Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that there are too many parked cars on the roads these days?

214 replies

JammyRedRooo · 17/02/2022 19:58

Its absolutely ridiculous in my area. Whole swathes of road are basically one lane only due to the amount of parked cars. It makes visibility when driving really difficult.

Half of the houses have empty drives as well!

You can't turn into my cul de sac on the correct side of the road because of the row of parked cars all the way up to the junction, it's just so dangerous.

I know you pay a premium for a house with parking, or households often have more cars than spaces but I find it so infuriating and unsafe.

Anyone else?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 18/02/2022 15:46

doing a big shop at an out of town supermarket just isn’t a thing for them.

I think they have supermarkets deliver the shopping, which is something you can have done here in the UK if you choose

JammyRedRooo · 18/02/2022 15:35

Also, me having a drive and 'taking' a parking space from someone is reducing the problem I'm talking about in the first place! If nobody had drives it would be even worse Confused

OP posts:
JammyRedRooo · 18/02/2022 15:30

@HomeHomeInTheRange

OP Mine isnt on the road it's on my drive

Every drive with a dropped kerb that has to be kept clear effectively takes up a parking space.

Thank you, you are the third person to make this point and I've responded up thread 🤷🏼‍♀️
OP posts:
DisappearingGirl · 18/02/2022 14:57

It's tricky. And very easy to propose solutions that only negatively impact other people!

We live in a Victorian terrace with no drive, so we park on the street. We can both walk to work in the city centre. If we moved in order to buy a house with a drive, we'd have to move further out, and would have to use our car more to get to work and other places. So on balance it seems better to stay where we are, park on the road but use our car less.

I'm not sure what will happen on terraced roads like ours when electric cars come in. I like the idea but not sure what we'll do about charging them.

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 14:55

@Brefugee

I wonder how the Japanese make that bit work? I am genuinely curious. As in, some people potentially priced out of car ownership.

all sorts of people in the UK are priced out of car ownership. They are also priced out of Maserati ownership, diamond tiara ownership and all sorts of other things.

What needs to improve is public transport.

I get that bit (the unjust deprivation of the diamond tiara!). What I’m curious about is this:

If it’s expensive to own or rent space to park a car in Japan, and why wouldn’t it be since they, like us, are a densely populated small island, AND if you have to prove that you have such space available in order to buy a car, AND Japanese people use cars in a similar way to British people, for commuting etc., how do they deal with objections like those raised by a PP?

Which were, that it would be perceived as unfair for people who can’t afford to buy a house with a drive, or a parking space in Osaka, or whatever, to not be permitted to own a car with the limitations that come with it, I.e. less choice of jobs if you can’t drive, expensive public transport.

I am genuinely curious. I think that the Japanese have got the right idea, but I wonder how they sold it to their citizens? Maybe the Japanese just live their lives differently to us and e.g. commuting by car or doing a big shop at an out of town supermarket just isn’t a thing for them.

bigbluebus · 18/02/2022 14:50

@etulosba

What do you propose?

The Japanese system seems to work.

To register a car, or when changing address, you need to prove to the local police that you have a parking space for it.

I believe that in Japan the train drivers get their wages docked if the train runs late. I suspect that they have a very efficient and reliable rail network. Unlike in this country where trains are cancelled all the time so no guarantee you can get to your destination. DS booked train tickets last week to go on a city break. Within a day of booking he had an email to say his 1st train was cancelled and the bus replacement wouldn't get him to the main station in time for his connection. So I had a 42 mile round trip to take him to the main station so he could catch the 2nd train as planned. Only a few weeks ago DH was coming back from a meeting in London. He got as far as the main station only to find his connecting train was cancelled so I had to go and collect him. Our rail service is a joke and we won't be giving up our cars until it's sorted which will be never. Fortunately we have 3 parking spaces on our drive for our 3 cars (3 adult household)
Brefugee · 18/02/2022 14:45

I wonder how the Japanese make that bit work? I am genuinely curious. As in, some people potentially priced out of car ownership.

all sorts of people in the UK are priced out of car ownership. They are also priced out of Maserati ownership, diamond tiara ownership and all sorts of other things.

What needs to improve is public transport.

Lockheart · 18/02/2022 14:39

[quote BABAHOTEL]@Lockheart but reducing would still mean they need a car, they'd have to stop completely to reduce the cars on the road! [/quote]
No, because they could use things like car clubs and/or hire cars.

BABAHOTEL · 18/02/2022 14:34

@Lockheart but reducing would still mean they need a car, they'd have to stop completely to reduce the cars on the road!

JustLyra · 18/02/2022 14:33

Our street is about to have residents parking permits set up primarily because of selfish twats who have drives, but don't use them for their cars. I can't wait.

Only three of the twelve houses don't have a drive. All of the drives can fit at least two cars on. There are 12 marked spaces on the street, then some unlined areas that twatty people park on.

There are three houses that park multiple cars on the street because they use their drives for something else. Including one - which has been the catalyst for the permits that has a drive that could fit 6/7 cats that they've turned into a basketball court for their teens so they park 5 cars and a van on the street.

Another house is let out by a selfish twat landlord who uses the drive when he's shopping or getting the train so his three tenants all have to park on street.

To be fair to the third house they mostly park on street because of the selfish parking of the first house I mentioned - they've been blocked onto their drive a few times so now have to park on the street when they know they need to go out.

If you don't have adrive then it's fair enough to park on the street - people have to. If folks have drives and just don't bother to use them then the're selfish twats.

Lockheart · 18/02/2022 14:30

[quote BABAHOTEL]@Lockheart how would reducing car usage help with parked cars, if the issue is people don't have off road parking? [/quote]
Because fewer people would own cars...?

bellamountain · 18/02/2022 14:26

And yet housing estates are still being built with single lane roads and no driveways.

BABAHOTEL · 18/02/2022 14:25

@Lockheart how would reducing car usage help with parked cars, if the issue is people don't have off road parking?

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 14:24

@goawaystormy

What do you propose?

The Japanese system seems to work.

To register a car, or when changing address, you need to prove to the local police that you have a parking space for it.

So essentially, poor people shouldn't be allowed to have a car? If you aren't rich enough to have a house with a drive you shouldn't be allowed to have a car? And therefore are limited in both job and travel opportunities, thus perpetuating the cycle of inequality. If you're too poor for a house with a drive you have to spend more money than you'd spend on a car on extortionate trains, buses etc.

I wonder how the Japanese make that bit work? I am genuinely curious. As in, some people potentially priced out of car ownership.
emmathedilemma · 18/02/2022 14:23

At least they're parked on the road and not the pavement!!

goawaystormy · 18/02/2022 14:21

What do you propose?

The Japanese system seems to work.

To register a car, or when changing address, you need to prove to the local police that you have a parking space for it.

So essentially, poor people shouldn't be allowed to have a car? If you aren't rich enough to have a house with a drive you shouldn't be allowed to have a car? And therefore are limited in both job and travel opportunities, thus perpetuating the cycle of inequality. If you're too poor for a house with a drive you have to spend more money than you'd spend on a car on extortionate trains, buses etc.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 18/02/2022 14:13

OP Mine isnt on the road it's on my drive

Every drive with a dropped kerb that has to be kept clear effectively takes up a parking space.

JammyRedRooo · 18/02/2022 14:09

Public transport needs to be better of course. And there are people that genuinely need the number of cars that they have that live in places with insufficient parking. But I also think there are a LOT of people who could make it work with less cars but just choose not to.

For example near me is a kids football field. The number of parents who clog up all the cul de sacs in the area with their cars, block driveways, park on private property when I'm pretty confident most of the kids who play live in our (walkable) town is just silly.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 14:07

I didn’t dispute that. Of course for some people a car is vital. Can nobody read any more?

I explicitly stated that people use the ‘bad public transport’ excuse for selfish and dangerous parking, and I don’t think it stands up. I used an example of a PP who said that she would be prepared to use a bus if it picked her up from outside her house and dropped her at the door of work, at a time of her choice, of course. Which is just silly.

I didn’t say, “everyone should use public transport because nobody really needs a car”.

Thanks for telling us about your local bus service, though.

JammyRedRooo · 18/02/2022 14:04

@Notjustanymum

Oh the irony of the OP saying “ Mine isnt on the road it's on my drive!”, thus neatly and (just as selfishly as those who don’t have a drive so park on the road) removing at least one space available for parking, from the road!

The problem is indeed, too many cars - but until an alternative infrastructure exists to get everyone from their different A’s to B’s, I can’t see the situation improving.

I kind of see what you are saying, although I think my previous point about there needing to be dropped curb areas where cars cant park for pedestrian/accessibility reasons still stands. If nobody had drives and cars were parked all the way along the road for miles how are prams and wheelchair users supposed to cross?
OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 18/02/2022 13:58

@Iamthewombat

Yes, but does that justify blocking junctions, or pavements, or other dangerous and selfish parking practices?
No of course it doesn’t, I’m just saying that for some people a car is vital.
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/02/2022 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Upamountain43 · 18/02/2022 13:49

In my area people park on the pavement on both sides - its the only way to enable vehicles to drive down the road.

The solution is taxpayers paying for a heavily subsidised mass public transport system or taxpayers being willing to pay for half the population to stop working.

There really is no options for the millions of us who live in Victorian Terraced Houses or the like.

megletthesecond · 18/02/2022 13:25

Yanbu. In my estate (1960's) there is one space per household.
It's a nightmare now we have two or three car families.

Brefugee · 18/02/2022 13:22

On the other hand there are so many properties being built now without parking so people have to park somewhere and will end up in nearby roads.

that is ridiculous. In Germany all new build properties have to have off road parking.