Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are women's worst enemies for equality?

136 replies

CherryBlossomTreee · 18/02/2022 08:58

I've just got a new job at a senior level. My new secretary has emailed to work out some logistics before I start and to introduce me via cc to the rest of the secretarial/admin team. At the same level in the company are 3 men, who I'll call Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. I am replacing Mr Big.

It appears in this company the convention is to call the seniors by their surname - so throughout the email she writes of Mr Big, Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. However, when I am mentioned, I am Cherry rather than Ms BlossomTreee. For example 'When Mr Big leaves, Cherry will be taking over the X account. Mr Biggest will have the conference room for team meetings on Mondays and Wednesday lunchtimes, Mr Bigger will have it on Tuesday lunchtime and Cherry can choose between Thursday and Friday when she arrives - Mr Big always had it on Thursday'

Now, I would much rather my secretary called me by my first name. But when introducing me to a wider group, some of whom I will be managing, it feels incredibly undermining to use my first name if the convention is all the seniors are known by their surname.

I know from past experience if I try and adjust it so I am also known as Ms BlossomTree rather than Cherry, I will be seen as 'difficult' and it will make my working relationships harder, and since I will partly be working remotely (as the others do too) this would be especially challenging. So, I will just have to suck it up, breathe deeply and once again prove that I am as good as those whose ability and seniority is instantly accepted by grace of them having a Y chromosome.

I am just so sick that in the fight for equality it often seems to be other women who do a lot of the undermining.

Anyone have any soothing words?

OP posts:
formalineadeline · 19/02/2022 21:33

Sexism doesn't require malicious intent to be harmful.

Autumn42 · 19/02/2022 21:12

@WouldIBeATwat

That’s just how I would personally interpret the situation as a women, maybe my experience of being treated differently in a non consequential way as a woman has usually been done with benign intentions where as most peoples experience of being treated differently due to race rarely is

Autumn42 · 19/02/2022 21:10

That’s just how I would personally interpret the situation as a women, maybe my experience of being treated differently in a non consequential way as a woman has usually been done with benign intentions where as most peoples experienced of being treated differently due to race rarely is

KatharinaRosalie · 19/02/2022 20:07

I would tell her as it is, addressing men and women differently will give the impression that you are junior to Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest. So either all last names or all first names.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/02/2022 19:50

In situations like thos, I tend to play stupid. Ask the secretary what the culture is, do the mr bigs prefer to be called by first name or is it just in formal coms etc. How would someone normally refer to someone in your position? It may just be a weird quirk of mr bigger and mr biggest and the rest of the company dont think about it. It might just be her, and being questioned will make her actually think about it. But depending on the answer you might be able to ask further questions to make it more equal without sounding like you're kicking off

WouldIBeATwat · 19/02/2022 19:09

@Autumn42

Maybe she doesn’t know whether your miss, mrs it ms. Tbh I’ll often reply to men as Mr x in correspondence but because I’m not sure of their title I’ll refer to women by their first names. Personally anyway I wouldn’t be offended by her referring to me by my first name as a women as maybe she just felt more familiar with me as my secretary or because I’m another women. Would be more suspicious if e.g. all of a certain race referred to by surnames and then not myself
Erm, sex is a protected characteristic just like race. Why are you thinking one can be the cause of discriminatory behaviour and the other can’t?
Brefugee · 19/02/2022 18:16

Maybe she doesn’t know whether your miss, mrs it ms. Tbh I’ll often reply to men as Mr x in correspondence but because I’m not sure of their title I’ll refer to women by their first names.

JFC. that is what Ms is for.

The idea that a company is a heirarchical entity where people expect the courtesy of Mr Biggest etc doesn't mean they are up themselves. It is an admittedly old fashioned attitude, but there is nothing wrong with it. The issue is that OP should also be afforded the same courtesy.

MayMorris · 19/02/2022 17:54

No women are not enemies…they are just ingrained with unconscious bias same as everyone. Misogynists are women worst enemies

Just talk to her fgs. Ask her why she did it? It’s a way of getting to know each other? While you’re at it ask why bigger and biggest are so stuck up their own condescending and superior arses to insist on being called Mr. it’s so old fashion and doesn’t make people respect their seniority. Ask her what’s that all about? Then work on bigger and biggest to get them to stop that twattish behaviour after you’ve earned your stripes.

Unless you’re all medical consultants in which case it’s just about ok, but even then surely colleagues call them by first name?

FanciedChange · 19/02/2022 17:21

OK, so this was 8 years ago but I worked for a company (not for very long!) where the admin "girls" were upstairs and the sales team (nearly all men) were down one flight of stairs. There was a problem I was having with one of the sales team, emails going back and forth, so I said "I'm just going to go and talk to him". I got told by my line manager that under no circumstances was I to go down there as the girls "distracted" the men's important work. Not one of the very established women had challenged this in all the years they had worked there so the culture persisted.

I think, at some point, you should ask them the question about why there is hierarchy in place, what business need is there for it?

Autumn42 · 19/02/2022 13:08

Maybe she doesn’t know whether your miss, mrs it ms. Tbh I’ll often reply to men as Mr x in correspondence but because I’m not sure of their title I’ll refer to women by their first names.
Personally anyway I wouldn’t be offended by her referring to me by my first name as a women as maybe she just felt more familiar with me as my secretary or because I’m another women. Would be more suspicious if e.g. all of a certain race referred to by surnames and then not myself

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/02/2022 12:55

Why are excluding medical doctors from not being up themselves and power tripping egomaniacs?

My GP isn't, I'm happy to say. I call him Steve!

Louisianagumbo · 19/02/2022 11:12

@nosyupnorth

I think anybody demanding that people call them up their title in the workplace is completely up themselves, unless they are a medical doctor. Sounds like Misters Big, Bigger, and Biggest are that kind of tool and your secretary was giving you the benefit of the doubt in assuming you were a reasonable person not a power tripping egomaniac like them.
Why are excluding medical doctors from not being up themselves and power tripping egomaniacs?
Jewel1968 · 19/02/2022 11:04

Agree with some posters. I would challenge the culture of calling anyone by a title. That way you subtly point out the inconsistency but all look like a real people person. Say something like:

I notice the culture here seems to be to use titles for senior people rather than first names and that doesn't feel very inclusive.

Send it to Mr Bigger and Mr Biggest but make sure you use their first name.

Frazzled50yrold · 19/02/2022 10:46

In local government I used to work very closely with councillors. Some of them would have been close friends outside work but when I referred to them in meetings or in emails they were always Councillor White etc. It would have given a significant message in terms of equality if I'd called one councillor Michael and another Councillor White. It was a constant balancing act and titles were really important.In your case it looks like you would infer a lack of respect or authority if you're called by your first name.
Have an open conversation with her about this, it's probably not occurred to her.

nosyupnorth · 19/02/2022 10:37

I think anybody demanding that people call them up their title in the workplace is completely up themselves, unless they are a medical doctor. Sounds like Misters Big, Bigger, and Biggest are that kind of tool and your secretary was giving you the benefit of the doubt in assuming you were a reasonable person not a power tripping egomaniac like them.

Thirkettle · 19/02/2022 10:31

I work on an all male team in an almost all male office. I'm the only female performing my role. Male dominated industry.

Woman joins the team in a clerical role. All very welcoming.

Upon being assigned some tasks, she got upset and called a meeting to say she felt jumped on and perplexed at having questions asked about the tasks. She didn't complete any of those tasks. She told her manager she didn't have enough to do - possibly enjoying being the victim, as the work is sat right there undone - and they gave her more, so now she's upset she's 'swamped'.

We just sort of sit there side eyeing each other trying to figure what to do with her constant sniffly 'upsets', tears, complaining, and the tasks she won't even start. It's so embarrassing. And yes. I do think uncharitable things about her 'letting the side down.'

PegasusReturns · 19/02/2022 09:50

@formalineadeline executive assistant or administrator. Occasionally personal assistant.

ChristmasCrackered · 19/02/2022 09:36

Sounds like the company is 30 years behind 99% of the rest of the workforce in terms of using Mr/Mrs, so perhaps it is it is behind in equality also.

It’s a reach to think that this very unusual thing that’s happened to you, is evidence of sexism more widely.

5128gap · 19/02/2022 09:27

@formalineadeline

What would posters prefer to "secretary" then? That's still a job title where I work. What is wrong with it?
Administrator.
Valeriekat · 19/02/2022 06:30

Good grief if you can't manage this little thing how will you have any authority in your new role?

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 19:36

@formalineadeline

What would posters prefer to "secretary" then? That's still a job title where I work. What is wrong with it?
I haven’t heard it for years. Executive Assistant is most commonly used where I’ve worked.
formalineadeline · 18/02/2022 19:32

What would posters prefer to "secretary" then? That's still a job title where I work. What is wrong with it?

MiladyBerserko · 18/02/2022 14:08

What industry is this OP?

MarshaBradyo · 18/02/2022 13:00

I can’t imagine that culture and would hate it

But you’ll have to join in via the PA too so they need to change, or try and change the lot

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 12:59

[quote HundredMilesAnHour]@girlmom21

But is that the case at all levels?

No, senior (or mid-senior) only pretty much. No-one really cares about the more junior ranks to be frank.[/quote]
That's awful!

Swipe left for the next trending thread