Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inlaws abandoning us to move away

440 replies

mag2305 · 18/02/2022 00:25

My inlaws (in their late 50s) currently live a few miles up the road from us but will be relocating 3 hours away to a countryside location. They've bought this second property as a holiday home but have now decided to live and retire there and my MIL will be taking her 85 year old mum too. The reason they're leaving is just because they like the area better, no other family live there.
My dh found out today and is feeling really upset. Also, because his sister, grandma and uncle knew before us, it just feels extra rubbish. We suspected something was going on as they've been spending more and more time at this holiday home. Plus, they've started getting the grandma's flat redecorated for no reason - well we now know the reason.

We're sad because we have a 3 year old and 7 month old and thought my dh's parents enjoyed being grandparents and seeing us but that's not even been factored in. They've been really unemotional about leaving. My ds especially is really going to miss them as they've had loads to do with him. I feel like they're trying to get away from us maybe and they don't want to help out as grandparents. But we haven't asked that much of them over the years.

I understand that they have their own lives but AIBU to think that they should have more importance on family? It's normally the younger generations who move away, not the older ones.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 22:29

Not everyone needs help. Not everyone gets old. It’s unrealistic and unfair to expect people to live their lives to please other people just in case they might need support when they’re older. Hopefully they’ve got enough money to pay for any help they need. I don’t remember previous generations being so transactional in their relationships.

BearOfEasttown · 18/02/2022 22:20

@LovelyYellowLabrador

They’ll be back when they want looking after in their old age ….

Yeah this. Karma will bite them on the arse if they're not careful.

The OP and her DH, will get used to them not being around to help and become a bit more tough and self sufficient (because she is forced to with no parental support,) and may decide to move on with her family, to somewhere much FURTHER away than 3 hours. And then THEY won't be around to help the in-laws when they're elderly.

Her in-laws should be careful what they wish for.

BearOfEasttown · 18/02/2022 22:19

or maybe they're just not into grandchildren as much as we thought.

@diddl

Oh come on now!

They are only three hours away-you could see each other once a week!

Have you - and the other small handful of posters dismissing a so called 'paltry' 3 hour trip (a 6 hour ROUND trip) got any clue how much of a ballache a SIX hour round trip would be EVERY WEEKEND?

Do people on here actually live in the real world? Confused I can only surmise you people dismissing this distance have shag-all to do in your lives! Can't have if it's just sooooo easy to do one or more '6 hour round-trips' a week to see family!

I agree that the OPs in-laws are showing they are not bothered with too much regular contact... People only move that distance away because they don't really want to be particularly close.

@SirChenjins

No, you were attempting a snarky little dig. Did you do a search for the OP, or did you miraculously just happen to remember that post from a week ago from all the other hundreds/thousands there have been on MN in that time?

Some people do like to do this on here! Going through people old posts to try and dig something up to use against them is really poor form, and sneaky, and stalkerish.

shinynewapple22 · 18/02/2022 22:09

@Sarcobaleno

sorry but yabu. They are already looking after the 85 year old granny, so they are thinking about family. You sound like you're being a bit needy over this. I'm sure they enjoy being grandparents but it's their life, not yours. Be grateful you can live how you want without guilt wherever and however you choose now.

This 100%.

Makes a change from all the posts about interfering in-laws who live too close though !

JudgeJ · 18/02/2022 21:57

@JinglingHellsBells

I don't think that grown up children in their 30s ought to feel 'abandoned'.

These aren't even your own parents- they are in laws.

What right do you have to tell them where to live?

And the reason they are 'unemotional' is probably because they understand that 3 hours is not the end of the world. In reality, it's leaving home at 8am and arriving at 11 am. It's doable for a day, let alone a weekend.

Looking at it the other way, I have friends ( we are middle aged, like your in laws) whose adult children moved to other countries. They clearly were upset, but tried never to show it because they knew that they had to live their own lives.

This is MN where the space-time continuum is different, 3 hours is about 24 hours in the MN world, a lifetime away.
JudgeJ · 18/02/2022 21:52

@hiraffe

Or maybe many of them remember doing it without help and managing just fine.

The old I managed so why can't you argument. Very progressive!

Very progressive!

Very sneery, how the unpalatable is often perceived on MN!

saraclara · 18/02/2022 21:04

@Gilly12345

This sounds wonderful to me, you can live your life without the in-laws butting in.

Also as they are the ones moving away I wouldn’t be putting myself out visiting them too often.

Not everyone hates their inlaws. In fact OP has said that she loves them.
Gilly12345 · 18/02/2022 21:01

This sounds wonderful to me, you can live your life without the in-laws butting in.

Also as they are the ones moving away I wouldn’t be putting myself out visiting them too often.

hiraffe · 18/02/2022 20:45

@saraclara my mum cried when my brother moved from SW London to SE London 😆

hiraffe · 18/02/2022 20:39

OP is a married adult with children - she's not being "abandoned" because her in-laws want to move three hours away

Who claimed she was @fairylightsandwaxmelts?

Your response to a poster who said they were desperate for some support was Or maybe many of them remember doing it without help and managing just fine. Very helpful...

hiraffe · 18/02/2022 20:35

But what do you expect the in-laws to do? Ignore their own needs and wants, forgoing their much anticipated freedoms?

@whumpthereitis
How on earth did you come to that conclusion?

blanketyblanked · 18/02/2022 20:35

They've got one life and most of it is behind them,.not in front. I really admire their getgo and courage to be honest! You should wish them well and visit for amazing holidays

saraclara · 18/02/2022 20:17

[quote mag2305]@hiraffe I think that's probably how my inlaws feel too. They've often told us how they 'managed' with young children and family not local. The strange thing is that my mil's mum did the exact same thing. Moved away with her late husband to live somewhere more rural away from family, grandchildren, etc. Except his health then declined and they moved back because they needed help.[/quote]
We had no family near either. My parents 90 minutes away, my inlaws 2.5 hours. It was fine at the time (we thought). We had no expectations and we visited regularly.

However, now that I'm my adult DD's only parent, and a GM, I have a totally different outlook. I actually feel bad for my inlaws (who were the most loving and lovely people) that we lived so far away and they didn't have day to day contact with their adored DGDs. They never ever showed any resentment or complained, but I do remember my FIL once saying quite wistfully 'It would be so nice if I could just pop in for cup of tea'.

My DD's are 30 and 45 minutes away. If I'm honest, when one of them moved from 20 minutes away to 45, I was a bit gutted (it makes that whole popping in thing more of a trek for DD and DGD).

So yes, despite knowing that they have the right to move wherever they like, I do understand how you feel. You had something that you're losing.

saraclara · 18/02/2022 20:08

@girlmom21

No I recognised her username and couldn't remember why, so I searched it.

I wasn't looking for a snarky dig. I've made a very valid point.

If you don't like it that's your issue.

It's not valid at all. Stop stalking people. It's unnerving.
Thewindwhispers · 18/02/2022 19:26

Yanbu. That’s a real slap in the face, especially with others knowing before you. They obviously don’t appreciate their grandchildren as they should. I’m sorry 😔

whumpthereitis · 18/02/2022 19:24

@hiraffe

Or maybe many of them remember doing it without help and managing just fine.

The old I managed so why can't you argument. Very progressive!

But what do you expect the in-laws to do? Ignore their own needs and wants, forgoing their much anticipated freedoms?

Presumably they’ve spent 18+ years prioritizing raising family, and now they want to live for themselves. Maybe it’s not what you would choose, but it doesn’t make them wrong.

OP will just have to adjust.

loislovesstewie · 18/02/2022 18:48

Do you really want them to stay and be unhappy? Do you want them to think 'I wish we had moved to (wherever) and done (whatever it is they want to do)? Perhaps they promised themselves years ago that one day they would do exactly what they are doing now? I understand that you will miss them but honestly don't you want them to enjoy the here and now?
FWIW, my DH died a month ago. I've told my adult kids to get on with their lives; they aren't my companions, they aren't here to keep me company. They have their own lives to lead and people to see. If they don't do that then it's all pointless. And, in return, they have told me, in no uncertain terms that I have to do whatever makes me happy. At the minute, that is difficult, but it makes me feel that I can get on with things without feeling that they are going to disapprove.
Can you not be happy for them that they are doing things that make them happy?

Sceptre86 · 18/02/2022 18:47

Your views on family don't align with theirs. It's not necessarily wrong. It would be difficult for you if they need care as they get older but it sounds like you and your dh would find a way to still pitch in and support them. I'd be less inclined to do so personally but you sound different.

My parents live 4 hours away and I have 3 kids, one a 5 month old baby. I'm limited to seeing them unless it's holidays but we do go. They come to us and stay with us for a night or two but it's rare as my dad struggles with the journey. They are still very close to my kids and watsapp call everyday do they can see and talk to them. My mil on the other hand lives 10 minutes away and whilst loving expects us to always go to hers. She sees the kids once a week and is not as close to them. That's her choice and I feel she misses out but if that's as much contact as she wants there isn't much we can do. Distance doesn't always mean that family ties will not be as strong, just requires that bit more effort.

BBCONEANDTWO · 18/02/2022 18:31

Just think though - school holidays they will probably want the kids to go there for a few nights. Peace for you and hubby.

jacks11 · 18/02/2022 18:30

I think YABU. You are happy where you are and that’s a good thing. I presume your parents are happy, though you say they would never move even if they weren’t “ because family matters”. This suggests you view that as the only “right way” to do things. But would you genuinely prefer that your PIL to be hankering after something else so that they can be close to you? Would that not create a lot of pressure on you too? If they stay for you, it’s going to be hard to justify you moving if you ever wanted or needed to.

Your PIL are moving to somewhere they really enjoy being because they can now they are retired. It’s great that they can do this whilst they are (presumably) in good health- they only get one life, just like you, and I think they are trying to make the most of it. I get that you might miss them, but 3 hours really isn’t that far.

They maybe didn’t want to say anything before it was decided and sorted as they knew you and DH would be upset and angry, or would try and talk them out of it. Or perhaps they genuinely didn’t feel the need to consult you both about the situation and/or just assumed you’d support their decision if that was what made them happy etc.

I don’t suppose you’d seek approval from them (or your parents, for that matter) if you wanted to move away- either for better job opportunity or because you found somewhere you loved being or any other reason- and how would you feel if they were angry and upset at you for wanting something different? I don’t see why it is ok for younger people to move if they want (or need) to but it’s wrong/unfair for people who have adult children (and even worse if they have DGC).

I suspect if they didn’t take DGM many would accuse them of “leaving you to pick up the slack” and I think you might not be best pleased to be left with that responsibility either.

FWIW, one set of my grandparents lived about 3.5 hours from us and we only really saw them in school holidays (though they phoned every week or so- pre face-time era!)- we would go up and stay for a week or more, sometimes with and sometimes without our parents. They were wonderful grandparents, we had the best times and I have so many wonderful memories of them. We were far closer to them than my other set of grandparents who we saw very regularly as they were 20 minutes away. I think it was partly a personality thing, but I think because they really valued the time we did get they focussed their time and attention on us when we did see them in a way they might not have wanted to/been able to if we’re around all the time. I can’t say for sure, but I just wanted to say that being close by does not guarantee a good, close relationship and being far away does not mean DGP’s cannot have a good, close and loving relationship with their DGC.

I would also say- as someone whose father is in poor health and has been for many years (since he was mid-50’s, actually- so not too dissimilar in age to your PIL), whose health is fading more rapidly as time passes- it’s fine to miss them, but be grateful for what you have. I would love for my dad to be well enough for him and my mum to go off and have an adventure or decide to move somewhere just because they love it there. Even if it meant I’d see them less, and my children would see them less. I think it’s great that your PIL get to fulfill ambitions and do things they want to, go where they want to and experience new things. It could so easily be taken away from them tomorrow or next week or next month or next year…. I say good on them for making the most of their retirement.

Geppili · 18/02/2022 18:18

Do you have abandonment issues from the past? My DM is dead. My DSF is in stage four alcoholism. They have never been interested in us and our DC. Lived 400 miles away. It is sad but you just have to focus on your family. They are still living. It must be a shock, but you will get used to it.

WonderfulYou · 18/02/2022 18:12

YABVU

It’s unfair that you/DH would rather they sacrifice their happiness for your own.
I can see why they told you guys last.

I would be so sad if my parents moved to the other side of the world but I would absolutely support them 100%

They’re only moving 3 hours away so you can easily still see them.
Chances are they’re moving to an area that will be really nice to visit too.

Roussette · 18/02/2022 18:07

@SirChenjins I am so with you on your post.

I had no help whatsoever when mine were young for various reasons but that doesn't mean to say I won't help! I will. But I won't put the rest of my life on hold to just be there for when I'm wanted.

It was so so difficult to have young DCs and look after elderly parents but I did it. How I coped looking back, I have no idea.

I juggled jobs like everyone has to do and I literally did everything I could to give my DCs a good childhood. Then all the teen years, Uni years, helping them move again and again and again... and it never goes away!

I deserve a break and that involves holidays when we want, living where we want and I don't think that's a lot to ask for.

mag2305 · 18/02/2022 18:06

@hiraffe I think that's probably how my inlaws feel too. They've often told us how they 'managed' with young children and family not local. The strange thing is that my mil's mum did the exact same thing. Moved away with her late husband to live somewhere more rural away from family, grandchildren, etc. Except his health then declined and they moved back because they needed help.

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 18/02/2022 18:01

@hiraffe

Or maybe many of them remember doing it without help and managing just fine.

The old I managed so why can't you argument. Very progressive!

Nothing to do with being progressive (or otherwise) - more that maybe many people don't see the need for all the dramatics?

OP is a married adult with children - she's not being "abandoned" because her in-laws want to move three hours away Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread