Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you allow best man's newborn at wedding

957 replies

questionofthedaywedding · 18/02/2022 15:29

If your best man would be father to a 1-2 month old new born on your wedding day, would you allow the newborn at the wedding, when it's generally a no children wedding ?

Is that being harsh to best man and his wife, who'll presumably only come if newborn can come?

Asking for a friend situation.

OP posts:
thefamous5 · 20/02/2022 09:27

Funny that because when I was getting a business loan I took my baby into a meeting with a bank manager.

And yes, I fed him before but funnily enough small babies feed often. They also feed for comfort. I mean, I could have let him scream and then not said my vows but you'd have a problem with that as well I imagine.

The registrar didn't care, she thought it was lovely. My guests didn't care. My husband and I didn't care.

Weirdly enough, I'm a fully grown adult, with (beautifully behaved) children, a former high school teacher & a successful business owner. I think I'm pretty ok thanks. I just like and care about kids.

LadyPropane · 20/02/2022 09:24

I certainly don't think it's "trashy and skanky".

What a weird comment to make. Says an awful lot about you and how you view the mother/baby relationship.

OnlyAFleshWound · 20/02/2022 09:24

@LadyPropane

Imagine posting on a parenting forum that breastfeeding your baby during your own wedding is"trashy and skanky"

Confused

and the memtion of it is going to make you vomit Confused

Very, very strange.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 09:23

@LadyPropane

Imagine posting on a parenting forum that breastfeeding your baby during your own wedding is"trashy and skanky"

Confused

You really think it's normal to get to the formal part of the ceremony and you're breastfeeding? Seriously? Please, please tell me you are joking! @LadyPropane
Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 09:22

@thefamous5

Trashy and skanky for feeding a tiny baby. Get a bloody grip.

These type of 'weddings'. You mean, a lovely family orientated wedding.

Some of us like children and don't expect them to be palmed off on strangers.

You cannot compare a family wedding to a bank manager meeting. I'd have taken my youngest to a bank manager meeting as well.

You couldn't have fed the baby before? You don't stand there feeding a baby while saying vows at a ceremony! Wow....

Sorry to break it to you but you can't take babies into bank managers or solicitors meetings. You will have to organise a babysitter. It's called being an adult. It seems you have a lot to learn about how to navigate society.

LadyPropane · 20/02/2022 09:21

Imagine posting on a parenting forum that breastfeeding your baby during your own wedding is"trashy and skanky"

Confused
thefamous5 · 20/02/2022 09:18

Trashy and skanky for feeding a tiny baby. Get a bloody grip.

These type of 'weddings'. You mean, a lovely family orientated wedding.

Some of us like children and don't expect them to be palmed off on strangers.

You cannot compare a family wedding to a bank manager meeting. I'd have taken my youngest to a bank manager meeting as well.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 09:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

thefamous5 · 20/02/2022 08:58

@Migrainesbythedozen

If weddings 'aren't suitable' for children, what do those of us do who - shock horror - have children BEFORE we get married do with our kids? Not invite them to something important to the whole family?

Our children made up 50% of our guest list. I even breastfed fed my son while saying our vows.

My siblings both had children
Before they were married. At their weddings they had plenty of kids, from
Babies up to teenagers. All beautifully behaved.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:52

[quote TolkiensFallow]@Migrainesbythedozen but this isn’t “children” it’s a newborn baby…[/quote]
@TolkiensFallow Again, but newborn babies scream and cry! Please read the full thread. So many other posters have given accounts of how a screaming baby drowned out the vows. Babies are as bad, if not worse than older children.

TolkiensFallow · 20/02/2022 08:49

@Migrainesbythedozen but this isn’t “children” it’s a newborn baby…

Whatinthelord · 20/02/2022 08:47

I think everyone has different experiences of weddings and expectations for what they want their own wedding to look like.

I’m from a very large family so every wedding in our family was filled with tons of children sitting under tables, skidding across the dance floor etc. So that seems normal to me, however I understand for other people this isn’t their experience or what they want of their wedding.

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:45

@musicalfrog

You're missing the point. They trusted us to behave and we did.

Sounds like your kids were absolute horrors if they needed to be kept an eye on constantly!

@musicalfrog Well clearly they were wrong because you were sitting on the floor under the table where food was dished out.....

I'm sure if one of you had hot soup or something spilled on your leg they'd be upset.

My children were raised properly to know you sit on a chair, or bench or stool, you don't sit on the floor underneath tables. I had also had concerned parents who supervised and would never have let me out in public ever again if they knew I was sitting on the floor under tables! That you think your behaviour is normal is terrible. But I do thank you for proving my point about irresponsible parents at weddings. I don't think you realise people will read your example and choose a childfree wedding....

musicalfrog · 20/02/2022 08:39

You're missing the point. They trusted us to behave and we did.

Sounds like your kids were absolute horrors if they needed to be kept an eye on constantly!

Pyri · 20/02/2022 08:39

@musicalfrog

I said we were under the table I said nothing about playing or hide and seek. We sat under there and chatted, it was sometimes the only time I saw my cousins.

You are making some strange leaps and are coming across as slightly bizarre!

Absolute lol at thinking that sitting under the table at a wedding is normal behaviour Grin
Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:35

@musicalfrog

I guess my parents were too busy having fun at a wedding to care about us not causing trouble under the table. You know that concept don't you? FUN? Sadly for you it seems to have passed you by. FYI there is no requirement to sit at a table right till the end of a wedding, you're allowed to get up and move around.

Do you think you might need a doctor for that rod up your rear end?

@musicalfrog Yes you admit your parents were too busy 'having fun' to be bothered knowing where their own children are. My point exactly. Confused You are the very reason more and more weddings are childfree. You really have no idea how abnormal your thinking and behaviour is/was.
Whatinthelord · 20/02/2022 08:35

@ArchibaldsDaddy

Yes to attending everything - with the exception of the ceremony.

That’s the important part of the day and doesn’t need to be made awkward by a potentially screaming baby…

Maybe if there’s an agreement that Best Man’s partner leaves the church with the child if it can’t be pacified that could be a compromise??

Yes this seems like the obvious solution, invite them but kindly let them know what parts you’d like quiet.
Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:33

[quote sunshinesandybeachclearbluesea]@Migrainesbythedozen Do you not think that by ostrisizing children we are creating a society that cannot handle formal functions and behave badly at social events? By inviting and including children, by showing them how to behave we are shaping the next generation and giving them to knowledge of how to act at these events. Which they won't have by not including them!
Yes you are entitled to your own opinion, but do not twist what others have said to take further nasty malicious stabs at them and make out they are not decent people![/quote]
@sunshinesandybeachclearbluesea Would you take children to a Hen's Night where there is a male stripper and penis straws, so children 'learn how to handle formal functions'? Would you take them to a meeting with the bank manager? Etc etc. There are some events that are simply not suitable for children. Weddings are one of them. You think it teaches them? Did you read the example above that I still can't get over, of someone bragging they were unsupervised and sitting under buffet tables? ??? It clearly didn't teach them how to sit at the table or behave at functions, did it? If parents 'showed them how to behave' that would be one thing, but the examples of people who see nothing wrong with children being unsupervised and sitting on the floor under the tables that hold the buffets shows the kids are being neglected and ignored and left to their own devices, certainly not taught how to behave properly. So you have a moot point there.
The point is, there are some events and functions that are not at all suitable for children. Even basic safeguarding attests to this. And the type of parent who thinks it's ok for their children to roam unsupervised at a wedding, and sit on the floor under tables holding food, instead of at the table, shows the type of parents who want children at weddings are the very reason more and more people now have childfree weddings.

Whatinthelord · 20/02/2022 08:31

@questionofthedaywedding

Wedding is quite far from where the BM and wife live.

The bridegroom are suggesting the best man just comes in his own and leaves wife and baby at home. They've even suggested BM can take another plus one instead of wife and baby.

Personally given the wedding is far from their home I would invite the partner and baby. Especially if BM is an important person to you, I wouldn’t want to make him feel he had to choose between attendance at the wedding and being available to his partner.

Most no child weddings I’ve known make exceptions for small babies because most people recognise that separation at the time might be particularly difficult for many reasons and small infants don’t often make much of an impact on events.

Cant the BM’s partner and baby come with him to stay, but come and go between the wedding and hotel room/grounds. You could let them know you understand she might want to avoid parts of the day or take time out of the events when she needs rest or the baby is unsettled.

musicalfrog · 20/02/2022 08:29

I guess my parents were too busy having fun at a wedding to care about us not causing trouble under the table. You know that concept don't you? FUN? Sadly for you it seems to have passed you by. FYI there is no requirement to sit at a table right till the end of a wedding, you're allowed to get up and move around.

Do you think you might need a doctor for that rod up your rear end?

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:27

@cheekyasfish

What are you going on about 'vows drowned out' its one newborn not a brass band

Newborns tend to sleep more than they're awake. Nobody is going to sit through a ceremony or speeches whilst their newborn screams.

I bet baby will sleep in a pram most if the day and cry a bit when ifs feeding time

@cheekyasfish Have you not read the full thread? There are many posters who said a newborn started screaming in the ceremony and they couldn't hear the vows. This has been said by other people too and not just on this thread. I take it you've never been to a wedding where a newborn started screaming and the mother stayed their and didn't take it outside. If so, lucky you. Many, many of us have.
ArchibaldsDaddy · 20/02/2022 08:25

Yes to attending everything - with the exception of the ceremony.

That’s the important part of the day and doesn’t need to be made awkward by a potentially screaming baby…

Maybe if there’s an agreement that Best Man’s partner leaves the church with the child if it can’t be pacified that could be a compromise??

sunshinesandybeachclearbluesea · 20/02/2022 08:22

@Migrainesbythedozen Do you not think that by ostrisizing children we are creating a society that cannot handle formal functions and behave badly at social events? By inviting and including children, by showing them how to behave we are shaping the next generation and giving them to knowledge of how to act at these events. Which they won't have by not including them!
Yes you are entitled to your own opinion, but do not twist what others have said to take further nasty malicious stabs at them and make out they are not decent people!

cheekyasfish · 20/02/2022 08:21

What are you going on about 'vows drowned out' its one newborn not a brass band

Newborns tend to sleep more than they're awake. Nobody is going to sit through a ceremony or speeches whilst their newborn screams.

I bet baby will sleep in a pram most if the day and cry a bit when ifs feeding time

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/02/2022 08:21

@MeandT

Not suggesting that an exception for the best man's newborn is the same as an all ages open invite *@Migrainesbythedozen*. But my oh my do you sound like an uptight fun sponge. Good luck to your future husband, that's all I can add at this point!
@MeandT Again, babies cry and drown out the vows.

And because I understand right from wrong I am a 'fun sponge'? Really? My husband of 22 years will laugh at that, as will my adult children. I'm the one that has the sense of humor.

But goodluck to any of your friendships when you grow up and get married, I doubt they'll survive if you think a newborn should be invited everywhere. Yeah, good luck with that. You'll find out quick smart that the world does not revolve around you and your newborn.