Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really not understand why DD doesn't like reading...

58 replies

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 11:38

DD is 8. She has always been in the top reading group at school, she taught herself to read while she was still at nursery. She loves books and loves being read to.

BUT she says she hates reading to herself. She did during lockdown, probably because she had so much time, but it has really tapered off now. She got given so many wonderful books for her recent birthday but she hasn't picked up a single one to read by herself (I will read them all to her, in time). Getting her to do her school reading is a huge chore, even though she can read all the books fluently.

Has anyone had a similar DC and is it just something I need to accept or is there a way for her to discover the joy of reading? I feel like she is missing out in a funny way - how lovely it is to get lost in a good book - but maybe that's just imposing my own thoughts/beliefs on her...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 17:55

I think reading is a bit of a sacred cow for some parents Yes, I think there’s a lot of truth to this! I’m hopefully not one of them, but there is a very slight element of sadness - which really makes no sense objectively, when I consider how enriching and full of fun and imagination her life is!

I think my other worry has been that school starts to change around this age from ‘learning to read’ to ‘reading to learn’, and sometimes she gets homework which involves finding info on the web - something she really doesn’t enjoy because of the trawling through a lot of text. I assume there will be more and more of this as she gets older.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 17/02/2022 14:37

I think reading is a bit of a sacred cow for some parents. I remember a thread a while back from a mother who needed shelf space in her son’s room, but couldn’t bring herself to remove his (dusty) books because it was would be ‘giving in’ and admitting he wasn’t ‘a reader’.

I certainly recognise the stories about parents feeling disappointed or upset that their children don’t share their love of reading. I can remember my dad being rather put out when I was about 13 and suddenly preferred to listen to my Walkman in bed rather than read. It was partly just that I was developing different interests, and partly that I was at a stage where I was too old for kids’ books, but probably not ready for a lot of adult ones.

I ended up doing an English degree, which meant I did very little other than read for three solid years, so it can’t have put me off that much Grin But it’s worth saying that it’s not the end of the world if a child just isn’t interested in reading. I think some people equate it with stupidity, which is a bit unfair.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 17/02/2022 14:17

Also meant to add that my other child is a complete bookworm, reads anything and everything.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 17/02/2022 14:16

It’s a tricky age. My DD has been a free reader since Y1, never struggled with learning to read at all but is only just beginning to read for fun. Many books at that age are rubbish, or chosen by adults as what they think children should like.

Despite being a fluent reader, DD struggled with chapter books and I think she found the length and structure complicated. However easier books are mostly shite (endless Fairy nonsense). She did much better with short form - non fiction, the Week, and anything to do with Minecraft. For actual novels, the lighter ones such as Tom Gates, Diary of BUG are hits.

She also really struggled with any kind of danger/peril/monsters/angst/meanness.

TheMooch · 17/02/2022 13:52

Have you tried her with a kindle? Sometimes the text /paper / ink can have sensory issues and seen a few reluctant very able readers take to a kindle much better.

Also do try the magazines, comics like Phoenix etc are brilliant in engaging children.

Itsnotover · 17/02/2022 13:51

I was like your dd until I studied English Literature for A level. From then, I loved books. Sorry, not much help(!)

Kokapetl · 17/02/2022 13:47

The Phoenix comic would be good to try. My 8 yr old loves it.

luckylavender · 17/02/2022 13:46

My DS is the same. Never very interested. It hasn't held him back.

Sparklesocks · 17/02/2022 13:45

Maybe try something like graphic novels or comics/manga and see if she likes reading in a different format?

firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 13:44

I’d be amazed if she is dyslexic… she’s never had any issues with reading/writing/spelling ability. No signs of that at all.

@kindlyensure Hetty Feather (and the sequels) are her very favourite books Smile

OP posts:
firstchopanonion · 17/02/2022 13:42

@AwkwardPaws27 She does like Goosebumps - still wants me to read them to her though! Funnily enough I was also a huge horror/Stephen King fan as a child and read lots of inappropriate things far too young Smile

Thanks for the comic suggestions CrackerGal, I will take a look at those.

And to those who say remember she is different to you - oh yes, I know this, and the things she can do that I can’t and never have been able to absolutely delight and amaze me. I think reading is just something that brings me and DH such pleasure, and always has, that it’s more a case of wanting her to be able to experience that too. It’s a different sort of very pleasure to sport or play and so on. But if she doesn’t then she doesn’t.

OP posts:
Opus17 · 17/02/2022 13:42

Could she be dyslexic? My cousins were both like this...both diagnosed with dyslexia in their teens.

sashh · 17/02/2022 13:39

I think when you read well as a child you run out of things to read that are age appropriate, I read 1984 when I was 12 or 13, I don't recommend it for a child.

Have you considered a kindle? You can get all the classics for free and lots of books for 99p.

And it is light, books can be heavy if you are small (or in my case have arthritis) and just holding the right page can be difficult.

And as someone else mentioned you can change the font and the size.

FredBair · 17/02/2022 13:39

My DC are adults now. Sometimes you just have to accept that not everyone enjoys reading for pleasure and it's better not to force it.
I do but DH does not.

DS1 could read fluently at 4. He was one of those kids queing at the bookshop for the latest Harry Potter.
He got to age 8 and stopped. Just didn't enjoy it any more.

It didn't affect him academically, he got all A*s at GCSE and A level and a first in Maths at uni.
He's 26 and probably hasn't read a book since he was 8.

DS2 was slow to learn to read and yet still reads for pleasure at 24.

kindlyensure · 17/02/2022 13:36

Hmm, my DD was v similar. Amazing reading ability. Loved being read to. Really struggled to read a book to herself. Really liked audio books. We got them from the library - when cds were a thing - (do you have a CD player?!) The reason I mention cds is that some of the books we borrowed might be out of print/not digitised. The best we had was The Silk Sisters by Fiona Dunbar.

Easy entries into reading to herself were Harry Potter and Jacqueline Wilson (but you have to be careful with the latter as they can be a bit heavy issue going. She really liked Little Darlings and Hetty Feather for e.g.).

Both Rowling and Wilson write in a pacy way with straightforward sentences, a bit like Enid Blyton who is very accessible for readers who enjoy books but find it hard to concentrate or stick at it.

MayMorris · 17/02/2022 13:35

2 sons. Both treated the same in terms of learning to read, being read to, listening to books on tape recordings etc , we had a house full of books
And both me and their father would be reading a lot too.
Eldest son would read by himself constantly. As adult he always has at least 1 book on the go.
Other son simply read when he had to. He loved listening to books and could do for hours . But I had to force him to read his books at school. I tried all sorts of books with him but he would give up after a few chapters. He still doesn’t read for pleasure now. His partner has tried to get him reading and again she has now given up. But he listens to audible a lot.

Both kids got degrees, in fact the non reader got a masters. So that wasn’t a problem

Some kids seem to never take to reading by themselves for pleasure. I think it must be to do with way their Brains work in terms of processing visual vs auditory information and that maybe links into the way their imagination works on conjuring up that world they are reading on paper. It quite a feet our brains can do that when you think about it, Don’t force it . Make sure she reads a bit, and for what is needed for school but then try audible or similar . this will still increase her vocabulary and knowledge and provide almost all of the benefits of reading

CrackerGal · 17/02/2022 13:23

Here's a link to some very good suggestions from a mighty girl (we took some from here originally).

Graphic novels my daughter really enjoyed:

Rania Telgemeier:
Smile
Sisters
Guts
The first 4x Babysitters Club Graphic novels.

Wolkwalkers
Coraline
The Graveyard Book (Neil Gainham)
Roller Girl
Invisible Emmie
Just Jamie
Camp & Click
Stargazing

You should be able to find all those by just putting the title into amazon.

There's also the Babysitters Club Little Sister series which my daughter didn't read yet.

www.amightygirl.com/books/fiction/graphic-novels

Hope that helps a bit!

Porcupineintherough · 17/02/2022 13:21

I think she's still quite young so its probably still quite hard work for her to read to herself, esp if her taste in books is a little ahead of her reading age.

AwkwardPaws27 · 17/02/2022 13:19

I was similar - learnt to read early, found that the books for my age were boring & the books for teens were all about things I wasn't interested in (boys, peer pressure etc).

Then my uncle gave me a completely inappropriate book (Firestarter by Stephen King) & I found a whole new genre 😆
I'm not suggesting Stephen King for your 8 year old (although I'm still hooked years later), but maybe a new genre will do the trick - Goosebumps or the "99 Fear Street" series, for example, if she might find horror a bit thrilling.

FantasticFebruary · 17/02/2022 13:19

She clearly has too many fun options!!

As she's not watching much tv or a tablet/phone etc but doing 'real' things, I'd just back off tbh, the only things I'd do is let her choose a book from an actual bookshop (but go in for me as part of a a shopping trip for other things, not make a big deal of it) and hopefully she'll find something she wants to read! & go on from there.

FurryGiraffe · 17/02/2022 13:19

DS1 is a reluctant reader, which I've always felt slightly sad about (because I'm another who never had her head out of a book as a child). In his case, although his reading is excellent, it's never been something he found particularly easy, and when he was younger he really struggled to track the words across the page. We bought him a kindle for Christmas and the difference has been unbelievable. He has the font much larger than it would be in the equivalent printed book, and he's now reading for up to an hour a day.

FloBot7 · 17/02/2022 13:17

She might just not enjoy it. My DH hasn't read a book since he was in school. He can read, write and spell perfectly well and has a good degree but doesn't read books for pleasure. The last time we had a beach holiday I read several books but he was happy with podcasts, music, news articles etc. He says he just can't get into books, within a few pages he stops paying attention and wants to put it down.

DoctorSnortles · 17/02/2022 13:16

The Barrington Stoke books mentioned are really good for reluctant or tired readers (I do think sometimes children are too tired to tackle more challenging texts at bedtime).

shouldistop · 17/02/2022 13:16

I do think it's difficult for some people to accept that our children are absolutely separate people who may well be utterly different from us.

I so agree with this. I'm 34 and my mum seems confused about the fact that I'm an inch taller than her. "But I'm only 5"3 so you can't be 5"4" it's bizarre. Even shoe size, she can't seem to accept that we have different sized feet from each other.