Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel concerned children (not all!) are a generation of screen addicts

120 replies

Sadbabysitter · 17/02/2022 23:38

I’ve been babysitting for many, many families for more than 15 years……

Over the last couple of years, although much more so recently, I’ve found very young children having literally hours of screen time during the day.

As a babysitter, I always want to engage with and play with the children, without the distraction of screens.
Not all families, but a concerning amount, will tell you their child (often 1/2/3/4 years old), likes the tv or phone/tablet and they have it on/in their hand as a default and it don’t be removed.

One child I’ve cared for since almost one year old and he watches coco melon for 4 hours straight while I care for him. If I turn it off he cries and mum tells me he wants it on all day long, so she puts it on for him. She laughs and says ‘he’s addicted’ which he is! He won’t play outside, build a tower of bricks, push a toy train………….

While it’s on (or any other screen) it’s impossible to develop any meaningful engagement with a child. They are drawn back to the screen, lying, sitting or just rolling around on the floor watching.

As a babysitter, I want the child to feel happy and comfortable and I will always work with the parents wishes, but this doesn’t feel right.
If the parent leaves the house, I will turn the device off and say ‘ah, it’s not working’ and I can then distract them with other activities, albeit with them regularly asking for the screen, maybe having a little cry at first. However, increasingly, parents need me to care for their child while they’re working in another room and they are clear that the device is to stay on.

Yesterday I was with a one year old who had her dad’s device in her hand from 6pm - 10pm with coco melon and other kids shows playing. He gave it to her when I arrived and was in the house the entire time so I couldn’t take it away as she cried and he told me she wanted it. Whenever we went into the living room dad put coco melon on the tv for her. She was exhausted but apparently doesn’t sleep until after 10pm - little wonder with the constant stimulation of shows!

Coco melon is the worse for turning tiny children into zombies, unable to take their eyes from the screen.

So my AIBU is, to be concerned that we are raising a generation of children who are sedentary, can’t use their imagination or focus on a task, can’t cope without the continuous pop of dopamine they are getting from these bright and rapidly changing images and this is going to lead to serious mental health problems in the future?

OP posts:
Arnia · 19/02/2022 08:45

I do think screens are an issue but what your describing sounds extreme to me and not the "norm". I have young DC and this doesn't reflect my house or that of their cousins/little friends.

Most parents are aware of the issues and try to put some limits in IME. Covid made many more parents/children dependent on screens (my own DC included) but now things are back to normal we've moved away from them again, besides a bit on Saturday mornings or when I'm making dinner during the week.

I think Netflix/YouTube etc. is more a "problem" than normal tv. The zombie-ness happens for my children when they can watch the same show over and over with no break. Like you mentioned with the Cocomelon. The variety of CBeebies etc. mean they don't get to that stupefied, eyes glazed over phase and lose interest when a programme comes on thy they're not interested in. So we now only let them use the tv that doesn't have any streaming services on it and all the issues have stopped and they never complain when it goes off.

Avarua · 19/02/2022 08:37

yADNBU.

Rosehugger · 19/02/2022 08:36

I agree about secondary school homework, and it got worse since lockdown. DD2 changed schools and it took us months to even have the right logins for all the apps they use for homework, timetable. I have never been tech-phobic but found myself wishing for the days they would just write something in a book and hand it in. There was a real change to the approach between DD1 and DD2 - four years apart.

Rosehugger · 19/02/2022 08:28

It just comes down to everything in moderation. How many adults are screen addicts and hardly move themselves? I've never found it a problem with DDs as they have always wanted to be really active as well as play on devices.

Iggly · 19/02/2022 08:27

@Polyanthus2

I think you should only spout disapproval if your DCs are young and you somehow manage without them looking at screens, tv or other.

Quoting how you managed your now adult DCs and limited their tv 15 years ago is not the same ball game,

Virtually all adults are on their phones at every opportunity.
I suspect many people will spend their lives on phones /games/ virtual reality and that's what it is. How much this matters to them or others time will tell. I suppose if they cannot hold down a job as they only know the virtual world it will have long term problems for society.

With both parents working, and especially with covid and home working how do you keep a child occupied for hours a day without screens. I remember mine when young squabbling and arguing, not doing worthwhile painting and reading. Fortunately I was a sahm for much of it.

^this

Everything is being moved online. It’s difficult to do things without requiring a device which means you end up being pushed onto devices.

My ds is at secondary school and all of his homework requires the internet. So, unsurprisingly he ends up pissing about on YouTube etc when in “my day”, that simply wasn’t an option.

I desperately want the kids to have screen free days but as soon as you need to do any homework etc then nope. Not possible.

And lockdown certainly hasn’t helped as it now forms a massive part of their interaction with their friends!

