Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel concerned children (not all!) are a generation of screen addicts

120 replies

Sadbabysitter · 17/02/2022 23:38

I’ve been babysitting for many, many families for more than 15 years……

Over the last couple of years, although much more so recently, I’ve found very young children having literally hours of screen time during the day.

As a babysitter, I always want to engage with and play with the children, without the distraction of screens.
Not all families, but a concerning amount, will tell you their child (often 1/2/3/4 years old), likes the tv or phone/tablet and they have it on/in their hand as a default and it don’t be removed.

One child I’ve cared for since almost one year old and he watches coco melon for 4 hours straight while I care for him. If I turn it off he cries and mum tells me he wants it on all day long, so she puts it on for him. She laughs and says ‘he’s addicted’ which he is! He won’t play outside, build a tower of bricks, push a toy train………….

While it’s on (or any other screen) it’s impossible to develop any meaningful engagement with a child. They are drawn back to the screen, lying, sitting or just rolling around on the floor watching.

As a babysitter, I want the child to feel happy and comfortable and I will always work with the parents wishes, but this doesn’t feel right.
If the parent leaves the house, I will turn the device off and say ‘ah, it’s not working’ and I can then distract them with other activities, albeit with them regularly asking for the screen, maybe having a little cry at first. However, increasingly, parents need me to care for their child while they’re working in another room and they are clear that the device is to stay on.

Yesterday I was with a one year old who had her dad’s device in her hand from 6pm - 10pm with coco melon and other kids shows playing. He gave it to her when I arrived and was in the house the entire time so I couldn’t take it away as she cried and he told me she wanted it. Whenever we went into the living room dad put coco melon on the tv for her. She was exhausted but apparently doesn’t sleep until after 10pm - little wonder with the constant stimulation of shows!

Coco melon is the worse for turning tiny children into zombies, unable to take their eyes from the screen.

So my AIBU is, to be concerned that we are raising a generation of children who are sedentary, can’t use their imagination or focus on a task, can’t cope without the continuous pop of dopamine they are getting from these bright and rapidly changing images and this is going to lead to serious mental health problems in the future?

OP posts:
chocolatebrowniesaddict · 19/02/2022 02:57

Technology is part of our lives now so as long as there is a balance, I don't find it particularly concerning. I have a friend who vocally makes it known that she has never allowed screen time and while telling us all of this, her two kids are sitting with us and she's constantly scrolling through instagram and replying to WhatsApp messages. It's like having a parent smoking next to you and telling the child that smokings bad. I allow screen time when we are travelling or when we are dining in a restaurant to keep my little one occupied enough so I could eat in peace but all day everyday, the TV is off and the toys are out during a rainy day. During a non rainy day, it's outdoors and some activities. If I need to use the loo or get something done without my toddler following me, then I put some screen time.

wtfwasthatmate · 19/02/2022 01:55

@HiDay

Saddest I saw was a child who at four had no idea how to turn a page in a book. He kept swiping at a corner to try and make it move on.
😂😂😂

Honestly fucking hell. You should be on the cover of the daily fail with a sad face.

Tv has been around for a long time. So have things like Nintendo's etc. You can put limits on things but somehow suggesting that your toddler is corrupted from Cocomelon is ridiculous. Speech pathologists actually recommend Cocomelon and Yakka Dee for children who are speech delayed.

A lot of schools insist on a laptop in high school so it's hard to prevent at that age.

As long as you make sure your child has plenty of other activities in their lives screen time won't ruin them.

whatdodos · 18/02/2022 23:10

My 4 year old has a tablet which he loves and plays games on, some educational some not. But I think I'm lucky that he's not addicted and actually really loves outside play/nature, building, board games etc just as much or even equally. If I ask him to turn it off so we go for a walk he will happily do so then we will spend hours outside with nature collecting sticks, bird spotting, splashing in puddles etc. I think knowing when enough is enough is key. I'm probably more of a screen addict than him and didn't grow up with that much technology

Ozanj · 18/02/2022 22:57

And it’s why non-interactive content like their own videogames consoles / TV / mobiles are not appropriate until after a child has developed their core physical, social and language skills. I would say 11 at the earliest. But there is research to suggest kids shouldn’t have unrestricted non-interactive screen time until after 14-16 as their brains are just not wired to be able to regulate it.

Ozanj · 18/02/2022 22:54

@MangyInseam

Yes, it is impacting small children entering school. They don't have the skills in terms of speech and motor coordination that earlier generations had.

I suspect that in the future people will look back on kids with screens similarly to the way we look at adults in the past giving kids laudanum or letting them smoke.

You are wrong. High rates of Educational TV / ipad watching after the age of 2 has been linked to higher attainment in kids as it’s considered a ‘social screen’. Anything that requires a parent’s input, even if it’s so the child has to ask them for a certain channel or ask them how to use a remote, develops language.

It is why many nurseries use screens.

For example DS is 2 and loves TV. Is addicted but I make sure he never gets more than 1-2 hours. He speaks in full sentences in 2 languages, has started hopping and jumping (becsuse he wants to copy the kids he sees on his shows), can climb about 6 ft up our tree, and is now talking fairly knowledgeably about tractors and helicopers and has developed an interest in knowing more since he saw a Blippi episode about them.

So it’s not the screen but the content. Anyone’s brain would rot if all they watched were the shitty random YouTube videos (crashing cars et c).

SoberCurious78 · 18/02/2022 22:38

I agree with OP that one year olds shouldn’t have screen time but I do laugh abit with all the posters claiming their 3,4,5 year old barely watch tv, they play and read etc
Well so did my two and I was one of those parents being strict but once they get to year5,6 there’s no way you’ll find it that easy anymore to say no to a tablet or screen time
I let my year 5 and 6 children have screen time but I refuse them insta, tik tok, you tube etc but as all their class friends are allowed these apps it’s causing daily arguments why they can’t have it and they will now always choose their phone rather than read a book during the day

SoberCurious78 · 18/02/2022 22:26

@SushiGo

Same here, I’ve been always very strict with screen time, no tablet or phone when younger, not too much tv- lots of outdoorsy stuff etc
Then they grew bit older, the last ones Of their peers to get a tablet or phone and now they’re just as addicted as their peers
Playing roblox with friends hours on end ( a habit which started in lockdown)
I find schools not helping too as all homework now set online all the time. Why can’t they just print off homework sheets 🙄
So hard to encourage them to other things now and feel quite sad as despite us trying so hard we still ended up with screen dependent kids and it’s a daily battle to get them off the screens ( and daily arguments as their peers dont have screen time settings etc)

IWasFunBeforeMum · 18/02/2022 22:24

I've banned Coco melon. Mine are 4 and nearly 3 and I limit screen time as much as possible because they're like zombies when it's on!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 18/02/2022 22:19

I don't really limit DS's screen time. He's nearly 9 though so not a toddler. We do plenty of other activities and days out. He does hobbies. He does well at school. Homework always done. Good social skills and plenty of friends. So I've no issue with him using screens when we're chilling out at home. He's not "addicted" and doesn't throw a strop if I tell him to turn it off.

Screens are the future whether we like it or not. A lot of us do jobs that involve us staring at a screen all day.

70kid · 18/02/2022 22:13

I’m on holiday at the moment
and I would say 8-out of 10 kids has a screen of some sort
Doesn’t matter if it’s by the pool in the restaurants in the bar they are all sat around on screens watching something and generally so are their parents 😂😂

Pyri · 18/02/2022 21:40

Coco melon is the worst

VestaTilley · 18/02/2022 21:38

YANBU, I agree completely.

Children raised like that will never have the attention span to read a novel, will be behind in speech and language and will end up with Lord knows what developmental issues. It’s awful.

My DS watches appropriate children’s TV (with me and/or DH, not alone unless we’re popping to the kitchen for 2 mins) and he is never ever allowed on our phones or ipad, and we don’t get our phones out around him.

It’s really harmful and I will do my best to keep my child from it as long as I can, while understanding they need to know how these things work at school.

Too many parents are lazy and use them for far longer than they ought to. Babies and toddlers can look at the scenery from a buggy and be talked to - they don’t need a screen! As for a 1 year old staying up til 10pm?? That’s neglect.

Sadbabysitter · 18/02/2022 21:36

@OnceuponaRainbow18 as this is what the family requested.

I won’t always know what the job entails until I’ve accepted the booking.
It’s problematic for the agency if I cancel after accepting.

On this occasion I knew dad would be around, but assumed he would be working while I was looking after his child.

He had no interest in interacting with his child. I was hired to care for his daughter while he watched TV….. go figure! 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
HiDay · 18/02/2022 21:32

Saddest I saw was a child who at four had no idea how to turn a page in a book. He kept swiping at a corner to try and make it move on.

Useruseruserusee · 18/02/2022 21:31

@LinuxPenguinPCnerd

Oh DFOD. Shielding and working from home with a small child around. You bet screen time was high. Needs must.
We also worked from home shielding as our youngest DC was on the CEV list at the beginning of the pandemic. Both full on jobs and DC were 2 and 5 at the time. Of course there was screen time, especially when I had meetings etc.

But there is a difference between that and what the OP is describing. I’m a Deputy Head in a primary school and we have children arriving who simply cannot engage in imaginative play. Who can’t make a strong mark with a pencil as they lack the gross and fine motor skills. Screen time is a part of life, sure, but it has to be balanced.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 18/02/2022 21:26

@Sadbabysitter

Why you babysitting a kid when their dad is there?

LinuxPenguinPCnerd · 18/02/2022 21:23

Oh DFOD. Shielding and working from home with a small child around. You bet screen time was high. Needs must.

metellaestinatrio · 18/02/2022 12:22

@Flickflak

Yes I see extreme device and screen time as neglect. Our six and seven year olds have no access to devices at all. They do watch tv, about an hour a day on a school day and maybe two hours on a Saturday or Sunday.

Engaging in imaginative play is so important for development. Our two can entertain each other and themselves for hours.

Excessive screen time is complete laziness by the parents.

I agree. My older ones are 6 and 3.5 and have no devices of their own. They do watch TV, similar amounts (although middle one occasionally has a bit more when I need to work on my days off - I justify it to myself because she no longer naps). However I have not yet managed to achieve the “entertaining themselves for hours” part - they always want me to join in! Sometimes I have to put the TV on just so I can make supper in peace Blush.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 18/02/2022 10:39

@MsTSwift

It’s worse for tiny children as those developmental stages and learning about the world are so key. Glad phones weren’t around when mine were pre schoolers.
Me too. My son was about 7 when he got his first Nintendo - I held out until he was 14 to get him an xbox.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 18/02/2022 10:38

It's not just children is it? It's adults as well. Especially if you have an office job, we use screens all day.

It's not so bad if you have a job which involves working outside.

I suspect the kids of today will need glasses much earlier than our generation have.

Flickflak · 18/02/2022 10:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BogRollBOGOF · 18/02/2022 09:59

Assuming age appropriate content, the biggest issue with screen time is what are you not doing. That's where time really matters because it's less time on physical activities, imagination, reading, drawing etc. Children need a broad range of experiences to develop their brains and neural connections.

The world has changed rapidly. DS1 is 11. When he was a baby, I had a Blackberry style phone. Pacifying him with youtube wasn't an option. We did watch CBeebies and his screen time increased the winter he turned 2 when we had a lot of poor winter weather and I ended up on crutches with SPD. When summer came, and I began to be more mobile again, the screen time was gradually reduced. At 11, he's one of the later children to get a mobile phone. The past two years seems to have accelerated that as many children were given phones to keep in touch with friends when school was out of bounds for 6 months.

WFH with young children present is the worst of all worlds because the priority becomes pacifying the child to get the job done.

As a parent to older children, it's tough to find the balance. Screen time is here to stay. It's part of society. It also has benefits. DS1 has ASD and dyslexia so he can access niche information to feed his interests whereas books of the right level of content are very difficult to process. He needs about 90 minutes to zone out after school before he's mentally fit to cope with other activities. But he does need that time away too and he needs to use his body.

When I was a child in the 80s/90s, self regulation wasn't much of an issue because the 4 channels on TV didn't put out more than a couple of hours of child-,orientated content at a time. If you did stay watching TV, it probably was informative/ educational. Now there is no natural trigger for people of any age to walk away.

canarycages · 18/02/2022 09:38

YANBU and I agree. We don't even own a TV. DS1 (now aged 4) got dysregulated by screen time and had the worst tantrums as a toddler, stopping the moment I removed screens entirely. DS2 (15months) has never had screen time. They both play independently for hours every day. This isn't a brag, this is normal for us. I'd sooner saw my arm off than go back to the days of DS1 tantrumming for days after an episode of Duggee.

MistyElla · 18/02/2022 09:35

I completely agree, OP. And as a parent, if you swim against the tide and have the backbone to limit your child’s screen time, you’re labeled everything from a tiger parent to a overprotective fool who is trying to make everyone else look bad. The worst is when parents smugly roll their eyes at people giving their children screen limits because ‘the more you make it a thing the more they’ll want it.’ I have a friend who is awful for saying this. I think she is trying to justify the fact that she gives her kids hours of screen time because she is exhausted after work and doesn’t have the bandwidth to deal with the fallout of saying ‘no’.

ufucoffee · 18/02/2022 09:25

Absolutely agree OP. It's definitely neglect. And God forbid anyone on Mumsnet suggests that parents taking small children to restaurants should do so without a screen to keep them quiet.