Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are women's worst enemies for equality?

136 replies

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 08:58

I've just got a new job at a senior level. My new secretary has emailed to work out some logistics before I start and to introduce me via cc to the rest of the secretarial/admin team. At the same level in the company are 3 men, who I'll call Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. I am replacing Mr Big.

It appears in this company the convention is to call the seniors by their surname - so throughout the email she writes of Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. However, when I am mentioned, I am Cherry rather than Ms BlossomTreee. For example 'When Mr Big leaves, Cherry will be taking over the X account. Mr Biggest will have the conference room for team meetings on Mondays and Wednesday lunchtimes, Mr Bigger will have it on Tuesday lunchtime and Cherry can choose between Thursday and Friday when she arrives - Mr Big always had it on Thursday'

Now, I would much rather my secretary called me by my first name. But when introducing me to a wider group, some of whom I will be managing, it feels incredibly undermining to use my first name if the convention is all the seniors are known by their surname.

I know from past experience if I try and adjust it so I am also known as Ms BlossomTree rather than Cherry, I will be seen as 'difficult' and it will make my working relationships harder, and since I will partly be working remotely (as the others do too) this would be especially challenging. So, I will just have to suck it up, breathe deeply and once again prove that I am as good as those whose ability and seniority is instantly accepted by grace of them having a Y chromosome.

I am just so sick that in the fight for equality it often seems to be other women who do a lot of the undermining.

Anyone have any soothing words?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 18/02/2022 11:29

I agree with this. I've only worked somewhere the seniors were addressed by surname in another country and twenty years ago.

Same here. I can't imagine what kind of organisation still does this.

If you want to be Ms Big tell your PA. Otherwise be the breath of fresh air that brings the organisation into the 2000s.

Exactly. If you want it, just ask. Only your own internalised sexism is stopping you.

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 11:18

@nothappytobeheretoday thats a nice way of phrasing it.
And yes,her title is secretary - her email footer is 'Secretary to Mr Big'. Her actual role however is clearly so much more - masses of coordination and generally keeping everything running.

OP posts:
nothappytobeheretoday · 18/02/2022 11:13

Since she seems efficient, friendly and helpful in all other respects, perhaps you could speak to her in a kind and friendly way about it?

So just sit down with tea/coffee at your weekly catch up or what ever and just say "I noticed this in the email you sent - a tiny thing but I've come up against a lot of sexism in my career and these little things can build up." She will probably apologise profusely - tell her not to worry about it ("it is so commonplace in our society") but that you want to be seen on the same working plane as the men. Maybe ask her if she's come up against anything similar?

On the other hand, there are probably a few things you have done to her that have made her feel "less than" in her role. Is her actual title "secretary"?

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 11:11

@Chimchiminie that is a fair point; I do subconsciously hold women to a higher standard.

@girlmom21 you are probably right, but I'd assume they refer to each other by first names in meetings too (when I've met them they've used first names when talking to each other)

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 11:02

@Notimeforaname

Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted

Do you honestly believe this?

What an absolutely insane statement. If only someone had told me that 50 years ago when my feminist journey began.
girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 11:00

Just another thought: it might be that Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest have only spoken about you in high level meetings so have only referred to you as Cherry so she hadn't even thought about it.

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 10:58

@brefugee - thank you for your insights. This is of course what in reality I will do - go in, get on with it and then try and make it more inclusive. This is how I have successfully become a senior in a male-dominated industry thus far. I guess I had just hoped there would become a point where it was less of an issue (haha)

I think I was also disappointed that the secretary - who seems hyper efficient, friendly and helpful - couldn't see the glaring inconsistency in her email.

I am also unsure if Mr Big wished to stay (this is a permanent role replacing a temporary one) so posters who noted the secretary may be loyal to him and be aggreived he is not staying could be correct, so perhaps I am entirely wrong in assuming this is anything to do with me being female.

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 18/02/2022 10:56

Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted

Do you honestly believe this?

Chimchiminie · 18/02/2022 10:52

I think YABU by singling out women for attention here. Unconscious sexism / discrimination is hardly limited to other women. And although annoying that anyone might address you and your make colleagues differently, there’s no reason why females should be held to a higher standard than males. The fact that she’s a woman is irrelevant here.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 18/02/2022 10:47

On the wider point, yes women are their worst enemies for equality. Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted.

Really? Confused

emzz8 · 18/02/2022 10:46

Oh OP. It would really piss me off !!!
Little cheeky cow

Notimeforaname · 18/02/2022 10:44

Just tell them all how you'd like to be addressed?

If you like being called by your first name, grand. Leave it at that.

If you don't, just say it to everyone. Its literally that simple.

maybe you are right and I should go in and encourage everyone to call ALL the seniors by their first names

I hope this was sarcasm

Brefugee · 18/02/2022 10:40

Right now OP can: carry on being the only one in senior management being referred to by everyone by firstname with the contempt that familiarity brings
or she can go in there and see how it goes for a month or two and then start to address it?

Someone coming into a company and shouting the odds from Day 1, is getting nowhere fast, with peers or subordinates. We don't like it but you have to play the game for a while to get the lie of the land and learn the moves. Then start the change.

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 10:37

I really don’t understand why you’d want to collude with and perpetuate such an outdated working culture. I thought the ridiculous use of titles in the workplace had bitten the dust a long time ago. It certainly hasn’t been used anywhere I’ve worked in the last 35 years.

Be the voice of innovation and change and bring the archaic culture into the 21st century.

Chasingaftermidnight · 18/02/2022 10:37

@MorningStarling

On the wider point, yes women are their worst enemies for equality. Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted. Most men could be won over if they thought we wanted equality. That's why feminists find their progress so slow, women's rights is seen as feminism, get feminism is not about equality. You get equality through seeing people as equal.
Wrong. But spouting that crap is a good way to get male approval, if you need it.
Chasingaftermidnight · 18/02/2022 10:29

@ANameChangeAgain

That's your female socialisation talking. If you want to be Ms Big then you need to stop pandering to others and fretting about getting a reputation as difficult.

You're ms big. Being difficult and saying harsh truths is surely part of the job description?

Agree wholeheartedly with this.

Congratulations BTW @CherryBlossomTreee

I hate with a passion the old school I'm Mr Big and will insist on calling my minions, usually female, by their first names. Either everyone is Mr Big, Ms Big or Mr Small, or everyone is Dave, Carol and Pete.

Exactly - I hate it and it’s extremely patriarchal. As you say the seniors are almost always male and the minions are almost always female.

OP, I think directing your anger at the actions of a junior woman in what is clearly a highly patriarchal organisation is completely misunderstanding workplace sexism and equality.

Hillarious · 18/02/2022 10:21

A PA is a very precious person, in every sense of the word!

WouldIBeATwat · 18/02/2022 10:20

@Gowithme

To me it's all a load of corporate BS, it's why I could never work in an office. Why would senior people be called by their surname but not junior people - are they less worthy? Why would men be called by their surname and not women - are they less worthy? Why is being called by your surname even seen as more respectful - it seems so outdated - but at the same time you should have the same same rule for everyone IMO. Either everyone is referred to by surname in emails or no one is. Earning the right to be called by your surname because you are male and more senior is just pathetic IMO.

This is your secretary and I think you need to get things straight with her. Just ask her to name everyone as Mr/Mrs in her emails out - not just senior men or senior women but everyone. If being called by your surname is respectful then everyone deserves to be treated with respect. Being afraid of looking difficult is often what holds women back IMO - in that way YOU are your own worst enemy. You don't have to be difficult about it, or rude or make her feel bad, just say that's how you like it done and why (to show the same respect to all) and it's all positive IMO.

Mrs? Confused
Brefugee · 18/02/2022 10:19

I don't think bringing feminism into this is stupid - what a really weird attitude to a way of thinking that wants men and women to be treated equally.

I also don't think OP should barge into the first exec meeting and demand they change their culture. That would be overstepping. The best way to get change is first to get women into exec positions (so go OP!) and the second is to work out how to make the change.

Confronting a men's club head on won't end well. We know that.

As it happens in my company we have an initiative to get more women into the higher echelons. They have a two pronged (well more, but the first thing you notice are these two) strategy: headhunt from competitors, and promote from within by mentoring women and identifying those who will do well.

OP is in the first of those groups, as seen from my perspective, and for me her best bet is to get in there, go with the culture and then work out how to adapt it well so that it is a welcoming place - especially for women and other minorities - to work.

MissBPotter · 18/02/2022 10:18

I agree this is sexism op, although I’m not sure it’s your PA’s fault, maybe a wider society thing. I am a teacher and my ex headmaster would only allow us to refer to him as Mr Smith (not real name) and he also referred to older male teachers as Mr etc. He always referred to me with my first name and this was one reason I left, as I found the school to have a sexist culture, this was just a symptom. However, I kind of wish now I had stayed and challenged it. You’re senior so you should challenge it, unlike me!

DiddyHeck · 18/02/2022 10:15

@Ozanj

This is why many senior execs insist on hiring their own secretary / PA. I would suggest you sit down in a room with her and hash all of this out - focus on it as you learning about the organisation. It is really important you trust each other and if you don’t it might be better to start having development conversations with her to see if there’s something else she wants to try.
Talk about making a meal of it! She just needs to tell her she'd like email correspondence to be kept as standard/uniform.

No need for sitting in a room, hashing it out or seeing if she wants to try something else. That's way OTT.

Polyanthus2 · 18/02/2022 10:15

Holy cow - so you think informing the whole company that everyone should be known by their first names from now on because you prefer it is NOT SEEN AS DIFFICULT - are you mad???????

And if you GENUINELY prefer first names why are you starting this thread at all?

Ozanj · 18/02/2022 10:13

I agree she probably isn’t stupid if she’s been a PA for execs this long. There’s probably a really simple reason for her not to use the same naming conventions for you - either she doesn’t know whether to refer to you as Ms / Mrs, or you told her to refer to her by name and so she did, or she was loyal to Mr Big and is either hurt he left or may have been offered a job in his new organisation & so doesn’t care - if this last point you need to manage her out and get a new PA.

honeylulu · 18/02/2022 10:13

Most women don't seem to grasp the fact that we could get equality almost overnight if that's what we actually wanted

I wish this were true but I fear it is not. I think even a lot of the "good guys" who talk the talk about equality secretly or subconsciously like the fact that men are at the top of the pecking order.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 10:12

This sounds like a bunch of bollocks. I'm not calling my seniors Mrs or Mr.

Just refer to them as Dave and John and encourage your Secretary to do the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread