Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do ambulance crew really believe someone with serious mental health issues will be helped at A&E?

310 replies

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 13:58

The other thread about ambulances made me think about this.

I was taken to A&E by ambulance a couple of times some time ago due to my mental health. Both times the ambulance crew reassured me I'd get the help I needed but both times I got no help for my mental health at all.

Honestly, no wonder these people are making repeat calls - they are probably desperate!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 21:47

@Darbs76

Their job is to ensure the patient is taken to hospital if they feel they need immediate treatment. They can’t guarantee that happens as their job ends when they hand the patient over to A&E. A friends husband was taken by ambulance last year and spent 8wks in hospital due to mental health breakdown
But that's the point. Of course they can't guarantee beyond, as someone has suggested that you will be spoken to, so just say that. Don't tell the patients things will happen that may not happen. I'm glad your friend's husband got help and only needed to be in hospital for 8 weeks. Did it help him recover?
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 21:44

@EllaVaNight

Dementia care has very specific reasons for avoiding the truth. It can also be the same with delusions. We need to be able differentiate. And I agree sadly, nothing will change under the Tories I wasn't saying they were the same? I was saying they were doing the best they could. Also, they possibly genuinely believed you would get support. As stated by myself and others, they have very little training in MH. But you've chosen to make out like I don't know the difference. Just as you chose a title which comes across as bashing paramedics but then denied that's what you were doing. Maybe ask MNHQ to change the title to something more appropriate if you didn't mean it to come across as though it's the paramedics fault for providing reassurance to someone who was not in a rational state of mind.
I know I have made all those points myself. I'm sorry if I made you feel I thought you didn't know the difference. I was just responding to your comment. I don't know if my title came across as sarcastic - it was actually a genuine question. And no I really do not like the blame game atall. I didn't realise it would come over like that. What could I get it changed to?
OP posts:
Darbs76 · 19/02/2022 21:20

Their job is to ensure the patient is taken to hospital if they feel they need immediate treatment. They can’t guarantee that happens as their job ends when they hand the patient over to A&E. A friends husband was taken by ambulance last year and spent 8wks in hospital due to mental health breakdown

EllaVaNight · 19/02/2022 21:18

Dementia care has very specific reasons for avoiding the truth. It can also be the same with delusions. We need to be able differentiate. And I agree sadly, nothing will change under the Tories I wasn't saying they were the same? I was saying they were doing the best they could. Also, they possibly genuinely believed you would get support. As stated by myself and others, they have very little training in MH. But you've chosen to make out like I don't know the difference. Just as you chose a title which comes across as bashing paramedics but then denied that's what you were doing. Maybe ask MNHQ to change the title to something more appropriate if you didn't mean it to come across as though it's the paramedics fault for providing reassurance to someone who was not in a rational state of mind.

LakieLady · 19/02/2022 20:44

Don't get me started on IAPT. It may have a place for minor illness. But I know so many therapists that would never work in IAPT as they know how traumatising it can be to just get to the point of being ready to talk 6/8/10 weeks in, unpacking everything and then therapy is over and you are left retraumatised and with everything unpacked but now having to deal with it alone.

I work in welfare rights, but all my referrals are for from clients under IAPT schemes, and I totally agree with this. Very often, clients deteriorate within a few weeks of a course of IAPT work ending. It's as useless and pointless as the 6 sessions of bereavement counselling that you get from my NHS trust.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:40

@Xmassprout

I'm sorry this has happened to you. I get where you're coming from. You felt like you finally may be getting some help, and in the end its just another failure with the health services and you're essentially left to fend by yourself again. It is well meaning by the paramedics, but actually doing more harm by giving you false hope.

Sometimes A+E do help, but I think only in extreme circumstances. A family member was taken to a+e by ambulance escorted by police (no crime had been committed, but at that time they were a real risk to themselves and anyone that came near them). They spent the night there heavily sedated, until a specialist team arrived to transport them safely to a psychiatric hospital.

When my family members mental health really took a turn for the worse, they was a minor so actually received better care than if they were an adult. A lot of help they got was from cahms when they finally returned home. When things got really bad the first option would be to get hold of the crisis team and make a quick evaluation to see if immediate hospitalisation would be necessary, and if they deemed that to be the case, quite often the parents would have to try and keep them safe until transport arrived. A+E was the last option and would only be an option if the police needed to be called for assistance. If A+E was required, usually their care would involve keep them safely sedated until transport would arrive.

Yes, exactly that. I am happy to hear your relative got good care. How are they doing now?
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:38

@XenoBitch

I'm so sorry to hear your experiences. The 'attention seeking' trope needs to die a death. It is quite normal for humans to seek attention and especially when feeling so unwell and unsafe

Thank you, and absolutely! My therapist said it is "help seeking", not attention seeking... and there is nothing wrong with seeking help. It is just that some of us struggle how to ask for help, and it comes out in behaviours etc.

That is such a useful idea, thank you for sharing.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:37

@CovoidOfAllHumanity

I haven't been admitted to an MH ward I work on one and have done in various places for twenty years. Obviously I know that we have nursing and OT and that MDT input is very important but people really are not admitted to acute general adult psych wards for those alone in the current climate. Twenty years ago they were as we used to offer respite admissions but now they would get a 3 day assessment if that. Inpatient psychology isn't a given everywhere and there will not be formal 1:1 therapy on a short stay ward. You are much more likely to be offered admission with a drug treatable illness than a non drug treatable one in my personal experience because then there js a clear pathway to discharge with a fairly predictable time frame. You said yourself that your long admission was in the private sector which surely proves my point that the NHS does not really offer this kind of treatment as an inpatient as it is just too costly and long term.

To answer your other qs threshold for MHA detention is set in law so is the same in all settings. It will always require an AMHP and 2 Drs wherever the assessment takes place community, police station or A&E.

The threshold for voluntary admission is also the same in all cases. There are no separate beds that can be accessed by community services vs by A&E. In most areas the beds are gate kept by the crisis team. The liaison team in A&E have no admission rights any more than the community team do. They speak to the crisis team and they decide if a bed is needed. This makes sense that one team prioritises all admission requests so that the beds go to those most in need.

I would argue that it would neither increase nor decrease your chance of admission to go via A&E and given that waits in A&E will be long and you will have to see non specialist personnel first to get a referral to psych and tell your story a number of times then a telephone triage service is better if you have one in your area or GP referral to the crisis team. It will all come down to the same thing in the end.

One of the criteria of the MHA is that detention is a last resort and voluntary admission and community treatment need to be tried first so it is quite unlikely that admission will be the first option offered to anyone unless community treatment is completely untenable due to risk and/ or unwillingness or inability to comply.
As such they might not have been wrong to ask you to try community treatment first. For many people it might have been effective. For you it was not and you got worse so you were admitted. With the benefit of hindsight you therefore believe you should have been admitted the first time but I am not sure how anyone would know that for sure without trying. Usually people will be offered community team or crisis team at first because not everyone can be admitted and many people do benefit from community treatment. There was a success story from someone upthread who did not go to A&E but got urgent community help and avoided admission. You see it from your perspective but there are other perspectives.

I work on an inpatient ward. We do get people better. Some people find the experience helpful but in fact some people hate it even though they got better. Inpatient wards can be scary as well as therapeutic despite our best endeavours. We have to admit people with very disturbed behaviour and that is frightening.
Inpatient admission worked for you but it's not the be all and end all and I would actually much much rather that investment was made in community services to help people stay well than in more hospital beds. It's extremely depressing when people relapse due to lack of community support and it happens a lot these days.

