Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Andy Burnham

163 replies

Thedogscollar · 17/02/2022 23:51

AIBU after watching and listening to Andy Burnham on Question Time to plead with him to be the next Labour Party Leader?

He was engaging, passionate, fair and stood up for the ordinary working families of this nation.

Keir Starmer is a nice enough man but when Andy Burnham speaks he is so passionate about his politics which seems lacking in Keir Starmer.

OP posts:
LightsoftheNorth · 18/02/2022 16:41

@REP22

I liked Andy Burnham for speaking out about Hillsborough.
He only 'spoke out' after being publicly shamed into it. He's since tried to muddy the timeline, but he did absolutely nothing until he was rightly heckled by grieving families. There's a newspaper article online somewhere setting out the timeline of action, but I can't find it annoyingly.

He cynically used the tragedy of Hillsborough to increase his own popularity, whilst the families campaigned, and people like Phil Scraton and David Conn worked so hard to support them and get the truth out.

A few well timed photo opportunities can leave people with a favourable opinion which may not be deserved.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 13:39

@OhWhyNot

Neither was Boris Johnson liked by many when he was mayor of London

But voted for mayor in a labour voting city

I’m not sure mayors are particularly popular but it’s a platform often for those with higher ambitions

Kier Starmer should be way ahead in the polls but he isn’t. Labour need to be looking at the next election he just is t winning over voters

Keir is ahead in the polls.

And London was not (and still isn't) a completely Labour city. Even now there are Conservative seats.

Also, of course, just as with the 2019 general election, people voted against as much as for.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 13:35

That said. If we must have a regionally focused PM, it's well past time that Londoners were levelled up. They've been fucked over for decades.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 13:33

think what he's actually saying is that those who live outside the SE, don't have a voice in parliament/government. Which is fair.

Which country? Not the UK, that's for sure.

London (in the SE of the UK) is the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency. And, yes, there is a housing crisis elsewhere too but nowhere so bad as London. And that's been the case for decades.

Two thirds of all of England's homeless families are in London. That's a majority. There are more homeless in London than the entire population of many UK towns.

Oh and tell the people of deprived SE towns including Jaywick Essex and Gillingham Kent about their 'voice' in Parliament.

Meanwhile we have a chancellor in Parliament who represents the affluent Northern constituency of Richmond, York's.

The talk of 'levelling up'. Where is the 'leveling up' for the many deprived people living struggling in the SE?

Still. Stoking regional division is the lazy and easy option isn't it. Saves on having to come up with actual policies that will help all those left behind. Regardless of where they live.

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:16

@REP22

I liked Andy Burnham for speaking out about Hillsborough.
And I despised him for his blatant grief thievery and cynical populism.
REP22 · 18/02/2022 10:55

I liked Andy Burnham for speaking out about Hillsborough.

Georgeskitchen · 18/02/2022 10:51

Given the fact Burnham is trying to bankrupt Manchester with his clean air charge, I doubt he would be a good bet

FirstAconite · 18/02/2022 10:45

This kind of stunt sums him upv

www.standard.co.uk/news/politics/andy-burnham-manchester-tier-3-funding-robert-jenrick-a4572385.html

It's always about Andy Burnham and furthering his ambitions.

MrsSkylerWhite · 18/02/2022 10:29

sst1234

He’s the epitome of ‘all fur coat and no knickers’. A career politician who would take any job to keep his ambitions to be PM on track. He was gbemm by labor health secretary at the time of PFIs, then ran for leadership, then mysteriously became so interested in local issues in the northwest that became the mayor there. Basically he wanted to distance himself from the rabid marxist takeover of Labour and saw a different route to party leadership one day.“

This. Bends with the wind, always has.

girlmom21 · 18/02/2022 10:25

@inheritancetrack

Keir Starmer is at least very intelligent and I can't say the same for AB or angela Raynor. All the labour party needs now is more left/right wing infighting to see them confined to the dustbin of history. Divided party is putting it mildly
He's a very intelligent man but he's not willing to use that intelligence to win voters because he's scared of saying the wrong things IMO. He does seem to believe in anything. He's got no passion.
trippinglyonthetongue · 18/02/2022 10:24

I mean Labour may well not win the next election - I remember reading at the time of the 2019 result that overturning an 80 seat majority had never/rarely been done within 5 years and that the most optimistic outcome for Labour in 2024 is a hung parliament? I think Starmer has a huge amount of repairing to do and it's a long-term task and would be whoever was leader. Obsessing about the polls now is pointless, though Labour are ahead anyway. A lot will change in the next year as the cost of living crisis hits and we need to see how the Tories deal with that and hope that Labour's response is a strong one. It was tough dealing with Covid as they had to be seen not to be scoring points off it and opposing for the sake of it where public health was concerned. They won't have that problem with this issue and that's got to be a good thing. Getting rid of Starmer would be madness and would take the spotlight off the Tories' leadership issues. And as far as this thread goes, it couldn't go to Burnham now anyway.

inheritancetrack · 18/02/2022 10:23

Keir Starmer is at least very intelligent and I can't say the same for AB or angela Raynor. All the labour party needs now is more left/right wing infighting to see them confined to the dustbin of history. Divided party is putting it mildly

Nightlystroll · 18/02/2022 10:19

@Thedogscollar

AIBU after watching and listening to Andy Burnham on Question Time to plead with him to be the next Labour Party Leader?

