Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Misuse of ambulances

117 replies

Lampshade7 · 18/02/2022 11:59

I work for one of the ambulance trusts. We have many, many people who phone up several times a day wanting ambulances. They are sent out but never need them. Obviously this is a vast waste of resources and time. If I had my way I would not send an ambulance no matter what the reason. One of my colleagues was horrified by this and said that they should be sent just in case. I think stuff them, you can cry wolf once too often. IABU?

OP posts:
BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 17:10

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 17:01

I should have refreshed first - x-posted to an extent with a few other PPs.

There was a thread on here woman ranting about hours and hours wait for ambulance.
She did have a medical need for hospital she said she rung numerous times chasing then on the last call said she told them not to bother and her husband drove her in.
Why didn't he take her in the 1st place and he was there with her all the time

I think this is a wider part of the problem, in that people see an ambulance as something that their circumstances merit or are simply entitled to as a basic right, rather than as a precious, limited, expensive resource to be used only by those for which it is necessary. It isn't there just to validate you or your health requirements as being 'serious'.

There are probably also a few who just want some pictures to post on SM, to get themselves attention and sympathy, in a way that being driven there undramatically by their DH/DW wouldn't really cut it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 16:51

Surely there's a training course or something you can go on if you are having difficulty with your response to this situation. We're constantly being told that the only problem with the NHS is funding but the staff themselves are all great. Don't go fucking that stored goodwill up with damn fool threads like this.

I think that comment is a really low blow. NHS workers are human too, and they're allowed to vent their frustration like anybody else - especially the emergency response team, who end up with all of the passed bucks. I'm not saying that the abusers should be denied the same rights as everybody else, but when it comes to NHS resources, they're hardly helping, are they? It costs a huge amount to send an ambulance out.

Are you saying that, if you constantly received hoax/ridiculous callouts for whatever your job is - preventing you from getting to people with a genuine need for you - you would turn up with a smile every time and not even be a little annoyed? Yes, the people making the endless calls are often vulnerable in certain ways, but so are the people having heart attacks, brain haemorrhages and being smashed into by drunk drivers.

Every time I've needed an ambulance, either me, or the person calling for me have had to answer so many questions to make sure it's needed.

But I assume you/they are relatively calm, lucid, reasonable and compliant when calling? If somebody faked an inability to breathe, cried out and spoke in forced gasps that they were dying, whilst refusing/ignoring any questions they were asked, an ambulance would be sent anyway - as their circumstances could just as easily be somebody in genuine desperate need of urgent assistance as somebody who knows how to 'perform' to get an ambulance out, even though there's nothing/very little wrong with them.

There definitely should be some kind of referral system afterwards for people calling multiple times a day/week, rather than just checking them and discharging them. I maintain that anybody who needs/claims to need an ambulance five times a day, every single day, is not capable of independent living.

The right kind of targeted help - going through their living and independent vs (possibly self-funded) residential accommodation options with them and making it clear that medical staff could act in their best interests if they were deemed to lack capacity - would both serve as a massive wake-up alarm call to the faking attention seekers who realised their game was up, whilst also proving a huge relief to those genuinely in need of ongoing medical assistance, that they might finally be helped to get it.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 16:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Topseyt · 18/02/2022 16:23

I get the frustration, but you can't refuse to send an ambulance.

You simply don't know whether or not the one time you refuse an ambulance could be the one time they really do need one.

I don't know what the solution is. A number of the frequent callers probably do have significant mental health issues which cloud their judgement and for which inadequate treatment is available, if any at all. Others are just too stupid to understand what a real emergency is. There are hoaxers too I assume, and they are lowlife scum sometimes dealt with by the police if they can catch them.

PollyPage · 18/02/2022 16:22

If you really do that job you are probably aware that there's no need to change anything, people are abandoned, neglected and killed every day while waiting up to 24 hours for an ambulance. No way would I associate myself with that big pile of shit, it's beyond criminal. I literally had a call today about a relative who died after waiting 5 hours for a cat 1 call out. He died after 5 hours from a heart attack, ambulance rocked up in the ninth hour despite many calls to cancel it.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 16:18

@BattenbergdowntheHatches

If someone is repeatedly calling an ambulance, then they are highly likely to have some degree of a mental health issue

Not necessarily. Some people are just so stupid they don’t know what an emergency.

The person who mugs your granny and nicks her pension for drugs probably also has a “mental health issue” but it doesn’t stop them being punished.

I’ve had GAD and depression most of my adult life so I’m not belittling it. But every Tucker and his dog blames MH for everything these days, so unless you’re willing to lock up 90% of the population, and pay 100% of your net salary to the Ambo service, stupid twats are still going to ring ambulances when they don’t need one.

It clearly is some form of mental health issue or distress - because calling an ambulance multiple times a day or week is hardly a fun pastime. Quite the opposite. There's going to be some mental or social care need. (I'm not talking about general anxiety - except perhaps a very severe form - possibly panic attacks).

Excellent post by sazza76. We need to invest in properly funded and run mental health care and social services.

EgonSpengler2020 · 18/02/2022 16:10

Your trust should have a frequent callers policy and an APP who deals with this group of service users.

The idea of the policy is to look into the reasons for the frequent calls (genuine or otherwise) which can be chronic illness, social needs, mental health/substance abuse and then work with the patient and/or their carers to find a more appropriate way to deal with their situation and to put in place services/equipment to facilitate this.

On occasions this will involve liaising with the police and very rarely might result in an ASBO, and then even rarer with a prison sentence for breech of asbo.

Your trust also presumably has a clinical desk manned by paramedics, nurses and APs who can "no send" to calls. So the days of everyone who calls getting an ambulance are long gone.

rwalker · 18/02/2022 16:07

There was a thread on here woman ranting about hours and hours wait for ambulance .
She did have a medical need for hospital she said she rung numerous times chasing then on the last call said she told them not to bother and her husband drove her in .
Why didn't he take her in the 1st place and he was there with her all the time

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 16:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ISpyCobraKai · 18/02/2022 15:52

@AlternativePerspective

Why must every unreasonable behaviour always be attributed to “mental health issues”? Obviously some people have MH issues, but are we not allowed to acknowledge that there are some thoughtless twats out there who really do waste the time of the emergency services?

People don’t want to believe it happens because they themselves wouldn’t do it. But it really does. And people know they can get away with it because others will justify it on the basis they “obviously are suffering with MH issues.”

MH is becoming too much of a get-out for twattish and unacceptable behaviour these days, and that means those with genuine MH issues are far less likely to be taken seriously.

I've been taken to hospital with brittle asthma and they tried to dismiss me with mental health issues. No word of a lie, a paramedic told the A&E staff that I just had agoraphobia. I'd never met him before, and I was kept in hospital on oxygen mainly for 16 days with my, diagnosed for 8 years brittle asthma. The A&E staff were furious when they realised what he'd said could have cost me my life.
MajorCarolDanvers · 18/02/2022 15:48

I get your frustration but I'm glad you are not in charge of dispatch because people don't deserve to die.

YouMuckyDuck · 18/02/2022 15:48

Just out of interest how would you boycott them?
Blacklist the address? People move
By their name?
Condition?
I'm curious

sazza76 · 18/02/2022 15:44

OP, what type of job do you do for the ambulance trust?

If someone is repeatedly calling an ambulance, then they are highly likely to have some degree of a mental health issue. I find it very sad that both the ambulance service and police service seem to spend a lot of time responding to people who should be being supported by mental health services or social services. These poor individuals who go round in circles in need of help and the front line workers who must feel frustrated at the situation, then of course there’s those in genuine need of an ambulance who have to wait in pain, fear and the impact that wait has on them. I really believe that our country would be very different if it had decent mental health care and social services. In the short term, there’s no easy answer but they can’t not attend to people who call.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 15:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Redroceritsover · 18/02/2022 15:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

VladmirsPoutine · 18/02/2022 15:41

Really? When I've thankfully rarely had to call an ambulance I was asked many questions - enough to decipher that it wasn't a paper cut and more that someone was clutching their chest / full on cardiac arrest. Who's calling the police though? I wouldn't even acknowledge one on the street let alone call them of my own volition Confused

XenoBitch · 18/02/2022 15:39

[quote BattenbergdowntheHatches]@Balcmange my good friend was a paramedic and the number of nuisance patients was the main reason why she isn’t any more. The ridiculousness and entitlement of the public drained her of compassion and she left after burnout. Before that, she had her own way of dealing with “frequent flyers”.

The woman who regularly feigned unconsciousness after fighting with her boyfriend got a precautionary cannula in the largest available size.

The drunks got their T-shirts necks pulled out just as they threw up so it went all over them. She used to tie their shoelaces together after they passed out.

She left after a week in which she retrieved her former teacher’s severed head from a field after a bike crash, had to wait a almost a whole shift for a morbidly obese man to be lifted out of his flat window using specialist equipment, and was then delayed getting to a gang-related stabbing in which a young teenage boy died while she was looking after him.

These people are human - and I couldn’t do the job. HCP’s aren’t saints but there is a horrible minority of the public who are basically illiterate, thoughtless twats.[/quote]
Well, I am glad your friend is no longer a paramedic if she was dealing with frequent flyers in such a way. Disgusting behaviour.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 15:34

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

AlternativePerspective · 18/02/2022 15:32

Why must every unreasonable behaviour always be attributed to “mental health issues”? Obviously some people have MH issues, but are we not allowed to acknowledge that there are some thoughtless twats out there who really do waste the time of the emergency services?

People don’t want to believe it happens because they themselves wouldn’t do it. But it really does. And people know they can get away with it because others will justify it on the basis they “obviously are suffering with MH issues.”

MH is becoming too much of a get-out for twattish and unacceptable behaviour these days, and that means those with genuine MH issues are far less likely to be taken seriously.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 15:29

Repeat nuisance callers get their numbers blocked.
That is a thing that happens.

Not being taken to hospital doesn't mean not requiring urgent medical attention.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 15:26

The woman who regularly feigned unconsciousness after fighting with her boyfriend got a precautionary cannula in the largest available size.

That could be a situation of domestic abuse. The victim doesn't explicitly ask for help out of fear or misplaced sense of shame. Calling for medical attention is their way of reaching out. It's not uncommon.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 15:21

@WheelieBinPrincess

They do not always send one in my experience, I had a pulmonary embolism and they didn’t send! Said I sounded very calm and to go to the GP. I took a taxi. I complained about that but they weren’t bothered, said they don’t sweats get it right 🤷🏻‍♀️
Sorry that happened to you.

An old colleague experienced similar for a different equally serious condition a few years ago. 111, and later 999, dismissed it as a panic attack.

BattenbergdowntheHatches · 18/02/2022 15:21

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ISpyCobraKai · 18/02/2022 15:18

@Lampshade7

I work for one of the ambulance trusts. We have many, many people who phone up several times a day wanting ambulances. They are sent out but never need them. Obviously this is a vast waste of resources and time. If I had my way I would not send an ambulance no matter what the reason. One of my colleagues was horrified by this and said that they should be sent just in case. I think stuff them, you can cry wolf once too often. IABU?
Really? Every time I've needed an ambulance, either me, or the person calling for me have had to answer so many questions to make sure it's needed. I have brittle asthma btw so definitely not just demanding one, and every time I've been kept in hospital, and often taken straight to resus.