Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Misuse of ambulances

117 replies

Lampshade7 · 18/02/2022 11:59

I work for one of the ambulance trusts. We have many, many people who phone up several times a day wanting ambulances. They are sent out but never need them. Obviously this is a vast waste of resources and time. If I had my way I would not send an ambulance no matter what the reason. One of my colleagues was horrified by this and said that they should be sent just in case. I think stuff them, you can cry wolf once too often. IABU?

OP posts:
LifesABotch · 18/02/2022 20:48

[quote BattenbergdowntheHatches]@Balcmange my good friend was a paramedic and the number of nuisance patients was the main reason why she isn’t any more. The ridiculousness and entitlement of the public drained her of compassion and she left after burnout. Before that, she had her own way of dealing with “frequent flyers”.

The woman who regularly feigned unconsciousness after fighting with her boyfriend got a precautionary cannula in the largest available size.

The drunks got their T-shirts necks pulled out just as they threw up so it went all over them. She used to tie their shoelaces together after they passed out.

She left after a week in which she retrieved her former teacher’s severed head from a field after a bike crash, had to wait a almost a whole shift for a morbidly obese man to be lifted out of his flat window using specialist equipment, and was then delayed getting to a gang-related stabbing in which a young teenage boy died while she was looking after him.

These people are human - and I couldn’t do the job. HCP’s aren’t saints but there is a horrible minority of the public who are basically illiterate, thoughtless twats.[/quote]
Bloody hell, I hope this is not true! Anyone incapable of treating all patients with dignity and respect should not be in the health service. Shame on your friend Sad

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 20:47

And this was a brilliant brainwave - very encouraging for everybody involved:

www.england.nhs.uk/2018/05/paramedics-brainwave-eases-ae-pressures-by-keeping-frequent-callers-away/

LifesABotch · 18/02/2022 20:39

YABU, blatantly.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 20:38

The South West Ambulance Service seem to have their heads screwed on in this regard:

www.swast.nhs.uk/welcome/hcps/frequent-callers-1

This woman called 97 times on Christmas Day - sometimes on two phones at the same time:

www.emas.nhs.uk/news/latest-news/2018-news/woman-told-to-pay-2000-after-calling-999-almost-100-times-on-christmas-day/

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 20:26

Wow, is that 4-5% of ALL ambulance use across the whole of Wales? Divided by 10, that's very nearly one call every day of the year - so the person at number 1 in the list almost certainly calls multiple times, every single day.

Considering that ambulances are intended for emergency cases - a high proportion of which will mean, sadly, that the patient will already be too ill to survive, in spite of the very best efforts of the paramedics and the hospital.... it does rather statistically suggest that they weren't genuine calls: I highly, highly doubt that, across the ambulance service as a whole, out of any random 365 admissions to hospital following an ambulance call-outs, every patient would survive.

It sounds like each trust needs a dedicated section to deal with these people and give them the help (or prosecute them if merited) that they need. When I worked in accounts, we had a general helpline number for about 99% of clients, but a separate team who looked after the rest - only 1% of the clients, but representing maybe 40% of all the business turnover.

If very frequent clients of Social Services have their own named case lead/contact to deal with their ongoing situation in an appropriate way, why shouldn't it be the same with constant ambulance-requesters?

The whole idea of 999 is that any one person will call them out very infrequently (if ever at all) - maybe moderately, depending on their personal circumstances; but the nature of a proper emergency is that they should be rare in any one person's life. Nobody has multiple genuine emergencies every single day of their life - if they believe that they do, they really need a dedicated case worker, who can refer them to the NHS help that they likely do need or, of course, send an ambulance if it is actually needed. It must be far cheaper and more helpful in the long run.

It's got to be a massive red flag that something isn't working properly when the most frequently-called number on a person's 'friends and family' list turns out to be the emergency services.

Teenylittlefella · 18/02/2022 19:36

I would now only use an ambulance for a situation where I did not dare move the patient. I might call one for a suspected heart attack but unless they could assure me they'd be there in 10 mins I would drive the person to hospital.

One issue is our hospital A and E has no parking immediately outside. You have to park in a multistory car park and walk 3-5 min. Not bad for standard appointments, but impossible with a person having a heart attack or a big child who can't walk. Once years ago I took a child to A and E and there was no parking available. I had to drive to another hospital. Fortunately we live in a large town with two hospitals. I often thought that he could in theory have died because of that lack of parking.

