Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not sell my old flat?

492 replies

baconroll12 · 18/02/2022 10:41

12 years ago when I was single I bought a gorgeous old 2 bedroom flat that was a bit rundown in a not so nice area. I flatshared with my best friend (lets call her Becca) for most of the time I lived there and we tried our hand at some DIY/restoration and had the place looking incredible.

My DP and I bought a house 3 years ago and before that he lived with his parents. We're not married and we have a joint bank account that all bills come out of with our own separate savings and current accounts.

Becca and her DH split a few years ago in pretty awful circumstances and her and my goddaughter (4) moved back into my flat. The rent is the same as it was when we lived together.

My DP has become quite fixated on this flat. The run down area has now been fully gentrified and is one of the top places to live in the area. He told me that the going rate for rent is now 5 x what Becca pays. He's also looked into recently sold prices and told me what 'we' could do with the money if I sold the flat now. DP has a lot of excellent qualities but he is extremely greedy when it comes to money.

It's become a really touchy subject for us and he keeps saying that I want to keep the flat because it reminds me of my 'wild single days' and that I'm not fully committed to the relationship until I let go of the flat.

YABU- sell the flat
YANBU- keep the flat as you'll need it when you leave him (said in slight jest)

OP posts:
sillysmiles · 18/02/2022 17:01

@Everanewbie
but I think most people would bang their head against a wall at a partner who's loyalty to their friend is doing the household out of thousands each year by not seeking market rate on the rent

I suppose it depends on how much you value your friends. The OP has made it clear that supporting her friend is important to her and they aren't desperate for the money.

theleafandnotthetree · 18/02/2022 17:00

You are being very unreasonable to be in a relationship with someone who aspires to have a conservatory.Confused What is he, 80?

Everanewbie · 18/02/2022 16:59

TravellingFrom well 3 years is the deadline to reclaim it. So too late now I suppose, but not 3 or 4 months ago

LittleOwl153 · 18/02/2022 16:54

This

The only, and only way I'd consider raising the rent would be if your friend is claiming housing benefit and your rent is below the rate the LHA, which would therefore be saving the state money but not your friend, or if you can see the flat needing work in thr next couple of years (eg new boiler, kitchen/bathroom refresh) and you wanted to create a fund to do that.

I'd be saying to him that if you sell the flat you will be paying off YOUR SHARE of the mortgage with the proceeds not paying for home improvements as you would want to maintain the value of the asset. That means it acutally only makes sense if your share of the mortgage interest is greater than the net income of the flat (including price gain).

TravellingFrom · 18/02/2022 16:47

@Everanewbie

Although this flat apparently has nothing to do with DP, did your ownership mean him paying 50% of second stamp duty on your joint property? If so, it has everything to do with him.
Even if they had paid for the stamp duty together, it’s a bit late 3 years later to have an issue with it and proclaim he has a say in what to do with the flat.

If he had an issue with it, he should have brought that up at the time (that is if the OP hadn’t been paying it anyway….)

TravellingFrom · 18/02/2022 16:45

I think most people would bang their head against a wall at a partner who's loyalty to their friend is doing the household out of thousands each year by not seeking market rate on the rent.

Why would it be an issue if it doesn’t stop them from doing the stuff they want - the stuff the have IN COMMON? She is taking any money out of the HOUSEHOLD money. She is ‘taking money out’ her own pocket. So what?

As it stands the OP isn’t fussed about the home improvement. She doesn’t have to agree to them.
Her DP is also not willing to put his share if the money - expecting the OP to pay for it on the sale. Which is crazy because a conservatory is a few thousands pounds, maybe £10k. And a flat is much much more money that, esp in a sought after area.
What is the DP expecting her to do with the rest if the money I wonder…

legalquestion1234 · 18/02/2022 16:43

The people arguing on DP's side - you don't seem to be getting them Becca and her daughter as clearly OP's family. Especially if you don't have kids yourself, you can become like a second mother in your friend's kids lives. A friend of mine had a relationship like this with her friend's mum and it's an incredibly special (and lucky) thing for both of them to have.

TravellingFrom · 18/02/2022 16:40

@Everanewbie why would you be annoyed as this is not your money and you don’t share that money with your DP?

If the OP had been married, then faut enough, but in that situation? The OP can do whatever she wants, including giving thousands of pounds to a charity, a friend or the Tory party if she wants to. Nothing to do with her DP.

lockdownalli · 18/02/2022 16:40

YANBU - definitely don't marry him even if he asks!! He would then have a right to some share of the flat if you split.

I would tell him it's none of his business and you never intend to sell the flat. 50/50 contribution to home improvements is fair.

NoSquirrels · 18/02/2022 16:40

They have separate finances.

If OP wants to ‘give away’ (although I wouldn’t see it like this at all!) any amount of her own money it’s of no business of her DP.

MargotEmin · 18/02/2022 16:37

she's effectively giving her friend £3,600pa.

She's really really not Hmm

IntermittentParps · 18/02/2022 16:35

@Blossomtoes

I'm not sure its a fallacy. If the tenant is paying £500pm and its actually worth £800pm, she's effectively giving her friend £3,600pa.If I was DP, I would be very annoyed at that, knowing that being generous to a friend is ranking above our present and future prosperity as a couple.

It is a fallacy because that £3,6k would still be OP’s money, not his.

Well yes, this, although that's not what I meant.
Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 16:28

I'm not sure its a fallacy. If the tenant is paying £500pm and its actually worth £800pm, she's effectively giving her friend £3,600pa.If I was DP, I would be very annoyed at that, knowing that being generous to a friend is ranking above our present and future prosperity as a couple.

It is a fallacy because that £3,6k would still be OP’s money, not his.

LolaSmiles · 18/02/2022 16:27

I find it very telling that he’s never suggested using any of his savings for the 'home improvements' he's proposing. You selling your flat to fund it while his savings remain untouched effectively transfers half of what you spend to him. Greedy, indeedsad. And not a little bit sly
I was thinking the same thing.
It's convenient how often chancers and grabby types seem awfully keen to spend other people's money.

Everanewbie · 18/02/2022 16:26

@IntermittentParps

I think most people would bang their head against a wall at a partner who's loyalty to their friend is doing the household out of thousands each year by not seeking market rate on the rent.

It's not 'doing the household out of thousands' Confused; that's a fallacy. The OP is choosing not to maximise the rent on her flat, sure, but that's not the same thing at all.
It'd be different if the rental raise or sale of the flat could dig the OP and her DP out of a serious financial hole or raise them out of poverty or whatever, but I don't think that's the case.

I'm not sure its a fallacy. If the tenant is paying £500pm and its actually worth £800pm, she's effectively giving her friend £3,600pa.

If I was DP, I would be very annoyed at that, knowing that being generous to a friend is ranking above our present and future prosperity as a couple.

I am concerned over his motives for trying to get it sold though. There is a bit of a hint of use your asset, not mine to fund the improvements.

GlitteriestFluff · 18/02/2022 16:17

As you can see on this thread, there are those who believe money is king (all the 'meet him half way/he's got a point' types), and those who believe it is of secondary value to other things.

Your DP is of the first type, you are of the second.

This is a huge difference in basic values - not one I'd be arsed to put up with, but it's your choice.

You will find this difference in values keeps on coming up in your relationship with him, over and over in different ways. Which is why I'd sack it off now.

IntermittentParps · 18/02/2022 16:16

I think most people would bang their head against a wall at a partner who's loyalty to their friend is doing the household out of thousands each year by not seeking market rate on the rent.

It's not 'doing the household out of thousands' Confused; that's a fallacy. The OP is choosing not to maximise the rent on her flat, sure, but that's not the same thing at all.
It'd be different if the rental raise or sale of the flat could dig the OP and her DP out of a serious financial hole or raise them out of poverty or whatever, but I don't think that's the case.

WhereYouLeftIt · 18/02/2022 16:15

OP, I've just gathered here the points from your posts which jumped out at me, re-ordered.

"DP has a lot of excellent qualities but he is extremely greedy when it comes to money."

"He has some savings but they're none of my business."

"It’s me that has said in this thread that his savings are none of my business, he hasn’t said it to me."

"He wants the money [from the sale of your flat] to make home improvements but with the view that it’ll make our property worth more. And he’s never suggested using any of his savings for this."

"I very much feel the goal is to add value on to the property rather than him actually having much interest in a conservatory."

"I'm not particularly interested in the home improvements he wants to make but I'm willing to contribute. 50:50 would be manageable."

"I very much feel the goal is to add value on to the property rather than him actually having much interest in a conservatory."

I find it very telling that he’s never suggested using any of his savings for the 'home improvements' he's proposing. You selling your flat to fund it while his savings remain untouched effectively transfers half of what you spend to him. Greedy, indeedSad. And not a little bit sly.

"He’s not mean with money in general but he is greedy. He will spend but always has his eye on the next thing."

"He's not typically stingy with things like gifts/holidays but he talks a lot about what he perceives other people to have and seems quite jealous."

And he perceives your friend Becca has something he wants. That makes him jealous. And covetous. And he wants it taken away from Becca and given to him, disguised as 'home improvements' that you (nor he!) actually want.

I wonder what is more important to him - taking it away from Becca, or having it himself?

"It's become a really touchy subject for us and he keeps saying that I want to keep the flat because it reminds me of my 'wild single days' and that I'm not fully committed to the relationship until I let go of the flat."

And this is where I would read him the Riot Act. The reason you want to keep the flat are nothing of the sort - and he knows it. He's just trying to find a button to press that will make you give him your money, and to hell with your friend and her daughter. Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!

I despise manipulation.

I would throw his accusations back in his face, and question his commitment to you, that he'd rather syphon money out of you and into his pockets than see you happy knowing that Becca and her daughter are well-housed. Is what YOU want so much less important than him getting his hands on your money whilst his savings stay locked away in his sole account?

His many excellent qualities are at risk of being eclipsed by his extreme greed. If they haven't been already.

peboh · 18/02/2022 16:07

Yanbu. He's completely overstepping the mark here. It's your property! If you wanted your friend to stay there rent free, it's still not his business. Having a property that you let out is a brilliant financial choice if you can afford it! I would also consider the longevity of this relationship if he's already trying to get his hands into everything you own.

NoSquirrels · 18/02/2022 16:03

[quote baconroll12]@Auntycorruption I'm not particularly interested in the home improvements he wants to make but I'm willing to contribute. 50:50 would be manageable.

I very much feel the goal is to add value on to the property rather than him actually having much interest in a conservatory.[/quote]
Conservatorys are shit.

Personally I think they devalue a property!

MargosKaftan · 18/02/2022 16:03

The only, and only way I'd consider raising the rent would be if your friend is claiming housing benefit and your rent is below the rate the LHA, which would therefore be saving the state money but not your friend, or if you can see the flat needing work in thr next couple of years (eg new boiler, kitchen/bathroom refresh) and you wanted to create a fund to do that.

Otherwise, keep it as it is. Its covering the mortgage, and if you can afford upkeep work out of the difference, then its costing you nothing to have a nest egg for the future.

If your friend decided to move on to a different property, you could put the rent up for a stranger tenant, but until then, providing her with security as her DD grows while also effectively buying yourself a pension plan is perfect.

I would think carefully about building a future with a greedy and selfish man. He seems to see his money as his and your assets as joint. Not good.

NurseButtercup · 18/02/2022 16:00

I have a small circle of friends I would move heaven & earth for if they needed my help, and they would do (and have done) the same for me.

I'm saying all this to outline how I agree with your stance in supporting your friend, to have a stable home is more important than the money grab, your DP and some posters on here are prioritising.

My opinion & love of my DP, would change if he was persistently pressurising me to make a decision that would leave my friend homeless & disinherit my goddaughter. I hope you're ok.

Everanewbie · 18/02/2022 16:00

I was in a similar boat. I owned a flat prior to getting together with him. A few years later we bought a house together. I let it out for 2 years. He pointed out the second stamp duty rebate we'd get on selling it, and the rent was only just exceeding the mortgage. Higher rate tax meant i hardly received anything back. Admittedly the tenant here wasn't a friend or family. We agreed to sale to use the rebate and profit towards a wedding and general savings. It was a joint decision, just as it will be when he inherits from his relative.

I saw us as a team, and still do. I trust him, and saw my asset as our asset.

I'm sorry there is this level of distrust where you feel its a battle. Me personally, if you don't trust him, retain the flat, but I think most people would bang their head against a wall at a partner who's loyalty to their friend is doing the household out of thousands each year by not seeking market rate on the rent.

crackersforcrackers · 18/02/2022 15:55

YANBU

Blahblahblah40 · 18/02/2022 15:55

YANBU. You are providing a safe home for your goddaughter until she is old enough to care for herself. When that time comes or if your friend meets another partner then you discuss upping the rent. If it’s desirable then Im sure you’d make enough on any eventual sale to offset any rent shortfall anyway. Ultimately it is up to you to decide if you sell but I’d be legally protecting every dime if you end up marrying DP!!