Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child benefit higher rate tax payer

34 replies

Nc4post99 · 17/02/2022 12:45

So my hubby just got a new role, v proud of him it’s long awaited. It pays £55k, £10k increase.

We’ve just had our second child so claim child benefit for 2.

I’m on mat leave, but when I’m in work I’m mid £30k, desperately need a new job when I get back but that’s irrelevant here lol.

What does this mean for CB, I know he’s a higher rate tax payer or at least he will be when he starts in June. I googled and it says something about a self assessment tax return and you pay some of it back? But this is virgin territory for me. Could someone explain for me please? :)

Side note it does seem a little silly/ unfair that it’s on sole income not joint. Family could be a single income house hold and then they are obviously worse off than 2 parents earning £35k each.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
gillybean2 · 18/02/2022 18:47

@girlmom21 I already posted the link for that up thread

girlmom21 · 17/02/2022 15:05

There's a calculator somewhere on the government website that'll tell you how much you would need to pay back.

We'd need to pay back all but 80p if we claim for our 2, so that's nice.
It's a bit shit it's focussed on the higher earners income, even if the lower earner is on SMP, SSP or whatever.

FeedMeSantiago · 17/02/2022 14:59

You have 3 options:

  1. Claim child benefit, opt into receiving the payments and DH, as the higher earner, registers for self-assessment and pays the tax charge. Doing this gives you the child benefit payments, generates an NI number (when DC is the right age) and gives whichever parent claims the benefit an NI credit until your child turns 12. I would recommend you claim it, not DH so that you get the NI credit during your mat leave as this counts towards your state pension entitlement.
  1. Claim child benefit and opt out of the payments. You still get the NI credit and your child is on the pathway for an NI number but no-one has to pay a tax charge, or register for self-assessment.
  1. Don't claim it at all. I wouldn't advise this as you'll lose out on the NI credit and your child will need to apply for an NI number at 16.
minipie · 17/02/2022 14:15

@minipie

Just to add, you can still register for child benefit but opt not receive payment.

I think I did this years ago after DD1 was born but I can’t remember Blush does anyone know how I would check?

Ignore me - managed to check via govt gateway
Nc4post99 · 17/02/2022 14:03

@McClary111

53333 I worked it out at assuming 1st June start date. So does he pay more than 278 into a pension each month?
He pays it as a % of his income and it’s a match contribution from his employer, think around £250.

When he starts at this job he’ll be able to adjust his pension again I imagine. It will be a similar scheme, employer will contribute a flat amount and then do a Match contribution up to x%. My job for instance 10% flat rate and then match up to 7%. There are quite a lot of perks at his soon to be new employer so I imagine it will be similar to mine.

OP posts:
minipie · 17/02/2022 14:00

Just to add, you can still register for child benefit but opt not receive payment.

I think I did this years ago after DD1 was born but I can’t remember Blush does anyone know how I would check?

Yellow85 · 17/02/2022 13:58

@SonicBoomBoom

No you don’t, but you need to call HMRC to remove your self assessment flag from your account. I’ve just had to do this as It kept reminding me to do one even though I didn’t receive CB anymore.

Thanks Yellow, what happens if that SA flag is on there and you don't do one?

I’m not actually sure, but the emails and text alerts got really frequent as the deadline approached!
SonicBoomBoom · 17/02/2022 13:52

No you don’t, but you need to call HMRC to remove your self assessment flag from your account. I’ve just had to do this as It kept reminding me to do one even though I didn’t receive CB anymore.

Thanks Yellow, what happens if that SA flag is on there and you don't do one?

Caterina99 · 17/02/2022 13:49

Echoing what everyone says

a. The system is stupidly unfair as you could have 2 parents earning 49,999k each and not have to pay back a penny, and yet one parent on more than 50k does

b. Do your sums and see if increasing pension contributions slightly will take you below the threshold. Its a double win usually due to the tax benefits.

FTEngineerM · 17/02/2022 13:44

Yeah it’s totally stupid @Opsiedaisy because two of you can earn 50k and have it all but if one earns 60k you get none which is ridiculous. Household of 100k=full chb house hold of 60k(one earner)=none. I’ve just cancelled mine because it’s such a headache I’m essentially getting money from
Him through the government…

FTEngineerM · 17/02/2022 13:42

Find out how much pension he’s paying though, gross maybe 55 but he will almost certainly be enrolled into a pension with them, if it’s a decent one it could take him below 50 and then all this is not required. Find out the employee pension contribution

Opsiedaisy · 17/02/2022 13:41

Be very careful if you decide to claim it. When we had children we started claiming it (partner was on salary of over £50,000) we were putting the monthly benefit we received into the children’s Isa’s we had set-up for that reason, and we knew partners tax code would increase whilst claiming it. I didn’t go back to work after maternity leave finished. My partner wasn’t self employed and was paid wages through normal means by his company. We were lead to believe that his tax code would be adjusted to a higher code automatically due to us receiving this benefit. Five years after we had started claiming CB, he received a letter from the tax office saying he owed them £15,000! Apparently you have to fill a self assessment form in due to claiming this. When he questioned why they had only contacted him after five years, they said it was his responsibility to keep up to date with his tax assessments, (which he didn’t have a clue he was supposed to be filing out each year). He was being charged daily interest on the outstanding arrears which went into £1000’s! It was shocking! Obviously we stopped receiving the benefit when all this came to light!

Yellow85 · 17/02/2022 13:41

@SonicBoomBoom

If you have opted out of receiving child benefit as salary over 60k, do you still have to do a self-assessment each year?

Or can you not both, and just let the tax etc be deducted monthly by PAYE, even if you have a car allowance etc included in the package?

No you don’t, but you need to call HMRC to remove your self assessment flag from your account. I’ve just had to do this as It kept reminding me to do one even though I didn’t receive CB anymore.

@Nc4post99 you are correct it next years problem, but whatever action you take now will determine how big that problem is! If you cancel now you’ll have less to payback. But you could always keep receiving and hedge your bets that you’ll fall below 60k inclusive of bonuses and only have to pay some of it back. I had a bill of £1400 my first year because I didn’t know.

McClary111 · 17/02/2022 13:40

53333 I worked it out at assuming 1st June start date. So does he pay more than 278 into a pension each month?

McClary111 · 17/02/2022 13:39

If he starts on 1st June you can work out how much he will earn next year. April and may at current rate (less pension employee contributions). Add 10 months at new rate less pension contributions. It may be that he is below the 50k, or he can up the pension to ensure he is under.
Any charity donations can be offset too.

EasterIssland · 17/02/2022 13:39

@Nc4post99

At 55k how much of it are we likely to pay back?

Does it take into account our household income as my salary is pretty average

I earned 54 last year. 1 child. Gained 1.1 in child benefit. Return 600
SonicBoomBoom · 17/02/2022 13:38

Thank you stackhead.

stackhead · 17/02/2022 13:35

@SonicBoomBoom

If you have opted out of receiving child benefit as salary over 60k, do you still have to do a self-assessment each year?

Or can you not both, and just let the tax etc be deducted monthly by PAYE, even if you have a car allowance etc included in the package?

No. If you've opted not to receive payment then no self assessment is needed.
SonicBoomBoom · 17/02/2022 13:34

If you have opted out of receiving child benefit as salary over 60k, do you still have to do a self-assessment each year?

Or can you not both, and just let the tax etc be deducted monthly by PAYE, even if you have a car allowance etc included in the package?

Nc4post99 · 17/02/2022 13:28

@stackhead

Your income is irrelevant.

He will need to complete a self assessment after next April using the details on his p60. If he puts 5k into his pension so his pre tax income is 50k then no charge. Otherwise it's 10% of the benefit per 1k over 50k.

Anything over 60k and you have to pay the whole thing back. At this point you change the claim so you get NI credits but don't receive the money.

Keep in mind, bonuses & benefits in kind also count so he'll need to see his p60 to understand what the total payback would be.

There’s bonuses in this role too, thanks for pointing that out!

Seems likes it’s next tax years problem though? Shouldn’t be too bad then as I’ll be back in work

OP posts:
stackhead · 17/02/2022 13:20

Your income is irrelevant.

He will need to complete a self assessment after next April using the details on his p60. If he puts 5k into his pension so his pre tax income is 50k then no charge. Otherwise it's 10% of the benefit per 1k over 50k.

Anything over 60k and you have to pay the whole thing back. At this point you change the claim so you get NI credits but don't receive the money.

Keep in mind, bonuses & benefits in kind also count so he'll need to see his p60 to understand what the total payback would be.

BuanoKubiamVej · 17/02/2022 13:16

As pp says he should just up his pension contributions to keep his post-pension total just under £50k.

You pay back 10% of the CB for each £1000 earned over £50k by one individual. No, there is no adjustment made according to what (if any) the other partner earns. The rule applies the same for any household where one adult earns more than £50k regardless of whether there's another high-earning adult, another adult with low or no earnings or no other adult at all.

It's not very fair no, but it has to be a system that is easy and cheap to administer and anything fairer than this would be likely to reduce the uptake among the poorest families, to the benefit of comfortably-off families.

But anyone in the £50k-£60k bracket can get around it with pension contributions and other salary-deduction schemes so you don't have to lose out on anything.

Nc4post99 · 17/02/2022 13:11

@dementedpixie

I already said its around 10% per extra £1k so at £55k he'd pay back 50% of it.

It is based only on the higher earners income

Blame baby brain
OP posts:
dementedpixie · 17/02/2022 13:08

I already said its around 10% per extra £1k so at £55k he'd pay back 50% of it.

It is based only on the higher earners income

gillybean2 · 17/02/2022 13:08

www.gov.uk/child-benefit-tax-calculator

Swipe left for the next trending thread