Sorry I missed this and thank you for taking time for all your helpful responses. Around here if you go in voluntarily you will go to an assessment unit for around 7 days. It is a notoriously awful place so is a last resort. Therefore it actually means people are sectioned more as they will then go to a n acute ward. In A&E you can bypass the main area and go straight to the mental health suite if there are no physical health needs. I'm not keen on telephone calls Vs face to face as a preference. I have had 1:1 time with a therapist on an acute ward but I was there 7 months. It wasn't formal therapy of course. I take your point about community treatment but I wasn't offered anything by A&E, they didn't even speak to my therapist who had called the ambulance the first time. You know, in all honesty I do need to admit these are my recollections when I was very unwell. It might not be entirely accurate. But a lot of it does just stick in my head as trauma can. Oh and yes, I am not denying community treatment works in many cases, but unfortunately I was beyond that. Luckily my therapist managed to get me seen by First response who sectioned me. It was all in a very short time frame. There had been community involvement prior that did nothing. I don't believe in those days I got significantly worse. Anyway, that's by the by.

The private hospital I went to was NHS funded so there are places for long term inpatient. Only for a quite specific subset though - although they get it wrong at times - but again another conversation!

I have nothing but praise for the acute wards I was on they helped me enormously. I was very compliant (too tired not to be) which helped. I didn't find it frightening but the second ward I went to I'd actually worked on before!

The problem with community support when discharged from inpatient is there is no joined up thinking. Noone will communicate with each other!

OP posts:
Xmassprout · 19/02/2022 20:17

I'm sorry this has happened to you. I get where you're coming from. You felt like you finally may be getting some help, and in the end its just another failure with the health services and you're essentially left to fend by yourself again. It is well meaning by the paramedics, but actually doing more harm by giving you false hope.

Sometimes A+E do help, but I think only in extreme circumstances. A family member was taken to a+e by ambulance escorted by police (no crime had been committed, but at that time they were a real risk to themselves and anyone that came near them). They spent the night there heavily sedated, until a specialist team arrived to transport them safely to a psychiatric hospital.

When my family members mental health really took a turn for the worse, they was a minor so actually received better care than if they were an adult. A lot of help they got was from cahms when they finally returned home. When things got really bad the first option would be to get hold of the crisis team and make a quick evaluation to see if immediate hospitalisation would be necessary, and if they deemed that to be the case, quite often the parents would have to try and keep them safe until transport arrived. A+E was the last option and would only be an option if the police needed to be called for assistance. If A+E was required, usually their care would involve keep them safely sedated until transport would arrive.

XenoBitch · 19/02/2022 20:16

I'm so sorry to hear your experiences. The 'attention seeking' trope needs to die a death. It is quite normal for humans to seek attention and especially when feeling so unwell and unsafe

Thank you, and absolutely! My therapist said it is "help seeking", not attention seeking... and there is nothing wrong with seeking help. It is just that some of us struggle how to ask for help, and it comes out in behaviours etc.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:15

@Toanewstart23

Who did?
The first time it was a therapist and the second time it was my ex-DH
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:12

@Toanewstart23

These paramedics would have resuscitated not breathing children in front of frantically screaming mothers Would have given heart compressions to men in front of weeping wives Dealt with young babies with serious scalding kettle water burns

So the fact they didn’t ask questions on the journey to the hospital
To someone conscious
No immediate physical medical need whatsoever

No I’m surprised they took the opportunity to sit there in peace

What are you talking about? Yes, in health we do all sorts of things and then we move onto our next patient and give them our all too. You do realise many people with physical health problems has a knock on effect on their mental health. Even in physical health we are dealing with mental health all the time. What do you mean didn't ask questions and sat in peace. Have you had any experience of paramedics? They don't do that! Whether you like it or not part of our current system is that mental health emergencies go via normal ambulances. What do you think should happen to people with serious mental illness suffering crisis? People who are psychotic, actively suicidal (i.e high risk of completing suicide), disorientated, unable to function normally, unable to care for their kids?
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 20:02

@Toanewstart23

Sorry were you discharged or sectioned? I’m not clear
You really don't get it. People in mental health crisis are experiencing slightly more than a mere thought about suicide. They are psychotic, disorientated, actively trying to end their lives, not sleeping, not eating, etc. That you don't realise mental health crisis is an emergency makes me extremely nauseous too. You do realise when I was discharged I had to go home and look after my DC. I was unable to do so. So they suffered too. I was discharged twice from A&E before being sectioned.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:57

@MrsBerthaRochester

Yanbu. I tried to commit suicide last year. Ambulance crew couldnt have cared less, not one of them spoke to me on route to hospital. While in hospital I was assured my the mh team I would get a cpn and access to counselling. Upon discharge told by cpn I didnt meet requirements. Asked gp and told its not up to them who cpn see. The social worker and school nurse put forward the case that I have a severe trauma history and were still told I didnt need a cpn. There is no help.
I'm so sorry to hear that. I had a situation with my ex-DH where the psychiatrist wanted him to have a cpn but that team didn't take the situation seriously and I think it took 2 years before he finally got one.

