Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do ambulance crew really believe someone with serious mental health issues will be helped at A&E?

310 replies

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 13:58

The other thread about ambulances made me think about this.

I was taken to A&E by ambulance a couple of times some time ago due to my mental health. Both times the ambulance crew reassured me I'd get the help I needed but both times I got no help for my mental health at all.

Honestly, no wonder these people are making repeat calls - they are probably desperate!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:47

But yes, as explained in my own situation it was devestating to be reassured I would get a bed and help to get better and I got nothing. I'm not blaming anyone. I think the paramedics genuinely believed what they told me and the mental health team are under a lot of pressure to discharge people quickly. Now the lack of help would have been hard anyway. But I have explained why specifically being told to expect things that didn't happen messed with my head. And I have spoken to many others who say similar. I am surprised you find it so unlikely. Managing expectations is often talked about in healthcare - around both physical and mental health.

OP posts:
Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 23:47

Again, you’re still extrapolating your own experiences. As I’m sure you know, there is a vast range of mental illnesses and how they present and how they should be approached. One size does not fit all.

In my (too many!) years in the system, it’s never been a problem of “managing expectations”. Complaints have rarely been about nice paramedics, for example! Many patients don’t wish to be admitted, many patients want to be seen urgent for a medical review, many patients would be horrified at being made to talk. You cannot presume your experience is universal.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:42

@Mickarooni - yes unfortunately it is very common. I mean you could reframe it and say of course the issue is people should be getting the help they need and they don't. Of course that is true. But unfortunately that is unlikely to change anytime soon. So expectations should be managed. And paramedics are part of that.

OP posts:
Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 23:33

^ just to add, not that it’s never a contributing factor. I just am astounded that it’s such a big issue. I am certain there are other significant and common contributing factors.

Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 23:32

[quote SpringTime2020]@Mickarooni - but what if time and again this was raised as a contributing factor? By patients, by family, by hcps? Would it not be worth looking into?[/quote]
Your specific example of a paramedic telling a patient they’ll get help and admission to a ward is a contributing factor? I find that incredibly narrow and unlikely. Do I think the systematic failures of the system are a contributing factor? 100 percent! But you’re specifically talking about paramedics reassuring people by saying they’ll get help and/or admission. I’m sorry but that’s not my experience at all and I’m certainly far from singing the praises of the system!

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:24

@Marv1nGay3

My Dd15 has suffered from some serious mental health problems as well as anorexia. We have had to call an ambulance on several occasions for her when she has been in crisis - the paramedics were absolutely brilliant each time- patient, kind and knowing exactly how best to talk to her. So much more help than the useless Camhs Crisis team. And she was admitted twice from A and E to paediatric ward and from there on to a specialist unit.
Oh, the paramedics I had were wonderful too. Crisis team not much help here either. That's great A&E worked for her. I was lucky enough to be admitted to an acute and then onto specialist too. I hope her inpatient stay helped?
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:21

@Schmoozer

I hear ya OP This happens across the mental health services They are not joined up generally very well One department will refer and discharge, referrals won’t be accepted for various reasons And before the referral is triaged by the receiving service the patient has already been promised a service !!! Very unhelpful for patients
Yes, absolutely. And it happens everywhere in the NHS in my experience. But this really is an issue that affects so many with SMI. I'm not sure why so many on this thread can't accept the lived experience of those with SMI. I guess it is a difficult truth that so many with SMI are let down.
OP posts:
Marv1nGay3 · 19/02/2022 23:19

My Dd15 has suffered from some serious mental health problems as well as anorexia. We have had to call an ambulance on several occasions for her when she has been in crisis - the paramedics were absolutely brilliant each time- patient, kind and knowing exactly how best to talk to her. So much more help than the useless Camhs Crisis team. And she was admitted twice from A and E to paediatric ward and from there on to a specialist unit.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:18

@Somebodylikeyew

Your comments saying your friend killed herself because of what the paramedic said are appalling.

Your friend killed herself because she had mental illness.

If you can’t draw those basic boundaries then I am not convinced you should be a nurse at the moment.

Have you read the thread? I don't believe I specifically stated that. If I did I retract it. I have said it was a contributing factor. I'm sorry if that is hard to hear but unfortunately as I said it comes up time and again. The devestating effect on someone's mental health when they are promised help that never materialised.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:15

@Talkwhilstyouwalk

They are more likely to get a bed by turning up at A&E, it's sometimes the only way for desperate relatives to start the process of getting them the necessary help.
Not in my experience. It appears to be less likely. But of course I'm talking about my area and surrounds. If only it was the start of help. I've been there as a relative, patient and HCP.

I hope if you have experienced this that you managed to get help. For me it was the first response team in the community that got me a bed.

OP posts:
Somebodylikeyew · 19/02/2022 23:14

Your comments saying your friend killed herself because of what the paramedic said are appalling.

Your friend killed herself because she had mental illness.

If you can’t draw those basic boundaries then I am not convinced you should be a nurse at the moment.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:11

@Mickarooni - but what if time and again this was raised as a contributing factor? By patients, by family, by hcps? Would it not be worth looking into?

OP posts:
Talkwhilstyouwalk · 19/02/2022 23:10

They are more likely to get a bed by turning up at A&E, it's sometimes the only way for desperate relatives to start the process of getting them the necessary help.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:09

@Mickarooni

What communication failed - out of interest. Your thread seems to be about the ambulance service and mental health care in A&E. It is clearly lacking but IMO, primarily due to underfunding and poor resourcing. There are, of course, some bad apples too.
When I am talking about communication between the mental health team at A&E and paramedics around managing expectations. This is a problem everywhere in the NHS not just here. Yes, absolutely underfunding etc is the cause. But there are ways to manage the situation. I will say again I am not blaming any one individual or team.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 23:06

@Awrite

It takes committed self centredness not to see that what might be best for them might not be best for everyone. A 'one size fits all' approach might not be appropriate in these circumstances.

A kindly 'false hope' or even just kindly hope might actually help others in crisis. It's not all about you!

A fair few posters have tried to point this out.

And I have pointed out endlessly this is not just about me! Did you miss the bit about my friend who died a few days ago? Did you miss the posters giving similar stories? I have spoken to so many people who have had this issue. When you have been in hospitals for an extended time you end up with a large network of people with SMI. Many have the same experience. People I have spoken to on Mind conferences/workshops have the same experience. People I spoke to through being a peer mentor. Some of my patients too. We are not all wrong! Stop trying to shut me up! Of course there should be no one size fits all. I've never said that. I have said this is an issue for many that deserves looking at. I deeply care about what happens to people with SMI so yes, I will talk about it. I find it pretty self-centred to try to dismiss patient's lived experience because it doesn't fit your agenda.
OP posts:
Schmoozer · 19/02/2022 23:05

I hear ya OP
This happens across the mental health services
They are not joined up generally very well
One department will refer and discharge, referrals won’t be accepted for various reasons
And before the referral is triaged by the receiving service the patient has already been promised a service !!! Very unhelpful for patients

Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 23:02

@SpringTime2020

And yes, of course it is a reflection of both those things. But that is always going to be the case for MH patients. Something that may seem so insignificant can tip someone over the edge. And this is a common one. That's all I'm saying!
It is absolutely impossible to know what is going to tip someone over the edge and quite unfair to put that burden on a well meaning HCP. Being told something different may well tip someone else over. Mental illness is very unique and people rarely end their lives because of a well meaning person tried to reassure them and help them. It’s far more nuanced.
Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 22:59

What communication failed - out of interest. Your thread seems to be about the ambulance service and mental health care in A&E. It is clearly lacking but IMO, primarily due to underfunding and poor resourcing. There are, of course, some bad apples too.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 22:57

And yes, of course it is a reflection of both those things. But that is always going to be the case for MH patients. Something that may seem so insignificant can tip someone over the edge. And this is a common one. That's all I'm saying!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 22:55

@Mickarooni

” I thought as the paramedics had said I would get help there and I didn't that I obviously didn't deserve help. I tried to take my own life.”

It is incredibly sad and difficult to read that you felt unworthy and like you didn’t matter. However, I think that’s a reflection on your mental state and the systemic failures of the MH system, rather than a well meaning paramedic who genuinely believed you would get help. “Get help” clearly means different things to different people, as this thread clearly shows.

As I said I genuinely think they believed I would get help. I got nothing. They also told me I would get a bed. I didn't. I absolutely am not blaming them. They did the best with the information they had. What I am talking about is more communication between multi-disciplinary teams. More training around mental health or specific mental health ambulance staff.
OP posts:
whataballbag · 19/02/2022 22:53

Please ignore the poster who mentioned all the other patients the ambulance service had to deal with.

You are no less entitled to care and compassion than anyone else who uses the service.

Doesn't matter what we have heard or seen before we speak to to you, if you're in crisis enough that we think you need an ambulance.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 22:52

@2bazookas

I am trying to understand why ambulance crew reassure you that you will get the help you need

Because it's their job to reassure and calm ALL their 999 emergency patients, for obvious medical reasons.

The 999 patient is in acute distress from some emergency; injury, pain, shock, fear, or symptoms of mental illness. Acute stress and shock can cause additional medical emergencies (stroke, heart failure, breathing problems). To reduce stress, the paramedic reassures the patient ( regardless of the presenting problem, or its severity). You're safe, we're looking after you.

You got the same verbal comforting and calming paramedics provide to all acute emergency patients. For the same reason.

But that isn't what happened as I have explained. The first time for me they told me I would get the help I needed and would get a bed. I reassure and calm my patients too. I do not promise things I have no control over. Assume you haven't read the thread. A paramedic posted about how they deal with their patients without giving them false hope. I raised this issue as I wasn't sure the reason this often happens with serious mental illness.
OP posts:
Awrite · 19/02/2022 22:40

It takes committed self centredness not to see that what might be best for them might not be best for everyone. A 'one size fits all' approach might not be appropriate in these circumstances.

A kindly 'false hope' or even just kindly hope might actually help others in crisis. It's not all about you!

A fair few posters have tried to point this out.

Mickarooni · 19/02/2022 22:38

” I thought as the paramedics had said I would get help there and I didn't that I obviously didn't deserve help. I tried to take my own life.”

It is incredibly sad and difficult to read that you felt unworthy and like you didn’t matter. However, I think that’s a reflection on your mental state and the systemic failures of the MH system, rather than a well meaning paramedic who genuinely believed you would get help. “Get help” clearly means different things to different people, as this thread clearly shows.

2bazookas · 19/02/2022 22:10

I am trying to understand why ambulance crew reassure you that you will get the help you need

Because it's their job to reassure and calm ALL their 999 emergency patients, for obvious medical reasons.

The 999 patient is in acute distress from some emergency; injury, pain, shock, fear, or symptoms of mental illness. Acute stress and shock can cause additional medical emergencies (stroke, heart failure, breathing problems). To reduce stress, the paramedic reassures the patient ( regardless of the presenting problem, or its severity). You're safe, we're looking after you.

You got the same verbal comforting and calming paramedics provide to all acute emergency patients. For the same reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread