Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did anyone here have a really good upbringing?

107 replies

TiktokClock · 17/02/2022 19:29

Lately I seem to hear constantly about the impact of childhood trauma and how it affects people going into adulthood, whether it be with their mental health, self esteem, addiction, relationships, attachment etc. I just wondered if those who had happy, healthy childhoods still suffer from these kinds of issues, or if they are relatively happy in life? Or is it a case of it doesn’t matter how you were raised, no one gets out unscathed?

OP posts:
Bran21 · 17/02/2022 20:26

Me , grew up in country village with both parents and brother. No crime area ,always had doors open. We always played outside with everyone in village and bikes and roller boots. Went for lots of picnics and days out to seaside. Didnt have loads of money but never effected us.

Furbulousnous · 17/02/2022 20:24

Not much money in our family but two parents who loved each other and loved us and were very affectionate. As I result I’m a fairly secure adult who makes friends easily and weathers life’s storms well. I’m generally optimistic and believe that most people are good/kind/ mean well and when they behave badly I give them the
Benefit of the doubt.
I think this all stems from a secure childhood.

Juliauns91 · 17/02/2022 20:23

Mine was great. Grew up in the country with parents, brother abd both sets of grandparents who were great. My parents were rare and wonderful people. My brother was my best friend from childhood until he died in an accident in his 30s.
It wasn't until I got to aged twenty or so that I realised they were actually unusual people, and that many people are actually stupid, horrible and disappointing.

RunningFromInsanity · 17/02/2022 20:22

Yes. Loving family for 4. Extremely close to my sister in childhood and as adults.
Hardworking, fun, fair parents.
Wealthy so got to experience great holidays, university and bought first house but still instilled a great work ethic.

Foolsrule · 17/02/2022 20:19

Pretty good, though as a parent myself now, there are things that I look back on and think - that shouldn’t have happened etc. There were a few bad times, serious illness of a parent etc. Far from resulting in trauma, these have made me more resilient if I’m honest. Actually, maybe they’ve made me too self sufficient and resilient! I can’t stand people who seemingly can’t cope at the slightest thing Confused

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 17/02/2022 20:17

Although my parents were not the most ideal, my dads an alcoholic and my mum suffers from health anxieties I was brought up well. I had very hands on grandparents and an aunt who i spent a lot of time with. Looking back I would say my childhood was happy. Having a set of parents who sometimes were focused on their own struggles made me very resilient and independent. I haven’t had any major mental health struggles throughout my life and feel well rounded.
My DP however always bleats on about how bad my parents are and how great his parents were and the wonderful childhood he had. I think he tells himself this as he doesn’t want to admit there was a lot of controlling behaviour within his parents relationship. He has not suffered any issues in regards to mental health but he is one of the most emotionally immature people I have ever met.

NeverChange · 17/02/2022 20:13

Yes and I never appreciated it until I got older and realised that it wasn't the same for everyone.

The kids/teenagers I envied as a child and especially in my teens because they had so much freedom and could do everything they wanted, out late, nightclubs at a young age, allowed do drugs and alcohol at home, teenage boyfriends sleeping over etc). I thought they had such cool parents where mind where out to restrict my fun and happiness.

My mum was the type that always said, no matter what you've done, or where you are you shouldn't be call me and I will get you home safely, won't embarrass you in from of friends, or go nuclear on you".

I tested that promise several times but my mum was the one who picked us up safety if we were drunk, allowed friends stay in ours to keep them alive rather than sending them home where they might be beaten or not kept an eye on & choke on their own vomit etc. I broke her heart numerous times and I was grounded etc. but nothing drastic.

We weren't well off at the time but had enough and things far more important than money can buy.

I was very very lucky.

SquarePeggyLeggy · 17/02/2022 20:10

My point being: once away and starting their own families- they’ve had challenges then. No different to my own, and my husband also had a difficult childhood, and he and I are very happy and stable, and communicate really well and healthily.

Rosebel · 17/02/2022 20:09

I had a good upbringing loving parents, siblings, enough money to not have to worry. We didn't have lots of family time as my dad ran his own business and worked long hours. Mum was always there though and my dad treated us to brilliant holidays and whatever hobbies we wanted.
Unfortunately life as an adult has been fucking hard. I have a husband and kids who I love very much but my mental health is awful.
So IME it's about what hand you get dealt as an adult not your upbringing. I feel terrible that I can't give my children the childhood I had.

SquarePeggyLeggy · 17/02/2022 20:07

Interested to see this. I had a dreadful childhood for a number of reasons. It’s really starting to come out only now in my 40s. My siblings and I are clearly not ok, though on surface appearances we are.
I have two childhood friends I’m still very close to. They had very stable childhoods, I was envious and spent as much time as possible at their houses. I’ve known them our whole lives.
They both have unhappy marriages, and one has mental health issues. I’d call all three of us successful and good Mums. The difference I can see is their safety net. They have support in times of crisis. I don’t. But then we support each other as friends too.
I don’t think I’m more unhappy or less successful than them, it’s just been harder for me at times. My adulthood from early twenties on has been success and happy by any measure.

Nostrings457 · 17/02/2022 20:06

Loving parents, ‘as long as we were happy they were happy too’. I didn’t appreciate what they did and sacrificed for us until I had my own DC, by which time my DM had tragically died. I’m now going through a separation and feel like a complete failure for not providing the stable loving upbringing by 2 loving parents that I was privileged to have had. I am grateful for the values and morals instilled in me though

Dessicator · 17/02/2022 20:02

I have 4 siblings, our parents had a golden child till the day they died. Our hobbies were never considered as important as the Golden Child.
It made me determined to never treat my children in that way and I haven't.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 17/02/2022 20:01

I had an absolutely wonderful childhood with discipline and independence in equal measure, I know I was loved but I was definitely not over indulged, there were boundaries but equally I was left to make my own choices and on occasion mistakes, my parents definitely didn’t fuss over us and lived their own lives along side us. The outcome two very happy, hard working, confident adults with wonderful memories of a loving childhood.

declutteringmymind · 17/02/2022 20:00

I had an unusual childhood, poor, hardworking families, harsh mother, loving extended family, high emphasis on education and left to fend for myself a lot.

Tbh I had a lot of insecurities as a young adult but once I'd made peace with it and accepted who I am, I've turned out well and I'm happy. I've got a loving family, High income, a great bunch of friends.

I got to a a point where I realised I could blame the shit parts of my childhood for feeling shit about myself, or make the choice to accept it and be happy.

It rears it's ugly head when my mum tells me to hit my child if he doesn't behave himself, or tells me he doesn't need a bath or I wash his clothes too much. I just roll my eyes at her and carry on.

There are lot of restorative CBT therapies that can help people deal with past traumas which fascinates me.

Yants · 17/02/2022 20:00

Definitely not, my parents did pretty much the bare essentials to avoid any accusations of child neglect, kept us fed, clothed and made sure we went to school and that was it.
There was no love or affection, no nurturing of our hobbies or interests, couldn't care less how well or badly we were doing at school, no material "extravagancies" despite my parents being decent earners.
They were basically just both very selfish and self centred and weren't ever prepared to make any compromises or sacrifices to their own personal wants and needs in life despite choosing to have kids.

HardbackWriter · 17/02/2022 19:58

Just to add to my post above - although having a very good childhood didn't 'protect' me from my mental health issues, it definitely hugely helped me when I was ill that I had a lot of family support around me.

steppemum · 17/02/2022 19:58

Happy stable loving childhood with 2 parents in a stable happy marriage.

I have grown into a happy adult who is able to deal with most of what life throws at me and I have a long happy marriage and kids.

SadFaceEmj · 17/02/2022 19:55

I had a lovely childhood up until my mid teens when my parents suddenly divorced and it wasn't amicable. Before that it was great. I'm still very close to both parents.

I've had some really tough times in life although all have had a very obviously cause which wasn't to do with my childhood. It helped a lot having a lot of loving, supportive family to prop me up during those times.

Northernsoullover · 17/02/2022 19:55

Yes, not materially and my parents practised a lot of benign neglect. We would disappear for hours on end on weekends and holidays and we never were pressured to achieve. But we were happy and as an adult I'm lucky to still have both parents around.

Ginger1982 · 17/02/2022 19:53

My childhood was very good up to the point where my dad died. Fortunately, my family were very supportive so I didn't go off the rails and have been mostly happy and content.

HardbackWriter · 17/02/2022 19:52

@MargotEmin

lots of holidays, music and dance classes, private education etc

I wouldn't consider those markers of a really good upbringing. For me, from a very low income background, a good upbringing is rooted in emotional warmth, security, laughter, joy, a sense of all muddling through together and has nothing to do with things my parents could buy.

I think that there's no difference in the emotional impact of having just enough money and having lots, but the impact of having not enough - of being in poverty - is usually profound.
Hohofortherobbers · 17/02/2022 19:51

Yes , I had a happy and stable childhood. I think I'm fairly well rounded, no issues, and am happily married, no drama...... (keeps fingers tightly crossed and touches wood!)

RandomUsernameHere · 17/02/2022 19:49

I was lucky enough to have a happy childhood, good upbringing and loving parents. I'd say as an adult in my thirties I'm happy and contented and pretty resilient.

HardbackWriter · 17/02/2022 19:48

My childhood was very good - not perfect, but very good. As an adult I've had very good, strong relationships but I also had a period of very poor mental health in my 20s. I think it is quite clear (and deeply unfair) that you start life at a huge advantage if you've had a loving, stable childhood though. The big thing I've really noticed is how differently people's baseline for what's 'good enough' treatment for others is set, and the profound impact that can have. For some people, through no fault of their own, it can lead to trauma after trauma after trauma.

MargotEmin · 17/02/2022 19:48

lots of holidays, music and dance classes, private education etc

I wouldn't consider those markers of a really good upbringing. For me, from a very low income background, a good upbringing is rooted in emotional warmth, security, laughter, joy, a sense of all muddling through together and has nothing to do with things my parents could buy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread