Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this upset you or is it fair enough?

262 replies

Fezzco · 17/02/2022 17:00

Been with dh 7 years and have one toddler together. We had some difficulties last year and nearly split, think lockdown was a bit of a pressure cooker and it was a result of a hard few years. We kept it very private and ended up working through it. I only confided at the time in a few friends.

One friend I confided in at the time I've grown more distant from in the last year, I've tried to meet up but we never seem to be free at the same time and we haven't seen each other, messages fizzled down to not many or not often. She didn't reply to my last message a few months ago, not an issue but it means when we found out I was pregnant (totally unplanned) she wasn't high on my list to tell

I posted a picture today just of toddler wearing a big brother jumper indicating that baby number is on the way. She messaged me basically straight away saying "Seriously? How have we gone from a crumbling relationship to a pregnancy announcement? It's not going to make anything better."

I spoke to her about our issues when we met up during that time period, it was April last year. I'm a little upset for her to taint what should be happy news by bringing it all back up and acting like I'm having some band aid baby? AIBU to be upset or do I need to take it on the chin given that she knows we nearly broke up? It just kind of changed the tone of the news a bit, I don't know.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Georgeandzippyzoo · 11/09/2023 16:44

Fezzco · 17/02/2022 17:26

Christ almost unanimous people saying they'd think the exact same. Makes me very glad I didn't speak to more than a couple of people. Honestly if one of my friends went through their first ever marriage difficulties during covid and were now nearly a year later announcing a pregnancy I'd be thinking I'm so happy they sorted it out when so many marriages didn't survive. I thought people would be happy for me. I guess not Blush

I think that had I not been kept up to date on how your relationship was going I might thinking something similar. The last she knew you were possibly breaking up and now you're expecting, HOWEVER I would not have said it, bit as a pp said I might have checked you were OK.

I'm not sure if you've responded but if uou wanted yo I think I'd say something along the lines if
'so glad we could work on the crap that covid situation caused in our relationship and we've made it out the other side'.

You ofcourse do not have to explain your actions at all!

People can go through horrendous situations which can cause relationship difficulties but it doesn't mean you will therefore split up. I think the tone of what was said sounds really bitter and wonder if her break up is affecting her thoughts.

Melocoton · 11/09/2023 16:33

Just wanting some support as feeling very stressed. Separated from controlling ex last year after years of miserable life. Had to move out to rental as life was really hard. He is a huge earner and is now trying to make me suffer by refusing a decent enough settlement to allow me to buy a home for my children and myself. After years of staying at home to bring up children , I have managed to get a full time job earning about £35k and I work really hard.
He has raised questions from my Form E and bank statements picking at my lifestyle choices ( not unreasonable).
. Has anyone else had experience of this, how did they get through this really difficult part and did it have a positive outcome.?
I am so frightened and worried and kids being poisoned daily with lies about me.
I have thought daily about leaving the area to start again as this is all becoming too hard.

YabuOrYanbu · 13/11/2022 13:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

AWOL66 · 25/02/2022 16:44

Congratulations first of all! :-) That's so exciting! Secondly your friend was really rude and what she said shows how negative she is - who needs that energy bringing you down on the best days of your life?! Thirdly couples have ups and downs all the blooming time especially when they have young children. I feel like a lot of readers on here and your friend are really clueless and naive if they think otherwise and see it as unwise to have had another child. What a blessing!

DTW33 · 20/02/2022 17:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Bluestripeddress · 20/02/2022 10:17

Can’t help wondering if she knows your husband and has been ‘comforting him’…hence pulling back from you and now been stunned by the news!

Mitzi067 · 20/02/2022 10:05

Fezzco.
How very unkind of her ! Just banish her from your life. Some people would only say such a thing because their life is miserable and she wants you to feel the same. Take careful notice not to divulge any private details to anyone other than those you deeply trust and remember an old saying 'a still tongue is a wise head'.
Every couple will go through a rough patch for a variety of reasons and you've got through it. You do not need to have any contact with this so-called unkind friend.
I'm delighted for you with having a baby.

Fudgemonkeys · 19/02/2022 18:47

I'd likely think it, but like others never have said it. We are all aware a baby doesn't always make a rocky relationship better but I'm happy you've worked through it and are planning a future together. Covid was a pressure cooker for almost everyone you were not alone. Smile

Shelby2010 · 19/02/2022 12:07

Congratulations! Your friend is being a bitch.

Even if she thought that, it was rude & unkind to say it. What was she expecting you to say - ‘Gosh, you’re right, I’m off to book a termination.’ ?

Sassoon · 19/02/2022 11:44

I'd have thought it to be fair but I wouldn't have said it.

Heart1234 · 19/02/2022 11:40

Sorry to hear this but a true friend wouldn't treat you like this. Dont dwell on it. Better off without.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/02/2022 10:58

First of all congratulations on your pregnancy ❤️

And I would ignore her she sounds pissed of you didn’t tell her before your announcement.

She’s rude and there’s no need for it at all, i wouldn’t even think that let alone saying it and anyone that would is so judgemental and quite nasty, no one knows how the last year has been for your relationship and especially her knowing your struggles to get pregnant before, it’s awful. You’ve explained how things went wrong and people still with shitty comments here. Relationships have issues now and then, so does that mean have one rough patch then never have another kid?

People are so weird.

Tell her when she’s been in a serious relationship and knows how to work through it then her comments will mean more but having a bitchy comment on things she has nothing to do with for over a year is none of her business.

Surprised she didn’t comment on any Xmas pics saying playing happy families when you was rowing in April.

And you don’t need to keep things private when you have relationships issues, friends (good) friends don’t hold things over you forever to have a dig and make you feel like shit. Since when was it anyones business what goes on in a marriage just cos you’ve vented to them so they can rule your life forever!? No.

shinynewapple22 · 19/02/2022 08:13

I think she was out of order saying it . For all she knew it was an accidental pregnancy and you were trying to make the best of things . I think it's reasonable in a close friendship to ask how a friend feels about pregnancy, but I don't think a judgement statement like that is helpful .

StargazerAli · 19/02/2022 08:03

It's hard to comment without knowing your history but I think your friend needs to learn about tact. She was obviously shocked but relationships change and she should perhaps have kept her doubts to herself until she met you in person instead of bullying you. With a reaction like that, just what does she expect you to do in your current situation other than be offended and feel crap?

Roo4u · 19/02/2022 07:41

I thought exactly the same ,maybe there's something they both aren't telling you

Roo4u · 19/02/2022 07:40

My thoughts exactly

Newmumatlast · 19/02/2022 06:17

Also having read more about what was wrong it doesnt seem like a big rough patch like mine was. It sounds pretty normal relationship bumps stuff. Perhaps this friend has gotten the completely wrong idea in your efforts to comfort her over her own failing relationship. Some people are just the wrong people to confide in and unfortunately you never really know for sure who they are.

As I say, ignore her and enjoy your pregnancy OP xx

Newmumatlast · 19/02/2022 06:14

@Fezzco

Christ almost unanimous people saying they'd think the exact same. Makes me very glad I didn't speak to more than a couple of people. Honestly if one of my friends went through their first ever marriage difficulties during covid and were now nearly a year later announcing a pregnancy I'd be thinking I'm so happy they sorted it out when so many marriages didn't survive. I thought people would be happy for me. I guess not Blush
I think people could simultaneously be happy for you because it's a nice thing but also roll their eyes a bit privately about the speed of a pregnancy after troubles in a relationship. I paused conceiving (like actively took contraceptives) when my husband and I hit a rocky patch and that was while concerned about possible infertility- because it's about potential babys best interests being brought into a relationship soon after a rocky patch not my own interests of wanting one. Obviously we resolved things and had a baby but not for a while after. I do think a lot of people would think similar to your friend but not a lot of people would upset you by saying it. Especially if they had not spoken to you for ages.

But whatever people might think it is your life OP, you're happy and only you know the state of your relationship. If you know you're solid and you both want this then huge congratulations, celebrate and enjoy it and ignore her

NerdleNoodle · 19/02/2022 06:05

OP I am gobsmacked at the responses that seem to think your friend's comment was acceptable, even valuable. Whatever your friend thinks - it's not friendship, it's malice, to put a bleak and pessimistic spin on something that is already done. And to reflect back at you the darkest time of your marriage. This is not a friend. Ditch her.

That way you can get on with feeling excited about your new baby and making your marriage as strong as possible. Lots of couples have wavered and come together again for many happy years together.

It's a exciting, optimistic period for you. Please don't let a mean-spirited friend suck the joy out of it for you.

Warmest congratulations on coming out of a hard period with your husband and on your pregnancy.

Madamum18 · 19/02/2022 05:52

@Fezzco

Nothing bad happened between dh and I, just I think we both got snipey with each other, very tit for tat about everything, we were on top of each other constantly, tired stressed etc. It just got to the point I didn't want to be around him, and I thought it may be permanent but to be honest we both just needed some space and to start prioritising each other again and it has been good since. We talk more rather than just watch tv every night, we've had date nights and weekends away, just making time for each other outside of parenting. His job caused him a lot of stress, he got a new one which he's much happier in and significantly more money so we're in a better place all around and both are excited to grow our family.
So you did all the right things to work things out, well done both of you. Enjoy looking forward to the new arrival and do consider whether this person is really a friend or not! Flowers
Madamum18 · 19/02/2022 05:50

@Fezzco

Christ almost unanimous people saying they'd think the exact same. Makes me very glad I didn't speak to more than a couple of people. Honestly if one of my friends went through their first ever marriage difficulties during covid and were now nearly a year later announcing a pregnancy I'd be thinking I'm so happy they sorted it out when so many marriages didn't survive. I thought people would be happy for me. I guess not Blush
I agree! I think her comment was thoughtless, unkind and unnecessary. She could so easily have said "Great news! I am so glad that things have improved for you since our last chat." or similar!

Not sure this is a friend you need in your life really!

TheresOnlyOneWay · 19/02/2022 00:15

I think your friend is bang out of order for saying that, and I would wonder if she's a friend at all.
Considering you haven't heard from her for months and she hasn't replied to your last text, she couldn't have been that bothered about your 'crumbling relationship' so why is she so bothered now?
Having a new baby, the pandemic etc causes a lot of stress and strain on couples and many people struggled during that time.
That's a really unsupportive message she's sent. Don't let her spoil your joy and celebrations. She sounds very bitter.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/02/2022 00:10

It's hard to know really without knowing what the state of your relationship was like and what you were telling her about it. If it was a couple of throwaway comments about him pissing you off I would think it an over-reaction. If it was a succession of nights out talking about you wanting to leave him etc I might feel a bit pissed off in her shoes: she might feel a bit used or she might just be a bit shocked at how rapidly you've changed your tune.

I know that with a baby on the way and things on the up you have to put the most positive spin possible on it and fair enough but it clearly was quite bad for you to be sharing detail about it with friends. I suspect you are slightly glossing over this now.

She certainly was very rude about it and handled it really badly and I would be pissed off in your shoes.

But I can see where she was coming from and honestly I would probably privately think the same.

caringcarer · 19/02/2022 00:01

As you and your DH were both committed to working on your relationship it is not surprising it improved. Also Covid and lockdown was a very testing time for many people. Congratulations on your baby news and I hope it brings you both much joy and hope for the future. Take no notice of your friend. Don't let her spoil this special time for you both.

mylifestory · 18/02/2022 23:47

Shes plain jealous and shd never have said that straight off

Swipe left for the next trending thread