Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you allow best man's newborn at wedding

957 replies

questionofthedaywedding · 18/02/2022 15:29

If your best man would be father to a 1-2 month old new born on your wedding day, would you allow the newborn at the wedding, when it's generally a no children wedding ?

Is that being harsh to best man and his wife, who'll presumably only come if newborn can come?

Asking for a friend situation.

OP posts:
MeandT · 20/02/2022 08:17

Not suggesting that an exception for the best man's newborn is the same as an all ages open invite @Migrainesbythedozen. But my oh my do you sound like an uptight fun sponge. Good luck to your future husband, that's all I can add at this point!

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 20/02/2022 08:16

www.facebook.com/261286409515/posts/10159980822924516/?d=n

Read the responses to this xx

CrankyFrankie · 20/02/2022 08:15

They’ve lost perspective! Even child free weddings usually make exceptions for newborns, let alone newborns belonging to members of the bridal party!

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:10

@musicalfrog

I said we were under the table I said nothing about playing or hide and seek. We sat under there and chatted, it was sometimes the only time I saw my cousins.

You are making some strange leaps and are coming across as slightly bizarre!

Exactly you were sitting under a table on which food was placed, at a wedding, and you still see nothing wrong with this? Are you having a lend or are you really serious? Where were your parents in this? Why weren't you sitting at the table with them? Why weren't they supervising you? What parent would allow their child to go and sit under the buffet table? You really can't be serious. It does back up my point though that children who aren't raised properly grow up to think that behaviour is acceptable. These grown ups then think it's ok for their children to sit under tables, run around, bump into people, go on the dance floor, etc. People who weren't brought up properly are the 'type' of parents. All this thread has done is firm my views. That you actually think sitting under a buffet table instead of at the table with your parents is even something to speak of, like it's a good thing? I still can't get over such boasting about such appalling bad behaviour. I even read it out to my mum, (she's staying over atm) she said paraphrasing 'if you did that, I can promise you you'd never do that ever again in your life, I didn't raise you like that.'

I still can't get over you weren't embarrassed about it and actually came on here and admitted you were that unsupervised and undisciplined... I just can't get over that, and I hope you're pulling our legs.

StargazerAli · 20/02/2022 08:05

Absolutely. I think the bride and groom may regret not inviting them.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:03

[quote MeandT]@Migrainesbythedozen are you the bride? You've made your opinions clear, you're in a serious minority...crack on and lose your best man and test how important that relationship is to your fiancé by all means!

I've only ever been to weddings where those with newborns were very conscious of not interrupting the service, and ducked out from the back row at the first wail. My own slept blissfully through the whole thing in someone else's arms, so it's hardly a guarantee that a baby will cause disruption!

If you want to take the view that a wedding is a solemn, serious occasion which your (best) friends can't be trusted to remove their babe in arms from if if starts wahhhing, fine. Others see it as a joyful union which they want their nearest and dearest to witness, and would move heaven and earth to facilitate them attending.

If it's all about you, and only you, obviously the day can go ahead without your best man Confused You'll need to find a new name to describe him by, of couse - can't imagine he'll see your husband to be as much of a friend by the time this has all gone down. Hope "the day" is worth it!!![/quote]
Actually @MeandT It's only on Mumsnet that people seem to take it as a personal offence that their children and babies are not invited to a wedding. In the real world, the vast majority know and understand. Mumsnet does not reflect the real world on this.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 07:59

[quote Noangelbuthavingfun]@migrainesbythedozen have you ever had a newborn yourself? I had exactly your opinion until I became a mum. And then you realize that babies in arms with considerate parents is no issue at all and in fact ensures the other half can enjoy himself rather than stressing about wife, feeling compelled to leave early or not go at all. People with no kids yet don't get this - I wouldn't now dream of having a child free wedding... plenty of ways to entertain kids and have parents there too. If no kids is a must, babies in arms can be the exception. Selfish bride view is what I am reading into this .... and if the best man decides to put his family first by not going then good on him[/quote]
@Noangelbuthavingfun Yes, I have, which is exactly why I understand having a newborn at a wedding is extremely risky. They cry. They drown out vows.

It's usually only the young ones with no experience of babies who say bring babies. Those of us older and with actual experience know what a nightmare and a minefield it is.

Selfish bride view
Yes, fancy the bride wanting to have her one day in her life the way she wants it, and to not have her vows drowned out. Fancy a person wanting their day their way.... how very odd! Doesn't the bride and groom realise the day is not theirs or about them? Wow.... Confused

musicalfrog · 20/02/2022 07:59

I said we were under the table I said nothing about playing or hide and seek. We sat under there and chatted, it was sometimes the only time I saw my cousins.

You are making some strange leaps and are coming across as slightly bizarre!

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 07:55

@musicalfrog

Wow *@Migrainesbythedozen* judgemental much?

Just because I like children at weddings I think they should be allowed to run riot?

Jog on love ❤️

@musicalfrog You actually thought it was a good thing to say you were playing hiding underneath the buffet table!!

If you don't think that's running riot, then I don't understand what you think is.

MeandT · 20/02/2022 07:53

@Migrainesbythedozen are you the bride? You've made your opinions clear, you're in a serious minority...crack on and lose your best man and test how important that relationship is to your fiancé by all means!

I've only ever been to weddings where those with newborns were very conscious of not interrupting the service, and ducked out from the back row at the first wail. My own slept blissfully through the whole thing in someone else's arms, so it's hardly a guarantee that a baby will cause disruption!

If you want to take the view that a wedding is a solemn, serious occasion which your (best) friends can't be trusted to remove their babe in arms from if if starts wahhhing, fine. Others see it as a joyful union which they want their nearest and dearest to witness, and would move heaven and earth to facilitate them attending.

If it's all about you, and only you, obviously the day can go ahead without your best man Confused You'll need to find a new name to describe him by, of couse - can't imagine he'll see your husband to be as much of a friend by the time this has all gone down. Hope "the day" is worth it!!!

Noangelbuthavingfun · 20/02/2022 07:52

@migrainesbythedozen have you ever had a newborn yourself? I had exactly your opinion until I became a mum. And then you realize that babies in arms with considerate parents is no issue at all and in fact ensures the other half can enjoy himself rather than stressing about wife, feeling compelled to leave early or not go at all. People with no kids yet don't get this - I wouldn't now dream of having a child free wedding... plenty of ways to entertain kids and have parents there too. If no kids is a must, babies in arms can be the exception. Selfish bride view is what I am reading into this .... and if the best man decides to put his family first by not going then good on him

marykitty · 20/02/2022 07:51

At our wedding we welcomed all children, it was amazing and I loved having them included

BUT

Everyone has the right to choose! I went to many "no kids" wedding.

Actually my DH will attend a glorious wedding in Italy this spring. He is the best man. It is a "no kids" wedding and, having a toddler and a newborn, i cannot join.
A bit jealous about it but it is how it is.

Rchl86 · 20/02/2022 07:45

After reading quite a few of your replies to others, you seem to be extremely judgemental on those who do not share the same opinion as your own. You seem to make general assumptions on the ‘kind,’ of parents people appear to be.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, I have mine, you have yours. They are opinions no one is right or wrong. I was just stating that I personally feel that expense for a newborn attending is not a factor and my experience planning my wedding was hugely down to cost and numbers which I’m sure plays a factor for many. As for crying newborns I appreciate that this is annoying and not desired but this is where respect from the babies mum comes in. Again my opinion!

musicalfrog · 20/02/2022 07:39

Wow @Migrainesbythedozen judgemental much?

Just because I like children at weddings I think they should be allowed to run riot?

Jog on love ❤️

FruminariaBandersnatcheosum · 20/02/2022 06:59

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]**@FruminariaBandersnatcheosum* Weddings should be lively, inclusive and unpredictable family affairs.*

What you are describing is a backyard family bbq or picnic at the local park. Not a weddings should never be unpredictable. I think people treating weddings as a hillbilly type joke is why so many marriages end in divorce. A wedding is a serious and solemn affair, not some trashy hillbilly thing. I truly think they are the soulless events. Proper weddings are never soulless.[/quote]
Migrainesbythedozen I think you are projecting a bit here with all the BBQ/picnic/local park stuff being hillbilly. I'm not talking about that level of extreme. I've never been to a wedding that was remotely 'hillbilly' and I'm sorry if you have.

milkieway · 20/02/2022 06:41

There's NO way my DH would have left me with our newborn to go to a wedding.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 06:33

@Rchl86

In my opinion I just think letting them bring there newborn baby isn’t a big deal and actually is the most nice understanding thing to do. You don’t have to agreed. I just think a newborn baby isn’t costing them financially as weddings are expensive especially the food and that it was pointed out what other guests may think if they haven’t been able to bring theirs and the rules have been ‘bend,’ for the best man, most in my opinion wouldn’t question it.
@Rchl86 It's not just the expense, it's about not wanting a crying newborn disrupting the ceremony, as many people on this thread have said has happened at weddings they went to, and the parents didn't take the crying baby out and drowned out the vows. It's about practicality. Babies cry and scream. And generally the type of parent who expects their newborn to be invited is the exact type of parent who won't take the baby outside when it starts crying. 100% bet on that, this thread has shown me that.
StoppinBy · 20/02/2022 05:43

Without a doubt, of course we would.

Rchl86 · 20/02/2022 05:29

In my opinion I just think letting them bring there newborn baby isn’t a big deal and actually is the most nice understanding thing to do. You don’t have to agreed. I just think a newborn baby isn’t costing them financially as weddings are expensive especially the food and that it was pointed out what other guests may think if they haven’t been able to bring theirs and the rules have been ‘bend,’ for the best man, most in my opinion wouldn’t question it.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 05:16

Oh please it's not about 'stealing attention from her', it's about not wanting a crying newborn disrupting the ceremony, @Cocogreen , as many people on this thread have said has happened at weddings they went to, and the parents didn't take the crying baby out and drowned out the vows. It's about practicality.

Cocogreen · 20/02/2022 05:14

@TheresOnlyOneWay

It MUST be the bride who has written this post. We are almost 800 comments in and there's been NO reply *@questionofthedaywedding*
I think so too. The vagueness about the exact age of the newborn indicates it's not the mother, but the bride who doesn't want a cute little baby stealing attention from her.
Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 05:06

@Rchl86

I would also like to state that I’m getting married and I’ve children from my first marriage, (5) children. They are of course attending and invited. But I have said no children to our wedding. This is because weddings are costly, and it was a choice made on finances. Guests understand but a newborn baby not to be allowed to come especially when it’s not any guests baby it’s the best man’s in my opinion doesn’t come in the caption of ‘why can’t parents be apart from there children for one occasion’ it’s a NEWBORN baby. Is the baby breastfed, that’s a huge factor in itself. A newborn baby doesn’t have a sit down meal so not costing silly amounts and taking up a ‘guests,’ place. So not sure what the issue is. Also i oh think majority if not all guests wouldn’t question why a newborn baby of the best man is there when there children were not allowed….Christ It’s common sense that a newborn baby being away from their mummy is not practical and quite frankly it’s the most understanding and kindest thing to do but allowing her to attend with her partner/husband with their newborn in tow.
Then the mother can't go. It's really as simple as that, @Rchl86 . No one is talking about separating mother from baby. The point is, if the wife has a newborn, she can't go.

It's as simple as that. She just can't go. And as he is best man, and the baby doesn't rely on him to breastfeed it, he needs to go. She doesn't. All this carry on over the fact that the mother of a newborn naturally can't go.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 05:04

@Tilltheend99

“But no one is expecting 'them' to leave the baby. The wife doesn't need to be there, she doesn't need to go.”

Sexist much. Maybe the father doesn’t want to leave his new baby to travel halfway across the country to a wedding his wife is no welcome at.

If it’s a case of staying overnight, who’s to say the wife wants to be alone with a newborn for all that time or that the husband wants to leave the baby for the first time at such a young age?

It’s reasonable to exclude children from a wedding but incredibly unreasonable to exclude a baby who is dependent.

@Tilltheend99 I don't think it's sexist, it's being a realist. Especially in this case where the wife has no role. It is the best man of the groom.

Besides that, unfortunately being a mother that has a baby dependent on you especially for breastfeeding, it's simply a matter of biology and reality that sometimes that means you have to miss out on something because you have a baby. That's life. Life doesn't change it's entire operating because you decided to have a baby. Life doesn't revolve around a mother and newborn. The real world doesn't work like that. Part of being a mother (or even parent) is realising that some places you cannot take your baby to.
It's how the world operates.

Rchl86 · 20/02/2022 05:00

I would also like to state that I’m getting married and I’ve children from my first marriage, (5) children. They are of course attending and invited. But I have said no children to our wedding. This is because weddings are costly, and it was a choice made on finances. Guests understand but a newborn baby not to be allowed to come especially when it’s not any guests baby it’s the best man’s in my opinion doesn’t come in the caption of ‘why can’t parents be apart from there children for one occasion’ it’s a NEWBORN baby. Is the baby breastfed, that’s a huge factor in itself. A newborn baby doesn’t have a sit down meal so not costing silly amounts and taking up a ‘guests,’ place. So not sure what the issue is. Also i oh think majority if not all guests wouldn’t question why a newborn baby of the best man is there when there children were not allowed….Christ It’s common sense that a newborn baby being away from their mummy is not practical and quite frankly it’s the most understanding and kindest thing to do but allowing her to attend with her partner/husband with their newborn in tow.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 04:54

@Emberino

Why is this even a discussion the bride and groom need to get over themselves and grow up…new born babies need to be with their mum’s especially if breast fed - should have picked a different best man if this was going to be an issue.
@Emberino No it is the best man and his wife who need to get over themselves and grow up. The best man can go, the wife doesn't even need to go. The day is about the bride and groom, the best man and wife need to grow up and stop being so selfish and get over themselves. You are right though, if the best man is going to make it all about him, instead of the groom, then the groom needs to choose another best man. One who will actually consider the groom's wishes and respect them on the groom's own day!