How are things now? Is there a First response team your GP can refer you to?

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:47

Sorry and just to say within my work people are mostly always keen to develop best practice. If every comment was taken as 'blame' I think we'd be buried under it!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:45

@Ramalamadingdongs

I'm certainly not against mental health provision being improved. I've had ptsd and been suicidal. But no one thing caused me to be that way. It was a combination of a great many factors. I wouldn't have even considered blaming someone who had tried to help me in a crisis for me being suicidal.

I've read the whole thread and it's still not clear what you think the paramedic should have said because it seems that you're placing a great deal of importance on this one interaction out of all the many interactions you must have had with health professionals.

I would have thought that a paramedic doing a very difficult job and trying to get you to someone that could help you was at the bottom of a long list of things to blame.

If you really have read you'll see I and others have answered that over and over. Also it is not about blame. If we want to change a practice within healthcare it is never useful to blame. It is about developing best practice. When you are very ill one thing (that may seem insignificant to others) can tip you over the edge. This is such a common one that comes up time and again.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:39

@HoppingPavlova

No need to stay in an A&E bed - there is a mental health suite. I realise that is not everywhere but it is here and in other hospitals. Where there is no separate mental health people do indeed stay in A&E beds at times. And the mental health team in A&E do have capacity for assessment.

It’s great saying there are suites and all will be fine but you are missing so many things. Chronic staff shortages in the mental health units for instance, that often affects diverting people for assessment in suites/units, or their resource for MH consults in A&E. If the suites are understaffed or none can come it makes things difficult.

Not every A&E is crawling with a mental health team twiddling their thumbs waiting for someone to turn up. It just doesn’t work like that. You do know that you can request a consult for a patient and …. nada. Again, a service that’s been stripped down, combine that with staff shortages and it’s not really a guaranteed service.

You are not really understanding that at the acute point, sometimes there are just no options. No immediate resources, units either overfill or staff shortages meaning can’t run at capacity, no beds for those that do need them. We used to shunt to any old ward once upon a time to wait it out for a bed if people were deemed to need one but that’s stopped as it was too problematic all round. It’s a disgrace but sometimes there are truly no options other than for a person to be sent home in an unfit state and you cross your fingers and hope to hell the system doesn’t break down and community reaches them as soon as possible and get the ball rolling and there is not a tragedy meanwhile. That’s the reality at times.

I think you may have misunderstood me. I am aware of all of that only too well.
OP posts:
Ramalamadingdongs · 19/02/2022 19:37

I'm certainly not against mental health provision being improved. I've had ptsd and been suicidal. But no one thing caused me to be that way. It was a combination of a great many factors. I wouldn't have even considered blaming someone who had tried to help me in a crisis for me being suicidal.

I've read the whole thread and it's still not clear what you think the paramedic should have said because it seems that you're placing a great deal of importance on this one interaction out of all the many interactions you must have had with health professionals.

I would have thought that a paramedic doing a very difficult job and trying to get you to someone that could help you was at the bottom of a long list of things to blame.

maxbabi · 19/02/2022 19:35

Thanks spring! I really hope something is done soon
Police have told me they are seeing a lot of this in kids/teens now since lockdown
It's so difficult if you don't know the system and then thrown in the deep end and trying to juggle it all

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:34

@XenoBitch

A&E is rubbish for MH. Paramedics tell me that, and A&E staff too. A&E staff are there to fix things in an accident or emergency. MH is not something that can be fixed by waiting for a few hours in A&E. That is what frustrates the staff too.. they can't fix you and send you on your way. You need long term help. At best, you see the MH liaison team, who will most likely tell you to call your GP the next day, or they promise crisis team involvement, which often never comes. People in crisis who post on MN are often told to go to A&E... just to be sat waiting for ages then sent home with some leaflets.

