Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Response to storm Arwen vs Eunice

364 replies

ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 08:52

Curious to hear other peoples POV. Does anyone feel let down by the government’s response to storm Eunice versus storm Arwen, both with rare red warning storms?

For Eunice the Government have held an emergency cobra meeting, thousands of schools have been closed and there’s huge national media coverage. I think this absolutely is the right thing to do.

When Arwen was brewing there was no cobra meeting, just general advice to be careful from the Met Office. it was in the media but only to a very small extent www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-59419772. We live in the areas affected by Arwen and it was pretty terrifying when it hit. It took out trees and roofs local to where we live, at PIL it blew down their garden wall and fencing and left a 6ft hole. It knocked out power to nearly 250,000 homes. It took at least 5 days to get the army in to help those still cut off. I’ve not seen anything like it in my lifetime.

The optimistic part of me likes to think the government learnt from Arwen and have now pulled their socks up to deal with Eunice the way they should have done but the cynical part of me just feels like they weren’t bothered about Arwen as it was up in Scotland and the North East

AIBU to feel this way?

YANBU - it’s yet another example of the government not caring unless its a problem that affects the south/London

YABU - the government didn’t recognise the severity of Arwen and have learnt from their mistakes with Eunice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
kittensinthekitchen · 19/02/2022 09:37

WTF at the idea Scotland is some alternative backwards universe.

@ChoiceMummy

Where in Scotland have you visited?

Plumbear2 · 19/02/2022 09:37

And we all heard about the 02 buildings roof yesterday on national news. Did we hear about any of the buildings in my area that also had there roof blown on national news? No? Exactly it's only a concern if it's in London 😡

BurntO · 19/02/2022 09:34

I heard plenty about Arwen but only AFTER it happened. There were next to no warnings for the areas affected and no one gave a shot really. Eunice had a vastly different approach despite the level of damage being similar. YANBU

Plumbear2 · 19/02/2022 09:32

[quote ChoiceMummy]@Plumbear2
The South have strong winds today again and at various point forecasted this week. Did you know that?
You only bother with what affects you.

@ontana
I am not sure. I've chosen to live where I do. As do most. Whether that's where they were born, family moved to or some other driving factor.
Regardless, we have to accept that our choices what drove them have consequences and different implications that we have to allow for.
For example, around here, most of the seafront homes have shutters as standard that would have been shit for the storm. A part of being a basic prerequisite.
Same as that I don't know many homes in Scotland that have aircon, I do know homes in the South that have paid for systems of varying levels.[/quote]
Actually I did know that, it's on the news. The forecast for yourksire tomorrow I could only find on my weather app. That's my point

BobbinHood · 19/02/2022 09:31

The South have strong winds today again and at various point forecasted this week. Did you know that?
You only bother with what affects you.

Oh really? Because the yellow warning for wind (or indeed any weather) only remains over the south of England today. For Sunday and Monday it covers the North West and most of Scotland. Nothing in the south. Perhaps the Met Office are also in on the conspiracy of whinging northerners?

ChoiceMummy · 19/02/2022 09:29

[quote ontana]@ChoiceMummy you seem to be conflating "living in Scotland" with "living in the middle of nowhere" 🤔🤔 There are 7 cities in Scotland you know. [/quote]
Not at all.

ChoiceMummy · 19/02/2022 09:28

@Plumbear2
The South have strong winds today again and at various point forecasted this week. Did you know that?
You only bother with what affects you.

@ontana
I am not sure. I've chosen to live where I do. As do most. Whether that's where they were born, family moved to or some other driving factor.
Regardless, we have to accept that our choices what drove them have consequences and different implications that we have to allow for.
For example, around here, most of the seafront homes have shutters as standard that would have been shit for the storm. A part of being a basic prerequisite.
Same as that I don't know many homes in Scotland that have aircon, I do know homes in the South that have paid for systems of varying levels.

ontana · 19/02/2022 09:24

@ChoiceMummy you seem to be conflating "living in Scotland" with "living in the middle of nowhere" 🤔🤔 There are 7 cities in Scotland you know.

ChoiceMummy · 19/02/2022 09:22

@StarsAndSugarlumps

This thread is so sad Sad.

So many people saying (paraphrased obviously):

“I had no heat, no light, for 10 days in the depths of winter. No power. No access to hot food. Did you not know, or did you not care?”

And the majority responses, from those who weren’t affected:

“I didn’t know, but I still don’t care”

Didn't care? No, not that people don't care per se, but as a rule of most people genuinely only care when they're directly impacted. And again those in Scotland for example, should be far more prepared/setup for such situations than you'd anticipate in the South. No different to how majority of people I know who live in the absolute middle of nowhere in the south have alternative power sources, such as generators etc and usually also different heating sources.
ontana · 19/02/2022 09:22

*@ChoiceMummy
*
But is that not par for the course of choosing to live where you do in Scotland versus living in the south east where such storms and snow would be extrairdinary

"Choosing to live in Scotland" is a strange way to think about it. Most people live where they are born/where they grow up, it's not really a matter of "choosing"

