Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really not understand why DD doesn't like reading...

58 replies

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 11:38

DD is 8. She has always been in the top reading group at school, she taught herself to read while she was still at nursery. She loves books and loves being read to.

BUT she says she hates reading to herself. She did during lockdown, probably because she had so much time, but it has really tapered off now. She got given so many wonderful books for her recent birthday but she hasn't picked up a single one to read by herself (I will read them all to her, in time). Getting her to do her school reading is a huge chore, even though she can read all the books fluently.

Has anyone had a similar DC and is it just something I need to accept or is there a way for her to discover the joy of reading? I feel like she is missing out in a funny way - how lovely it is to get lost in a good book - but maybe that's just imposing my own thoughts/beliefs on her...

OP posts:
McClary111 · 17/02/2022 13:15

A few book suggestions (I have an eight year old).
Percy Jackson.
The endling (read this at school in year 2) but reread this year.
Philip Pullman - firework makers daughter, read during lock down and reread.
Phillip Pullman - northern lights graphic novel. In fact most Pullman books are popular.
Hilda and the troll graphic novels
The ordnance survey puzzle book - a bit random.
Those 1980s Ian Livingston choose your own adventure books. You need dice.
The famous five and Mallory towers.
Wizard of once books
Harry Potter - all of them!
A childrens/young persons bible. Not religious at all but enjoyed.
Horrible history books

Swonderful · 17/02/2022 13:13

Audio books are great. I can't really understand why people see them as less good than actual reading. In fact they're probably better as you can't skim over them. They will still build vocab, grammar, imagination etc.

I much prefer podcasts/audio books over reading books as an adult. I do read a lot, but mainly boring stuff for work.

BettyOBarley · 17/02/2022 13:12

I could have written this about my 8 year old DD.
She was a free reader by Year 1 but absolutely hates reading now. It's a hassle to even get her to read her school book.

I think part of the problem is she doesn't enjoy longer chapter books, I think she forgets what she's already read and then can't get into the book. Her teacher recommended Barrington Stoke books as they have shorter chapters.

Recently I've been sitting with her and we take it in turns to read a page and she seems to enjoy that, or her younger brothers books Julia Donaldson types which can be read in one sitting.

If I leave her to read her school book on her own she just says she's read it when she clearly hasn't.

It is a shame, I was only talking to her last night about all the books I loved at her age and we said we would read some together. I do agree that in our childhood we didn't have much TV or tablets so books were so much more appealing.

BlackCoffeeInAPoolOfSunshine · 17/02/2022 13:10

I do think it's difficult for some people to accept that our children are absolutely separate people who may well be utterly different from us. I don't enjoy playing video games even though I can play them and sometimes play with one of my sons if he's having a bad day and feeling down, because it means a lot to him. My DH loses himself in a videogame given the opportunity the same way I lose myself in a good book - why don't/ can't I? Am I missing out?

I do think that adult type reading doesn't necessarily "kick in" until a certain fairly late stage of brain development. Being able to read functionally is only a part of the skill. It's not possible to "lose" yourself in a book if you're reading every word laboriously, and reading a school book aloud is totally different to listening to a good reader read to you, which is again utterly different from reading silently to yourself - and that isn't one experience either as a fully developed adult reader absorbing fiction for pleasure is having an experience with no meaningful similarity to the same adult reading a dry technical text, or a child reading one word at a time in a linear way even if silently.

My eldest loves to read now at 16 but I read to her until she was 13. She read some children's and teen fiction to herself but not much. Then suddenly at 13 she started to read the Brontës and Jane Austen at astonishing speed and no longer wanted to be read to 😱 It was a staggering developmental leap really, from the occasional Jaquelin Wilson, to The Hunger Games and Maze Runner but really only reading perhaps four or five books per year, to suddenly reading Pride and Prejudice and Wuthering Heights and Emma all in one week and burning through my bookshelves, planning trips specifically to bookshops etc.

My 10 year old is dyslexic and yet has always liked to read, but for him it fulfills a need as he has problems sleeping and worries about not being able to sleep, and knowing that he has books is a security blanket, and reading helps him quiet his busy mind. He read comic type books (Captain Underpants, Dog Man, Hilo and we had a Beano subscription) for the longest time but more recently he reads on in Rick Riordan books I read to him at bedtime.

My 14 year old still doesn't read for pleasure really but he motors his way through a set reading list for extra credit for school to bring his grades up - he has to take comprehension tests on each book which makes it a chore and I'm on the fence about whether I think this is good as at least he reads or bad because it's potentially going to put him off coming to reading for pleasure in his own time one day.

My DH reads for pleasure sporadically - he'll get into a series or author and read one book after another for a few weeks or months then suddenly stop and not pick up a book again for a year... He says he never read a book voluntarily until his early 20s

In other words everyone is different, she isn't you and should be different to you. Don't push her - she might come to reading for pleasure all of a sudden much later than you expect.

shouldistop · 17/02/2022 13:10

It might be that she likes the time with you reading to her so is subconsciously resisting reading by herself incase story time with you ends?

SnotMikeUpPuffedHe · 17/02/2022 13:10

I think at the moment just accept it as it is; the best way might just be to let her see you getting pleasure out of reading.

I am a massive bookworm from a family of massive bookworms. When I met my DH and was talking about him to my mum one of her first questions about him was 'what does he read?' and when I said 'he doesn't really' her reaction made it very clear she saw this as some sort of moral failing.

This is clearly so ridiculous that it made me examine my feelings about it all. I'm so glad I did because I now have two non-reading children; I think I could easily have made them feel I was disappointed in them for not reading if I had my own mother's attitude.

DH does read more now. Maybe the DC will when they're older. Maybe they won't. Either is fine.