Not all paramedics are sympathetic either. I have met some awful ones, including one who I pursued a case against for assault after he dug his nail so far into my hand, it bled... whilst saying I was attention seeking.

I'm so sorry to hear your experiences. The 'attention seeking' trope needs to die a death. It is quite normal for humans to seek attention and especially when feeling so unwell and unsafe.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:32

@FateHasRedesignedMost

People with psychosis or who have made a genuine attempt to take their life will usually be admitted for further evaluation on a psychiatric ward.

People with personality disorders, suicidal ideation with no plan (and the capacity and ability to safety plan) will usually be sent home with a referral to community mental health services. Or signposted to appropriate services if no mental health laision team is available.

Obviously if someone has physical injuries from self harm or overdose they’ll be treated for these, and their mental state assessed discreetly as well.

What sort of help did you want?

In all honesty, anything! I was too ill to think beyond that. The other hcps I saw wanted me to be given a bed as I was psychotic and actively suicidal and in hindsight they were quite right. I had had insomnia for 3 months only sleeping 2 hours a night no wonder was psychotic! Even something to help me sleep would have helped. I was in an awful state to be honest. I gave up hope after that experience. I thought as the paramedics had said I would get help there and I didn't that I obviously didn't deserve help. I tried to take my own life. Thank god I was found.
OP posts:
XenoBitch · 19/02/2022 19:22

A&E is rubbish for MH. Paramedics tell me that, and A&E staff too.
A&E staff are there to fix things in an accident or emergency. MH is not something that can be fixed by waiting for a few hours in A&E. That is what frustrates the staff too.. they can't fix you and send you on your way. You need long term help.
At best, you see the MH liaison team, who will most likely tell you to call your GP the next day, or they promise crisis team involvement, which often never comes.
People in crisis who post on MN are often told to go to A&E... just to be sat waiting for ages then sent home with some leaflets.

Not all paramedics are sympathetic either. I have met some awful ones, including one who I pursued a case against for assault after he dug his nail so far into my hand, it bled... whilst saying I was attention seeking.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:22

Incidentally, I find it interesting people keep refering to 'my therapist'. I've not said anything about having a therapist!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 19:21

@CovoidOfAllHumanity

A lot of the issue is that MH services are very siloed in the health service

General and mental health nursing training diverge very quickly. Most A&E Drs would not do any mental health training beyond 6 weeks at medical school. Whereas mental health Drs do at least 2 yrs post qualification in medicine and surgery. The Hospitals and Trusts are wholly separate. Most have no idea what services we have, what treatment we may offer etc. Its just admit them to a bed out of sight out of mind. I would think the paramedics suggested admission out of ignorance of what the likelihood of that was and of what else there might be to offer

I would say that I have a whole lot better understanding of physical health problems and services than most physical health people have of mental health. Most of them do not care or see it as important as we are such a poor relation. When training is offered most don't actually even want it they see it as someone else's problem and not part of their own job at all. Again this attitude is clearly on display in this thread.

This is not an accident. It's a result of stigma. The public still want people with mental health problems to go off somewhere else like in the old asylums and not darken the door of 'their' police, ambulance and A&E services. They largely fail to see that 'people with mental health problems' are just people until they or someone they love is in need of such help and then they are often surprised by how good we can be and how little resources we have.

Until no health without mental health is more than just a slogan nothing will really change

I completely agree with all that. No health without mental health is so important as is the other one no mental health without physical health. Those of us with SMI die on average 10 years earlier than those without. But sadly the don't care attitude is plain to see on this thread.
OP posts:
Merrymumoftwo · 19/02/2022 19:18

It definitely has, people now end up miles away from family and isolated. Providing they have been lucky enough to get a bed in the first place.

It’s extremely difficult for everyone involved

Swipe left for the next trending thread