One of my kids developed bleeding from the nose and mouth and a petechial rash when we were staying in the middle of nowhere on a holiday. I drove him to hospital 45 mins rather than even attempt to wait for an ambulance. Once there we were seen at triage within 2 min and by a consultant in a private bay within 5 min. He had IV antibiotics running 15 min after we arrived at hospital. I think had I called an ambulance we would have waited several hours.

EgonSpengler2020 · 18/02/2022 19:08

I think the people complaining about GPs and other similar issues on this thread, are discussing a different issue all together and not understanding the meaning of what is considered a "frequent caller" within the ambulance service. This quote should give it some perspective.

"In 2017, the "top 10" most prolific callers accounted for 3,284 calls to the Welsh Ambulance Service...

...These types of calls account for between 4% and 5% of the service's 999 call volume each month."

Ethelily · 18/02/2022 18:54

@EgonSpengler2020

Your trust should have a frequent callers policy and an APP who deals with this group of service users.

The idea of the policy is to look into the reasons for the frequent calls (genuine or otherwise) which can be chronic illness, social needs, mental health/substance abuse and then work with the patient and/or their carers to find a more appropriate way to deal with their situation and to put in place services/equipment to facilitate this.

On occasions this will involve liaising with the police and very rarely might result in an ASBO, and then even rarer with a prison sentence for breech of asbo.

Your trust also presumably has a clinical desk manned by paramedics, nurses and APs who can "no send" to calls. So the days of everyone who calls getting an ambulance are long gone.

This.

My previous trust also had a policy of 3 attendances in 24 hours that were deemed unnecessary and they would not dispatch another ambulance for further calls for the next 24 hours.

There are numerous reasons why regular callers regularly call - these need evaluating on an individual basis and the cause of their dependence on the ambulance service needs mitigating, whether that be referral to additional services, education on appropriate access to healthcare or going down the criminal route.

It is completely unacceptable to adopt a blanket approach to any regular caller and demonstrates a real lack of understanding from you as a clinician. As annoying as it is, you need to be referring them through the correct pathway your trust advocates. Speak to a manager or clinician team lead if you have particular concerns and see what can be done about it.

Cheekypeach · 18/02/2022 18:33

@drpet49

If people were charged a nominal fee it would soon cut out the time wasters
I agree. Privatising the NHS is the only way to go sadly.
Cheekypeach · 18/02/2022 18:32

I agree OP. If you keep abusing a service you can’t be surprised to have it withdrawn. I see no reason why others should suffer (in real life or death situations) in order to pander to the unreasonable whims of others who clearly don’t give a shit.

TooManyPJs · 18/02/2022 18:28

I don't believe this for a second. 999 call handlers don't just send out ambulances to everyone who phones. They are trained to triage the calls.

makingmiracles · 18/02/2022 18:28

Hopefully given how stretched the ambulance service/nhs is, these people that do this will be left waiting 6hrs etc whilst genuine calls are prioritised. I do think after x amount of false call outs they should be referred to mental health team and calls redirected to them to assess instead. Absolute gross waste of money sending ambulances out to the type of people that do this, even if they made a specific job opening in mental health for an outreach worker, it’s got to be cheaper than sending ambulances each time.
I’ve watched ambulance programs and some times almost the whole programme is them going out to unneeded visits, some times multiple times a day to the same person!

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 18:21

I know the staff always say “that’s what we are here for” or “you did the right thing calling us” … I do sometimes think they should also be educating people about what an ambulance is / isn’t for.

My DB was a paramedic.
He's incredibly good at educating people in this way but he's very good with words and I think it's a difficult thing to get across to people who are a bit hard of thinking

Topseyt · 18/02/2022 18:19

And yes, it would also severely disadvantage poor people.

Topseyt · 18/02/2022 18:18

@drpet49

If people were charged a nominal fee it would soon cut out the time wasters
It might in many cases.

However, what if those time wasters are actually GP's Surgeries like my mother's? Sending paramedics instead of ever actually seeing their patients at all, either in the surgery or on a home visit.

Perhaps it would force them to return to seeing patients face to face again, as they should be doing anyway.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 18:18

@drpet49

If people were charged a nominal fee it would soon cut out the time wasters
And the poor.
drpet49 · 18/02/2022 18:11

If people were charged a nominal fee it would soon cut out the time wasters

Topseyt · 18/02/2022 18:07

Plenty of cases where people could get themselves to a hospital, or a GP visit is more appropriate

Some GPs themselves don't help the situation. My mother's surgery (crap at the best of times) upped the drawbridges at the start of the pandemic and have still not lowered them again. No face to face still, only phone calls if you are lucky. Nor do they make home visits. If they think someone needs to be seen for any reason at all they send paramedics, who usually arrive in an emergency ambulance - thus tying up resources that are probably needed elsewhere. This has happened several times to my parents, and a lot of the time the GP could have dealt with it.

All of the GP Surgeries in the my mother's town are under the same management, so it isn't possible to change to another one. Especially as my mother is in her eighties, lives alone now and can no longer drive due to poor eyesight and other medical issues. She has no choice but to accept this.

So some GPs themselves are not helping the problem of ambulance availability, and in some cases are adding to the woes.

balalake · 18/02/2022 18:04

I think that when people call an ambulance or indeed police and are wasting time and it transpires there is not an emergency, the answer is prosecution and a court case. Not refusing to send them on the day.

bloodywhitecat · 18/02/2022 17:47

We recently waited an hour for an ambulance for my husband who had suffered a massive stroke, luckily 999 were brilliant and got me through to a call handler straight away but the wait for an out of area ambulance was awful. There will always be people who misuse the system but I am not sure that refusing to send out an ambulance is the answer.

Sarahcoggles · 18/02/2022 17:43

I think many people on MN don’t realise that there are people out there who genuinely do call ambulances because they think it’ll enhance their life in some way. They may be feeling neglected by their family, bored, rejected by their partner, hurt by their friends, or they just feel a bit insignificant and pointless. Having an ambulance with trained paramedics arriving makes them feel special, and it makes their loved ones sit up and notice. The drama makes them feel better. These people don’t have mental health problems. They just have rather pathetic lives. It’s all very sad, but it doesn’t warrant taking an ambulance from a genuine emergency.

Sarahcoggles · 18/02/2022 17:35

@BattenbergdowntheHatches

It clearly is some form of mental health issue or distress - because calling an ambulance multiple times a day or week is hardly a fun pastime

You’d think not wouldn’t you? But it often is nothing more than laziness, inability to comprehend danger, need for drama due to boredom/shit life syndrome or self-righteous anger because they can’t see a GP/get what they want from a GP.

Until being thick as mince and/or a selfish tosspot is declared a MH condition, and all sufferers are locked up, there will still be unnecessary callouts.

Absolutely!
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/02/2022 17:23

People who “check in” on SM at A&E will be first up against the wall come the Battenberg revolution. Followed by the “u okay hun” crew.

I'm loving the sound of the Battenberg revolution!!

I agree that the “u okay hun” crew only serve to enable and encourage the drama llamas. Maybe if, instead of faux concern, they all instantly responded with a stoic, resigned "Well, we all gotta die sometime, babes - and you've already had a better innings than some get", they might stop doing it Grin

LIZS · 18/02/2022 17:20

With gp services and ooh access more restricted people may delay seeking treatment until they feel more acutely ill. Ambulance also highlighted inadequacies of mh provision which created a cycle of repeated call outs and lack of intervention. Not everyone has transport or relatives they can use to get themselves to hospital .

ExtraOnion · 18/02/2022 17:11

I watch the “Ambulance” programme (which I know is TV) .. and there us often a bit of side-eye around why people are calling ambulances.

Plenty of cases where people could get themselves to a hospital, or a GP visit is more appropriate, or it’s something that isn’t really medically related.

I know the staff always say “that’s what we are here for” or “you did the right thing calling us” … I do sometimes think they should also be educating people about what an ambulance is / isn’t for.

It does feel like people have lost the ability to do minor first aid, or use the pharmacist - it’s like the ambulance is the first point if call, rather than the last.

Part of the problem (well quite a lot), is the lack of decent, local, “out of hours” care (I should also have said properly funded)

The big emergencies get lost in a sea of minor calls …