Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yurt living. How awful is this going to be?

158 replies

Lairymary · 17/02/2022 20:12

I'm hoping someone can convince me that this won't be as awful as I think it's going to be...
Here goes... My OH and I have just purchased a property that needs a lot of work, we're talking complete renovation and needs plumbing and electricity installing. We have found a property to rent while we do it up, (6 months) but that is a 40 minute drive away (literally no other options closer to the property). DH has seriously suggested that we just buy a yurt and live in that on site to save the money on rent and petrol. In theory, yes it's a good money saving idea (will probably save at least 12 grand in total) but in the pit of my stomach I'm a bit horrified at the thought of potentially 6 long months of camping. Hopefully the house will be habitable before then. I just have this awful feeling that it's going to make me miserable, also to add there is a three year old in this scenario too!!
Does anyone have experience of yurt living for longer than a "glamping" holiday. Is it going to be awful?
Just to add, we plan to get the bathroom and a washing machine sorted as a priority, fingers crossed, so hygiene won't be an issue.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BillMasheen · 19/02/2022 13:50

@crowisland

Well, for centuries millions of people in Central Asia lived year round in yurts. With no electricity or plumbing. The camels and other livestock were their sources of food.
It IS possible to live in a yurt (though the nomadic people that use them seem to have a winter base, and use the yurt to live in the high pasture in summer)

The main difference is the great British weather. Yurts were never designed to be used in prolonged wet weather.

LaChanticleer · 19/02/2022 13:22

If you can save £12,0000 for your renovation, do it. DO IT!

You’ll be glad of the extra money and time. You really will. A caravan rather than a yurt is such a good idea.

But save money and time, really - you’ll need to. I lived with builders for 2 years while they did a huge renovation job on my house, and know that it always costs more than you think.

LittleBearPad · 19/02/2022 13:21

Sounds utterly horrendous.

Don’t live on site. You’ll need to get away from the mud, noise and general crappiness of building work.

Renting 40 minutes away sounds much more bearable. Plus the build will inevitably overrrun.

TeaAndStrumpets · 19/02/2022 13:10

@Yants

As another option how about a motorhome? Used ones have always held their value incredibly well even long before the whole lockdown staycationing madness became a thing, so you should be able to eventually resell it easily with minimal depreciation. It could also be quite useful for getting bulky materials for your refurb project, large sheets of plasterboard, flat pack units etc will easily fit in compared to what you'd get in a car.
This is such a great idea, actually! My cousin and hubby bought a new motorhome just before lockdown, and have only used it twice in the last two years. It has increased £10,000 in value now because there is a shortage.
Yants · 19/02/2022 08:47

As another option how about a motorhome?
Used ones have always held their value incredibly well even long before the whole lockdown staycationing madness became a thing, so you should be able to eventually resell it easily with minimal depreciation.
It could also be quite useful for getting bulky materials for your refurb project, large sheets of plasterboard, flat pack units etc will easily fit in compared to what you'd get in a car.

zestyflavour · 19/02/2022 08:34

I stayed in a yurt for a week - it was humid, full of bugs, awkward shape so difficult to move around/get dressed - the people saying you should get a caravan are right but you’ll be cramped in that too and they aren’t cheap!! - all sounds very exciting though

Gonnagetgoing · 19/02/2022 08:29

Few small iPhone typing errors but think you get my drift! Wink

Gonnagetgoing · 19/02/2022 08:28

@BoredZelda

I know you say this project has your attention full time but unless you're architects/builders etc or have experience please consider using someone professional in to help or advise. Speaking from experience not mine but close friends.

This.

It is my job to manage and cost these projects. I’ve 25 years experience in the industry and projects can still go wrong if the wrong people are involved. I know how to mitigate it and lessen the impact to get things on track but to a novice they’d be stuck.

I don’t assume I could walk in to anyone else’s job and do it with no training or experience, I’m not sure why self builders think they can do mine and succeed. Any episode of grand designs will show how people fail when they don’t pay a few grand to a PM or QS to manage the job.

@BoredZelda - I worked as PA in 2 architects firms for 7 years, still have architect and interior designer friends. Also worked briefly for very small Houzz type architect.

I also worked with George Clarke briefly.

Far far better to employ a small architect/PM who know what they’re doing than ho it yourself and risk alienating contractors etc!

You definitely need to spend money on a PM who will oversee builders - money well spent! I’ve not done a huge job mystic but friends have and they’ve overrun etc, even an architect friend of mine had issues with builders when converting a huge battersea house of 3 flats into one family home plus attic conversion and extension!

Bertiebiscuit · 18/02/2022 23:21

And with a small child - are you drug addled hippies - or just insane

Bertiebiscuit · 18/02/2022 23:18

That's a hard no from me - 1)building work always take twice as long as is promised 2)it will be cold, damp, as it for 3/4 of the year, basically you will be living in a transit camp - DON'T DO IT, nothing is worth a nightmare like this

Sunshineboo · 18/02/2022 22:13

i honeymooned in a yurt. great for 3 days awful after that!

caravan is the way forward. you can sell
it on after

dworky · 18/02/2022 21:57

April onwards should be bearable, otherwise I would hire a caravan for the duration.

DrSK2 · 18/02/2022 21:13

That would be extremely unfair for a 3 years old baby — it’s even too difficult for an adult. The physical environment is key to the child’s health and wellbeing. I think you must think about your child first.

Flatwhitetostayin · 18/02/2022 19:44

Sorry, haven't read the whole thread but would a prefab garden room/ garden office be a possibility? It would end up costing you as much as the rent and petrol etc, but would possibly be an amazing addition to your home long term. They have brilliant insulation so wouldnt have to worry too much about the cold or heat. You could add an orning/gazebo to increase the living space but would at. Least be a permanent safe structure to live in temporarily.

perenniallymessy · 18/02/2022 19:40

If you've got the land, could you build a nice garden room and live in that whilst building work is going on, then have the space for a den/gym/craft area/bar afterwards? Could always get an old caravan too for cooking/chemical loo facilities. Would probably cost about the same as the rent elsewhere but you'd have an amazing space for afterwards.

Obviously depends on timescales as I guess it takes a while to get one sorted.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 18/02/2022 19:00

R u doing the work or having tradespeople? If the latter why do you need to be onsite daily?
I’d rent/stay with friends/caravan for a few months while you sort the plumbing and get a bathroom in then do up 1 bedroom and basically live in that while you do the rest.

squashyhat · 18/02/2022 19:00

My nephew and his partner lived in one in my sister's garden for a couple of years. They had a woodburner and cooking gas inside and access to hot water, shower, loo etc in an adjacent outhouse. I assume they used my sister's washing machine. AFAIK it was fine.

oakleaffy · 18/02/2022 18:44

@BoredZelda

I know you say this project has your attention full time but unless you're architects/builders etc or have experience please consider using someone professional in to help or advise. Speaking from experience not mine but close friends.

This.

It is my job to manage and cost these projects. I’ve 25 years experience in the industry and projects can still go wrong if the wrong people are involved. I know how to mitigate it and lessen the impact to get things on track but to a novice they’d be stuck.

I don’t assume I could walk in to anyone else’s job and do it with no training or experience, I’m not sure why self builders think they can do mine and succeed. Any episode of grand designs will show how people fail when they don’t pay a few grand to a PM or QS to manage the job.

Hear Hear! Amateurs just cause ill feeling with good craftsmen and builders in my experience.

Don't ask an experienced Trade for advice and then say ''But on you tube'' &c &c
Don't even attempt to project manage a build unless you have prior experience of project managing said work.

Amateurs think ''How hard can it be?''
But renovating an old property is WAY harder than building a new design from scratch.

oakleaffy · 18/02/2022 18:34

@labazslovesliving

a lot of people opt for statics but a yurt is liveable. there is a lady on Tiktok I follow who lives in one full time and with a log burner, her yurt seems very cosy. I think she is in the USA but there is a couple doing the same in Scotland. with the right sort of yurt, I should think it is very doable, especially with a log burner or similar.
''Properly made Yurt'' is the crucial bit.
oakleaffy · 18/02/2022 18:31

@Lairymary
A properly made Yurt, made by someone who know what they are doing should be watertight and warm.

You will be ''On site'' and save a fortune in rent.

I'd say go for it {or a caravan}
Best of luck!

kmbegs · 18/02/2022 18:30

We did similar (without a child but I was pregnant) and we lived there from the start and just really pushed on to get a new bathroom in, our bedroom in a decent state and a sink installed in a spare room then made that room in to a temp kitchen while we did the rest. I would say it's not for the faint hearted. We obviously had a child soon enough and it's hard with a little one. But we did save so much money that we would have spent renting elsewhere. And obviously living on site means no travelling back and forth.

Leedsfan247 · 18/02/2022 18:29

A caravan would be better

MdNdD · 18/02/2022 18:26

Caravan! And then sell when you’re done.

Pinklemonade1 · 18/02/2022 18:07

My brother , his wife and 2 young children have lived in a yurt in rural New Zealand for 4 years..they love it.
They are hippies though but it works for them. I don't think I could cope and would prefer a mobile home .

Mitzimccormack · 18/02/2022 18:04

We have just done a massive house renovation, had to move out for 6 months, just moved back in with most of work done. It is a very stressful time. If we hadn't owned the other property we would have bought a static caravan (you can pick them up for a couple of thousand) they are big (much bigger than a normal caravan) and you can put a lot of your own stuff in to make it feel homely. A Yurt might be fashionable, but its camping. No proper cooker, no nice warm shower room, clothes damp all the time. No thanks.