Plumbear2 · 19/02/2022 09:19

@ABCDEF1234

Yesterday we had the same winds than the South (according to the met Office) The south had a red weather warning whilst we had yellow-oh and we also had snow. How does that work?!
Exactly. Plus early tomorrow morning untill Monday lunchtime we have very strong winds yet again. Why isn't this on the news? Oh yes because its Yorkshire not London 😡
ChoiceMummy · 19/02/2022 09:18

@feelingdizzy

I was thinking this watching news today .I live in be Scotland I was without power for 5 days no phone signal either , schools shut . I also lost power for 3 days with storm Malik more recently whilst I had Covid!! Today we have 20 cm of snow that fell today . I have had 8 days without power recently 5 days out of work as schools shut no power and today snow . Imagine the news if this was the SE !
But is that not par for the course of choosing to live where you do in Scotland versus living in the south east where such storms and snow would be extrairdinary?
StarsAndSugarlumps · 19/02/2022 09:16

This thread is so sad Sad.

So many people saying (paraphrased obviously):

“I had no heat, no light, for 10 days in the depths of winter. No power. No access to hot food. Did you not know, or did you not care?”

And the majority responses, from those who weren’t affected:

“I didn’t know, but I still don’t care”

StarsAndSugarlumps · 19/02/2022 08:57

@Mumofsend she doesn’t control the media.

Mumofsend · 19/02/2022 07:22

@feelingdizzy

I was thinking this watching news today .I live in be Scotland I was without power for 5 days no phone signal either , schools shut . I also lost power for 3 days with storm Malik more recently whilst I had Covid!! Today we have 20 cm of snow that fell today . I have had 8 days without power recently 5 days out of work as schools shut no power and today snow . Imagine the news if this was the SE !
Surely that is on sturgeon, not the "southern nancys"?
Indoctro · 19/02/2022 07:20

Sturgeon should of took responsibility for Scotland but because it was the NE of Scotland she didn't give a crap.

10 days some people where left with no power.

She is a disgrace to Scotland and like Boris only cares about the capital and surrounding areas

Mumofsend · 19/02/2022 06:59

@ABCDEF1234 my family in the Midlands didn't have close to the winds we did on the south coast let alone further north.

ABCDEF1234 · 19/02/2022 05:11

Yesterday we had the same winds than the South (according to the met Office) The south had a red weather warning whilst we had yellow-oh and we also had snow. How does that work?!

feelingdizzy · 19/02/2022 04:13

I was thinking this watching news today .I live in be Scotland I was without power for 5 days no phone signal either , schools shut .
I also lost power for 3 days with storm Malik more recently whilst I had Covid!!
Today we have 20 cm of snow that fell today .
I have had 8 days without power recently 5 days out of work as schools shut no power and today snow .
Imagine the news if this was the SE !

ontana · 19/02/2022 01:35

@MajorCarolDanvers I'm not meaning to be rude, I'm just genuinely wondering if you understand what is being said here and if you know the meanings of some words because your posts so far suggest not.

StarsAndSugarlumps · 18/02/2022 21:37

@Peasandcabbage I am sorry you have had such a difficult time Flowers

tigger1001 · 18/02/2022 21:34

@JaninaDuszejko

Anyone remember the big storm in 2016 when windspeeds hit 144mph in Scotland? Thought not. While I think it's true that houses in northern Scotland are designed to cope with a 'big wind' as we call them that's not true in the NE of England. My Dad was genuinely horrified at the construction of our house in NE England and told me 'but you'll lose all your slates when it's windy'. We lived there 15 years and never lost a slate due to the wind. Also trees make a big wind more dangerous, this is not an issue in the north of Scotland.
Oh I do! Seem to remember it was called hurricane bawbag 😂😂 but then I'm Scottish and lived in a red warning area.
Peasandcabbage · 18/02/2022 21:30

@StarsAndSugarlumps yes, this absolutely. Then I think these are the bits people see, the valleys, my goodness. Absolutely destroyed

StarsAndSugarlumps · 18/02/2022 21:28

I still can’t believe the aftermath of Arwen. I have never seen anything like it.

Towards Dunns - several areas, each with 50 or more mature trees, maybe 30 years old and several meters around the trunk. Snapped. SNAPPED!. Right through the thickest part of the trunk, 5-10 meters up in the air. Whole groups of them, all snapped the same way at the same height. They must have sounded like cannons going off. Looked like the aftermath of a mention or a bomb on a sci-fi movie.

Towards Moffat, rows of trees 10m high gone down like dominoes. The entire 5m wide rootball of each tree completely uprooted. And by “rows” I mean the first row of 50 ten meter high trees, lying on top of the second row of 50 ten meter high trees, going on for rows and rows and rows. Thousand of trees.

Down the A1, an entire forest just completely flattened, Another one which is now just a series of 5m high broken trunks, snapped straight through like twigs, the same as the others.

That’s just the trees. I won’t get started on the wildlife, property … There were hundreds of seal-pups lost off of art Abbs Sad

Peasandcabbage · 18/02/2022 21:22

@kittensinthekitchen not at all, I need more laughter, to hold me up for the call! But yes today I am cross, and bloody sad.