Mybestyear · 19/02/2022 08:24

Meant to add - after reading the post about the meta verse I feel we are doomed…..it’s all so depressing.

Mybestyear · 19/02/2022 08:23

YANBU OP. I read an article in the Sunday times magazine a few years back about research done on Japanese children and they found that the use of hyper stimulating content on screens, gaming etc was actually physically changing the structure of their brains as shown by MRI scans. Their explanation was that our brains were not designed to constantly be in “flight” mode so the areas of the brain which dealt with that response were getting bigger whilst other areas shrunk. I am feeling more and more like the human race is doomed every day!

Polyanthus2 · 19/02/2022 08:13

Its a huge problem and there are studies about how screen addiction damages the developing brain.

Yes and our mega millionaire/trillionaire owners of these products assure us they do their best to control what children watch etc. It's evil it really is.

waterrat · 19/02/2022 08:06

Op the situation you describe with the 1 year old is so grossly disturbing I would think about saying something. Letting a 1 year old watch screens for hours while paying someone to look after them also suggests a manic obsession with pacifying the child at all costs. That child will not develop properly

My own children use too much screens though I hate it and push a lot for outdoor play to come first. We have to also look at the world outside and eg cars taking over our residential streets so thst kids can't just step outside and play anymore

Charles11 · 19/02/2022 07:59

Working with kids and seeing the damage that screen addiction causes in families, I banned devices during the week except for homework and tv. I’ve seen teenagers with fractured relationships with family members as they’re all addicted to their phones and who won’t even go out with friends as they’d rather spend their time on their phone. They don’t do their homework and are failing even though they are bright, because they’d rather chill on their phone and parents are too busy chilling on theirs to guide them.
I don’t think it’s likely that many of these kids will be pioneers of technology or innovators. They’re passive users of tech and lack the creativity and focus it would take.
Its a huge problem and there are studies about how screen addiction damages the developing brain.

Joinedforthis22 · 19/02/2022 07:24

If you Google there are various articles about how shit Coco Melon is for children, parents don't have to necessarily limit screen time but there is a wide choice of other shows that resulting to that over-stimulating garbage!

Polyanthus2 · 19/02/2022 07:18

I think you should only spout disapproval if your DCs are young and you somehow manage without them looking at screens, tv or other.

Quoting how you managed your now adult DCs and limited their tv 15 years ago is not the same ball game,

Virtually all adults are on their phones at every opportunity.
I suspect many people will spend their lives on phones /games/ virtual reality and that's what it is. How much this matters to them or others time will tell. I suppose if they cannot hold down a job as they only know the virtual world it will have long term problems for society.

With both parents working, and especially with covid and home working how do you keep a child occupied for hours a day without screens. I remember mine when young squabbling and arguing, not doing worthwhile painting and reading. Fortunately I was a sahm for much of it.

Ticklyrain · 19/02/2022 07:07

@househunters

And I should add I only felt like I 'needed' to use the tv in that first year because it coincided with lockdown. Now things are open and they're a bit older so I no longer have a 15 month old and a newborn it's monumentally easier for me to take them out of the house to a farm, park, play cafe, toddler classes etc. However, I appreciate most of those things cost money and I'm lucky enough to be able to do them every day if I want. If lack of funds meant I could only go the park and library then I'm sure I would use a lot more screen time- especially during winter.

I really did feel that I needed that screen time when DC2 was born, and being judged for it would have made me feel even worse about myself. So please stop being overly judgey.

I think it’s about having a balanced perspective on it. I 100% judge the mum I know who lets her kid watch 3+ hours of non-stop You Tube each night, that’s clearly unhealthy and unnecessary. But having really rigid thinking about it and sticking to a super strict schedule doesn’t strike me as healthy either. There are going to be times (like lockdown) when kids watch more tv and some when they watch less - but life ebbs and flows like that in general. When it’s something that’s gone on for years and is an ingrained part of the household, that’s something different again.
FairWindClearSailing · 19/02/2022 06:58

I personally agree with you. My son is 18 months and he gets the TV on for about an hour after his nap but it's watching buses, trains and trams that he likes, or music videos (real versions...not Cartoons). I
don't even have the TV on in the background (maybe once or twice a month I put a movie on in the mornings but he isn't interested anyway) as I worry about screen time and that's why we limit it. If I say I don't let him watch TV all day/ cocomelon / etc. If someone asks me, or we're at a baby group discussing TV, and I say this, I'm looked at like I have a problem 🤷🏼‍♀️

Ticklyrain · 19/02/2022 06:56

@Pyri

Coco melon is the worst
I used to think that, until I met the rip off version (evil) Baby Jojo. All the worst bits of Cocomelon, plus weird messsges about not trusting strangers, constant songs about being careful, plus a baby that eats donuts and ice creams constantly. The worst.

