Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Response to storm Arwen vs Eunice

364 replies

ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 08:52

Curious to hear other peoples POV. Does anyone feel let down by the government’s response to storm Eunice versus storm Arwen, both with rare red warning storms?

For Eunice the Government have held an emergency cobra meeting, thousands of schools have been closed and there’s huge national media coverage. I think this absolutely is the right thing to do.

When Arwen was brewing there was no cobra meeting, just general advice to be careful from the Met Office. it was in the media but only to a very small extent www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-59419772. We live in the areas affected by Arwen and it was pretty terrifying when it hit. It took out trees and roofs local to where we live, at PIL it blew down their garden wall and fencing and left a 6ft hole. It knocked out power to nearly 250,000 homes. It took at least 5 days to get the army in to help those still cut off. I’ve not seen anything like it in my lifetime.

The optimistic part of me likes to think the government learnt from Arwen and have now pulled their socks up to deal with Eunice the way they should have done but the cynical part of me just feels like they weren’t bothered about Arwen as it was up in Scotland and the North East

AIBU to feel this way?

YANBU - it’s yet another example of the government not caring unless its a problem that affects the south/London

YABU - the government didn’t recognise the severity of Arwen and have learnt from their mistakes with Eunice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Mumofsend · 20/02/2022 13:05

School closure decisions were entirely local, don't blame southerners for your LAs not making a sensible decision during a red warning. I find it insane any LA wouldn't close schools during a red warning.

As for India, I would expect news affecting London to be of greater international importance than the north east purely as its our capital city. Something happening in a random part of France wouldn't make our news but Paris would. Surely that is obvious?

There is an awful lot of resentment that aren't was clearly handled badly but it is all local decisions. Cobra was not mentioned before our LA acted. Nothing prevents an LA making sensible decisions.

MarianosOnHisWay · 20/02/2022 12:52

@ChoiceMummy Maybe so but they didn’t get in touch with worry after hearing any coverage of Arwen (because they didn’t hear any)

ChoiceMummy · 20/02/2022 12:47

@JuniorMint

Well something has just happened that to me as totally proved your point OP. My parents have friends in India, they have visited etc. We have a group chat which they used while they were there to send updates etc, with the Indian friends also in the group. Currently used to send happy birthdays and a few other updates every now and then. Obviously there was no mention on Arwen- I wouldn’t expect there to be. We do live in the north east and had the fence blow over and trees down in the street during Arwen. Yesterday morning one of the Indian friend messaged the group chat “We hope you are all keeping well and safe, we have heard about the storm “Younis” and are worrying about you!” Eunice has been some rain and slightly heavier than usual winds here. They have obviously had coverage in India of the storm in the south of England.
That's most likely due to them not understanding the geography of the UK. Its like a storm in Goa and asking if this affected them in Delhi!
Ghislainedefeligonde · 20/02/2022 12:30

I saw a photo on a local fb page of Scottish and southern electricity preparing to hand out emergency packs on the same day as Eunice hit, yet strangely there was nothing in place for Arwen despite thousands of people being without power for days or even weeks…

Ghislainedefeligonde · 20/02/2022 12:28

Yes red warning for Arwen was from 3pm but even by 2 it was extremely windy, almost enough to blow you off your feet (so could have easily blown kids over)
So timing has nothing to do with it.

bellabasset · 20/02/2022 12:14

The government didn't think through the threat to life or the difficulties in restoring power, and getting assistance to older or disabled people left without power for days. Eunice potentially covered the whole country and pre planning was put in place to warn people to stay indoors, minimise travel, stay away from the sea, get supplies in. Many areas have voluntary help for people when there are floods Some people don't tie down or secure items that can be blown around, hence the red warnings for the densely populated areas in the South East. It made me check and replace torches, get spare matches and get shopping in I could cook on the gas hob.

CharacterForming · 20/02/2022 10:46

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharacterForming

Are you being deliberately obtuse?

The trees in the north came down not because it was strong but because the winds were blowing the wrong way ?! Hmm

The winds where I am in the red zone were 100 miles an hour and highest was 110 recorded. We are still repairing and many parks are still closed. Friends had to stay in hotels as no electricity for weeks.

Do not tell me the wind wasn't strong.[/quote]
The wind was strong, but its effect was disproportionate to its speed because the winds came from the north rather than the west so the trees' root systems weren't developed to handle it - huge numbers of mature trees came down which would have survived even these very high speeds if they'd come from the normal direction. Hence it did much more damage than a "normal" wind of that speed would have done. This is not a controversial point of view, it's literally the first line on Wikipedia.

It doesn't excuse the poor response by the electricity companies though - they knew which direction it would be coming from in advance and while it was an unusual storm it was foreseeable enough that it should have been planned for.

DementedPanda · 20/02/2022 10:18

Arwen was forecast for 3pm just as schools got out. In my opinion they should have finished by 1.30 as by 3pm it was getting bad.

Hospedia · 20/02/2022 10:15

Arwen left people without power for longer than five days, my mum's friend and her disabled husband had no power for nearly two weeks. They lost all the food in their freezer, no hot water or heating because there was no electricity to run the boiler, no means to cook hot food so they were living on sandwiches and takeaway, no lights. The helplines were always engaged so they couldn't even get through then when they did get through they were offered a blanket bundle and one flask of hot water per person per day. They still haven't received any compensation for it either.

Saz12 · 20/02/2022 10:03

Timing of Eunice was worse than that of Arwen, hence school closures etc.

But the piss-poor sorting of the aftermath of Arwen was shocking - people with no power for 5 days, respite centres set up in village schools, which obviously then had to shut to pupils, where village halls could have been used instead. Not the fault of Westminster decisions as such, but should’ve at least been using army support much sooner.

Power outages in the areas affected by Eunice won’t be allowed to last 5 days - there’ll be far more pressure on power companies to get it sorted, and far better support. As there should have been with Arwen.

Willyoujustbequiet · 20/02/2022 09:44

@CharacterForming

Are you being deliberately obtuse?

The trees in the north came down not because it was strong but because the winds were blowing the wrong way ?! Hmm

The winds where I am in the red zone were 100 miles an hour and highest was 110 recorded. We are still repairing and many parks are still closed. Friends had to stay in hotels as no electricity for weeks.

Do not tell me the wind wasn't strong.

MarianosOnHisWay · 20/02/2022 09:30

[quote Ifailed]@JuniorMint there's plenty of things wrong with the UK government, but I think it's a bit of a stretch to blame them for the output of Indian media.[/quote]
The Indian media will cover things that the U.K. government is doing- so if they have a cobra meeting and put out comment on storm Eunice, then the Indian media will cover that, if they don’t do anything about storm Arwen then the Indian media won’t mention it. Also I think it’s probably likely my friends watch BBC World Service.

Ifailed · 20/02/2022 09:05

@JuniorMint there's plenty of things wrong with the UK government, but I think it's a bit of a stretch to blame them for the output of Indian media.

JuniorMint · 20/02/2022 08:10

Well something has just happened that to me as totally proved your point OP.
My parents have friends in India, they have visited etc. We have a group chat which they used while they were there to send updates etc, with the Indian friends also in the group. Currently used to send happy birthdays and a few other updates every now and then.
Obviously there was no mention on Arwen- I wouldn’t expect there to be.
We do live in the north east and had the fence blow over and trees down in the street during Arwen.
Yesterday morning one of the Indian friend messaged the group chat
“We hope you are all keeping well and safe, we have heard about the storm “Younis” and are worrying about you!”
Eunice has been some rain and slightly heavier than usual winds here. They have obviously had coverage in India of the storm in the south of England.

PupInAPram · 20/02/2022 06:40

@Mumofsend I have spent half my life growing up and living in the South, the second half in the North. Judging by the long term s**tshow that is 'levelling up', I would say it seems to me that the South hates the North.

ontana · 20/02/2022 05:49

Re schools - the timing was different for Arwen as it hit on a Friday night

DementedPanda · 19/02/2022 21:48

Your local authorities definately made the right call. Its a shame ours didn't. I hope you haven't suffered too much damage. I don't think Southern Nancy's by the way.. just annoyed we didn't get the same level of response but that is not your fault. The point of the thread was the differences in the way each event was handled by the powers that be, and I think its clear Storm Arwen wasn't handled well.

Hope everyone affected by eunice has power/damage rectified soon.

StarsAndSugarlumps · 19/02/2022 21:42

@Mumofsend I hope your power is back soon.

Mumofsend · 19/02/2022 21:35

@DementedPanda

We were aware there was a red alert, but no schools were closed, people had to go about their business as normal, no contingency measures etc. Stark difference to the response of a red alert in the south.
But that is on your local authorities? Our LA made the decision well before cobra was ever mentioned.

Good job really as one local school suffered bad damage during the school day (their solar panels flew off the roof) which landed on a thankfully empty playground. My DC's school lost power at 10am and it still isn't back on.

I'm glad our LA made the decision to close, it's a shame yours didn't during Arwen.

Mumofsend · 19/02/2022 21:33

@ontana people in my town and other towns are expected to be back on on the 23rd. Thousands are without power. We aren't south east but are the south coast..

Or are the south not actually allowed to have a bad storm because we are southern and pathetic and "nancys" despite it being our worse in 24 years?

Not our fault your local authorities didn't close your schools but ours chose to. That is a local authority decision.

DementedPanda · 19/02/2022 21:22

We were aware there was a red alert, but no schools were closed, people had to go about their business as normal, no contingency measures etc. Stark difference to the response of a red alert in the south.

DementedPanda · 19/02/2022 21:15

This is why people who suffered damage were annoyed about all the media coverage about eunice countrywide but nothing was done for all the people up here without power for weeks. Some families were still crammed into temp accommodation for Christmas. It's about the difference in response to both storms.

ontana · 19/02/2022 21:13

How many people in the south east are now without power due to storm Eunice and will they still be without power in a week's time? I'd be Interested to know given we lost power for 6 days after Arwen and no one cared.

DementedPanda · 19/02/2022 21:05

Not really... just proves that eunice has more media coverage than arwen. Both storms were red events.