Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel concerned children (not all!) are a generation of screen addicts

120 replies

Sadbabysitter · 17/02/2022 23:38

I’ve been babysitting for many, many families for more than 15 years……

Over the last couple of years, although much more so recently, I’ve found very young children having literally hours of screen time during the day.

As a babysitter, I always want to engage with and play with the children, without the distraction of screens.
Not all families, but a concerning amount, will tell you their child (often 1/2/3/4 years old), likes the tv or phone/tablet and they have it on/in their hand as a default and it don’t be removed.

One child I’ve cared for since almost one year old and he watches coco melon for 4 hours straight while I care for him. If I turn it off he cries and mum tells me he wants it on all day long, so she puts it on for him. She laughs and says ‘he’s addicted’ which he is! He won’t play outside, build a tower of bricks, push a toy train………….

While it’s on (or any other screen) it’s impossible to develop any meaningful engagement with a child. They are drawn back to the screen, lying, sitting or just rolling around on the floor watching.

As a babysitter, I want the child to feel happy and comfortable and I will always work with the parents wishes, but this doesn’t feel right.
If the parent leaves the house, I will turn the device off and say ‘ah, it’s not working’ and I can then distract them with other activities, albeit with them regularly asking for the screen, maybe having a little cry at first. However, increasingly, parents need me to care for their child while they’re working in another room and they are clear that the device is to stay on.

Yesterday I was with a one year old who had her dad’s device in her hand from 6pm - 10pm with coco melon and other kids shows playing. He gave it to her when I arrived and was in the house the entire time so I couldn’t take it away as she cried and he told me she wanted it. Whenever we went into the living room dad put coco melon on the tv for her. She was exhausted but apparently doesn’t sleep until after 10pm - little wonder with the constant stimulation of shows!

Coco melon is the worse for turning tiny children into zombies, unable to take their eyes from the screen.

So my AIBU is, to be concerned that we are raising a generation of children who are sedentary, can’t use their imagination or focus on a task, can’t cope without the continuous pop of dopamine they are getting from these bright and rapidly changing images and this is going to lead to serious mental health problems in the future?

OP posts:
SushiGo · 18/02/2022 09:22

I limited my kids screen time a lot as young kids, they are still screen addicted now as tweens/teens.

I don't think they would be so bad, but we had to get then individual devices to do school work during lockdown (2x full time working parents) and that really fucked up our ability to meaningfully limit their use. (Its really easy to sneak off and hide with a smaller screen!)

The idea that children self limit is just laughable to me. With busy distracted parents while we working I lockdown the kids never ever got bored of screens. And the more time they spent on them they harder they found it to come up with other activity ideas.

We're working on it. But it's bloody hard to change these patterns. I do feel sorry for parents who were trying to work with toddlers during lockdowns I agree the damage could be immense.

Sadbabysitter · 18/02/2022 09:21

@Pumpfive I’m a babysitter.
Ad hoc sitting for lots of families.
A lot of evening work, but often 4- 6 hour periods during the day time, for various reasons.
The evening referenced in my OP I was booked from 6pm - 10pm and the child had the screen the entire time. She was exhausted, but I was told not to put her to bed as she ‘doesn’t sleep’. Dad was there the whole time, so I couldn’t over rule.
He couldn’t see the stimulation of the screen was keeping her brain awake when she was actually very tired.

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 18/02/2022 09:16

I am continually horrified that friends buy their toddlers their own tablets. I mean why?

Macademiamum · 18/02/2022 09:05

That Dad sounds awful. But I don't think the fault is with coco melon and their catchy songs and hypnotic images, or even with screen time in general. He sounds like an utterly inept parent, and we have a word for parents who cannot set boundaries and meet their children's need. That is neglect.
The thousands of parents using Cocomelon to stop their toddlers bouncing off the walls for hours today whilst nursery is cancelled due to the storm? That's not neglect, it's a parenting tool.
Misuse of anything is not ok. Kids doing homework? Great, supporting their learning, absolutely. Kids doing homework every moment they aren't in school? Miserable, depressing, no way to live. Kids doing exercise? Fabulous, joyful, healthy. Kids being made to exercise all day every day? Straight up abuse.
It's the same with screens. There is a healthy medium

ringoutthebells · 18/02/2022 08:47

I agree and it's a real concern, but these families sound extreme and personally I'd refuse to work with them and find others more in line with your values - they are out there. Not saying they don't exist, but I don't know anyone who uses screens to this extent with such young children, or even older.

It really is tough though, dd was very limited in her preschool years but it does become harder as they develop their own lives and preferences at school, we can't control every aspect of it. I do feel sad that it is now just accepted to be a thing (eg pretty much all 11+ year olds have a smart phone, tv & computer time at school from the very start) - it makes it very hard to opt out, even if you don't agree.

Beachsidesunset · 18/02/2022 08:36

When they're adults they're highly likely to be staring at a screen for 8 hours a day. Aren't they just being prepared for the world of work?

ExactlyThat · 18/02/2022 08:29

It really worries me that people don’t care or don’t do their own research. All of my friends with older children have their kids on fb and ig, TikTok etc because it’s the norm but don’t teach them how to limit their time or explain why.

I myself am a phone addict and I hate it, so I am mean mummy with my kids and don’t let them on screens until after lunch every day and then I have to seriously regulate them. They would sit there staring as a screen 24/7 if I let them.

Jamaicatheyhaveabobsledteam · 18/02/2022 08:24

I agree. I am unusual in my friendship and child’s school group that he doesn’t have access to a tablet and very rarely a phone. He watches tv weekends but rarely during the week as it affects his behaviour (year r so very very tired!). We are having a tv day today as storm has cancelled school. I know I use my phone and try not to but it is addictive and I don’t want that for him until he’s old enough to regulate. My husband works in IT and he is very against him having his own tablet.

Xtraincome · 18/02/2022 08:24

Excessive screen time, I feel, should fall into the neglect category too.
Screens are great for downtime and it's important for kids to enjoy them. However, we rely on parents, some of whom didn't want kids, to stimulate their children and assist in their development.

Each generation has different ways to neglect their children

Hospedia · 18/02/2022 08:20

All four of my DC, from reception up to Year 8, have online homework too.

Mamamia7962 · 18/02/2022 08:20

I see lots of adults pushing prams whilst looking at their phones. There's also a lady I see regularly walking her dog, well I say walking him, she just ambles along whilst looking at her phone, unaware of anything else. I feel like shouting to her just walk the fucking dog.

Hospedia · 18/02/2022 08:20

So I don't think it has to be 30 minutes of TV on a Sunday and no other access to devises or screen zombies, there's a space in the middle but it's about parent interaction

Exactly this. Screen time isn't necessarily bad. I don't limit my DC time but they're fairly good at self-regulating and if I think they've been on too long they cone off when told. They play out, they go to groups, they call on friends, they draw, they play games, it's all in moderation. My older two DC do 90% of their reading on a screen as DD likes her kindle and their school reading scheme is all online and weekly spellings and grammar are issued/practiced via an app.

lololololollll · 18/02/2022 08:19

I've always got some kind of tv on in the background, sometimes they watch it but mostly we are reading and playing. Don't see an issue when it's like this, I always had tv on in the background as a kid

MsTSwift · 18/02/2022 08:16

It’s worse for tiny children as those developmental stages and learning about the world are so key. Glad phones weren’t around when mine were pre schoolers.

ThatsNotMyGolem · 18/02/2022 08:15

It's definitely additive.

DD (18 months) watches Hebrew songs and kids shows on YouTube (apart from DH and MIL, it's the only way to teach her Hebrew) and she gets visibly annoyed when I switch it off after a couple of songs.

Furbulousnous · 18/02/2022 08:11

What you are describing is bordering on neglect, but I don’t know if anyone who lets their young children watch screens like that regularly let alone with a babysitter in the house.

Pumpfive · 18/02/2022 08:05

Are you a babysitter or a nanny? Babysitter is usually evening time when children are asleep or at least going to sleep. It's nannying in the day..you seem to spend a lot of time with them to know this much about them so I assume it's nannying.
I nanny for some kids who don't have a limit on screen time per se, however I don't use the TV much. My rules tend to be no tv for kids who nap (the ones who nap may get some screen time maybe once a month) then once they reach the no napping age, they get maybe 30 mins after lunch. I work 11 hour days. With obviously no break because I'm always in charge of them so I use screen time as a way for me to have a 'break' for 30 mins. So if I have napping kids, I don't need to use screen time.

NumberTheory · 18/02/2022 03:33

When I saw your title I assumed I was going to think you were BU. But what you describe is a concern. In fact it shocks me a bit. As someone said above, it sounds neglectful. That you are experiencing it a lot with parents able to pay for babysitting when they are in the house (presumably working or similar), and that the parents are the ones pushing for the screens to stay on rather than wanting to take advantage of having an adult there who would play with the kids - that's a worry. It sounds like these parents aren't just making the best of a bad situation where they have few resources, but instead have missed the memo on what young children need to develop well. If that's happening a lot it's definitely a cause for concern.

fiveminutebreak · 18/02/2022 03:05

It is a huge concern. But not just for the kids. Many parents really struggle with their own screen addiction and not interacting with their kids, just glued to a device . It's really sad. My kids are 10 and 8 and things seem to have got worse in that time. My eldest didn't watch any TV until he was nearly 2 because the advice then was that it's damaging for v young children. That advice seems to have gone by the wayside now. And it's much more common to see toddlers with a small screen in their hands.

TibetanTerrah · 18/02/2022 02:59

I once babysat a friend's young child with a similar screen addiction. The thing that struck me was the complete lack of strength and dexterity in their hands and fingers. I brought over some games and we were playing pop up pirate, and they couldn't push the little knives in. I really believe it's connected to using screens and swiping, rather than developing motor skills like we did in my childhood with lego and stuff Sad

SleepingStandingUp · 18/02/2022 02:56

We don't limit screen time and all three do love their telly BUT 6 year old will happily declare a TV break and turn it off, 2 year olds will also be happy without it. All three are really physical and active, love having the music on to dance, play imaginatively with their toys, love playing in other rooms (only have a TV in the living room) etc. These an xbox that's used occasionally, and eldest gets limited time on kids YouTube on my phone at specific times (late bus back after gymnastics for example). No Switches or tablets etc.

So I don't think it has to be 30 minutes of TV on a Sunday and no other access to devises or screen zombies, there's a space in the middle but it's about parent interaction.

MangyInseam · 18/02/2022 02:50

Yes, it is impacting small children entering school. They don't have the skills in terms of speech and motor coordination that earlier generations had.

I suspect that in the future people will look back on kids with screens similarly to the way we look at adults in the past giving kids laudanum or letting them smoke.

SpringTime2020 · 18/02/2022 02:48

I don't know...every generation thinks the younger generation will be ruined.

I mean what you describe doesn't sound good. But most DC my DD's age (9) if her and her friends are anything to go by don't really watch much TV and when they do half the time they are still bouncing around and doing cart wheels not just sitting staring at it! Their main 'screen time' is playing games like Animal Crossing or Roblox. These games are very social and imaginative and they all play together.

Aside from that they love being active - dancing and gymnastics classes are popular, racing around playing games at Brownies, skipping in the playground at playtime, bouncing on their trampolines at home and playing in the park after school.

LimeSegment · 18/02/2022 02:39

So I think you as a babysitter shouldn't take so much worry on to your own shoulders. What will happen will happen.

Even though I agree and cringe when I see babies with screens.

LimeSegment · 18/02/2022 02:37

Yes there probably is.

I meant more from the perspective of, children are going to become screen addicts anyway. Growing up without screen didn't prevent that. So although I personally ban screens for my kids, I don't put too much of my hopes for their futures in to doing that. If you see what i mean.