Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do ambulance crew really believe someone with serious mental health issues will be helped at A&E?

310 replies

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 13:58

The other thread about ambulances made me think about this.

I was taken to A&E by ambulance a couple of times some time ago due to my mental health. Both times the ambulance crew reassured me I'd get the help I needed but both times I got no help for my mental health at all.

Honestly, no wonder these people are making repeat calls - they are probably desperate!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 05:36

@tcjotm

What precisely did they say to her and what would you have preferred they say? I mean, if you were training paramedics, what exact words would you like them to say to a suicidal patents?

Not being arsey, I’m trying to get my head around where you see the line is between being reassuring and giving false hope. I personally think it’s very much in the eye of the beholder and unfair to put on paramedics. For example how “we’re going to get you help” is interpreted will vary. For paramedics it means “we’re going to get you to the hospital”. Not their fault if the next step in the chain doesn’t give the person help.

What precisely should they say that’s comforting but doesn’t give false hope? I’ve been suicidal. Never called an ambulance but I would have liked them saying I’d get help. At least I’d feel they cared. But I appreciate your perspective is different and I’d like to understand what you would want to hear.

I mean in the example I gave above about a person dying, I said they’d say things like ‘you’ll be ok’. That’s not saying that the person isn’t going to die, you aren’t giving false hope but comfort. It’s what I’d want to hear if I were scared I was dying. ‘there’s pain relief available’ would be no comfort to someone scared who is feeling their life ebb away and probably beyond pain. Likewise when I was so depressed I wanted to die, I wanted comfort. What would you have had them tell me? Just a very precise ‘we are transporting you to hospital, they will assess you”. To me that’s like being told ‘your call is important to us, please hold’.

When you are told that 'you are going to get the help you need now'. Suggestions that they'll get you a bed etc. This was one of my situations. A hcp had called the ambulance and had passed on to the paramedics how serious things were. I think they genuinely thought I would get help. They really thought I would be found a bed. Now, when I was treated with contempt and discharged with no help there is the crushing disappointment which if hopes have been raised is much worse. Then there is the fear...they said I would get help here but there wasn't any help but if this is the place people get help then I will never be helped. Life is pointless, I might as well give up.

What can paramedics say/do? They can be with their patient in that moment. Supporting them with breathing etc, grounding and reorienting. I mean there are many things our wonderful talented paramedics could do if mental health training happened. They can show kindness and compassion for their patient. 'I know things feel awful right now and I'm truly sorry you are experiencing this' The thing is being told you will get help might make you feel better at the time but if you don't get that help you will be left feeling much worse. You may have experienced that yourself if you had been taken to A&E. Paramedics have always shown they care so much aside from refering to help.

Actually pain is one of the thing many patients are afraid of. Letting them know there is pain relief can be a huge comfort.

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 05:17

@ZealAndArdour - I'm not talking just about me. I wish I was! Did you not see my friend died a few days ago! I don't think you understand what I mean by serious mental illness. A cup of tea?! You must live in a very different place to me! Noone is being made cups of tea and when you have a SMI a cup of tea really doesn't cut it! When you have been in psych hospitals a long time you get a very large network of people with SMI. You hear their stories everyday. It's nice to imagine all those scenarios you suggest. And of course they happen. But a much larger proportion of people are let down in A&E. And all I'm saying is managing expectations is preferable.

And regarding myself I have complained and they were upheld (not just A&E situation). But speculating on how I presented is not likely to lead to any useful discussion.

OP posts:
tcjotm · 19/02/2022 05:16

What precisely did they say to her and what would you have preferred they say? I mean, if you were training paramedics, what exact words would you like them to say to a suicidal patents?

Not being arsey, I’m trying to get my head around where you see the line is between being reassuring and giving false hope. I personally think it’s very much in the eye of the beholder and unfair to put on paramedics. For example how “we’re going to get you help” is interpreted will vary. For paramedics it means “we’re going to get you to the hospital”. Not their fault if the next step in the chain doesn’t give the person help.

What precisely should they say that’s comforting but doesn’t give false hope? I’ve been suicidal. Never called an ambulance but I would have liked them saying I’d get help. At least I’d feel they cared. But I appreciate your perspective is different and I’d like to understand what you would want to hear.