I can see how insanely addictive both are for kids, especially Baby Jojo - the songs would get stuck in my head for days in a really intrusive way. Both are pretty much banned in our house.

One of the mums at my child’s preschool lets her 4 year old watch Ryan’s world for hours when they get home. I really can’t think of anything worse, Cocomelon at least has a stab at ACBD and the like.

househunters · 19/02/2022 06:47

@LemonDrizzles

This is why I was so confused that CBeebies offer cocomelon....
Do they? I've never seen it shown live- is it just on the iPlayer function?
LemonDrizzles · 19/02/2022 06:42

This is why I was so confused that CBeebies offer cocomelon....

househunters · 19/02/2022 06:13

And I should add I only felt like I 'needed' to use the tv in that first year because it coincided with lockdown. Now things are open and they're a bit older so I no longer have a 15 month old and a newborn it's monumentally easier for me to take them out of the house to a farm, park, play cafe, toddler classes etc. However, I appreciate most of those things cost money and I'm lucky enough to be able to do them every day if I want. If lack of funds meant I could only go the park and library then I'm sure I would use a lot more screen time- especially during winter.

I really did feel that I needed that screen time when DC2 was born, and being judged for it would have made me feel even worse about myself. So please stop being overly judgey.

househunters · 19/02/2022 06:07

There is definitely a balance to be had, and there are some extremely judgey comments on this thread.

To the poster who judged the mums looking at their phones whilst pushing their prams- don't judge them. Maybe that was their only chance to do so that day. Maybe they were on their way to a baby class or the library or a swimming lesson and just needed to check their phone, or actually have some adult interaction with someone by replying to a WhatsApp message.

I do agree that cocomelon is awful though. I showed it to DC1 a couple of times when he was a young toddler and vowed never again- he still occasionally asks for it now a year later after those two times of watching it. I don't see how it has any educational value at all and is just far, far too addictive.

However he does watch cbeebies, and more than I would like. He was only 15 months when DC2 was born and I needed to use cbeebies to get me through that first year to be honest. We have started to cut it down now and he has no tv at all now on nursery days, and maybe 2-3 hours on non nursery days (which I will continue to cut down).

I have not and will not buy him his own tablet until he is much, much older.

labyrinthlaziness · 19/02/2022 06:05

The stuff I read said the screentime itself is not inherently damaging, it just eats up time they could be doing positive stuff, so kids are not developing the skills and talents they could.

Apparently one of the aspects experts are most concerned about is every minute a baby is looking at a screen is potentially one they are not looking at a human - they are therefore much weaker at understanding people, reading cues, interaction etc.

I am a bit of a grouch when it comes to screens for kids. I am very into tech for kids - they code etc - but not just watching crap.

scandikate · 19/02/2022 06:01

I hate it. I think in the examples you gave it sounds like the parents need a babysitter because they are working from home so may need some silence in the house? Maybe they've saved all the screen time for then?
I have a 3 and 5 year old so I know the challenges and do try to limit it as much as possible. They do seem to have a lot at school though and get increasing amounts set as homework too. I tutor teens and find their concentration is so much worse than 5/10 years ago and wonder whether this is to do with screens. My friend is a driving instructor and says the same.

SpringTime2020 · 19/02/2022 05:52

Incidentally, I have never limited my DC's 'screen time' so they have learnt to self regulate. Plus there's tonnes of other things they want to do like go to gymnastics or the park or finish reading their book. I mean they can't be that unusual as the gymnastic classes are full, the park is busy and the library is full of children.

Solasum · 19/02/2022 05:42

I saw a dad carrying a baby in a forward-facing sling the other day, holding his phone with a cartoon on it right in front of the baby’s face. The baby was paying no attention to the screen and was trying to look around. It was perfectly calm. No idea why he thought the screen was necessary

haikyew · 19/02/2022 05:11

Can't stand seeing kids
Eating while watching iPads
Unhealthy habit

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 19/02/2022 03:25

I grew up in the 80s. Siblings and I were in front of the telly a lot when not at school during the colder months. Genuinely did me no harm. I have friends, am educated and have a good job.

I think OPs examples are a bit extreme but I wonder if there’s a bit of exaggeration going on. I mean what parent would pay for a babysitter and insist their child only sits in front of Cocomelon for hours? It sounds more likely the dad suggested to OP, that this was the child’s favourite programme in order to give OP easier time rather than insist that’s what the child had to do. Also, practically all of OPs clients are similar? Hmm.

Although I abhor genuine neglect and benign neglect including sitting kids in front of tv all day with zero interaction, this thread just sounds like a bit of an excuse to encourage PPs to bash ‘inferior’ parents. Do you have kids OP?