Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you allow best man's newborn at wedding

957 replies

questionofthedaywedding · 18/02/2022 15:29

If your best man would be father to a 1-2 month old new born on your wedding day, would you allow the newborn at the wedding, when it's generally a no children wedding ?

Is that being harsh to best man and his wife, who'll presumably only come if newborn can come?

Asking for a friend situation.

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 22/02/2022 15:35

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]**@ChristinaXYZ* Completely unreasonable. You can't expect them to leave such a new baby.*

But no one is expecting 'them' to leave the baby. The wife doesn't need to be there, she doesn't need to go.[/quote]
Who @migrainesbythedozen would go to a wedding that his wife is not welcome at. Also why should wife deal with baby on her own all weekend. If she is on maternity leave still she probably does so all week already and what is suggested is not fair. If my husband sodded off to a wedding when I had a new baby I've be furious.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 22/02/2022 15:03

No ones wedding justifies starving my baby. And when my baby is tiny I’m not sure anyone’s wedding justifies leaving my baby with someone else not their parents, nor my husband leaving us for a weekend.

I think in the position of the best man's wife I'd be very happy not to attend. Boobs leaking over impractical clothing, not least keeping alert enough on half a night's sleep to participate through an interminably long day (they nearly always are), making small talk with strangers, not least getting through my own dinner without a need for changing or feeding in the middle. My meals at this juncture of DC's life nearly always went cold! As a newish mum, a day hunkered down in front of the TV in loungewear, napping if ever the opportunity arises, would have appealed far more to me than attending a wedding.

The 'bring another +1' suggestion might well have me reevaluating my view of the couple in question, though.

VelmasGlasses101 · 22/02/2022 14:34

No ones wedding justifies starving my baby. And when my baby is tiny I’m not sure anyone’s wedding justifies leaving my baby with someone else not their parents, nor my husband leaving us for a weekend

He could go and come back after speeches, like other posters have suggested? They could even go and stay closer to the wedding and make a weekend of it? Do something together the next day?

You’ve said no ones wedding justifies X… then if your baby is the your number one priority, not attending a wedding where you aren’t even in the bridal party shouldn’t even matter! Don’t go and get on with your life

MabelsApron · 22/02/2022 10:21

@Eucalyptusbee

IS the OP Coming back to let us know what happened? I'm guessing if she doesn't reappear that she was in fact the bride in question!
Would you? Given the way the bride has been described on this thread and the way in which anyone trying to stick up for her has been treated?
timeisnotaline · 22/02/2022 08:30

@AntiEntitlement

First off, everyone seems to be assuming she is breastfeeding, maybe this is not the case, but if she is, there are some really great products called breast pumps that have been available for a few years, now (eye-roll here). I don't see anything wrong with this couple wanting their special day to be everything THEY want, and are paying for. Babies fuss and cry, even if the new mother gets up and leaves the room, it still creates a stir. Why should they have to worry about this at their ceremony? The best man, should be understanding of this and not make it about him and his wife as new parents rather than his friend's milestone in his/her life. If he's making about him, they should find a new best man.
Your name seems very unsuited to you. Not everyone can pump . Not all babies take bottles . I nearly didn’t go to a wedding my 6mo wasn’t invited to since my baby wasn’t yet eating food (we were trying) and didn’t take bottles. No ones wedding justifies starving my baby. And when my baby is tiny I’m not sure anyone’s wedding justifies leaving my baby with someone else not their parents, nor my husband leaving us for a weekend. They probably should find a new best man as you say, since they don’t actually value the one they have as a friend.
Eucalyptusbee · 21/02/2022 23:18

IS the OP Coming back to let us know what happened? I'm guessing if she doesn't reappear that she was in fact the bride in question!

MeandT · 21/02/2022 22:57

Brooke321 nails it. Love the suggestion upthread that the best man is replaceable Hmm These are your best friends (or at least one is the groom's) and multiple people are suggesting that:
a) you can't have a clear conversation with them about wife and child of best man needing to sit near an exit with clear caveat to leave at the first squeak and
b) you care so little about your long term relationship with them that it is suggested that the best man just behave like a care free bachelor to facilitate your special day.

If bride and groom can't include the best man properly on their wedding day, he clearly IS just replaceable and isn't the best man at all. Probably better that he finds this out sooner rather than later though.

Brooke321 · 21/02/2022 21:46

I actually had this happen to me. My son was going to be 7 weeks old and my husband was the best man in his cousin's wedding. The wedding took place over a full day in NYC. We live 1 1/2 hours away. We also had a toddler. The plan was to get a hotel suite, have a sitter come with us to stay in the hotel with the toddler but bring the newborn since I was nursing. This also gave me flexibility to leave if needed due to a fussy baby or toddler. Gave the bride a heads up to the entire plan explaining that I would definitely leave if the baby even whimpered and was told "No, I'm sorry but the venue is very expensive and I don't want the baby to break anything". I decoded to stay home and my husband went alone but didn't spend the night -drove home after. Needless to say I have hated that woman ever since.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 21/02/2022 21:30

^ 'You' in my PP above is meant in a generic sense, not as a response to that particular poster. I'm agreeing with them, just more cynical about how common a phenomenon 'shit' weddings are when the all-too-frequent power plays kick in.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 21/02/2022 21:28

@HogDogKetchup

Nobody has said that.

The Brides importance doesn’t invalidate everyone else’s feelings though.

If it did and everyone had a shit time it would be a shit wedding. Weddings are about everyone enjoying themselves.

IME more than a small number are more about FOG, and a certain amount of power manoeuvring goes on around those circumstances because it's the one day B&G get to call the shots and some of them very much want to make the most of it.

These include the ones whose families (who are not paying) try to dictate events, or the PA bride who invites all friends in a particular group leaving just one out, as detailed on a previous thread this week, or the B&G who make circumstances impossible for some of the guests to attend, then throw a strop and end the friendship. Sometimes it's a friendship of decades.

Eloping was a decision we've never regretted. If we could turn the clock back we'd do the same thing again.

Cold-light-of-day fact: Your wedding is not as important to anyone else as it is to you.

HogDogKetchup · 21/02/2022 21:11

@SecretSpAD

The Brides importance doesn’t invalidate everyone else’s feelings though

The bride and groom, both of them, are the important people in a wedding. These days they are probably the ones stumping up the cash as well. So whilst other people are allowed their feelings, the actual wishes of the bride and groom, are paramount and must be respected. If someone decides that their feelings and wishes are more important than the actual people who this day is about, then not only are they startlingly selfish and self absorbed, but they are really really not deserving of an invitation to be part of this couples celebration.

Nobody has suggested that anyone who is dissatisfied turns up anyway and starts a newborn sit in.
SecretSpAD · 21/02/2022 20:37

The Brides importance doesn’t invalidate everyone else’s feelings though

The bride and groom, both of them, are the important people in a wedding. These days they are probably the ones stumping up the cash as well. So whilst other people are allowed their feelings, the actual wishes of the bride and groom, are paramount and must be respected. If someone decides that their feelings and wishes are more important than the actual people who this day is about, then not only are they startlingly selfish and self absorbed, but they are really really not deserving of an invitation to be part of this couples celebration.

HogDogKetchup · 21/02/2022 20:03

Nobody has said that.

The Brides importance doesn’t invalidate everyone else’s feelings though.

If it did and everyone had a shit time it would be a shit wedding. Weddings are about everyone enjoying themselves.

SecretSpAD · 21/02/2022 19:51

@Opus17

Op must be the bride since she hasn't come back
If she is, can you blame her? She's been called all sorts for daring to want her own wedding day to be the day that she and her husband to be wants and has planned for. Who knew that a random baby of a best man (who is actually replaceable) would be more important on a wedding day than the actual bride and groom? Wow.
Opus17 · 21/02/2022 19:34

Op must be the bride since she hasn't come back

Xyyxxx · 21/02/2022 19:13

Ditto

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 21/02/2022 19:06

People this precious about a new born attending their wedding are going to be a nightmare if they have kids themselves, you can guarantee they will think everyone thinks their pnb is as wonderful as they do and will be shocked if they were told no babies at a wedding

Run quickly now !

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 19:03

Pumps and bottles! Damn autocorrect!

hellithurt · 21/02/2022 18:49

@AntiEntitlement

First off, everyone seems to be assuming she is breastfeeding, maybe this is not the case, but if she is, there are some really great products called breast pumps that have been available for a few years, now (eye-roll here). I don't see anything wrong with this couple wanting their special day to be everything THEY want, and are paying for. Babies fuss and cry, even if the new mother gets up and leaves the room, it still creates a stir. Why should they have to worry about this at their ceremony? The best man, should be understanding of this and not make it about him and his wife as new parents rather than his friend's milestone in his/her life. If he's making about him, they should find a new best man.
Eye roll

It might not have come to your attention, not everyone can use breast pinups, not every breastfed baby takes a baby.

It's really not difficult to understand all that, maybe read more so you're not so Ill educated about breast feeding.

You've made yourself like a sarcastic, misinformed person. I expect a bin set of people have eye rilled at your comment.

Lilcaz88 · 21/02/2022 18:38

The best man and his wife sound way too good for these people. What a narcissistic, entitled bride and groom!

Sexnotgender · 21/02/2022 17:26

@HogDogKetchup

Even if you can pump - who wants to take care of a newborn that is only really happy with their Mother? I have absolutely nobody who would have wanted my 3 week old and even if they did, I wouldn’t have felt it was fair to leave him distressed.
Exactly! Imagine thinking it was ok to ask a new mother to do that.

And pumping doesn’t work for everyone. It certainly doesn’t for me. Plus the recommendations are not to pump until feeding is established around 6 weeks.

HogDogKetchup · 21/02/2022 16:37

Even if you can pump - who wants to take care of a newborn that is only really happy with their Mother? I have absolutely nobody who would have wanted my 3 week old and even if they did, I wouldn’t have felt it was fair to leave him distressed.

Poppins2016 · 21/02/2022 16:32

@AntiEntitlement

First off, everyone seems to be assuming she is breastfeeding, maybe this is not the case, but if she is, there are some really great products called breast pumps that have been available for a few years, now (eye-roll here). I don't see anything wrong with this couple wanting their special day to be everything THEY want, and are paying for. Babies fuss and cry, even if the new mother gets up and leaves the room, it still creates a stir. Why should they have to worry about this at their ceremony? The best man, should be understanding of this and not make it about him and his wife as new parents rather than his friend's milestone in his/her life. If he's making about him, they should find a new best man.
Some women don't produce anything when they pump. Some babies don't accept bottles.

Some people (women or men) don't want to leave their newborns for the best part of a day (regardless of how they're fed).

You could turn the statement around and say that the couple getting married are making it all about themselves and not being considerate of the other couples milestone. I've often read (on MN) about how someone had a child free wedding and insisted that people left their babies, then felt guilty years later when they personally realised how hard it was to do that as a parent.

HogDogKetchup · 21/02/2022 16:28

[quote CorneliusVetch]@HogDogKetchup you weren’t “Excluded’ any more than any one else who was unable to attend for any reason. Im sorry you were upset but emotive language like that doesn’t help.

That wedding was a lot more important to the bride and groom than it was to you presumably, so I’m not sure why you think your feelings about the day are more important than theirs? I’ve been at several weddings where a fractious baby has been a nightmare and you’re asking them to take that risk with their wedding. It’s really selfish.[/quote]
Well no, but by the same token they asked my husband to do a reading, so he felt obliged to go where he perhaps would have chosen to stay home with his post partum wife and toddler. They made him a part of the day whilst excluding me. I couldn’t have left my three week old who’d had a tongue tie snipped and so we hadn’t perfected breastfeeding let alone bottle feeding.

I felt if I was to be told I shouldn’t go they shouldn’t have made my husband an integral part of the day.

Clearly the wedding was more important to the bride but that doesn’t alter the fact I think they behaved badly.

AntiEntitlement · 21/02/2022 15:50

First off, everyone seems to be assuming she is breastfeeding, maybe this is not the case, but if she is, there are some really great products called breast pumps that have been available for a few years, now (eye-roll here). I don't see anything wrong with this couple wanting their special day to be everything THEY want, and are paying for. Babies fuss and cry, even if the new mother gets up and leaves the room, it still creates a stir. Why should they have to worry about this at their ceremony? The best man, should be understanding of this and not make it about him and his wife as new parents rather than his friend's milestone in his/her life. If he's making about him, they should find a new best man.