Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that I'm unsettled by a school play for making a joke about prostitution

56 replies

Woolyminded · 18/02/2022 17:00

I'm either becoming a raging, permanently angry feminist in my middle age, or I'm justifiably miffed. I need to be told whether I need to get a grip or send the email I'm thinking of writing.
I love musicals and on Monday night I went to see a performance of the Sound of Music at my partners kids school. The school is known as a predominantly middle-class, well off families, very disciplined, very Christian sort of school. So I wasnt surprised when the performance was very swish, polished, and the kids were confident and sparkling. I was impressed.
In the first half two of the von trapps servants are engaging in a bit of banter about being in the navy. The pretty female housekeeper says something like 'i wouldn't know, I've never been in the navy', the male butler replies 'thats a shame, youd have made a fortune" with a sly wink at the audience. I cant think of what this could refer to apart from prostitution?! It just seemed so wrong to be said by a young boy, to a girl, in front of an audience of children and parents. They couldve left it out. I'm not a prude but I don't see whats funny about a joke referring to the objectification and exploitation of women.
When I mentioned it to my partner he brushed it off with 'it was a joke only the adults would get, its harmless'.
The older I get the more bothered I am about the normalisation of shit like this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FlasherMcGruff · 19/02/2022 22:21

Many years ago I appeared in a play called ‘Lock Up Your Daughters’ performed by the local youth theatre. The plot is based on a comedy called ‘Rape Upon Rape’ and the plot, taken from Wiki, is:
‘ In London, 1735, naive young Hilaret leaves the over-protective walls of her father's house resolved to elope with her beloved Captain Constant. She charges Ramble with rape, and her maid Cloris charges Constant with rape. The cases are tried by the corrupt justice, Mr. Squeezum.’

I had no grasp of how weird this was at the time. Imagine that play being performed now, let alone by a cast of teenagers?

That joke in the play you saw will have gone right over their heads. But you’re right - they should cut the line. Times have changed.

ChekhovsMum · 19/02/2022 21:50

This is it - I really can’t see the tickets getting sold for a show by an unknown playwright. Also, even with those, isn’t there some kind of copyright law so that the playwright’s name isn’t going on a piece of work that isn’t theirs? And when you say ‘edit’, is this with the writer’s permission? You can’t ‘buy in’ a play as far as I know, only pay performing rights to put it on. But if there are companies that will let you do this, that sounds fantastic for key stage 3 maybe.
By upper secondary most kids would expect to be in something full-length, and if I’ve got to write a two-hour play from scratch every year and then direct it for 60 hours, all for free, then I officially quit!

Comefromaway · 19/02/2022 21:13

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

In primary we buy in and edit or write our own plays. And that's without being an expert in the field of drama. So what's stopping, presumably secondary, from doing the same? Plenty of non westend shows written particularly for schools, although, as I stated earlier, they usually need scenes cutting to be suitable.
In secondary children want to perform and parents want to watch big, well known musicals.

Most secondaries will also be putting on straight plays or devised work as well.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 19/02/2022 21:11

In primary we buy in and edit or write our own plays. And that's without being an expert in the field of drama.
So what's stopping, presumably secondary, from doing the same?
Plenty of non westend shows written particularly for schools, although, as I stated earlier, they usually need scenes cutting to be suitable.

ChekhovsMum · 19/02/2022 21:02

Making my first ever MN post for this point…
If you search the three main companies that hold the performing rights to plays and musicals, look for shows with big enough casts, which people have actually heard of and will pay to come and see, where you’re allowed to use performers over the age of 13 (so not Disney), and which have musical scores which the singers and musicians in a secondary school can handle, you end up with about 8. One of them is Grease and one of them is Guys and Dolls, both of which are, let’s be honest, a wee bit sexist. Another is High School Musical, so if you’re presenting to parents with high aspirations for their children then that one’s out - and by the time you’re done it’s either ‘The Sound of Music’, the show with the joke that might be about prostitution but probably isn’t, or ‘Pretty Woman: The Musical’.

Do you also realise that there is no overtime paid for directing school shows, and the average musical will have taken at least two members of staff at least 60 hours of rehearsal apiece, which should amount to a Christmas bonus of about two grand each, but doesn’t, because they know what a life-changing experience it is for a child to be involved in a performance like that, so they just plough on with it. And those numbers don’t take into account the time spent reading perusal copies of scripts, scheduling rehearsals, sourcing props and costumes, and doing other admin.

Perhaps next year you could read all the scripts that fit the bill, combing them for any joke that could possibly be about something triggering to someone if they read it a certain way, and put your name on the programme so that people can complain to you after you’ve put in months of work giving their child an incredible opportunity for no money.

Momicrone · 19/02/2022 13:22

I remember when some kid on Britain's got talent made a joke about Amanda holden being a dog, I thought that was horrible

LouisRenault · 19/02/2022 13:17

If schools don't want their time taken up dealing with questions like this they shouldn't produce plays with dodgy content.

'Schools' don't produce plays. Members of staff do, putting in hours of their own time. If too much more time is taken up, they'll probably say 'sod this for a game of soldiers', and stop producing plays at all. Then there'll be nothing to worry about.

Comefromaway · 19/02/2022 12:09

As a teacher, when faced with an ambiguous line like that, made worse by a stage direction to wink at the audience, I would have edited something;

There is no stage direction to wink at the audience in the Sound of Music. It’s a show that does not break the fourth wall.

Ohdearthatwasntgreatwasit · 19/02/2022 10:10

I think in this case you might have misunderstood OP, but in general I agree with you.

We won’t be attending Panto again for this reason. The inherent misogyny of drag queens combined with some very questionable ‘jokes’ really needs to die a death now, it’s 2022 and these things are no longer acceptable IMO.

TwoShades1 · 19/02/2022 10:08

I think it has been “acted wrong” by the student which has given the impression of prostitution, rather than rising through the navy ranks due to her manner. So either the student has incorrectly interpreted the script as meaning prostitution or they were for some reason told to deliver the line this way.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 19/02/2022 09:59

@shinynewapple22

Given that the person who they are making a joke around is the housekeeper, I would have taken it that the men in the Navy were very untidy and she would have had a good job cleaning up after them . Given that is what her job actually is .
Sailors are very, very tidy indeed. They have to be living and working in tiny cramped quarters. That's where the phrase 'ship shape' comes from. And I guess the NCOs in charge have to be strict/bossy to din those habits into the young ratings.
JaninaDuszejko · 19/02/2022 09:24

Write to the school and question it. If schools don't want their time taken up dealing with questions like this they shouldn't produce plays with dodgy content.

lottiegarbanzo · 19/02/2022 09:16

So has the 'knowing wink' been re-defined in a way many of us don't know about? I understand it's use in drama as signalling a saucy comment or double entendre.

shinynewapple22 · 19/02/2022 08:33

Given that the person who they are making a joke around is the housekeeper, I would have taken it that the men in the Navy were very untidy and she would have had a good job cleaning up after them . Given that is what her job actually is .

lottiegarbanzo · 19/02/2022 08:28

Hello @Valeriekat It's nice of you to tell me about JF's early films but, why?

Have you confused me with another poster? (Or psychically intuited my old Jodie Foster crush?! Though she had not come to mind at all, in connection with a discussion of TSOM).

DailyMailBestForBums · 19/02/2022 08:27

If you're concerned about it, contact the company who supplied the script.

However, most literature is problematic. Romeo & Juliet has 2 kids dying by suicide. Juliet is 13. Have you seen Grease? Actually, have you turned on the TV ever? The only way to avoid this is for schools to produce brand new, woke, plays, but many people attend musicals because they enjoy familiar songs. And musicals, in particular, are full of tasteless humour.

I used to produce school plays. Voluntarily, during my own time. It was unbelievably hard work because as well as sorting the acting and learning of lines, I had to source costumes and make props with zero budget. I once produced a panto with 14-year-olds. A character was hanged at the end for their crimes. The Head came to the dress rehearsal and forced it to be changed in case some in the audience might be triggered if they had been affected by suicide. That was the last thing I produced.

This is a long-winded way of saying, YABU. Do not email the school.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 19/02/2022 07:26

As a teacher, when faced with an ambiguous line like that, made worse by a stage direction to wink at the audience, I would have edited something; either the line itself or switched the stage direction from a knowing sideways wink to snapping into an enthusiastic salute.
A PP has suggested directors are prohibited from making changes to licenced plays, but a small thing like that? Who'd know?
Oh, and hi again, haikyew!

Magicmonster · 19/02/2022 07:09

I find it odd that people are still talking about prostitution. Elvendreamer’s explanation - about rising through the ranks quickly to a highly paid role - makes much more sense.

haikyew · 19/02/2022 06:53

Prostitution jokes
Have no place in a school play
Maybe oversight?

Thatsplentyjack · 19/02/2022 06:43

@Viviennemary

I wouldnt find it funny. But I wouldn't be annoyed about it. It wouldn't enter my head that it had anything to do with prostitution. Why would it.
Seriously? What else would it mean?
Viviennemary · 18/02/2022 22:26

I wouldnt find it funny. But I wouldn't be annoyed about it. It wouldn't enter my head that it had anything to do with prostitution. Why would it.

Valeriekat · 18/02/2022 22:21

@lottiegarbanzo

There were several films made in the 70s that should be considered highly problematic and Jodie Foster was in 2 of them.

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/02/2022 18:16

I wouldn’t complain but I do not see how “you’d have made a fortune” could be referencing how good at giving orders she is. Fair enough it might not be about prostitution but it’s a silly line that doesn’t make much sense if the point was about giving orders.

flowerschocandchampagne · 18/02/2022 18:15

What palava said. It also perpetuates stereotypes that service people use prostitutes. I think the way you interpreted it was correct OP and that most people in the audience would have viewed it as having the same meaning. I would be upset from a feminist perspective but also as a military family- if there are military kids at the school how to they feel hearing the message that it's normal if their serving parent uses prostitutes? I would raise with the school 100%.

Comefromaway · 18/02/2022 18:09

I’ve seen several professional and amateur version of sound of music including being in one myself as a teenager and that line was always said in a sarcastic sort of way referring to her authoritarian ways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread