Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Response to storm Arwen vs Eunice

364 replies

ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 08:52

Curious to hear other peoples POV. Does anyone feel let down by the government’s response to storm Eunice versus storm Arwen, both with rare red warning storms?

For Eunice the Government have held an emergency cobra meeting, thousands of schools have been closed and there’s huge national media coverage. I think this absolutely is the right thing to do.

When Arwen was brewing there was no cobra meeting, just general advice to be careful from the Met Office. it was in the media but only to a very small extent www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-59419772. We live in the areas affected by Arwen and it was pretty terrifying when it hit. It took out trees and roofs local to where we live, at PIL it blew down their garden wall and fencing and left a 6ft hole. It knocked out power to nearly 250,000 homes. It took at least 5 days to get the army in to help those still cut off. I’ve not seen anything like it in my lifetime.

The optimistic part of me likes to think the government learnt from Arwen and have now pulled their socks up to deal with Eunice the way they should have done but the cynical part of me just feels like they weren’t bothered about Arwen as it was up in Scotland and the North East

AIBU to feel this way?

YANBU - it’s yet another example of the government not caring unless its a problem that affects the south/London

YABU - the government didn’t recognise the severity of Arwen and have learnt from their mistakes with Eunice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 16:16

@MajorCarolDanvers

This storm has red warnings so it's more serious. Loss of life expected.
So did Arwen. 3 people died.
Eastie77Returns · 18/02/2022 16:12

@outdooryone I’m not an economist so this is a genuine question for my info: how does a company in Scotland reporting shares and profits in London (and I’m not really sure what that means ) contribute towards the fiscal surplus here?

MajorCarolDanvers · 18/02/2022 16:10

This storm has red warnings so it's more serious. Loss of life expected.

DementedPanda · 18/02/2022 16:06

At the moment we have gusts of 83km/h, local tips etc have closed. Trains cancelled etc yet no weather warning that I have seen. But going by that chart areas below York with those gust speeds are in Amber Hmm

I too would like to know the difference between building construction in the North to south?

Mumofsend · 18/02/2022 16:00

I wouldn't expect down in Dorset to have extensive coverage of a weather warning in Durham to warn us. I would expect local authorities to do as ours have done with eunice to make sure they warned and prepared their residents. Perhaps the failure has been on part of the local authorities rather than mocking the South.

Huge parts of the south are NOT London or the south east. The likes of Cornwall and Devon and Somerset are at no more an advantage than the North. However, we all get lumped into one generalisation of the favoured south.

And of course London is significantly important, the lives aren't but the city is.

We are also completely without power.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 15:59

@kittensinthekitchen

I have to go out for a bit, but will be back later to read all the evidence people will post about homes in Scotland and Northern England being built to withstand storms
Yeah I wish someone told my house this. Our garden gate blew off and took down a wall at the bottom of our garden.
StarsAreWishes · 18/02/2022 15:58

@Wnkingawalrus

It’s the first time the met office have issues a red warning for London, the most heavily populated area of the country. It’s also incredibly rare that the whole country is under red/amber warnings, it’s usually a bit more regionalised than that. Plus the impact of the high spring tide brings greater risk of flooding than we’ve seen with other storms.

But don’t let all that stop the chips gathering on your shoulders.

”whole country under red/amber warnings” (stops slight south of York).

I feel you trampled on your own point there @Wnkingawalrus

Response to storm Arwen vs Eunice
kittensinthekitchen · 18/02/2022 15:54

I have to go out for a bit, but will be back later to read all the evidence people will post about homes in Scotland and Northern England being built to withstand storms

katienana · 18/02/2022 15:45

There was some media coverage after Arwen hit but almost nothing to raise awareness of the red warning. I only knew there was a bad storm coming because a Scottish Instagram account mentioned it do I checked and saw it covered Newcastle. We tied down patio stuff and wedged the wheelie bins. Our fence came down, it had only just been fixed when it got tested by the more recent storm! Trees came down everywhere, a huge tree destroyed a wall in a neighbouring street. We have a caravan in Northumberland and the site was devastated, loads of caravans destroyed and trees down. People were staying there that night and had to be evacuated to the entertainment venue!
I'd like to think lessons were learnt after Arwen and we would get a good response if it was hitting the North again but let's see what happens next time!

outdooryone · 18/02/2022 15:32

"London is viewed as more than important than other cities because from an economic standpoint it is. The fiscal surplus generated here funds services in other parts of the country so if London goes down so do a lot of other places."

Ah yes, the place where the money earned in Scottish oil waters, car manufacturing in north and midlands, and digital media companies based in NW or Scotland report their shares and profits to, so (partly) responsible for London's apparent fiscal surplus....? ;-)

There is more than one way to look at these things - and at some point the decision to alter the ever increasing SE-centric cycle (London is valuable->more investment->more important now->London is valuable and repeat) should be made in my view. And recognise that London & SE are partly such powerhouses because of the system which supports the system....

ontana · 18/02/2022 15:29

I didn't have power to my home on the outskirts of Newcastle for 6 days after Arwen. When that happens to people in London I'll be sympathetic.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 15:22

The snow in the north is getting plenty of media coverage (photogenic?)

Where is this infamous snow? I'm in Northumberland and we've had a slop of sleet at best!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 15:21

I mean I do get it. The Capital is down south. The Palace is down south. The UK's powerhouse is down south. The population is greater. This is something we all get and have no problem with! I think the problem is, if England had to sacrifice an area, it would always be the North and we know this. We know we're not as important and knowing this is a bit depressing. It feels like our lives/homes/livelihoods/children are not as important and there is nothing we can do about it.

If the powers that be could just pretend to care about us all the same we'd probably be a bit happier!

RancidOldHag · 18/02/2022 15:14

Sorry - no idea at all how that emoji got in there! I know I type erratically, but I didn't think it was that bad!!

RancidOldHag · 18/02/2022 15:13

There also the basic spread of the population:over 18m live in London and the SE (one of this morning's Red weather warnings)

There are 8m in Scotland and the NE

So it's affecting over twice as many people, before adding in the extent of the Amber and also the Red area in the SW.

The snow in the north is getting plenty of media coverage (photogenic?)

Eastie77Returns · 18/02/2022 15:04

London is viewed as more than important than other cities because from an economic standpoint it is. The fiscal surplus generated here funds services in other parts of the country so if London goes down so do a lot of other places.

That is not to say the lives of people who live London are more important than the lives of people who live elsewhere. However it does explain why the media and government seem particularly concerned when the city is under a perceived threat.

I don’t understand the hate and sneering at London tbh. I wouldn’t dream of speaking in derogatory terms about someone’s home town yet if I had a penny for people who have been quick to tell me London is a shithole, the people are awful etc I’d be a millionaire.

Stay safe everyone, wherever you live.

ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 15:02

@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea @DementedPanda

I like your posts, that's what I'm trying to get at xx

OP posts:
DementedPanda · 18/02/2022 14:55

Storm Eunice is affecting the North east. We had Dudley just on Wednesday too. Now I'm not saying Dudley is as bad as Eunice because it's not but I don't suppose people out of the area are aware how much disruption we have in the North East. Just as many are not aware Storm Arwen didn't just happen in Scotland.

But... the divide is how the government and media respond to these events. The whole country knows about Eunice, I doubt they are aware if the scale of devastation the North East experienced and continues to experience.

I think that's the point many are trying to make.

FairyLightQueen · 18/02/2022 14:54

Yep. Arwen took away our power for a week but the response was crap. We're in NE Scotland and I really think some of it is down to political divisions.

CharacterForming · 18/02/2022 14:49

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharacterForming

Its absolute bollocks that the buildings and trees in the north of England are better designed/developed than the south. If anything we have older housing stock that has received less investment and greater poverty.

Just laughable that you and a couple of other posters think that.

Tens of thousands of trees were lost in Kielder alone under Arwen.

This is why many northerners would prefer to be part of Scotland.[/quote]
Knot for knot the trees in regions which get frequent strong winds are better at withstanding them than trees in regions which rarely get them. Arwen was unusually devastating to Scottish/Northern English trees not because it was strong, but because it was from the wrong direction - this was of course predictable in advance and the authorities should have done a better job.

HufflepuffPride · 18/02/2022 14:49

Looks like I’ve been stalked onto this thread as well then…

My posts were response to those who were piling on to and attacking posters who were simply pointing out that it wasn’t that bad by them. God forbid other people should be having a different experience to you. Where I live we have high winds and trees come down fairly often. We just get on with it.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 14:46

We say this about nearly every group of people out there but it still applies here. If someone is telling you there is a problem, don't disregard it because you yourself haven't experienced it.

We in the North are saying we see problems with the Londoncentric England we live in. Don't tell us we're wrong because you (Southerners) haven't noticed it.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 18/02/2022 14:45

I mean, this thread is a great example of people forgetting about the North.

Several people either didn't realise that the North of England was even affected by a devastating storm. The whole country is fully aware of this current one.

The fact that the country's key decision makers are based in London means that often the country only appears to react to things on a Southern-scale. So if something happened up here, it would be a shame, if the same thing happens down there, it's a tragedy and we all have to hear about it for days on end.

I love the places daaannn saaaafff that I've visited. I've got some wonderful friends and family down there. I adore the West End and feel that it should be protected at all costs so I am certainly no Southern-hating Northerner. But it would be nice if we were thought of as important as the South.

T00Ts · 18/02/2022 14:40

@outdooryone

"You bleating on about a north-south divide is pathetic."

Be careful please - many of us live with the reality of that divide. While I agree the wording of some statements is poor, it comes from a place of deep frustration.

Tell that to that poster, then. That’s exactly what they were doing and said. Their posts read that because it was hitting people in ‘the south’, they were being overly dramatic. Really not on. People are getting badly hurt.
ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 14:38

I actually wanted to say something I've thought a few times to try and show a bit of balance so I'm not coming across as woe is us up in the north east.

Sounds a bit off topic but just as an example, whenever a new business proposes something a bit controversial for example the whey eye on Newcastle quayside. (have a Google if you're bored) The developers always say something about how it will bring much needed jobs to the region. And the councils often okay it on this basis.

I dislike hearing this because it's almost as though there is a view that we are desperate in the north east for jobs and regeneration and so will accept any old shite because it will benefit us economically and that trumps everything

There are a lot of deprived areas up where I live and a lot of people in poverty who need support. But there are a lot other areas that aren't.

I'm not too good with words but the convoluted point I'm trying to make is that I disagree with some of the comments where people have implied that those of us in the north east have massive chips on our shoulders or hate the south.

I actually love living up here and I've got a lot of love for other parts of the country too. I just wanted to get across that we don't all sit here thinking that we get nothing up north and the south get everything. That's too black and white a thought process. I do however quite often feel that the north east gets overlooked and I felt that way with Arwen

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread