Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are women's worst enemies for equality?

136 replies

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 08:58

I've just got a new job at a senior level. My new secretary has emailed to work out some logistics before I start and to introduce me via cc to the rest of the secretarial/admin team. At the same level in the company are 3 men, who I'll call Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. I am replacing Mr Big.

It appears in this company the convention is to call the seniors by their surname - so throughout the email she writes of Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. However, when I am mentioned, I am Cherry rather than Ms BlossomTreee. For example 'When Mr Big leaves, Cherry will be taking over the X account. Mr Biggest will have the conference room for team meetings on Mondays and Wednesday lunchtimes, Mr Bigger will have it on Tuesday lunchtime and Cherry can choose between Thursday and Friday when she arrives - Mr Big always had it on Thursday'

Now, I would much rather my secretary called me by my first name. But when introducing me to a wider group, some of whom I will be managing, it feels incredibly undermining to use my first name if the convention is all the seniors are known by their surname.

I know from past experience if I try and adjust it so I am also known as Ms BlossomTree rather than Cherry, I will be seen as 'difficult' and it will make my working relationships harder, and since I will partly be working remotely (as the others do too) this would be especially challenging. So, I will just have to suck it up, breathe deeply and once again prove that I am as good as those whose ability and seniority is instantly accepted by grace of them having a Y chromosome.

I am just so sick that in the fight for equality it often seems to be other women who do a lot of the undermining.

Anyone have any soothing words?

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 18/02/2022 09:17

Oh yes, women are most certainly FAR worse than men for being sexist arseholes.
Or maybe you need to just tackle the issue rather than make sweeping generalisations

Gowithme · 18/02/2022 09:16

To me it's all a load of corporate BS, it's why I could never work in an office. Why would senior people be called by their surname but not junior people - are they less worthy? Why would men be called by their surname and not women - are they less worthy? Why is being called by your surname even seen as more respectful - it seems so outdated - but at the same time you should have the same same rule for everyone IMO. Either everyone is referred to by surname in emails or no one is. Earning the right to be called by your surname because you are male and more senior is just pathetic IMO.

This is your secretary and I think you need to get things straight with her. Just ask her to name everyone as Mr/Mrs in her emails out - not just senior men or senior women but everyone. If being called by your surname is respectful then everyone deserves to be treated with respect. Being afraid of looking difficult is often what holds women back IMO - in that way YOU are your own worst enemy. You don't have to be difficult about it, or rude or make her feel bad, just say that's how you like it done and why (to show the same respect to all) and it's all positive IMO.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 18/02/2022 09:11

That's your female socialisation talking. If you want to be Ms Big then you need to stop pandering to others and fretting about getting a reputation as difficult.

You're ms big. Being difficult and saying harsh truths is surely part of the job description?

DiddyHeck · 18/02/2022 09:08

I know from past experience if I try and adjust it so I am also known as Ms BlossomTree rather than Cherry, I will be seen as 'difficult' and it will make my working relationships harder, and since I will partly be working remotely (as the others do too) this would be especially challenging. So, I will just have to suck it up, breathe deeply and once again prove that I am as good as those whose ability and seniority is instantly accepted by grace of them having a Y chromosome.

Having read that ^^ I'd say you are your own worst enemy when it comes to equality.

Why are you so worried about being seen as 'difficult'? I bet the men at senior level aren't worried about that sort of thing.

Just tell your secretary to refer to you in the same way as the others and stop worrying about 'how it makes you look'.

PurpleDaisies · 18/02/2022 09:08

She can call you your first name when you’re alone but refer to you as Ms blossom when introducing you to a wider group.

Just be clear to her about when to use your first name and when to use your name and title.

Pinkbonbon · 18/02/2022 09:07

Why not just point it out?

I wouldn't think you were difficult if you said 'hey, did you notice that you introduced the men woth their surnames and me by cherry? Maybe because we automatically want to make women seem more approachable. But actually it could contribute to me being taken less seriously. And we don't want that as women. So in future maybe try call me by my surname to others. I'm fine with you calling me cherry though obviously'.

backinthebox · 18/02/2022 09:07

Your secretary can call you Cherry, but you are Ms BlossomTree in emails. Let her know that is your protocol. What’s so difficult about that?

ohhooh · 18/02/2022 09:07

This is tricky - it could be that for introducing you, Cherry is being used rather than Ms BlossomTree so that people actually know your first name!

If you'd prefer them to use your first name, and that's what they've used in the email I wouldn't be too put out - I'd probably just assume Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest had been idiots previously and requested the 'Mr' title, or that the secretary is so used to using Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest in general emails to clients / externals (and presumably will use Ms BlossomTree in more formal communication going forward rather than Cherry) that she's put it in this email too.

Do you know Mr Bigger and Mr Biggests first names? I'd also wonder if she didn't want to put "Tony" and "Martin" incase you didn't know who was who?

WutheringHeights66 · 18/02/2022 09:05

Ask her why she referred to you by Cherry and not Ms Blossom Tree? it would wind me up too. She can call you Cherry in the confines of your office but you expect to be called the same as your peers in all professional situations.

She probably isn't aware of her own ingrained sexism.

saltedcaramelanything · 18/02/2022 09:04

Congratulations on the new role.

That is really frustrating. But I think I would drop an email - or Teams message - to your secretary to say you're happy for her to call you Cherry, but would appreciate if in company comms she refers to you as MsBlossomTree, as with Mr Bigger & Mr Biggest

Chestofdraws · 18/02/2022 09:03

I don’t understand she’s your secretary just say hey can you call me x. Instead of all this mad fretting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread