Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is a red flag?

86 replies

availablesizerange · 18/02/2022 10:16

Name changed for this but regular poster.

Feel very worried after a conversation with my fiancé last night. We’ve always had the same attitude towards infidelity - as in, whenever we’ve watched it on TV etc. we agree what is cheating (emotional affairs) and we’ve both always said we’d have zero tolerance if the other person did it. Never had any worries at all about him.

However, one of his best friends has just been caught cheating. He’d clearly been having an emotional affair with a woman from work for a few months before splitting with his partner. They separated on the Friday night (as in, had a conversation and decided they weren’t working well together, partly because he wasn’t putting effort in) and then on Saturday afternoon he slept with this new woman. He and his partner had been together for 11 years, own a home together etc. so were obviously still living together. My fiancé is really relaxed about this. Last night we were discussing it and he said he doesn’t really think his mate has done anything wrong.

AIBU to feel like this is a red flag? It’s certainly not how I feel about the situation, and it’s not how I would want to be treated. I’m just so in my head now that he thinks this is OK and it means he’ll do the same to me.

OP posts:
LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/02/2022 13:32

Does the friends ex even know friend slept with someone else? They shouldn't know about it unless friend or others are stiring.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 13:28

The emotional affair is cheating.

The sex was disrespectful and you'd probably feel like the relationship wasn't what you thought it was but it's not cheating.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/02/2022 13:27

I thimk I must be missing something, the friend ended the relationship before sleeping with the woman he had been talking to? Surely thats the right way to do it?

Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 13:26

But how can he be cheating if he sleeps with someone AFTER finishing the relationship?

Emotional affair - yes cheating
Sleeping with someone after moving out and ending it - not cheating

availablesizerange · 18/02/2022 13:25

@Toanewstart23 Both.

OP posts:
Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 13:24

* I guess for me if my fiancé did that to me I would consider that cheating. And that’s what I can’t get past. *

Did WHAT?

Emotional affair
Or
Sleep with someone after ending the relationship?

Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 13:22

For me

Relaxed about an Emotional affair - red flag
Relaxed about sleeping with someone else within 24 hours of relationship ending - NOT a red flag

Is one or both for you OP?

availablesizerange · 18/02/2022 13:21

@DillonPanthersTexas Sorry, I meant in the course of these responses I’ve realised I don’t care. I didn’t know that when I posted.

OP posts:
MelaniaFlump · 18/02/2022 13:20

I think you're being completely OTT in fretting about something your partner might hypothetically do in some imagined future based on nothing much.

Noone sets out to have an emotional affair. If you find yourself in one, the decent thing to do is stop or else end your existing relationship. The friend has done the latter- seems ok to me. Upsetting for his ex but that's break-ups.

KrisAkabusi · 18/02/2022 13:18

I guess for me if my fiancé did that to me I would consider that cheating. And that’s what I can’t get past.

But he wouldn't be your fiance any more. You would have broken up before he slept with anyone else. You wouldn't need to get past it, you're already split up! Think about it. You can't say "My ex slept with someone else after we broke up. He cheated on me!" That just doesn't make sense.

Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 13:16

It’s a red flag to YOU

Bookworm20 · 18/02/2022 13:15

I am surprised by some of these responses.

I'd be utterly dismayed if my fiance said he thought it was fine for a man to go off and sleep with another woman less than 24 hours after ending an 11 year relationship.

The guy had an emotional affair and then slept with the affair partner immediately after splitting. I find that pretty sickening to be honest. And I'd be certainly worrying about a partners reaction to that being all fine and dandy - just because the guy was then single. (barely!)
What a kick in the teeth to the guys long term partner. I mean talk about kicking someone when they are down. What a shit.

I'd see it as a red flag too. My DP is perfectly entitled to have a different opinion to me on stuff, but this sort of opinion would really floor me.

DillonPanthersTexas · 18/02/2022 13:13

I don’t really care if others think I’m being unreasonable

So why post on the AIBU boards then?Hmm

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/02/2022 13:12

I think people often have different responses to things when it’s someone they know. You’ve said it’s his best friend - I don’t find it that surprising that it skews his view and he feels like he wants to defend him.

Bbq1 · 18/02/2022 13:04

@availablesizerange

Name changed for this but regular poster.

Feel very worried after a conversation with my fiancé last night. We’ve always had the same attitude towards infidelity - as in, whenever we’ve watched it on TV etc. we agree what is cheating (emotional affairs) and we’ve both always said we’d have zero tolerance if the other person did it. Never had any worries at all about him.

However, one of his best friends has just been caught cheating. He’d clearly been having an emotional affair with a woman from work for a few months before splitting with his partner. They separated on the Friday night (as in, had a conversation and decided they weren’t working well together, partly because he wasn’t putting effort in) and then on Saturday afternoon he slept with this new woman. He and his partner had been together for 11 years, own a home together etc. so were obviously still living together. My fiancé is really relaxed about this. Last night we were discussing it and he said he doesn’t really think his mate has done anything wrong.

AIBU to feel like this is a red flag? It’s certainly not how I feel about the situation, and it’s not how I would want to be treated. I’m just so in my head now that he thinks this is OK and it means he’ll do the same to me.

Op, I think he's just siding with his mate. I personally wouldn't agree either if my dh sided with a friend like that but I guess your dh doesn't want to lose the friendship. You never truly know what goes on behind closed doors and what his marriage was like prior to the affair - clearly not happy. Me and my dh have the same values as you but I do think you're over reacting. Nowhere has your dh suddenly said he agrees with the situation and would do the same. Sticking by a friend who has done this (rightly or wrongly) doesn't make your dh more or less likely to have an affair than before.
Moretodo · 18/02/2022 13:04

He might have a lower standard for his friend.

My friends have done some stupid shit, as have I, but we will be there for each other.
Some of my friends, one in particular carries on like this, she has very low self esteem and it causes her a lot of pain.

It doesn't mean that's what your stbh would do.

I think you might be taking it personally, instead of condemning the guy (the friend) , have a conversation with stbh and say how upset you would be if you were her.
If he reassures you its secure bonjour imo.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 13:00

Can you clarify, is it the emotional affair he's saying isn't cheating, or the sex?

availablesizerange · 18/02/2022 12:51

I didn’t mean my post to be rude, I think it reads a bit like that. I’m grateful for everyone’s thoughts so far, it’s been clarifying.

OP posts:
availablesizerange · 18/02/2022 12:50

I think the responses on this thread have really clarified my reaction - I don’t really care how many of you think it’s cheating or not - that’s not my concern. I’m not marrying any of you. My concern is that I do, and I’m uncomfortable with my fiancé minimising the actions of his mate.

I need to have a further conversation with him about this to see the way forward. I don’t really care if others think I’m being unreasonable, it turns out! I just have different boundaries and I need to work out if my fiancé not sharing them is a deal breaker.

OP posts:
Sleepytimebear · 18/02/2022 12:48

I'm not quite clear which bit he is relaxed about. If it's the sex post break up, I guess technically he has done nothing wrong but it's pretty shitty behaviour when he still lives with his OH and they've had such a long relationship. If they were "on a break" then in my eyes definitely cheating and would firmly close the door on getting back together. If it's the emotional affair before then this is completely at odds with what he said he believed and what you believe, so yes I would be worried that my partner does not have the same view on cheating as me (although in these instances I generally find the person thinks its OK for them to have the emotional affair but would not be ok for their partner - little double standard!). If this was my friend I would think they had behaved really badly and disrespectfully towards their partner, irrespective of whether they were technically broken up before having sex. I don't think I am disloyal to be disappointed in my friend's behaviour and could still stand by them following this, but I don't have to think they "did nothing wrong". I wouldn't be happy with your partner's response either.

didshedidntshe · 18/02/2022 12:39

This is very Ross and Rachel.. it all depends on what was said on that Friday night, was it 'let's have some space' or was it 'we are over'. If they actually broke up, then although it's hurtful that he would sleep with someone the next day, it isn't cheating IMO

noirchatsdeux · 18/02/2022 12:23

To be honest I'm amazed his friend waited until the next evening.

I've lost count of the number of male friends/acquaintances who have told me with zero guilt that they slept with another woman the same day/evening they'd split with their girlfriend/wife.

If they'd agreed to split, it's not cheating. Still tacky as fuck, though.

Sally872 · 18/02/2022 12:12

If the friend is done with the marriage and knows no way back then I suppose it is fair enough so long as he realises it is closing the door on marriage and communicates that to wife ASAP so she isn't weighing up options.

If friend thinks he can decide in a few days "but we were on a break" then that's stupid.

Your dh probably wants to think well of friend rather than any indication that he would do the same.

Mo1911 · 18/02/2022 12:12

@availablesizerange

I guess for me if my fiancé did that to me I would consider that cheating. And that’s what I can’t get past.

I suppose my opinion is not his issue, but at the same time I just don’t know if I can go forward with someone who thinks it would be OK to sleep with someone not even 24 hours after we decided to reevaluate our relationship. I also don’t think he’d say it was fine if I did that to him/if his mate’s ex had done that to him.

I just feel so confused. Maybe my feelings will fade over time but I don’t know how to proceed when we’re just so not in sync on this point.

I think you need to have a gentle and not accusatory conversation otherwise you're in danger of costing yourself what has been an otherwise good relationship.

Just because people excuse other people or even are just a bit defensive when they know you won't approve of their friends behaviour, does not mean anything.

Comedycook · 18/02/2022 12:07

Sorry but I think you're being very ott and are thinking in very black and white terms.

An emotional affair could creep up on someone without them even realising. They just get on as friends then feelings get a bit deeper. Life is complicated. It's easy to say in theory, that it's an awful thing to do but in practice, it's easy to see how it happens.

People, both men and women, stick up for their friends. They are also more likely to hear one side of the story.

Swipe left for the next trending thread