisation, you could be offered a similar job.
In this case, the job cannot be on worse terms than before. For example, the following must be the same:
• pay
• benefits
• holiday entitlement
• seniority
• where the job is

  1. if you request a position with less responsibility/hours, you won't necessarily be on the same rate of pay.

  2. if they've offered your old job to someone else, that's their problem to sort out. You are still entitled to go back to your own job or a similar one with the same terms as your old job (see ACAS above). This is protected in law and it would be discrimination if you aren't able to return to it.

  3. ignore any of the posts that suggests that accepting your maternity rights is cheeky or stupid or greedy. These laws are there to protect women at a vulnerable time in their lives. There's so much inequality in the workplace, cling onto the rights we do have!

  4. please get proper legal advice, don't try to navigate this on your own and definitely don't get swayed by some of the completely ignorant posts on this thread.

OP has been offered her old job back and told it is still available but it will end April 2022. So needs to look at the redundancy process I think to check it's been followed.
Swipe left for the next trending thread