I mean in the example I gave above about a person dying, I said they’d say things like ‘you’ll be ok’. That’s not saying that the person isn’t going to die, you aren’t giving false hope but comfort. It’s what I’d want to hear if I were scared I was dying. ‘there’s pain relief available’ would be no comfort to someone scared who is feeling their life ebb away and probably beyond pain. Likewise when I was so depressed I wanted to die, I wanted comfort. What would you have had them tell me? Just a very precise ‘we are transporting you to hospital, they will assess you”. To me that’s like being told ‘your call is important to us, please hold’.

ZealAndArdour · 19/02/2022 05:01

But maybe some people did find A&E helpful, perhaps some of them just needed to be heard, and felt better after a listening ear and a cup of tea, some people might have even signposted to other mental health services or referred for CBT or simile, others might have been sectioned, and another person might have had a dose of diazepam and their breathing coached to help them out of a panic attack, and some of them might have had a reversible physical problem causing their mental health issue I.e. an elderly person with delirium, and there’s a lot of others who feel a lot, lot better after the drink or drugs have worn up and their loved on has come to comfort the and collect them to go home.

You’re talking specifically about your situation, like it’s a universal experience for everyone attending A&E for a mental health issue and it’s not the case. If you feel your care was misleading or substandard, it is within your rights to complain about that and have it addressed. But also consider that maybe you assessed very differently on the day you were taken to A&E, than you did on the day you were finally sectioned. Perhaps the person performing the first assessment has a higher threshold of risk that they’re comfortable working to and if a different person assessed you the first time you might have been sectioned.

There are so many nuances and variables, but you’re taking in absolutes.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:57

@ZealAndArdour

I don’t understand how you can be a nurse and have so little insight into how fucked and broken the system is. There is a vast gaping chasm between how everything should work and how it does work in reality, I don’t know a HCP alive who doesn’t know that.

I’m struggling to understand what you want out of the thread? You’re griping at paramedics for doing they only possible thing they can do in the situation they’re presented with. Would you rather they just told you “don’t bother going to A&E, they can’t help you, you might as well just stay here and kill yourself”. Like realistically, what else could the possibly say to you other than “please come to hospital, you’ll get help”.

My faith in the system is pretty low too, in fact I’ve paid to go privately three times in the last year, once for a gastroenterologist, once for a cardiologist and I’m still seeing a private psychiatrist and paying private prescription charges for my meds. I know the system is broken, I know that timely help isn’t there, but this thread moaning about your supposed HCP colleagues is absolutely redundant,

I'm more than aware of it as I have referred to in many of my posts.

Again as I have said I am not griping at paramedics atall. They are free not to raise false hopes (if they are aware help is unlikely). As I have said in my nurse training this was very important - how to reassure a patient and manage expectations. It isn't something that is impossible for ambulance crew to do.

And no it's not redundant. Not when people's lives could be saved if people understood the point I am making. Luckily the ambulance crew on this thread did understand and we have been able to have a useful conversation. Communication is so important and we've been able to have it here. If the thread is not of interest to you - no need to post.

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:51

@tcjotm

OP I get what you’re saying but what else can the paramedics say? They want to reassure the person. Brutal honesty isn’t going to be very nice. I mean if they are dealing with someone with severe blood loss from an injury, they’ll say ‘you’ll be ok, come on, stay with me, it’s ok’ not ‘shot, you’re doomed mate, no Band-Aid big enough to cover that hole! I’m going to get a cuppa, no point in staying with you’.

They want to think their patient will get help (otherwise what’s the point of having an ambulance service) and it’s not up to them to tell you that there’s no point and you’ll just be sent home again. It’s not their job to deliver that message. They go to their jobs with hope and the aim to do their very best for the person. They need to keep that hope.

I get that it’s horrible having your hopes up, but I don’t think outcomes would be better if they answered a call just to turn up and say ‘no point, you won’t get help’. That’s not going to lead to a good outcome either. With an actively suicidal person it’s often important to break the moment. The person is still depressed, but hopefully no longer actively suicidal. I’m so sorry that wasn’t the case with your friend. It’s truly tragic she was let down. But what else could they say? Humans make reassuring sounds to a person in distress. You’d have to be a sociopath to be able to deal with someone in such a state and not say anything at all. Paramedics do their part in the chain of people who will hopefully get a person well. They shouldn’t have to do that differently just because the rest of the services can’t cope.

There’s no good outcome here. The government need to totally re prioritise funding. It’s just appalling how stretched services are now. And this is the outcome.

They can not make false promises. I'm a nurse and know how important that is. You can reassure someone without telling them things that may or may not happen. That is different to brutal honesty. If someone is in danger of death I would reassure them we are doing all we can for them and there is pain relief available - I would not promise them they would not die.

The trouble is raising false hope is making the situation worse for the patient. By being reassuring but realistic you prevent the horrendous feeling of hopes being dashed again. That is what paramedics should be doing, imvho. It was part of my nurse training.

OP posts:
ZealAndArdour · 19/02/2022 04:50

I don’t understand how you can be a nurse and have so little insight into how fucked and broken the system is. There is a vast gaping chasm between how everything should work and how it does work in reality, I don’t know a HCP alive who doesn’t know that.

I’m struggling to understand what you want out of the thread? You’re griping at paramedics for doing they only possible thing they can do in the situation they’re presented with. Would you rather they just told you “don’t bother going to A&E, they can’t help you, you might as well just stay here and kill yourself”. Like realistically, what else could the possibly say to you other than “please come to hospital, you’ll get help”.

My faith in the system is pretty low too, in fact I’ve paid to go privately three times in the last year, once for a gastroenterologist, once for a cardiologist and I’m still seeing a private psychiatrist and paying private prescription charges for my meds. I know the system is broken, I know that timely help isn’t there, but this thread moaning about your supposed HCP colleagues is absolutely redundant,

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:43

@ZealAndArdour

I am trying to understand why ambulance crew reassure you that you will get the help you need when in most cases you will not.

Because they aren’t mental health professionals capable of taking a full psychiatry history, risk assessing your mental state, suggesting differential diagnoses and identifying a treatment plan for your mental health needs.

They only have access to/knowledge of some initial brief screening tools that likely suggested A&E based on what you told them. They probably believed you would get help. Help comes in many forms and it’s different for everyone.

Usually the mental health team in the department will give you details to self refer to talking therapy at the very least, if not access to the crisis team for a defined period of time or they might write to your GP to recommend a referral to outpatient psychiatry.

Nobody with a physical or mental health need gets to go to hospital and demand what treatment they think they need, it is based on a skilled assessment and an evidence base of information which informs what treatment your particular presentation is most likely to benefit from.

Yes, thanks for that. As you say they don't know so best not get hopes up. Demand treatment? If only I was well enough to do just that. It nearly cost me my life. Self refer to talking therapy...you must be joking?! And yes eventually I was assessed. I was sectioned and in hospital for a long time. Luckily I wasn't dead before this happened. Many others weren't so lucky.
OP posts:
tcjotm · 19/02/2022 04:40

OP I get what you’re saying but what else can the paramedics say? They want to reassure the person. Brutal honesty isn’t going to be very nice. I mean if they are dealing with someone with severe blood loss from an injury, they’ll say ‘you’ll be ok, come on, stay with me, it’s ok’ not ‘shot, you’re doomed mate, no Band-Aid big enough to cover that hole! I’m going to get a cuppa, no point in staying with you’.

They want to think their patient will get help (otherwise what’s the point of having an ambulance service) and it’s not up to them to tell you that there’s no point and you’ll just be sent home again. It’s not their job to deliver that message. They go to their jobs with hope and the aim to do their very best for the person. They need to keep that hope.

I get that it’s horrible having your hopes up, but I don’t think outcomes would be better if they answered a call just to turn up and say ‘no point, you won’t get help’. That’s not going to lead to a good outcome either. With an actively suicidal person it’s often important to break the moment. The person is still depressed, but hopefully no longer actively suicidal. I’m so sorry that wasn’t the case with your friend. It’s truly tragic she was let down. But what else could they say? Humans make reassuring sounds to a person in distress. You’d have to be a sociopath to be able to deal with someone in such a state and not say anything at all. Paramedics do their part in the chain of people who will hopefully get a person well. They shouldn’t have to do that differently just because the rest of the services can’t cope.

There’s no good outcome here. The government need to totally re prioritise funding. It’s just appalling how stretched services are now. And this is the outcome.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:38

@saraclara

You got help, OP. Help to keep you safe. That's all they will have meant. The difference between leaving you at home and taking you to a&e meant that with the latter prob you'd get help in the form of safety, and presumably any acute medication.

They weren't lying to you. You just have a different definition of help.