He was engaging, passionate, fair and stood up for the ordinary working families of this nation.

Keir Starmer is a nice enough man but when Andy Burnham speaks he is so passionate about his politics which seems lacking in Keir Starmer.

As a Mancunian it's great to see people admire our elected officials. Can I ask you to name some of the great things he's done for Manchester?
Otherpeoplesteens · 18/02/2022 10:11

I worked in the NHS when he was SoS for Health, in a role where what he said in public mattered. He was a liability, and the reason he comes across as likeable is because he gives the impression of giving you exactly what you want when it's really not in his gift to do so. So there were a few occasions where he said something in a speech, NHS managers rushed to adopt it as gospel, and we found ourselves wide open to litigation.

He easy to listen to and for some easy on the eye, but he is a naked populist, just clever enough not to sound like one. Just look at how he has vacillated over the Greater Manchester Clean Air Zone, promising voters that it won't impact them personally and suddenly backtracking when he realised it is toxic to small businesses, the owners of which happen to be voters too.

He'll never make a decent leader because he simply does not understand either responsibility or accountability, or the difference between the two.

As Mayor of Greater Manchester he can get away with talking an awful lot without actually doing anything, and everything is always someone else's responsibility, although that says as much about how much real power has been devolved as it does about the little weasel himself.

OhWhyNot · 18/02/2022 10:10

Let’s hope Labour become more ambitious than just being the better party this isn’t enough

Labour should be so far ahead in the polls and they are not

SNUG2022 · 18/02/2022 10:07

Full on TWAW, so no.

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 10:06

Well Starmer will not win the next election

Let’s hope your crystal ball’s malfunctioning.

OhWhyNot · 18/02/2022 10:04

Well Starmer will not win the next election

Labour should take that chance can be down swiftly polices will not be hugely different and I don’t think many people care about the party looking inwards if they think the leader could do a good job at leading the country

That the problem with Labour they are too self absorbed about party politics that most don’t care about rather than getting voters to vote for them

CorrBlimeyGG · 18/02/2022 10:02

Your obviously not from Manchester as he is not well liked here as our mayor

He got 70% of the vote at the last election, an increase from the previous one. And that's before the second round votes were counted (they didn't count them as it was a clear win). That level of support is very rare in mayoral elections.

Datgal · 18/02/2022 09:59

He's very relatable.. normal sounding bloke. We need someone like that on our sides. Not the utter ridiculousness we have in power at the moment.
My bf is from greater Manchester and he was given a great chance after some difficulties on some amazing courses funded by Andy Burnham in GM. He'd always get my vote.

trippinglyonthetongue · 18/02/2022 09:58

The very last thing Labour needs now is another leadership election. It would take up all their energy in the two years leading up to the GE and there definitely wouldn't be any clear policies coming through until the new person was bedded in with a team around them. They would look self-obsessed and inward looking rather than caring about the electorate. When campaigning starts we'll get a fair look at the policies but they have a long way to go as a result of the disastrous Corbyn years.

MapleMay11 · 18/02/2022 09:56

@trippinglyonthetongue

Kier Starmer should be way ahead in the polls but he isn’t. Labour need to be looking at the next election he just is t winning over voters

Labour are ahead in the polls at the moment and have been for a few weeks. Someone upthread said it should be a Labour landslide if there was a GE next week and it wouldn't be and that's Keir Starmer's fault. I completely disagree with that. Tories got a massive majority a couple of years ago and overturning that was never going to be easy for Labour no matter who their leader was. It's relatively easy for Burnham to pop up now and again shouting about the north and being quite bombastic. There are many who find that appealing and call it charisma, but just as many who don't. As leader of the opposition he'd have had more airtime and would have had to appeal to a broader base. I don't think he'd have been any more of a miracle worker than Starmer has been.

I've been disappointed with Starmer at some points over the last two years but I think he's finding his feet and is finally cutting through, though he's obviously being helped by the Tories at the moment. I'm sick of people saying he has no policies when Labour have clearly set out alternative plans for the fuel price rises and coming out of Covid and there's loads more detail about longer term stuff on their website too.

I think Burnham would be quite divisive as leader and I agree with those who didn't like seeing him go against Yvette Cooper - nasty attitude came through too often. I just think anyone who wants the Tories out needs to get behind the leader we now have in KS at the moment.

Labour's lead dropped hugely when a more representative sample of the population was polled.

Kier Starmer is unelectable. Even when the Tories are at rock bottom, Starmer remains a weak, bumbling buffoon with no ideas on how to take the party forward.

MapleMay11 · 18/02/2022 09:51

He’s the epitome of ‘all fur coat and no knickers’. A career politician who would take any job to keep his ambitions to be PM on track.

That just about sums him up in my opinion.

Violetparis · 18/02/2022 09:49

I am from Greater Manchester and he is well liked as Mayor amongst the people I know. I like his passion and he seems relatable, something Keir Starmer is lacking.