Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Response to storm Arwen vs Eunice

364 replies

ArwenVsEunice · 18/02/2022 08:52

Curious to hear other peoples POV. Does anyone feel let down by the government’s response to storm Eunice versus storm Arwen, both with rare red warning storms?

For Eunice the Government have held an emergency cobra meeting, thousands of schools have been closed and there’s huge national media coverage. I think this absolutely is the right thing to do.

When Arwen was brewing there was no cobra meeting, just general advice to be careful from the Met Office. it was in the media but only to a very small extent www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-tyne-59419772. We live in the areas affected by Arwen and it was pretty terrifying when it hit. It took out trees and roofs local to where we live, at PIL it blew down their garden wall and fencing and left a 6ft hole. It knocked out power to nearly 250,000 homes. It took at least 5 days to get the army in to help those still cut off. I’ve not seen anything like it in my lifetime.

The optimistic part of me likes to think the government learnt from Arwen and have now pulled their socks up to deal with Eunice the way they should have done but the cynical part of me just feels like they weren’t bothered about Arwen as it was up in Scotland and the North East

AIBU to feel this way?

YANBU - it’s yet another example of the government not caring unless its a problem that affects the south/London

YABU - the government didn’t recognise the severity of Arwen and have learnt from their mistakes with Eunice

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
GrouchyKiwi · 18/02/2022 09:42

YANBU

We had 70+MPH winds with Arwen and my area was just an Amber alert. The tree damage in woods around us was horrendous.

ihavespoken · 18/02/2022 09:41

100% agree - I was just thinking this myself

IamSamantha · 18/02/2022 09:36

@MorningStarling

It's less of a concern if a red storm hits the north of England or Scotland because these areas are better-equipped to cope with it. These areas traditionally see more storms and higher winds than the south or Wales, so buildings are designed to withstand this and coastal defences are built stronger.

If a red storm hits areas where structures and defences are weaker, it requires a stronger response from the government.

I also think part of it is down to population. Scotland has 5.4 million people, southern England has 28 million. Clearly the threat is more severe where the population is higher, even if the effects of the storms were the same.

It's sadly predictable though that those who seek to divide the country use natural disasters as a means to spread their propaganda.

And what about the people in the 200miles of Northern England 🤔. Our houses are built the same as yours, we have the same species of trees growing and we're actually more exposed in many places.

The North are no more structurally prepared than any other area of England.

DementedPanda · 18/02/2022 09:34

It's the same when snow hits... 4ft in the North east? Get ya spades oot! 1cm in London and its a disaster 🤣

MrsMoastyToasty · 18/02/2022 09:33

One of the reasons is because its also coupled with spring tides. The Severn estuary has the 2nd highest tidal range in the world and even coastal flood barriers may be breached by sea surges.

OneTiredMam · 18/02/2022 09:33

@MorningStarling

It's less of a concern if a red storm hits the north of England or Scotland because these areas are better-equipped to cope with it. These areas traditionally see more storms and higher winds than the south or Wales, so buildings are designed to withstand this and coastal defences are built stronger.

If a red storm hits areas where structures and defences are weaker, it requires a stronger response from the government.

I also think part of it is down to population. Scotland has 5.4 million people, southern England has 28 million. Clearly the threat is more severe where the population is higher, even if the effects of the storms were the same.

It's sadly predictable though that those who seek to divide the country use natural disasters as a means to spread their propaganda.

Your joking right? The north are not equipped to deal with it! Some of us had no power for weeks on end!
IamSamantha · 18/02/2022 09:32

@jowly

Please excuse my southerly ignorance but a genuine question.. where does Nicola Sturgeons responsibility to prepare sit in this?
For Scotland yes. For England no and Arwen was red for a large part of Northern England. I think people forget that there is 170 miles north of Leeds to the borders that is still England. Leeds to London is only 195 miles.

Manchester to Scottish Boarder is a larger distance than Manchester to London Cross Country.

The North is a big place!

MorningStarling · 18/02/2022 09:32

It's less of a concern if a red storm hits the north of England or Scotland because these areas are better-equipped to cope with it. These areas traditionally see more storms and higher winds than the south or Wales, so buildings are designed to withstand this and coastal defences are built stronger.

If a red storm hits areas where structures and defences are weaker, it requires a stronger response from the government.

I also think part of it is down to population. Scotland has 5.4 million people, southern England has 28 million. Clearly the threat is more severe where the population is higher, even if the effects of the storms were the same.

It's sadly predictable though that those who seek to divide the country use natural disasters as a means to spread their propaganda.

garlictwist · 18/02/2022 09:27

I was thinking the same thing. We had no power for a week because of Storm Arwen, the tree damage was insane and still hasn't been cleared and yet there really wasn't the national coverage or response that this one is getting.

Onionpatch · 18/02/2022 09:27

I saw a lot of media coverage about Arwen.
As an individual the only advice I have had for this storm is its a red weather warning .

I dont know what a cobra meeting does and whether it will result in a better response to any after effects or not. Its a bit early to tell. Its clear the response to Arwen was not good enough though..

MarianosOnHisWay · 18/02/2022 09:26

@jowly

Please excuse my southerly ignorance but a genuine question.. where does Nicola Sturgeons responsibility to prepare sit in this?
Nicola Sturgeon isn’t the First Minister of Newcastle and Northumberland
Redact · 18/02/2022 09:26

OP YANBU we were just saying this too. In fact we're still dealing with some damage from storm Arwen

OneTiredMam · 18/02/2022 09:25

YANBU.

The government doesn't care about the north they've made that especially clear time and time again. We had 80 mph winds during that storm and had no power for a week... nobody cared. regularly get 50/60mph winds on a weekly basis in winter... and you never hear about it but the southerners get it? And omg it's all hands on deck. 🙃

Hospedia · 18/02/2022 09:23

We still have a few local businesses who are closed due to damage from Arwen, one was so badly damaged they've got the builders in to strip the place and redo it from the ground up. There are still warnings in place from the council to stay away from wooded areas due to loose trees/tree limbs that haven't yet been dealt with, and council tenants are still being told that only essential/emergency repairs are being carried out to homes as all available staffing resources are still dealing with storm damage repairs.

jowly · 18/02/2022 09:23

Please excuse my southerly ignorance but a genuine question.. where does Nicola Sturgeons responsibility to prepare sit in this?

MarchCrocus · 18/02/2022 09:20

[quote gorgeousbimbam]@trollopolis

Arwen absolutely was a red alert and the fact that you don't know this kinda proves the OP's point.

It was red. They did know. No cobra, no army, no preparation and 250,000 homes without power.

OP, YANBU. If it had happened in Guildford, it would have been a national emergency.[/quote]
Correct.

IamSamantha · 18/02/2022 09:20

I've no idea why I have sad faces 🙄

IamSamantha · 18/02/2022 09:20

@trollopolis

Arwen didn't have 'red' warnings, did it?

You'd only get things like cobra meetings when it's a red

I know the impact was bad, but it wasn't predicted like this one is.

It was red for North East and it wasn't fun. Hundreds of trees down, roofs off houses, flying debris and sadly people did die. Mainly from trees on cars.

I don't recall a cobra meeting. We're still clearing up but we were then hit by a further two Amber wind warnings so anything loosened by Arwen then went as well, and now it's yellow for wind and snow. That's going to be fun......

trollopolis · 18/02/2022 09:18

Thank you - stand corrected!!

(and have changed vote!)

eurochick · 18/02/2022 09:17

I heard loads about Arwen and I wasn't in the affected area.

Due to the areas affected Eunice has the potential to negatively impact many, many more people.

onalittledishy · 18/02/2022 09:17

@EatYourVegetables

I agree. Everyone around here has had serious damage from Arwen, but there were no school closures or people missing work.
Our school was closed for a week after Arwen... no power, damage to the roof, all the boundary fences flattened.
Candleabra · 18/02/2022 09:17

@Hospedia

I think they didn't give a shit because it was in the North of England and Scotland, the same as the Cumbria floods several years ago.
I was just going to say the same thing. As soon as a storm could affect MPs second homes it’s a different matter
gorgeousbimbam · 18/02/2022 09:17

@trollopolis

Arwen absolutely was a red alert and the fact that you don't know this kinda proves the OP's point.

It was red. They did know. No cobra, no army, no preparation and 250,000 homes without power.

OP, YANBU. If it had happened in Guildford, it would have been a national emergency.

onalittledishy · 18/02/2022 09:15

Absolutely, we've been saying this too - the difference in preparation (and media coverage) is pretty stark.

MarianosOnHisWay · 18/02/2022 09:15

@trollopolis

Arwen didn't have 'red' warnings, did it?

You'd only get things like cobra meetings when it's a red

I know the impact was bad, but it wasn't predicted like this one is.

Yes, storm Arwen did have red warnings, up here in the north east