Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Andy Burnham

163 replies

Thedogscollar · 17/02/2022 23:51

AIBU after watching and listening to Andy Burnham on Question Time to plead with him to be the next Labour Party Leader?

He was engaging, passionate, fair and stood up for the ordinary working families of this nation.

Keir Starmer is a nice enough man but when Andy Burnham speaks he is so passionate about his politics which seems lacking in Keir Starmer.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 19/02/2022 13:16

@sst1234

It’s amazing how people get taken in by a career politician with a track record of delivering precisely 0. It’s also reflective of what the Labour Party have become. The choices are current woeful leadership or people like this chancer who’ll take any job and say anything to further his future leadership bid.
Because the Tories are so much better. Allowing the most corrupt politician of my lifetime to cling to power because they can’t think of anyone better. Best to look at what’s happening on your political doorstep before you start criticising the opposition @sst1234.
NETSRIK · 19/02/2022 12:56

I think he would be a great PM.

Armadeus · 19/02/2022 11:40

@MarshaBradyo don't worry. Starmer changed his mind re the £15 nmw. Hence Andy Mcdonald resigning and the hard left revolting.

Alexandra2001 · 19/02/2022 10:59

Andy Burnham doesn't come under media scrutiny like Starmer does, if he did become labour leader, he would have to speak a lot more carefully and behave differently.

We have a choice, a decent hard working former lawyer & family man vs a former journalist, sacked twice for lying, with a string of women & children betrayed behind him.

Yet for some reason we want Boris... if any woman came on here with a partner like Boris, we'd all be shouting LTB !!!!

Zonder · 19/02/2022 10:49

People who resort to slamming someone for being a career politician really make me laugh. There are career politicians in all parties and being one isn't necessarily a bad thing. It can show dedication and passion. And of course not being a career politician doesn't make someone any better. Just look at our current PM.

sst1234 · 19/02/2022 10:13

It’s amazing how people get taken in by a career politician with a track record of delivering precisely 0. It’s also reflective of what the Labour Party have become. The choices are current woeful leadership or people like this chancer who’ll take any job and say anything to further his future leadership bid.

Louisianagumbo · 19/02/2022 00:21

It sounds like your party politics mean you are not going to accept anything good said about him.

You have no idea what my politics are. Anyone can talk and promise, but you have to deliver. You live in GM and you voted for him. If you've got good things to say about him, persuade me I'm wrong to not rate him. I asked you to give me some examples of what he's achieved for GM in his 6 years of being a mayor. You couldn't give me one.

Also if Manchester was offered £60 million but that was dropped to £22 million, don't you think that shows central government in a worse light than AB O_o Or do you think its ok for places that voted a representative in from a different party to be 'punished' for trying to negotiate a better deal for local people?

Well done. You've just found another skill he hasn't got. Negotiation. When you're negotiating, you need to get what you can but to refuse an offer so you end up with nothing, is not good negotiation. The govt offered 60m as a proportionate amount that had been offered and received by L'pool and Lancs. The 60m was never withdrawn. Burnham just refused to take it. The 22m was a separate amount and was given to help implement restrictions. There's no punishment. There was a formula that was used to calculate the funding for each area. Others, including labour areas, accepted it. AB thought he could push for more and he ended up with nothing. GM businesses still got funding but it was more complicated because of Burnhams actions.

I also find the comparison to the Liverpool mayor in bad taste, given he had lost a close family member to covid he made different choices, who can say if mass testing in GM would have the same effect given the difference *in population size.

Anderson took up the offer of mass testing, indeed he pushed to get it. It had a massive impact reducing Liverpool from having the highest areas to the lowest areas. Why is that in bad taste to point that out because his brother died? Anderson looked at the science and made the appropriate decision. Burnham was actually critical of the mass testing and told L'pool they were wasting their time because it wouldn't work. Except it did.

I'd have been for it but as far as I can see nowhere else in England took it up either.

You are very wrong. After seeing L'pool's success, 67 areas in England started doing mass testing. It was so successful that they couldn't keep up with demand and by the time it got to where I lived, they targeted it at certain groups rather than to the whole population.

Plus the funding offered to Liverpool was more per head than Manchester, you can't just compare the lump sum, and that was one of AB arguments for continuing the negotiations.

As I said above, it was worked out based on a formula. No one else refused the package they were offered other than the Burnham. While he was arguing, the hospitals were pleading for a lockdown because they were on the verge of being overrun. Ultimately, the govt locked GM down and Burnham walked away with no money. He's a tactical genius.

Having said all of that, I'm happy to hear your description of his successes as mayor. Prove me wrong for thinking he's a dud.

AlternativelyWired · 18/02/2022 21:28

He was a good health secretary but now he doesn't know what a woman is, doesn't respond to questions from the people of Manchester and has become a bit of a plonker imo. I voted for him as our mayor too. Wouldn't do it again.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/02/2022 20:45

@Louisianagumbo it sounds like your party politics mean you are not going to accept anything good said about him. As I said I'm not a labor voter so I did take the time to listen to all the candidates and there was not a single offering on par with him.

Also if Manchester was offered £60 million but that was dropped to £22 million, don't you think that shows central government in a worse light than AB O_o Or do you think its ok for places that voted a representative in from a different party to be 'punished' for trying to negotiate a better deal for local people?

I also find the comparison to the Liverpool mayor in bad taste, given he had lost a close family member to covid he made different choices, who can say if mass testing in GM would have the same effect given the difference in population size. I'd have been for it but as far as I can see nowhere else in England took it up either.

Plus the funding offered to Liverpool was more per head than Manchester, you can't just compare the lump sum, and that was one of AB arguments for continuing the negotiations.

RestingStitchFace · 18/02/2022 20:30

I don't think Starmer has any less conviction. I just think he's a calmer personality type - people place too much emphasis on personality imo. Look at Boris - all charisma and absolutely no moral scruples or skill.

(And Tbh, unless Labour change their stance on protecting the rights of natal women and girls, I wouldn't vote for any of them....)

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 20:18

Still no reason for labelling him a misogynistic homophobe, then? Thought not.

VikingLundyMalin · 18/02/2022 20:00

[quote ExtraOnion]I live in Greater Manchester … I love our King of the North .. as do the huge percentage of people who voted for him.

For those interested in the facts about the CAZ, rather that the Tory propaganda about it .. please read this recently released statement. The CAZ was anyways, and remains, a government initiative, with govt decided deadlines.

andyformayor.co.uk/2022/02/18/personal-statement-by-rt-hon-andy-burnham-mayor-of-greater-manchester-on-the-gm-clean-air-zone/[/quote]
What has he actually done to deserve the title King of the North. The North is a big place, he's done nothing for Greater Manchester - the rest of the north are better off without him.

VikingLundyMalin · 18/02/2022 19:58

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Everyone in my local Labour Party want Andy Burnham as leader.

Down to earth.

We need a leader not someone who is down to earth.
VikingLundyMalin · 18/02/2022 19:57

@AngelicaElizaAndPeggy

He's all kind of noble and fierce and stands up for the north. I think he's great.
Noble and fierce are not words I would use to describe Andy Burnham - what has he done to bring you to this conclusion?
Louisianagumbo · 18/02/2022 19:56

@ExtraOnion
I live in Greater Manchester … I love our King of the North .. as do the huge percentage of people who voted for him.

16% of the electorate voted for him. It's not really huge, is it?

gluenotsoup · 18/02/2022 19:54

He’s my mayor. Not sure I would vote for him, not much has improved in things I feel strong about. But he does have fabulous eyelashes. ….

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 19:50

Andy (and Keir - and the Conservatives too) should read this excellent article by Omar Khan on the, as he says, lazy and reductive “London is cosmopolitan elite” narrative

citymonitor.ai/government/why-aren-t-working-class-people-living-cities-also-left-behind-4694

Even 72 people dying in the Grenfell Tower tragedy, a preventable fire which happened within sight of Parliament, hasn’t dislodged the dominant narrative of London as a leafy cosmopolitan elite bubble.

Tealightsandd · 18/02/2022 19:48

And yes there has always been areas of London that vote Tory but for some time now London has been a Labour voting city (being considered London centric has been an issues since Blair times)

Take a voter base for granted at your peril.

Blair was possibly London centric (in the same way that a vampire relates to his victim) but he sure as hell wasn't Londonder centric. That hasn't been a thing for decades. Very much the opposite.

Hopefully both Labour and the Conservatives will finally look to levelling up London soon. It's badly needed.

They may not care about Londoners, but would be ill advised to continue ignoring a massive voter base. Who knows, if they keep going, both could lose London. Just as Scotland went to the SNP (albeit with some resurged support for the Scottish Tories).

Louisianagumbo · 18/02/2022 19:48

@LivingDeadGirlUK

I was really impressed with him during the pandemic, sticking up for Manchester, who were going to be given so much less cash per head than other (Tory or London) areas of the UK, in funding for businesses etc. I think he has done well as Mayor in a city that is predominantly labor voting, with the current government everything is a battle. My MP used to love taking pot shots at him (really useless ones that backfired every time) before he defected to labor.

If you watched the Mayoral debates (both this time and the first) he was so far above the other candidates it was like they had just dragged any old person in off the street, I'm not actually a labor voter so was really open to who I voted for but he was hands down the best candidate.

I'd like to see him in the leadership role but I'm not sure its what he wants. I think Keir is ok but he needs a bit more gusto.

He stuck up for Manchester? He refused to lockdown even though all of GMs hospitals were at the point of collapse and their doctors were begging him to lockdown. He refused a 60m offer of funding to hold out for 65m and so ended up 22m. And the govt locked down anyway. Brilliant!

Meanwhile in Liverpool, another Labour stronghold, the mayor accepted the offer from the govt and locked down. And Anderson went further he actively pursued the offer of having mass testing through his region. The result was from having the highest figures in the North West, they fell to the lowest. So you'd think Burnham would be supporting that, but no. Burnham in fact said that mass testing was a waste of time because they'd tried it in GM and it didn't work. Strange that it worked so well in Liverpool but Burnham couldn't make it work in GM.

I'm interested to hear about him doing well as the mayor. Give me some examples of what he's achieved. He's had six years so he must have achieved quite a few things by now.

When he was in govt, he never managed to hold a ministerial role for longer than a year. So if you think he wouldn't drop Manchester like a hot coal to be Labour leader, you have absolutely zero idea of who Andy Burnham is.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 18/02/2022 19:45

Yes Yvette cooper. I also liked Emily thingy. She had such a calm manner. Imagine her in charge of a pandemic instead of twat face.

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 19:38

Yvette Cooper would be a good shout.

Zonder · 18/02/2022 19:36

@KookaburraSits

Labour are well overdue for a female leader, not another bloke. It's embarrassing that the other parties have managed it and they haven't.
Who would you suggest?
KookaburraSits · 18/02/2022 19:17

Labour are well overdue for a female leader, not another bloke. It's embarrassing that the other parties have managed it and they haven't.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/02/2022 19:16

Lots of hate for the clean air zone I see, I think its a great idea but then I do work on one of the most congested roads in the country outside of London. My feelings aside, its all come from central government. They have also been trying to bring in a congestion charge for Manchester for over 10 years, this is just one of the things we need to do to live in a greener society.

I remember my MP wrote an open letter to AB with another Tory MP during the pandemic about how disgraceful some policy was. They looked like a pair of idiots given the policy was dictated by central government. We seem to live in a time where politicians just say whatever they want and see if they can get it to stick!

OhWhyNot · 18/02/2022 19:15

There isn’t anyone that will have the same appeal as Boris did but he would be replaced if Starmer was more of a threat

He won’t ever be considered the worse PM for the Tories not with an 80 seat majority

It doesn’t matter that you or I think he isn’t great at debating (he never has been his strength is speeches and winning voters over) and that is a big part of elections