Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you allow best man's newborn at wedding

957 replies

questionofthedaywedding · 18/02/2022 15:29

If your best man would be father to a 1-2 month old new born on your wedding day, would you allow the newborn at the wedding, when it's generally a no children wedding ?

Is that being harsh to best man and his wife, who'll presumably only come if newborn can come?

Asking for a friend situation.

OP posts:
CorneliusVetch · 21/02/2022 15:43

*so someone they don’t sound all that close to doesn’t feel excluded. Weird word order, sorry.

CorneliusVetch · 21/02/2022 15:42

@Pigeonpocket

a fractious baby has been a nightmare

And this isn't emotive language? Why is a baby making a bit of noise a nightmare? It's not like the baby is accusing the groom of having an affair or something that might actually be a nightmare on a wedding day.

Of course breastfeeding mothers are being excluded from weddings if their baby is not invited. That means essentially the mum is not invited too. It's not the same as being invited but unable to go because you've already booked a holiday or something. The couple getting married could allow a baby in order for their family/friend to be able to attend but they're choosing not to. Sure it's their wedding, but isn't the point of having a wedding with guests to have your loved ones with you? If having a baby making a bit of a fuss is more important to them than having you attend, then yeah, it feels like an exclusion.

Not being able to accept an invitation on the terms offered isn’t an exclusion. Are teachers “excluded” from weekday weddings?

I don’t think the fact that hotdog had some mutual friends with her DH’s friends that were getting married qualifies her as a “loved one”. She doesn’t even say she was upset to miss out on seeing them get married, just that she wanted to catch up with some guests there that she knew. The best man situation from the OP is different as presumably they are very close.

Honestly if you had been at the weddings I am thinking of when a baby has caused disruption, and you would still say someone is selfish for not wanting that on their wedding day so someone they don’t sound all that close to doesn’t feel “excluded”, then I don’t think you have very much respect at all for the bride and groom and the fact it’s an important day to them. That’s fine, I know on MN some take the view of so what it’s only a wedding. I disagree. It’s an important day and not unreasonable for the couple getting married to want it to go well, and not risk having a baby crying through their vows.

I had children at my wedding. My choice. I respect other people may make another choice for their wedding day, and have in fact missed weddings when I had a baby I couldn’t take. But someone else’s wedding day isn’t about me.

PleasantBirthday · 21/02/2022 14:56

Is the problem with babies potentially crying that the ceremony is being videoed? I can't see why it would be much of an issue otherwise.

Pigeonpocket · 21/02/2022 14:30

a fractious baby has been a nightmare

And this isn't emotive language? Why is a baby making a bit of noise a nightmare? It's not like the baby is accusing the groom of having an affair or something that might actually be a nightmare on a wedding day.

Of course breastfeeding mothers are being excluded from weddings if their baby is not invited. That means essentially the mum is not invited too. It's not the same as being invited but unable to go because you've already booked a holiday or something. The couple getting married could allow a baby in order for their family/friend to be able to attend but they're choosing not to. Sure it's their wedding, but isn't the point of having a wedding with guests to have your loved ones with you? If having a baby making a bit of a fuss is more important to them than having you attend, then yeah, it feels like an exclusion.

CorneliusVetch · 21/02/2022 13:42

@HogDogKetchup you weren’t “Excluded’ any more than any one else who was unable to attend for any reason. Im sorry you were upset but emotive language like that doesn’t help.

That wedding was a lot more important to the bride and groom than it was to you presumably, so I’m not sure why you think your feelings about the day are more important than theirs? I’ve been at several weddings where a fractious baby has been a nightmare and you’re asking them to take that risk with their wedding. It’s really selfish.

PlntLady · 21/02/2022 13:23

We had a friend in this exact situation. The wedding was at the hotel venue. Her parents came and hung out in the hotel with the baby (it had a cafe, pool and gardens). No only was the husband best man, the wife was the only bridesmaid and the baby was exclusively breast fed. The bridesmaid time feeding around the ceremony and pumped for extra just in case. Worked out really well for all parties.

HogDogKetchup · 21/02/2022 13:21

@Castlequeen

A breastfeeding mother would have little choice but to not attend. It's the parents, and moreover, the mum, who would have to deal with an unsettled bub at the event. Generally speaking, no kids, doesn't mean no babies. Obviously there needs to be a 'cut off' somewhere but many people don't want children at weddings because a) they are distracting, b) require paid meals, c) don't have a relationship with the bride and groom, d) may add too much cost etc. A baby need be no issue with any of these.
Precisely. I felt really upset that I was excluded from DH’s friends wedding. We have some mutual friends who I get on well with and would have liked to have caught up with. DH said I would sit out of the vows etc if that made them more comfortable and it was a hotel so would have been easy for me to find a quiet corner if baby was upset. When you’ve just given birth and are feeling a bit delicate it’s a horrible feeling basically being told you’re not welcome.
Castlequeen · 21/02/2022 02:17

A breastfeeding mother would have little choice but to not attend. It's the parents, and moreover, the mum, who would have to deal with an unsettled bub at the event. Generally speaking, no kids, doesn't mean no babies. Obviously there needs to be a 'cut off' somewhere but many people don't want children at weddings because a) they are distracting, b) require paid meals, c) don't have a relationship with the bride and groom, d) may add too much cost etc. A baby need be no issue with any of these.

BeckonCall · 21/02/2022 00:12

That wedding was awesome - no fights - just bliss.

@FrozenWillow263 Are fights normal at other weddings you attend?

Wantthisfriend · 20/02/2022 22:27

The baby will be newborn. The best man will have half his mind on the baby/wife and if he's a considerate person will leave as soon as he can for home. I would keep the invite open for both, itll cost them nothing, the newborn is very very likely to be sleeping for 3 or so hours at a time. Both BM and wife will have fond memories of your "friends" big day, rather than icky memories of either being uninvited or being replaced by "an other". Is there a chance the bridge or groom are feeling they might get upstaged by a babe in arms?

thing47 · 20/02/2022 22:20

I think the bride (and groom) are perfectly entitled to ask or not ask whoever they want to their wedding. I just think the groom will be looking for a new best man if his newborn baby – and by his extension, his wife –are excluded from it. And that is also perfectly reasonable.

Just as no one is obliged to be too bothered about someone else's baby, so too no one is obliged to be too bothered about someone else's wedding. It cuts both ways.

MabelsApron · 20/02/2022 20:18

@PetiteBanane23

I really hope the OP is not the bride because it’s been suggested her to be stuck-up, mean-spirited, nasty, selfish, bridezilla, childish… and we don’t actually know the woman. SMH
Yep. Meanwhile all the women who’ve made choices about their own weddings because of traumatic events have had to read them.

And I agree that people here have been desperate to paint the bride as a shallow self-absorbed young thing because that’s what always happens on threads where women suggest that their priority is something other than a another person’s baby. MN at its finest.

CorneliusVetch · 20/02/2022 20:12

[quote DizzySquirrel90]@CorneliusVetch it's up to them, obviously. If they don't want babies there then don't go. Simple.

I guess we were just lucky we weren't going to a stuck up brides wedding 🙂[/quote]
Calling someone stuck up for wanting an adult only wedding - honestly, have a word with yourself. It’s a really unpleasant attitude.

PetiteBanane23 · 20/02/2022 20:02

@PetiteBanane23

They didn’t say that though did they? I took it as she can come without baby or not come. And if BM feels he want to bring someone else instead he can. I mean it’s a bit strange but not nasty. My husband would probably say “great! I’ll bring my brother” if it was us and I declined to come

They hardly said “please bring anyone but your wife because we hate her”

In replying to @Radziwill
PetiteBanane23 · 20/02/2022 19:56

I think people are just desperate to make out the bride is a nasty piece of work because they don’t like the idea that not everyone wants their precious babies at a wedding.

PetiteBanane23 · 20/02/2022 19:54

They didn’t say that though did they? I took it as she can come without baby or not come. And if BM feels he want to bring someone else instead he can. I mean it’s a bit strange but not nasty. My husband would probably say “great! I’ll bring my brother” if it was us and I declined to come

They hardly said “please bring anyone but your wife because we hate her”

Radziwill · 20/02/2022 19:51

@PetiteBanane23, we know the bride and groom told the best man he could bring a plus-one as long as she wasn't his wife. Come on, that's nasty. Extremely passive-aggressive.

PetiteBanane23 · 20/02/2022 18:46

I really hope the OP is not the bride because it’s been suggested her to be stuck-up, mean-spirited, nasty, selfish, bridezilla, childish… and we don’t actually know the woman. SMH

DizzySquirrel90 · 20/02/2022 17:52

@CorneliusVetch it's up to them, obviously. If they don't want babies there then don't go. Simple.

I guess we were just lucky we weren't going to a stuck up brides wedding 🙂

CorneliusVetch · 20/02/2022 16:25

[quote DizzySquirrel90]@CorneliusVetch if my lil one was colicky I would have decided against it. However my partner was fully prepared to walk out of the ceremony with little one HAD he have started to stir or kicked off. That is not inconsiderate at all that is very responsible as a parent. [/quote]
It’s not inconsiderate at all as long as the bride and groom are happy to have the baby there and take that risk. You surely can’t actually think that babies never disrupt wedding ceremonies?

FrozenWillow263 · 20/02/2022 16:12

Yes I would allow it. I would allow children to my wedding - provided it is clear in the invitation that we are not responsible for your children so don't think of this as pawning your kids on us whilst you drink.

Happened at my friends wedding. Children allowed and my partner was Best Man. I made a solid choice to only have 1-2 alcoholic drinks and still keep my senses in tact to look after our children whilst partner attended to his duties as Best Man.

That wedding was awesome - no fights - just bliss. So yes, yes I would. If newborn is breastfeeding, newborn is going to need to be near mama 24/7 and Daddy won't want to be away from newborn.

Allow the child to come to the wedding! If you don't want a whole host of children there then say, only the bridal paries kids will be there and the rest need to get babysitters - you can come to a compromise.

DizzySquirrel90 · 20/02/2022 15:47

@CorneliusVetch if my lil one was colicky I would have decided against it. However my partner was fully prepared to walk out of the ceremony with little one HAD he have started to stir or kicked off. That is not inconsiderate at all that is very responsible as a parent.

CorneliusVetch · 20/02/2022 15:40

@DizzySquirrel90

Our 6 week old slept through the wedding we attended. I was maid of honour. He was the best behaved child there.
I’m really pleased about that, but had your six week old been colicky and a total nightmare all day, there wouldn’t have been anything you could do about it. You don’t know in advance what you’re going to get when you invite a newborn.
DizzySquirrel90 · 20/02/2022 15:35

Our 6 week old slept through the wedding we attended. I was maid of honour. He was the best behaved child there.

scandikate · 20/02/2022 15:34

I loved having children at my wedding so wouldn't have an issue with this but if I was the best man I would respect the wishes of the bride and groom for a child free wedding and go alone. My husband was best man at a wedding a couple of years ago and I went with my newborn and it wasn't fun for me at all - he was cluster feeding, crying, wouldn't settle and then I had to spend a lot of time walking around in the carrier to get him to sleep.