Fabuleuse · 17/02/2022 13:07

I've got a 7.5 year old boy who is so similar. He also taught himself to read and was reading fluently long before school. He's still being given harder reading books than the rest of his class at school. He is always read to at bedtime and enjoys that but he won't ever pick up a novel for fun. He does sometimes dip into factual books like Guinness Book of World Records. The only time he's ever voluntarily read novels was for the library summer reading challenge last year - he is very motivated by achievements like earning the virtual badge on his online profile for that. As a child from ages 6-12 I pretty much permanently had my nose stuck in a book so I am a little sad he doesn't seem to like reading.

McClary111 · 17/02/2022 13:07

I would go to a good bookshop and let her choose something. Readly app is a magazine app with quite a few kids magazines available. Aquila magazine is good too and very varied.

CrackerGal · 17/02/2022 13:06

[quote firstchopanonion]@CrackerGal Yes graphic novel suggestions would be great. She definitely wouldn't be into anything like superheroes, but babysitters club probably yes.[/quote]
My daughter sounds quite similar to yours I'll go grab a list for you! My daughter wouldn't be into superheroes either.

toastofthetown · 17/02/2022 13:05

As long as she has access to a variety of books, it’s her choice if she doesn’t want to read. As an adult I go through reading peaks and troughs. Just because she’s not into reading now, doesn’t mean she won’t start again as an adult (just as reading prolifically as a child doesn’t guarantee they’ll keep it up as they grow up). I’d just accept that about her for now and not make a big deal of it. Maybe she’ll come back to reading, maybe she won’t.

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 13:04

@CrackerGal Yes graphic novel suggestions would be great. She definitely wouldn't be into anything like superheroes, but babysitters club probably yes.

OP posts:
firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 13:03

@britnay Bookshop not really, and that might be a good avenue. Library yes, but honestly the selection at our local library is not great. Very fairies and unicorns 'for girls' and football 'for boys'. Neither of which appeal to her at all!

Her sport is gymnastics.

OP posts:
CrackerGal · 17/02/2022 13:02

Just to add, we took her to a comic book store & she actually picked out the babysitters club graphic novels herself.

Madcats · 17/02/2022 13:01

I've been there with my now 14 year old.

She really enjoyed audiobooks (lots are available to order from our local library or to download online). They help to build vocabulary and I suspect that they aid comprehension (because of the narrator's voice/expressiveness).

The school seems to take the view that I should pick my battles.

I do have form for "accidentally" forgetting to confirm WiFi/phone strength when we go on holiday.

CrackerGal · 17/02/2022 13:01

Yes, my daughter was an early advanced reader & went through this around 8 too. I ended up buying her lots of graphic novels which reeled her back into reading.
There are excellent graphic novels of the babysitters club for one, I've many many other suggestions if you're interested.
She probably only read graphic novels for about a year & now she's back into reading. She also likes factual age appropriate books now.

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 13:00

She really enjoys audiobooks.
@DoctorSnortles That's a good point, and may be part of the problem. The books that come home from school are pretty straightforward but the ones she has in her room at home, which she loves me reading to her, are probably either a bit tiring (Harry Potter etc) or a bit young (Isadora Moon etc).

OP posts:
WinnieWaits · 17/02/2022 12:57

Oh and non fiction was popular.

britnay · 17/02/2022 12:56

You've mentioned books bought for her. Does she spend any time choosing her own books either at a bookshop or library? Maybe she needs to explore other genres?
Maybe fiction books that are related to her sport? If you mention what sport maybe someone could suggest a suitable author?

WinnieWaits · 17/02/2022 12:55

My one child likes audio books better. Another one was slow to read but reading to him and getting him books that were at his level and just the right subject material got him into the habit. I'd maybe read chapter 1 or more to get him started too. Taking him to the library to choose NEW authors just didn't work. Whereas I loved the library and rather random books as a kid.
For him I would buy books of the film and the book of the video game in one case😂.

DoctorSnortles · 17/02/2022 12:54

What is she avoiding reading? She might be good at reading, but find it hard work, particularly if being encouraged to read more challenging texts as a 'good' reader. Can she pick something 'easy'? (Larger print, less text, off-white pages, more straightforward vocabulary?)

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 12:49

She doesn't have a tablet (none of us do). She watches a bit of TV but not much and certainly not on a daily basis. She loves drawing, crafts, playing with her toys, piano...she also spends a lot of time at her sport. I always offer her the chance to keep her light on and keep reading once I've read to her at bedtime but she doesn't go for it.. Maybe I do need to accept that reading just isn't her thing right now! Magazines etc are a good suggestion though as she doesn't ever seem to mind reading, say, directions for a board game.

I don't think it would be a problem if she associated reading with the pandemic; she enjoyed lockdown for the most part.

OP posts:
YesItsMeIDontCare · 17/02/2022 12:46

My DS was the same, still is tbh

Turns out he has Aphantasia, so a book is just words. He gets no imagery or emotions from them.

It also means Cards Against Humanity is a bit lost on him 😁

MostIneptThatEverStepped · 17/02/2022 12:44

Mine were all like this to a degree, which was quite hard for me to understand. Where I lived growing up there was literally nothing to do so my siblings and I read non stop.

It's really different for kids now, there are so many other distractions.

However...as adults now they are all readers! Maybe not as voracious as me but that's ok.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/02/2022 12:40

@blackdumpling

Remove the Tablet & cut back on TV time That will help her learn to love reading Agree with a PP that the book versions of her favourite movies may help
The OP hasn't mentioned if her dd has a tablet or watches TV.
blackdumpling · 17/02/2022 12:38

Remove the Tablet & cut back on TV time
That will help her learn to love reading
Agree with a PP that the book versions of her favourite movies may help