Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do ambulance crew really believe someone with serious mental health issues will be helped at A&E?

310 replies

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 13:58

The other thread about ambulances made me think about this.

I was taken to A&E by ambulance a couple of times some time ago due to my mental health. Both times the ambulance crew reassured me I'd get the help I needed but both times I got no help for my mental health at all.

Honestly, no wonder these people are making repeat calls - they are probably desperate!

OP posts:
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 19/02/2022 08:21

@londonrach

How’s it a place of safety when they are told to go
Home? Which happened to my friend, I was begging them not to send her home

ancientgran · 19/02/2022 08:18

@SleepyRich

Speaking as a Paramedic I received very little clinical training in regards to mental health, we're talking just a 2-4 hour lecture on the subject, no placements. Training programmes do vary so experiences differ.

So when I'm sent to assess someone in crisis/suicidal really it's not a lot different to sending a random member of the public unfortunately. Personally I go as someone for them to speak at for an hour or so and try to just listen/be supportive. But ultimately we're not tied into any mental health services, what we learn wont be forwarded onto any mental health teams, it's very poor.

Ultimately all I'm doing is trying to identify if a patient is actively contemplating suicide, if they are do they have a plan, if they have a plan do I think they're likely to try it, if they try their plan it is it likely to work. If the answer is yes to all those things then they're the people that A&E/crisis teams there would be most appropriate for.

To my knowledge the others that are suicidal but not having a realistic plan, have a long history of these thoughts but no serious attempts, call for help themselves as opposed to being discovered are likely to be discharged from A&E without treatment as it'll be felt their not likely to end their lives imminently. We still encourage patients calling 999 to attend A&E regardless of knowing they probably wont get the help they need because we recognise that we do not have mental health training, we are not mental health professionals, it is not our place to discharge them. Personally I'd never promise to a patient that they'll get help, just that they'll be able to speak face to face with someone from the mental health team.

I think that is all very understandable but I think the OPs point is if you promise a sick person they will get the help they need and they don't it makes things even worse for them as it is just one more let down. I don't think she expects the ambulance crew to work miracles she just wants them to be honest.

I can imagine if you are dealing with someone very distressed it must seem kind to reassure them but in the long run it might not be. It is difficult but I do think it is good to hear it from the service users point of view and it shows that you are doing the right thing when you don't make promises. Maybe it is a training need for some crew members?

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 19/02/2022 08:11

Some myths in this thread

Lack of beds
Well it depends. It's not the whole truth
If you were ravingly manic or psychotic a bed would be found somehow somewhere and you would get dosed up with some meds. You would clearly meet a threshold for admission and effective treatment would be available.
Beds for people with personality disorder, emotional trauma and other long term issues that require months and years of therapy and management more than meds are what is not available. It's obvious why not because the person would be occupying the bed for many months or even years so they won't come up often.
If the public want more people to be treated as inpatients for conditions such as these then it would require huge investment
Many people would argue that an admission to a short term general mental health bed for such a condition is not a whole lot more helpful than A&E because those treatments are not available in a general acute ward where most patients have psychotic mental illness.
In most areas 3 day crisis assessment beds exist and then the majority of the long term work is carried out by community services.
That is the real reason why people don't on the whole get admitted from A&E.
Not that there are no beds at all but there are none of the kinds of bed that would be helpful to someone with a non drug responsive condition

'Sectioning'
No one would be detained under the MHA if they were actually wanting or accepting treatment as the entire purpose of it is to enforce treatment. Being detained is not a fail safe marker of the severity of a persons mental illness. Many people with serious mental illness are never detained or haven't been for years as they learn how to avoid it. It is pretty aversive as you lose nearly all autonomy
You do not need to be 'sectioned' to be admitted if you agree to it and most people are not. You cannot be 'voluntarily sectioned' that is a total oxymoron. You can be voluntarily admitted and if you withdrew your consent and the MHA criteria were met then you could still later on be detained so it is never a one time decision.

Underfunding of MH services vs physical health is not a myth though.
Parity of funding and esteem is a pipe dream. I heard an oncologist on the radio once complaining about how shit MH services are vs cancer services and he did not once appear to realise that the funding differential and the stigma are the cause of that. If we had all the money and public goodwill that cancer services have things would be very different. As it is we have to cut our cloth to fit and for some people we pretty much cannot offer a service or not one that is any good as we don't have the money or the staff to do it. Hence why OP eventually went to a private unit I guess.
We do offer a good service for what we are good at which is largely schizophrenia, bipolar I and major depression.

londonrach · 19/02/2022 08:02

No they don't but they taking the person to a place a safety. Yabu

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 19/02/2022 08:01

I spent 8 hours getting a seriously mentally ill friend to a&e, police helped searched for her all day, she got told to come back tomo to a&e, was horrific. She didn’t go back

Snog · 19/02/2022 08:01

It is surely more important to focus energy on how to change the system so that people DO get the help they need and are not turned away feeling even more suicidal and without good support.

Do the paramedics need to say "I hope you get the care you need today but please be aware that this might not be possible" ? I'm not sure that everyone would find that helpful to hear, true or not.

Allelbowsandtoes · 19/02/2022 08:00

@Pandoh

Here anyone brought in for MH related things gets assessed by the relevant professionals that can section if needed. The trouble is that the threshold is so high and there's no beds, so for many who do require help sadly they still cannot access it. It's not even a funding thing at this point, there aren't enough staff to expand services. I do think there should be ambulances dedicated to MH calls with different equipment and mental health trained HCPs on board, it would free up ambulances as we know them and also the people would have more knowledge of the system and be able to provide more tailored care. Paramedics already have tonnes to know and learn, and to expect them to have an in depth knowledge of mental health as well is too much.
In most places in the UK there are street triage teams, made up of mental health professionals who can go out with police or paramedics to mental health calls. So it is a thing. OP - I'm sorry you've felt dismissed and struggled to get the help you needed. I'm a mental health nurse and I have found it increasingly difficult over the seven years I've been qualified, due to services being constantly cut and understaffed. But I can't imagine how hard it is when you're the person using those services and feeling that you're not getting the help or empathy you need. I think there has increasingly become a culture within MH services of making it difficult for people to get into secondary services or get the care they need, all under the guise of "encouraging independence " or not making people dependent on services. I hope that things start to get better for you Flowers
FranklyMyBeer · 19/02/2022 08:00

A&E can help. I drove myself there - actually to see them about another imagined condition I thought was happening to me.
I was having a breakdown with pnd. Luckily a social worker came in to chat to me in my cubicle and I heard her telling the doctor that he couldn’t let me go.
I spent about 8 hours there that day, dh collected me and I was under the community mental health team for weeks - they visited me twice a day and I had psychiatrist appointments regularly.
I've always had mh problems my whole life. This was the first time I ever went to a&e (although I have been in a private mh hospital before too).
They did help me - thanks to the social worker. Perhaps the ambulance crew thought you'd get seen by one. Also, it's probably their policy and the drivers themselves can either decide to leave you or take you to a and e. Perhaps they knew you would be sent home again.

CurtainTroubles · 19/02/2022 07:58

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

LakieLady · 19/02/2022 07:56

The people you need to be angry with are the current government, not paramedics, Nurses, Doctors or any other HCP!

And those who voted for them, who plainly don't give a damn about MH provision, until it actually affects them in some way.

You're more likely to get admitted to a psych unit from police custody than from A&E. A couple of clients have gone down this route in the last few months, thankfully only by causing some sort of disturbance or committing criminal damage.

MH services are so stretched that they can't possibly meet the need, which has increased since the pandemic. They're losing really good staff, because they are utterly demoralised by not being able to give people the help they need.

I have an ex-client who struggles with paranoid schizophrenia. They're supposed to have a fortnightly visit from a CPN. That all stopped in the first lockdown, they've had a phone call every few months, and 2 telephone reviews with a consultant in nearly 2 years. When they asked when visits or F2F appointments were going to resume, he was told that there were no plans to do that yet, because of cuts. He is really unwell.

MH services here are in crisis. I doubt if anyone has bothered to tell paramedics that the chances of anyone with MH issues getting meaningful help via A&E are, at best, slim.

MrsTophamHat · 19/02/2022 07:47

My DH works as part of a joint initiative between police and NHS to better deal with people in mental health crisis who would previously have ended up being sectioned. It's not something that happens everywhere yet but it works well and may become more widespread if other counties decide to set it up.

cptartapp · 19/02/2022 07:45

Nurse here too.
They're so very busy, I suspect that in good faith they just say what you want to hear to gain your cooperation, and move as quickly as possible onto their next call.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 19/02/2022 07:36

They take people to hospital if they feel they won't be safe at home. They have to do that obviously. If you are saying you will kill yourself if left at home then they have no choice do they? They will say what it takes to get you to go if the stakes are high.

'Get the help you need' is relative isn't it?
Surely you did not believe that A&E was a magic shortcut to being cured otherwise everyone else would also have discovered it. If the help you immediately need is to stay safe tonight then you will get that. You will usually also be seen by a MH professional but their role at that point is to ensure you are safe for discharge that night and refer you in to other services for the longer term problem. You might still have to wait though.

What is the help that you need in your view? Admission: only really helpful for conditions that can be cured by drugs. Psychotherapy? Not going to be available in A&E at any point

It's fine to go to A&E if you are in crisis as a place of safety and usually there will be a hospital liaison team or a duty psychiatrist to talk to but that's realistically all that's going to be available there. Many places have a crisis line 111 option 2 which would offer much the same if you are OK with telephone interactions and avoids the waiting around in A&E if there are no accompanying physical issues.

Prinnny · 19/02/2022 07:21

Paramedics go to multiple hospitals, and what happens at one may not happen at another. Yes we can call the crisis team, they often taken hours upon hours to come, then will simply check you not actively suicidal and will say discharge and follow up in the community. The threshold for admission is extremely high, and mental health beds are few and far between! They aren’t lying to you, they are not to blame, neither are the ED staff, our hands are tied.

pinkstripeycat · 19/02/2022 07:17

A friend was in A&E this week and was talking to a 19 year old boy. He’d tried to commit suicide and been brought in by the police. He’d sat there for 10 hrs. He said to my friend “I just want help and they’ve left me here.” So sad

Pandoh · 19/02/2022 07:11

@CurtainTroubles

Your frustration should be directed at the governing party who won’t fund mental health services.
They will chuck money at them but there aren't enough staff so there's no point. The nhs is beyond just chuck more money at it.
Polyanthus2 · 19/02/2022 07:05

Your frustration should be directed at the governing party who won’t fund mental health services.

Or at the public who won't pay more taxes.

Polyanthus2 · 19/02/2022 07:04

I don't understand how everyone can get a lift to the supermarket each week but suddenly need an ambulance to take them if they feel ill.
At the worst and you have no transport people get picked up from the supermarket by a taxi.
What the heck is it - unless you are dying of a heart attack - can't you just get a lift like the rest of the time.

CurtainTroubles · 19/02/2022 07:02

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Pandoh · 19/02/2022 07:02

Here anyone brought in for MH related things gets assessed by the relevant professionals that can section if needed. The trouble is that the threshold is so high and there's no beds, so for many who do require help sadly they still cannot access it. It's not even a funding thing at this point, there aren't enough staff to expand services. I do think there should be ambulances dedicated to MH calls with different equipment and mental health trained HCPs on board, it would free up ambulances as we know them and also the people would have more knowledge of the system and be able to provide more tailored care. Paramedics already have tonnes to know and learn, and to expect them to have an in depth knowledge of mental health as well is too much.

ThreeFeetTall · 19/02/2022 06:58

I have just read 'Can you hear me' which is written by a paramedic and covers this (along with lots of other stuff)

I agree no one should be lying but I might exaggerate a bit about what will happen at A&E if I thought it might save a life.

hattie43 · 19/02/2022 06:52

I work with someone now who left a paramedic job because he got totally fed up of the drain of mental health people constantly taking their call out time when he should be helping people with a life or death emergency . He felt the same people over and over were calling 999 for some attention seeking supposed suicide, preventing them getting to emergencies .
He decided to leave when he was starting to feel if they were genuinely suicidal they would bloody get on and do it and not delay everyone for hours on top of a motorway bridge they had no intention of falling from .
It's very sad all around but this explosion of 'mental health ' seems to permeate every sector and it's totally new and hard to understand for a lot of us .

HoppingPavlova · 19/02/2022 06:36

Just for some reason so many people in crisis are let down at A&E.

Easy answer. There are generally no beds to send you to and services are at capacity so the mandate is to refer to outpatient services who will get to you when they can (although this part seems to break down often and not everyone is contacted). Mental health beds don’t grow on trees and for one to be free while you are in A&E the stars and planets would have to be in alignment and that’s so rare. It’s not that A&E don’t care, there is literally nowhere to send you that had capacity at the time.

It’s unfortunate but someone can’t stay in an A&E bed for a few days until a mental health team has capacity to make a proper assessment and then for days until a mental health bed becomes available. A&E are no more happy about this than you are, let me assure you but it is what it is and yes, unfortunately some people may not survive this and no one is blind to that but in an individual level no one can do anything otherwise.

Perhaps instead of blaming paramedics and A&E you could put the blame squarely where it belongs, Govnt funding has stripped mental health services back past the bone, and THIS is where your anger should be directed.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 06:28

@tcjotm - thank you for your understanding. I ended up one of the lucky ones. I was sectioned and given lots of help in hospital. The long stay one was a private hospital so I got lots of wonderful extras not available in the NHS.

Just to clarify this is not a dig atall at our amazing paramedics. This is not a dig at any hcps. We all know the real answer is adequate funding.

OP posts:
tcjotm · 19/02/2022 05:50

Thank you @SpringTime2020that does really help. I agree, being told you’ll get a bed is a step too far, they can’t promise that at all. That must’ve been a crushing experience.

I acknowledge too that my experience is probably coloured by being in a better funded health system. What I read about the UK here is horrific. Mental health treatment still isn’t great, but overall the health system is much better resourced. But even here I wouldn’t assume I’d get admitted/get a bed. That shouldn’t be promised, though I’m sure the paramedics really hoped you would. “You’re going to get the help you need now” really should be a promise they can keep (at least some level of help” but sounds like things are beyond broken. A&E is less cutthroat where I am, I’ve always gotten some kind of help.

Again, really sorry for your loss. It must be so hard having had similar experiences yourself. It’s somehow worse to understand and still lose someone to it.