Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do ambulance crew really believe someone with serious mental health issues will be helped at A&E?

310 replies

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 13:58

The other thread about ambulances made me think about this.

I was taken to A&E by ambulance a couple of times some time ago due to my mental health. Both times the ambulance crew reassured me I'd get the help I needed but both times I got no help for my mental health at all.

Honestly, no wonder these people are making repeat calls - they are probably desperate!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 16:14

@Snog

It is surely more important to focus energy on how to change the system so that people DO get the help they need and are not turned away feeling even more suicidal and without good support.

Do the paramedics need to say "I hope you get the care you need today but please be aware that this might not be possible" ? I'm not sure that everyone would find that helpful to hear, true or not.

No paramedics absolutely do not need to say this, of course not! My point is hopes should not be raised. Paramedics should be given a realistic idea of what is happening in A&E so they don't raise hopes. This is something that can be done immediately and with little cost and would help many people enormously. Unfortunately that can't be said for changing the system so people do get help. They aren't mutually exclusive, though of course!
OP posts:
PigeonLittle · 19/02/2022 16:13

@Prinnny

The paramedics job is to treat any life threatening injuries and take the patient to a place of safety.

A&E is for people who have had an accident or emergency, they can treat the issues caused by mental health problems such as injuries caused by self harm etc but they can diagnose and treat mental health problems.

Can’t believe people think paramedics and A&E are the place for mental health support, all they can do is refer you on.

God forbid suicide is considered an emergency Confused
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 16:11

@Allelbowsandtoes - thank you so much. You sound lovely and I'm sure your patients are lucky to have you. And I think you are so right re: secondary services. It has swung too much the other way. If course it is a fine line and we don't want to hospitalise people unnecessarily but there comes a time when it is necessary. And cuts to these services are explained by way of helping people avoid unnecessary admission. I mean home treatment team - is described as the benefits of hospitalisation in the community. It is really, really not beneficial like hospital!!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 16:05

@FranklyMyBeer

A&E can help. I drove myself there - actually to see them about another imagined condition I thought was happening to me. I was having a breakdown with pnd. Luckily a social worker came in to chat to me in my cubicle and I heard her telling the doctor that he couldn’t let me go. I spent about 8 hours there that day, dh collected me and I was under the community mental health team for weeks - they visited me twice a day and I had psychiatrist appointments regularly. I've always had mh problems my whole life. This was the first time I ever went to a&e (although I have been in a private mh hospital before too). They did help me - thanks to the social worker. Perhaps the ambulance crew thought you'd get seen by one. Also, it's probably their policy and the drivers themselves can either decide to leave you or take you to a and e. Perhaps they knew you would be sent home again.
I'm so glad it worked for you. Just seeing the right person at the right time can make the world of difference. Crisis team is purely phone calls now.

And yes, you do get seen by the MH team here. But so common to be discharged in a worse state than you went in. Luckily soon after my A&E incidents I saw someone incredible. I was sectioned and in hospital for a long time. It was what I really needed. And if the team in A&E had really listened and not been so quick just to get rid of me (or if indeed they had spoken to the HCP who phoned the ambulance in the first incident) maybe they could have helped too.

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:57

@LakieLady

The people you need to be angry with are the current government, not paramedics, Nurses, Doctors or any other HCP!

And those who voted for them, who plainly don't give a damn about MH provision, until it actually affects them in some way.

You're more likely to get admitted to a psych unit from police custody than from A&E. A couple of clients have gone down this route in the last few months, thankfully only by causing some sort of disturbance or committing criminal damage.

MH services are so stretched that they can't possibly meet the need, which has increased since the pandemic. They're losing really good staff, because they are utterly demoralised by not being able to give people the help they need.

I have an ex-client who struggles with paranoid schizophrenia. They're supposed to have a fortnightly visit from a CPN. That all stopped in the first lockdown, they've had a phone call every few months, and 2 telephone reviews with a consultant in nearly 2 years. When they asked when visits or F2F appointments were going to resume, he was told that there were no plans to do that yet, because of cuts. He is really unwell.

MH services here are in crisis. I doubt if anyone has bothered to tell paramedics that the chances of anyone with MH issues getting meaningful help via A&E are, at best, slim.

I mean they were stretched pre-pandemic so I totally take your point. My personal experiences were pre-Covid. But yes, community services are dire now. My CPN is actually seeing me in person in a couple of weeks but it has been awful with only phone contact. All OT services have stopped, all volunteer services. There has literally been hardly any support in the community. So I do empathise with your ex-client and I really hope he can get some help before it is too late.

Your point about noone having told the paramedics the real situation is exactly what I'm asking. I'm always amazed at the way different departments just do not communicate properly within the NHS.

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:51

@MrsTophamHat

My DH works as part of a joint initiative between police and NHS to better deal with people in mental health crisis who would previously have ended up being sectioned. It's not something that happens everywhere yet but it works well and may become more widespread if other counties decide to set it up.
That sounds brilliant. I am always all for multi-disciplinary working.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:49

@cptartapp

Nurse here too. They're so very busy, I suspect that in good faith they just say what you want to hear to gain your cooperation, and move as quickly as possible onto their next call.
Yes, there could be something in that but these things were said once I was in the ambulance so already cooperating.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:47

@CovoidOfAllHumanity

They take people to hospital if they feel they won't be safe at home. They have to do that obviously. If you are saying you will kill yourself if left at home then they have no choice do they? They will say what it takes to get you to go if the stakes are high.

'Get the help you need' is relative isn't it?
Surely you did not believe that A&E was a magic shortcut to being cured otherwise everyone else would also have discovered it. If the help you immediately need is to stay safe tonight then you will get that. You will usually also be seen by a MH professional but their role at that point is to ensure you are safe for discharge that night and refer you in to other services for the longer term problem. You might still have to wait though.

What is the help that you need in your view? Admission: only really helpful for conditions that can be cured by drugs. Psychotherapy? Not going to be available in A&E at any point

It's fine to go to A&E if you are in crisis as a place of safety and usually there will be a hospital liaison team or a duty psychiatrist to talk to but that's realistically all that's going to be available there. Many places have a crisis line 111 option 2 which would offer much the same if you are OK with telephone interactions and avoids the waiting around in A&E if there are no accompanying physical issues.

Sorry didn't reply to the rest.

Admission is not only for conditions that can be cured by drugs. Tbh, most people who are at threshold to be admitted can not be cured by drugs. Helped yes, but not cured. There is so much more to admission than drugs! I find that rather insulting of the amazing mental health wards- the psychs, nurses, SWs and OTs etc that you think it is only about drugs! Have you been on a psych ward? Perhaps that was your experience but it is certainly not mine.

In my personal situation I needed a bed. There is more available to a psych nurse/SW etc in A&E than just discharge once they deem safe. They can prescribe (or get a Dr to), they can show compassion, kindness. Communicate to a patient next steps, provide information as to help while waiting for community services. But also they can find beds. As far as I am aware in the same way the community services can. People keep saying the threshold is high but it is higher in A&E?

OP posts:
MrsBerthaRochester · 19/02/2022 15:41

Yanbu. I tried to commit suicide last year. Ambulance crew couldnt have cared less, not one of them spoke to me on route to hospital.
While in hospital I was assured my the mh team I would get a cpn and access to counselling. Upon discharge told by cpn I didnt meet requirements. Asked gp and told its not up to them who cpn see. The social worker and school nurse put forward the case that I have a severe trauma history and were still told I didnt need a cpn.
There is no help.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:37

@CovoidOfAllHumanity

They take people to hospital if they feel they won't be safe at home. They have to do that obviously. If you are saying you will kill yourself if left at home then they have no choice do they? They will say what it takes to get you to go if the stakes are high.

'Get the help you need' is relative isn't it?
Surely you did not believe that A&E was a magic shortcut to being cured otherwise everyone else would also have discovered it. If the help you immediately need is to stay safe tonight then you will get that. You will usually also be seen by a MH professional but their role at that point is to ensure you are safe for discharge that night and refer you in to other services for the longer term problem. You might still have to wait though.

What is the help that you need in your view? Admission: only really helpful for conditions that can be cured by drugs. Psychotherapy? Not going to be available in A&E at any point

It's fine to go to A&E if you are in crisis as a place of safety and usually there will be a hospital liaison team or a duty psychiatrist to talk to but that's realistically all that's going to be available there. Many places have a crisis line 111 option 2 which would offer much the same if you are OK with telephone interactions and avoids the waiting around in A&E if there are no accompanying physical issues.

My situation was not as described - there are many reasons you may be taken in. Now, if nothing has changed since you being brought in and discharged except you now feel even more let down and even more hopeless and even more suicidal - how is that helping? I'm sorry but I find your 'magic shortcut' comment patronising. Noone with SMI (or a close relative) thinks there are any shortcuts. We spend years banging our heads against a brick wall - metaphorically and literally at times!
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:32

@Prinnny

Paramedics go to multiple hospitals, and what happens at one may not happen at another. Yes we can call the crisis team, they often taken hours upon hours to come, then will simply check you not actively suicidal and will say discharge and follow up in the community. The threshold for admission is extremely high, and mental health beds are few and far between! They aren’t lying to you, they are not to blame, neither are the ED staff, our hands are tied.
As I have already said of course they aren't to blame. Here we have a mental health team in A&E. Is their threshold higher than in the community?
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:30

@pinkstripeycat

A friend was in A&E this week and was talking to a 19 year old boy. He’d tried to commit suicide and been brought in by the police. He’d sat there for 10 hrs. He said to my friend “I just want help and they’ve left me here.” So sad
It is so sad. I know that feeling of being desperate for help. And sadly when you have a large network of people with SMI you hear too often of no help being given and suicide being completed. All these young lives being wasted.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:26

@Polyanthus2

I don't understand how everyone can get a lift to the supermarket each week but suddenly need an ambulance to take them if they feel ill. At the worst and you have no transport people get picked up from the supermarket by a taxi. What the heck is it - unless you are dying of a heart attack - can't you just get a lift like the rest of the time.
Are you for real? Have you ever seen someone having an acute psychotic episode? Someone passed out from overdose? You really can't understand why an ambulance would be called apart from a heart attack? And everyone really does not get lifts to the supermarket every week!! Most people get there themselves! What a strange comment!
OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 19/02/2022 15:25

No need to stay in an A&E bed - there is a mental health suite. I realise that is not everywhere but it is here and in other hospitals. Where there is no separate mental health people do indeed stay in A&E beds at times. And the mental health team in A&E do have capacity for assessment.

It’s great saying there are suites and all will be fine but you are missing so many things. Chronic staff shortages in the mental health units for instance, that often affects diverting people for assessment in suites/units, or their resource for MH consults in A&E. If the suites are understaffed or none can come it makes things difficult.

Not every A&E is crawling with a mental health team twiddling their thumbs waiting for someone to turn up. It just doesn’t work like that. You do know that you can request a consult for a patient and …. nada. Again, a service that’s been stripped down, combine that with staff shortages and it’s not really a guaranteed service.

You are not really understanding that at the acute point, sometimes there are just no options. No immediate resources, units either overfill or staff shortages meaning can’t run at capacity, no beds for those that do need them. We used to shunt to any old ward once upon a time to wait it out for a bed if people were deemed to need one but that’s stopped as it was too problematic all round. It’s a disgrace but sometimes there are truly no options other than for a person to be sent home in an unfit state and you cross your fingers and hope to hell the system doesn’t break down and community reaches them as soon as possible and get the ball rolling and there is not a tragedy meanwhile. That’s the reality at times.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:20

@Pandoh

Here anyone brought in for MH related things gets assessed by the relevant professionals that can section if needed. The trouble is that the threshold is so high and there's no beds, so for many who do require help sadly they still cannot access it. It's not even a funding thing at this point, there aren't enough staff to expand services. I do think there should be ambulances dedicated to MH calls with different equipment and mental health trained HCPs on board, it would free up ambulances as we know them and also the people would have more knowledge of the system and be able to provide more tailored care. Paramedics already have tonnes to know and learn, and to expect them to have an in depth knowledge of mental health as well is too much.
I completely agree with you about MH ambulances. I have often thought this would be a great idea. Re: sectioning - is the threshold higher in A&E than in the community? The problem with A&E is they often just treat you like you are wasting their time. There are brilliant parts of our mental health facilities in this area (and beyond according to others) but A&E (and assessment units) seem to let people down so much. I mean I have been told a reason why but trying to explore it more. Is it harder for A&E to find beds than care cos and AMHPs? It doesn't make sense that it would do.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:12

@ThreeFeetTall

I have just read 'Can you hear me' which is written by a paramedic and covers this (along with lots of other stuff)

I agree no one should be lying but I might exaggerate a bit about what will happen at A&E if I thought it might save a life.

The trouble is often it doesn't save a life but ends it. The crushing feeling of being let down yet again when you were told there really would be help this time sent me into such despair it made me attempt to take my life. And that is an all too common story. Often by the time you get to A&E you have already been let down repeatedly by crisis team, by the assessment unit, home treatment team etc.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 15:06

@HoppingPavlova

Just for some reason so many people in crisis are let down at A&E.

Easy answer. There are generally no beds to send you to and services are at capacity so the mandate is to refer to outpatient services who will get to you when they can (although this part seems to break down often and not everyone is contacted). Mental health beds don’t grow on trees and for one to be free while you are in A&E the stars and planets would have to be in alignment and that’s so rare. It’s not that A&E don’t care, there is literally nowhere to send you that had capacity at the time.

It’s unfortunate but someone can’t stay in an A&E bed for a few days until a mental health team has capacity to make a proper assessment and then for days until a mental health bed becomes available. A&E are no more happy about this than you are, let me assure you but it is what it is and yes, unfortunately some people may not survive this and no one is blind to that but in an individual level no one can do anything otherwise.

Perhaps instead of blaming paramedics and A&E you could put the blame squarely where it belongs, Govnt funding has stripped mental health services back past the bone, and THIS is where your anger should be directed.

Oh for goodness sake - how many times - I am not blaming paramedics! Has noone RTFT?

Mental health beds are hard to come by no doubt. But they aren't harder for the mental health team in A&E to come by than for a psych and AMPH.
No need to stay in an A&E bed - there is a mental health suite. I realise that is not everywhere but it is here and in other hospitals. Where there is no separate mental health people do indeed stay in A&E beds at times. And the mental health team in A&E do have capacity for assessment.

I have said exactly that about government. I have no anger towards paramedics.

OP posts:
Realitydawning98 · 19/02/2022 15:01

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

GrolliffetheDragon · 19/02/2022 13:48

I know if people being kept in A&E or on the assessment ward for 48 hours or more while they wait for someone from mental health services to show up. And of people who have made serious attempts at ending their own life - as in only being found in time because someone else came home unexpectedly - being told it wasn't and therefore not being referred.

The system is at risk of collapse, despite the best efforts of many of those within it.

tcjotm · 19/02/2022 12:53

@hurtingandworried

I had an ambulance sent out to me ten days ago after I phoned 111 and told them I had the means and the desire to end my life and planned to do so there and then .

Paramedic (his colleague was a soldier so just stood in the hallway) sat with me, rang my GP, GP spoke to me for 25 minutes calamine me down, paramedic got me a cup of tea and talked me down and talked to GP too .

Both explained that they could take me to A&E thirty miles away but GP said I’d be in a cubicle for three hours then discharged and GP said I’d then have a new problem of trying to get a bus home when agitated anxious and alone - so said last place I was going was A&E .

GP said she would contact MH services urgently, within 72 hours I got a call telling me I’d been made an appt with a clinical psychologist for three weeks time and practice therapist is going to phone me in the meantime .

The 111 call handler even called me two hours later to make sure I was OK .

I’m aware that’s unusual and previous experiences haven’t been like that at all, In fact usually the opposite - but I’ve nothing but praise for the system just now - if it wasn’t for them I’d have done it .

I’m so glad they they helped you like that. Really practical and compassionate and effective. Someone helped and in that moment it’s what you needed. So glad you called. I hope things have been better since.
Chickenpoxtwins · 19/02/2022 11:34

Shame of you both belittling and ridiculing the OP, who’s clearly struggling with their mental health, maybe you could offer something productive or make sarcastic comments else where

I'm not belittling anyone and i wasnt being sarcastic. I genuinely want to know what the op thinks the paramedics should have said if trying to give her hope was the wrong thing to do, should they have been honest with her and told her the services aren't there to help her? How would that have helped her in the short term?

I think they're damned if they do and damned if they don't. They're overworked and underpaid, understaffed and underappreciated. They're doing their best in a failing system. Their job is to take her to hospital, which they did. They seem to be copping the blame for the fact that there is little to no mental health provision in this country and that they tried to give a distressed person some hope.

gamerchick · 19/02/2022 11:29

The threshold is a danger to others rather than a danger to yourself. It's very hard to get help now.

Booboobibles · 19/02/2022 11:18

About eight years ago my then bf took himself to A&E and told them he was suicidal. They sent him immediately to the local psychiatric hospital where he was assessed for three days and visited at home for about a week afterwards.

A couple of years later in a different area, he wasn’t offered any help at all.

Even the GP counselling service is now a complete joke. They seem to be quickly training people who aren’t at all suited to the role….when the ‘therapist’ phoned me I thought she was the admin person doing a preliminary assessment. I wasn’t in too bad a state at that time but it could have tipped someone over the edge if they were feeling desperate.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 19/02/2022 11:07

People with psychosis or who have made a genuine attempt to take their life will usually be admitted for further evaluation on a psychiatric ward.

People with personality disorders, suicidal ideation with no plan (and the capacity and ability to safety plan) will usually be sent home with a referral to community mental health services. Or signposted to appropriate services if no mental health laision team is available.

Obviously if someone has physical injuries from self harm or overdose they’ll be treated for these, and their mental state assessed discreetly as well.

What sort of help did you want?

Pyewhacket · 19/02/2022 11:00

@TiredSloth

Mental health services are severely lacking, what do you think paramedics should do?
That's because nobody wants to do the job.