No, that isn't all they meant. And no I didn"t get help to keep me safe beyond the short time I was in A&E. Then it was back to my DC even more suicidal. And no, no acute meds either. You presume wrong.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:36

@ZealAndArdour

But A&E aren’t letting you down on purpose, nobody works in A&E to make anyones life worse. There is no funding.

Write to your MP? Stand in your next local election? Try and discourage people you know from voting for the tories? Train to be a mental health nurse? Or psychiatrist?

I'm already a nurse.

They may not be letting us down on purpose but they are and people are dying. As has been discussed a small thing paramedics can do is not raise people's hopes. That can be done much quicker and will affect many more people than me standing for election or training to be a psych!!! And how you think I can afford to do that anyway!

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:32

@SleepyRich

Speaking as a Paramedic I received very little clinical training in regards to mental health, we're talking just a 2-4 hour lecture on the subject, no placements. Training programmes do vary so experiences differ.

So when I'm sent to assess someone in crisis/suicidal really it's not a lot different to sending a random member of the public unfortunately. Personally I go as someone for them to speak at for an hour or so and try to just listen/be supportive. But ultimately we're not tied into any mental health services, what we learn wont be forwarded onto any mental health teams, it's very poor.

Ultimately all I'm doing is trying to identify if a patient is actively contemplating suicide, if they are do they have a plan, if they have a plan do I think they're likely to try it, if they try their plan it is it likely to work. If the answer is yes to all those things then they're the people that A&E/crisis teams there would be most appropriate for.

To my knowledge the others that are suicidal but not having a realistic plan, have a long history of these thoughts but no serious attempts, call for help themselves as opposed to being discovered are likely to be discharged from A&E without treatment as it'll be felt their not likely to end their lives imminently. We still encourage patients calling 999 to attend A&E regardless of knowing they probably wont get the help they need because we recognise that we do not have mental health training, we are not mental health professionals, it is not our place to discharge them. Personally I'd never promise to a patient that they'll get help, just that they'll be able to speak face to face with someone from the mental health team.

Thank you for your post. And admire you so much. It is absolutely awful the lack of MH training you get. It's great that you never promise things that might not happen. I think it is so important. And yes, you lot are wonderful to talk to and it helps a lot to have a friendly ear to listen.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:28

@BettyBag - it is often the ambulance service that takes you to your psych hospital but private ambulances are used to.

It is disappointing that some people don't understand MH crisis can be an emergency.

OP posts:
ZealAndArdour · 19/02/2022 04:26

But A&E aren’t letting you down on purpose, nobody works in A&E to make anyones life worse. There is no funding.

Write to your MP? Stand in your next local election? Try and discourage people you know from voting for the tories? Train to be a mental health nurse? Or psychiatrist?

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:24

@caranations

Better the ambulance crew take them in than leave them at home, which is what they did with my late DM when I was a child. She was having a complete mental breakdown and they drove off and left her alone with me. It was only because the neighbour across the way had seen the ambulance, were worried and came across to see if we were ok that anything got done. They called the ambulance again (who refused to come, by the way), then called their own GP who came and sectioned her. The GP insisted that the ambulance returned, and they took her off to a psychiatric hospital. She was there for several months.

I just wish the ambulance had taken her in the first time, instead of fucking off and leaving me alone with her. I have never felt so abandoned in my life as I did that day.

Well, I was soon back at home with my DC. Just because you are in A&E for a few hours coming back home even more suicidal is even worse. I'm glad your DM got help. She most likely wouldn't have done if taken to A&E.
OP posts:
ZealAndArdour · 19/02/2022 04:23

I am trying to understand why ambulance crew reassure you that you will get the help you need when in most cases you will not.

Because they aren’t mental health professionals capable of taking a full psychiatry history, risk assessing your mental state, suggesting differential diagnoses and identifying a treatment plan for your mental health needs.

They only have access to/knowledge of some initial brief screening tools that likely suggested A&E based on what you told them. They probably believed you would get help. Help comes in many forms and it’s different for everyone.

Usually the mental health team in the department will give you details to self refer to talking therapy at the very least, if not access to the crisis team for a defined period of time or they might write to your GP to recommend a referral to outpatient psychiatry.

Nobody with a physical or mental health need gets to go to hospital and demand what treatment they think they need, it is based on a skilled assessment and an evidence base of information which informs what treatment your particular presentation is most likely to benefit from.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:21

@ZealAndArdour

Actually A&E depts often do have access to Crisis team nurses who can come and do an assessment and if they deem it necessary can get the patient admitted to a psychiatry bed/seen by a psychiatrist if they’re very sick. But it’s a very high threshold of mental health issue that would necessitate psychiatry admission these days. Unless you’re actively suicidal with a credible plan and the means to carry it out, or psychotic or have already made a credible attempt on your life then you’re unlikely to be deemed in need of sectioning, and these days they prefer to get a lot of people in on a voluntary “section” which comes with its own pitfalls for the likely care you’ll get, the follow up you’d have and other procedural things, but essentially, when you calm down from the crisis and things settle, you can ask to leave and they won’t stop you, thus absolving themselves as you’re there voluntarily.

It’s a rubbish underfunded system, but neither 999 or A&E places for depressed or anxious people who have no active intent to kill themselves or harm others. Some liaison psychiatry teams won’t even leave their office to see a patient unless that threshold is met.

Well in my situation I was actively suicidal and made even more so by the mental health team at A&E. Having hopes raised and then dashed and being treated with contempt by A&E lead to further attempts. I needed a bed. And luckily I was soon sectioned and in hospital for a long time. So yes I did meet the threshold. Just for some reason so many people in crisis are let down at A&E.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:16

@HowToStopThinking

Fabulous, yet another stick to bet the ambulance service with.

I say that as a person with a list of diagnosed mental health conditions and with a DH who works, on the road, as part of an ambulance crew (AAP). My DH puts his life at risk every time he has to be a part of a blue light run!

Paramedics and ambulance crew/staff have no say, absolutely no say, about what happens in the hospital. If they are told that a patient with MH concerns will get help how on earth do you expect them to know different, it's not like they always get updated on how the patients are after they have been handed over.

The people you need to be angry with are the current government, not paramedics, Nurses, Doctors or any other HCP!

I'm not angry with paramedics!!! You have completely missed the point. When seriously mentally ill patients keep having their hopes raised (by ambulance crew) and then dashed (by the mental health team) it makes them even more likely to take their own life. This was the situation for a friend of mine a few days ago and she passed away. This is important!! Who is telling ambulance crew they will get help? Why are patient's hopes being raised like this? Because it leads to another young women completing suicide. And if anyone thinks that is not worth discussing please think again.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:10

@Prinnny

The paramedics job is to treat any life threatening injuries and take the patient to a place of safety.

A&E is for people who have had an accident or emergency, they can treat the issues caused by mental health problems such as injuries caused by self harm etc but they can diagnose and treat mental health problems.

Can’t believe people think paramedics and A&E are the place for mental health support, all they can do is refer you on.

No they have a mental health team. Can't believe people don't realise that. And it is an emergency when you are actively suicidal.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:09

@Oblomov22

I seriously can't believe I'm reading Ambulance staff being criticised for this.

Have you made an appointment with your GP since, or are you under any other MH team OP?

Criticised by who? Certainly not me. I am trying to understand why ambulance crew reassure you that you will get the help you need when in most cases you will not.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:07

@BankersBonus - I'm so sorry to hear that. It is very common. They patch you up and send you on your way feeling even worse. I hope your brother is doing better?

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:03

I mean in theory A&E can do it but it is very rare.

OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:02

@Christienne

My DM has a significant mental health issue. Last time we needed to get her admitted, we were informed via A&E was the only way to do this.
Really? And did it work? Here the psychs and AMHPs do it.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:01

@elenacampana

Everybody is desperate OP, staff and patients.
Yes, I agree.
OP posts:
SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 04:00

@ToastieCrumbs

Very soon after starting to deal with MH services on behalf of a sibling, I learnt very quickly to have basically no expectations and not to make promises to them that I couldn’t keep.

The system is appalling and ends up being cruel to unwell people and yes that is not the fault of paramedics, but I agree that they do need to be careful what they say to patients.

It doesn’t help practically, but I’m sure the paramedics that came to you OP would be devastated to know that you weren’t cared for though, and that they had raised your expectations only to have them crushed.

Thank you - someone who understands the point I am making! All the paramedics I have ever been cared for by have been amazing. I know they meant know harm. But I wondered if they really know what happens when you get to hospital? Talked to like you are wasting their time and discharged with nothing.
OP posts: