Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are women's worst enemies for equality?

136 replies

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 08:58

I've just got a new job at a senior level. My new secretary has emailed to work out some logistics before I start and to introduce me via cc to the rest of the secretarial/admin team. At the same level in the company are 3 men, who I'll call Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. I am replacing Mr Big.

It appears in this company the convention is to call the seniors by their surname - so throughout the email she writes of Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. However, when I am mentioned, I am Cherry rather than Ms BlossomTreee. For example 'When Mr Big leaves, Cherry will be taking over the X account. Mr Biggest will have the conference room for team meetings on Mondays and Wednesday lunchtimes, Mr Bigger will have it on Tuesday lunchtime and Cherry can choose between Thursday and Friday when she arrives - Mr Big always had it on Thursday'

Now, I would much rather my secretary called me by my first name. But when introducing me to a wider group, some of whom I will be managing, it feels incredibly undermining to use my first name if the convention is all the seniors are known by their surname.

I know from past experience if I try and adjust it so I am also known as Ms BlossomTree rather than Cherry, I will be seen as 'difficult' and it will make my working relationships harder, and since I will partly be working remotely (as the others do too) this would be especially challenging. So, I will just have to suck it up, breathe deeply and once again prove that I am as good as those whose ability and seniority is instantly accepted by grace of them having a Y chromosome.

I am just so sick that in the fight for equality it often seems to be other women who do a lot of the undermining.

Anyone have any soothing words?

OP posts:
MissTrip82 · 18/02/2022 10:10

No. Other women aren’t our biggest problem. That’s your own misogyny showing.

Ozanj · 18/02/2022 10:09

This is why many senior execs insist on hiring their own secretary / PA. I would suggest you sit down in a room with her and hash all of this out - focus on it as you learning about the organisation. It is really important you trust each other and if you don’t it might be better to start having development conversations with her to see if there’s something else she wants to try.

honeylulu · 18/02/2022 10:09

Do you think a man in this situation would think twice about challenging being referred to as "John" when others in his peer group are referred to as Mr Big etc? He definitely wouldn't be bothered about being seen as difficult - it wouldn't even occur to him.

Just tell sec firmly and politely that you are happy for her to use your first name when conversing but in emails of this nature you wish to be referred to in the same way as your colleagues. No need to apologise or justify. She may be unclear if you are Miss/Mrs/Ms/ other so use the opportunity to clarify that too.

Even if it is "difficult" sometimes we need to be difficult to challenge difficult things like endemic sexism.

Flickflak · 18/02/2022 10:08

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

NeverChange · 18/02/2022 10:03

If this is an issue, there will be more.

What us so difficult about just asking her to ask to keep naming conventions uniform in all correspondence. Spell it out that if one name is formal all need to be, and one person is first name only, then all others should be the same.

Don't start bringing feminism into it or anything else which is excessive. You want to address email standards. You can address anything else as it arises.

MorningStarling · 18/02/2022 09:58

On the wider point, yes women are their worst enemies for equality. Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted. Most men could be won over if they thought we wanted equality. That's why feminists find their progress so slow, women's rights is seen as feminism, get feminism is not about equality. You get equality through seeing people as equal.

Brefugee · 18/02/2022 09:55

my go-to for any situation is: what would a man do?

Brefugee · 18/02/2022 09:55

I get that OP, but you are a woman at director level. We need you to woman up and make it normal that we are treated the same as the men. You can cultivate a perfectly good relationship with your secretary, first name terms both ways and so on, whilst emphasising to her that you want to be deferred to in the same way as Mr Big.

She's a woman - if she doesn't get this you are going to have to spell it out. I have railed and railed against the need for women to act like the men to get into the top positions, but this is how we are going to get women up there and once we're inside, like a Trojan horse, start to change company culture from within.

DiddyHeck · 18/02/2022 09:53

[quote CherryBlossomTreee]@DiddyHeck being seen as difficult is a problem as you need your secretary to be telling you the things you need to know that others won't/don't tell you... if you offend them, they will do their job but not the 'fringe' parts that actually help you be successful in yours.[/quote]
Oh come on, just speak up like I've no doubt the senior men do.You're going to struggle in this job if you don't learn to do that. Take responsibility for how you want to be addressed and stop worrying about the ifs and buts.

Icenii · 18/02/2022 09:51

Don't emulate this culture, break it!

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 09:47

@eurochick since I prefer first names maybe you are right and I should go in and encourage everyone to call ALL the seniors by their first names - totally agree with @icenii regarding inclusive culture. And to answer the question - I'm the first female in a senior role they've ever had.

OP posts:
KatherineJaneway · 18/02/2022 09:45

Sorry but if you can't say to the person who will be your new secretary 'In future correspondence please refer to me as Ms BlossomTreee' you have far bigger issues to worry about.

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 09:44

@DiddyHeck being seen as difficult is a problem as you need your secretary to be telling you the things you need to know that others won't/don't tell you... if you offend them, they will do their job but not the 'fringe' parts that actually help you be successful in yours.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 18/02/2022 09:44

Nip it in the bud now.
Write, only to the secretary and explain how you would like to be referred to. And don't waver.

congrats on the new job

Icenii · 18/02/2022 09:43

I don't believe in using surnames for more senior people and I'd be saying, when introducing myself that I would want people to call me by my first name to create an inclusive culture. I bet there are more senior males of a certain background type and the less senior are mainly females or those from different minority groups ? What's the social mobility like in the organisation?

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 09:43

I think part of the issue is I've come from a company where everyone is first names and I am far more comfortable with that, I was just a bit surprised that if the company I'm moving to has a culture of surnames that that culture is dependent on seniority and Y chromosome possession.

I haven't yet started and will tackle this as a conversation when I start. As much as I hate a surname for seniors culture, its a big company so if that is the culture and I am known as first name I will be assumed to be more junior than I am.

It is also a very male dominated industry, so the very fact I am female makes it likely my role will be mistaken and that is before the introductions vary

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 18/02/2022 09:39

That was ingrained misogyny at work on her part, however, you’re also being your worst enemy. How do you wish to be addressed? Start from there.

TooWicked · 18/02/2022 09:38

The Mr Bigs wouldn’t care a jot about being seen as difficult and would tell the secretary to refer to them appropriately in line with how they refer to other senior staff.

So actually, you are your worst enemy here, not the ‘other women’ you’re referring to.

eurochick · 18/02/2022 09:38

@ouch321

Why on earth would you apply to work in a company where they go by surnames for certain levels of staff and by first names for the rest?

That's the problem here, not what you've written about. That's so messed up...

I agree with this. I've only worked somewhere the seniors were addressed by surname in another country and twenty years ago.

If you want to be Ms Big tell your PA. Otherwise be the breath of fresh air that brings the organisation into the 2000s.

bjjgirl · 18/02/2022 09:34

In certain sectors rank and surname is normal to address senior people and first name to address less senior.

So if I am conversing up the rank I could say mr /mrs or rank then surname and if I am addressing lower I would use first names

As the persons Pa I would refer as their rank
Along with everyone else's

ouch321 · 18/02/2022 09:25

Why on earth would you apply to work in a company where they go by surnames for certain levels of staff and by first names for the rest?

That's the problem here, not what you've written about. That's so messed up...

DiddyHeck · 18/02/2022 09:25

@Hollyhead

As a senior manager I would expect you to be able to just tell people what you want and rise above any comments. I would just tell people what I want. In fact you’ve waltzed in and behind her back are blaming a more junior woman for something you’re not prepared to tackle. I’d spend some time to reflect on how well you’re supporting the quest for equality.
This 100%
ANameChangeAgain · 18/02/2022 09:23

That's your female socialisation talking. If you want to be Ms Big then you need to stop pandering to others and fretting about getting a reputation as difficult.

You're ms big. Being difficult and saying harsh truths is surely part of the job description?

Agree wholeheartedly with this.

Congratulations BTW @CherryBlossomTreee

I hate with a passion the old school I'm Mr Big and will insist on calling my minions, usually female, by their first names. Either everyone is Mr Big, Ms Big or Mr Small, or everyone is Dave, Carol and Pete.

EatYourVegetables · 18/02/2022 09:22
  • Ask her why she referred to you by Cherry and not Ms Blossom Tree? it would wind me up too. She can call you Cherry in the confines of your office but you expect to be called the same as your peers in all professional situations.

She probably isn't aware of her own ingrained sexism.*

This.

It is sexism, not “mad fretting” as someone said. It shouldn’t be our job to correct it, but unfortunately it is. It also shouldn’t be our job to worry about the emotions of the people who have offended us, but unfortunately it is. If you reply to this gently but firmly, you could get an ally. It’s relentless.

But no, women are not our worst enemy. They’re worse than we hope for but better than men. Sorry this is happening to you.

Hollyhead · 18/02/2022 09:20

As a senior manager I would expect you to be able to just tell people what you want and rise above any comments. I would just tell people what I want. In fact you’ve waltzed in and behind her back are blaming a more junior woman for something you’re not prepared to tackle. I’d spend some time to reflect on how well you’re supporting the quest for equality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread